Plymouth Café

No frills, classic NY cafe for simple deli faves. Really friendly staff!

The food is absolutely amazing (definitely made with love because oh my goodness gracious) and the owner is so nice!!

I was having a terrible morning—I felt nauseous, grumpy without coffee, and absolutely exhausted. I swear to god, the egg and cheese bagel I ordered RESURRECTED me. Along with the super sweet owner, a good cup of joe, and reasonable prices, this place is great! It seriously saved my day.

Isai Garcia

Sandwiches are pretty good compared to the other delis around the area and their coffee is really good too

Nick Abbate

I popped in to grab a quick lunch sandwich here. It’s very unassuming on the inside, but the really nice man behind the counter made me a DELICIOUS vegetarian cheese sandwich that is exactly how my mom used to make for me. The ingredients and bread were super fresh. I was expecting bodega quality and my expectations were blown away by this little sandwich. This is a cute local gem for sure!

Naomi Pena

No frills, classic NY cafe for simple deli faves. Really friendly staff!

v v

The food is absolutely amazing (definitely made with love because oh my goodness gracious) and the owner is so nice!!

Natalie Mastalerz

A very sweet Dumbo spot for authentic New York bagels and wraps in a lovely area. The owner is extremely friendly and chatty and the food is tasty and affordable. Will definitely be inviting my tourist pals here :)

Christina Georgiou

I was having a terrible morning—I felt nauseous, grumpy without coffee, and absolutely exhausted. I swear to god, the egg and cheese bagel I ordered RESURRECTED me. Along with the super sweet owner, a good cup of joe, and reasonable prices, this place is great! It seriously saved my day.

James Napier

I've been going here for years -- always for breakfast. I always get the same thing -- egg and bacon (no cheese) on an everything bagel. It always hits the spot -- bacon almost always crispy (as I like it) and the bagels are fresh. I can't speak for the rest of the menu but there's a reason I keep going back . . ..

Charlie Anastasi

Has become my go-to coffee/bagel spot. Reasonable prices and the two guys who run the store are incredibly kind and friendly. Surprised by some of the other comments I read. I've been 50+ times and I've never been greeted with anything but a big smile.

Luke Stroehlein

The owner is very friendly, always has a smile on his face when you walk in. This place is ground level with a small ramp so it's stroller and wheelchair friendly. I love the omelets here. I've never gotten anything other than breakfast but the omelets are just as good if not better than any close restaurants and around half the price. Definitely a hidden gem worth checking out!

Freshly baked bagel with cream cheese for only 3.50! Simple local cafe with American specialties, unpretentious atmosphere and friendly service. If you are visiting Brooklyn Heights Promenade and fancy a snack this must be your spot.

Eugene Bugrim

Freshly baked bagel with cream cheese for only 3.50! Simple local cafe with American specialties, unpretentious atmosphere and friendly service. If you are visiting Brooklyn Heights Promenade and fancy a snack this must be your spot.

Large bodega deli with a decent amount of seating. Large communal area / waiting area. The service was a bit slow although I was the only one ordering at the time, but I was happy to see they cleaned the grill before making my vegetarian wrap so they regained a star for that; it consisted of 3 egg whites, carrots, peppers and tomato for 5$. Overall an okay place to stop by for a quick wrap or coffee to go.

Pretty good food, idk why it says there’s Wi-Fi here on Gmap, this is definitely not a Wi-Fi cafe. Owner is really kind and the food came out very quickly.

Theo

Pretty good food, idk why it says there’s Wi-Fi here on Gmap, this is definitely not a Wi-Fi cafe. Owner is really kind and the food came out very quickly.

Michael Whitley, PMHNP-BC, Head Noodle Psychiatry

Large bodega deli with a decent amount of seating. Large communal area / waiting area. The service was a bit slow although I was the only one ordering at the time, but I was happy to see they cleaned the grill before making my vegetarian wrap so they regained a star for that; it consisted of 3 egg whites, carrots, peppers and tomato for 5$. Overall an okay place to stop by for a quick wrap or coffee to go.

This is the second time when the man behind the counter has charged me extra 1-2$ And when I am asking for what was 11,35 (I ordered a burger, which is 8.95$) he told me onion and lettuce. Seriously?? I used to come here to get something for lunch, but I won't come back.

Vlad Lesun

This is the second time when the man behind the counter has charged me extra 1-2$ And when I am asking for what was 11,35 (I ordered a burger, which is 8.95$) he told me onion and lettuce. Seriously?? I used to come here to get something for lunch, but I won't come back.

I would give it one star, but giving it two stars because the price was on the cheaper end for this neighborhood. However I ordered a bacon, egg, and cheddar cheese on a roll toasted with butter after he tried to mansplain how to order a breakfast sandwich to me. Then when I got my sandwich there was no butter and American cheese. I tried to ask him if he could fix it. He refused and told me there is butter, but it’s just melted. It was just bacon grease. Mind you, I was the only person in the store, so the fact that he got my entire order wrong is ridiculous.

Guy is rude. Turkey cheese on a roll 11.0. Arizona is 3.50. Save your money.

I got breakfast there and the juice ended up being overpriced and not tasting particularly fresh. This was for a total price (incl tax) of approx $40 including tax for 2 breakfast wraps (~9$ each) and 2 juices (~9$ each, way too much but I didn't check until after I had ordered everything since I assumed they were going to charge something more reasonable for orange juice).

Lilah De Leon

I would give it one star, but giving it two stars because the price was on the cheaper end for this neighborhood. However I ordered a bacon, egg, and cheddar cheese on a roll toasted with butter after he tried to mansplain how to order a breakfast sandwich to me. Then when I got my sandwich there was no butter and American cheese. I tried to ask him if he could fix it. He refused and told me there is butter, but it’s just melted. It was just bacon grease. Mind you, I was the only person in the store, so the fact that he got my entire order wrong is ridiculous.

Emilio Acosta

Guy is rude. Turkey cheese on a roll 11.0. Arizona is 3.50. Save your money.

Owen Whitley

I got breakfast there and the juice ended up being overpriced and not tasting particularly fresh. This was for a total price (incl tax) of approx $40 including tax for 2 breakfast wraps (~9$ each) and 2 juices (~9$ each, way too much but I didn't check until after I had ordered everything since I assumed they were going to charge something more reasonable for orange juice).

WRONG ORDERS. OVERPRICED. Friendly face when you walk in, but charged over $15 for a large iced coffee and egg and cheese on a roll. I repeated my order a few times and they said they got it. But then when I opened my sandwich outside, it was a spinach wrap with bacon, egg, avocado, lettuce. Not what I ordered at all. The whole thing was dripping so I ran in for an extra two napkins and they first yelled “no!” before conceding and letting me take some. I said I ordered a roll, and they just said oh sorry. Overall, a huge waste of time and money. Couldn’t eat the wrap for dietary reasons. Go somewhere else

Just got an Italian sandwich last week and now have food poisoning from it. Likely the lettuce or the sliced Italian meats.

Jeff Witscher

Just got an Italian sandwich last week and now have food poisoning from it. Likely the lettuce or the sliced Italian meats.

Yehudis M

WRONG ORDERS. OVERPRICED. Friendly face when you walk in, but charged over $15 for a large iced coffee and egg and cheese on a roll. I repeated my order a few times and they said they got it. But then when I opened my sandwich outside, it was a spinach wrap with bacon, egg, avocado, lettuce. Not what I ordered at all. The whole thing was dripping so I ran in for an extra two napkins and they first yelled “no!” before conceding and letting me take some. I said I ordered a roll, and they just said oh sorry. Overall, a huge waste of time and money. Couldn’t eat the wrap for dietary reasons. Go somewhere else