EDITORIAL

Best Italian Restaurants in New York — 200 Options Ranked

Based on 200 restaurants analyzed

⭐ 4.5 avg 📍 New York
By PosDo Editorial · PosDo
#1

Carmine's

⭐ 4.5 (18,388 reviews) $$
Italian

"We had great service, wonderful food & fantastic dessert."

— Marrissa Lefebvre
Carmine's
#2

Olio e Più

⭐ 4.7 (9,650 reviews) $$
Italian

"Great pizza, amazing tiramisu, super friendly service."

— Alberto Migliore
Olio e Più
#3

La Pecora Bianca

⭐ 4.8 (4,785 reviews) $$
Italian

"All our entree’s were exceptionally delicious!"

— Denna Shamoun
La Pecora Bianca

The Numbers

4.5★ Average Rating
200 Options in New York
248,595 reviews
€€ Average Price
🛵 173 delivery ☀️ 133 terrace
"

We had great service, wonderful food & fantastic dessert.

★ ★ ★ ★ ★
Marrissa Lefebvre at L'Osteria

Explore All Options

Discover all 200 best italian restaurants in New York

#1 Carmine's 4.5★
#2 Olio e Più 4.7★
#3 La Pecora Bianca 4.8★
📍 See All in New York
See All in New York