Thomas Castriota

I tried the Bill and Sal's Excellent Adventure IPA on draft and was not disappointed. My gal had a Paulie Colada which substituted amaretto instead of rum and she loved it. The Daniela Spinachi with the tomato sauce instead of just white was absolutely delightful. The arancini was amazing with the melted mozzarella inside and tomato sauce outside complemented it so well. Our server, Jordan was warm and welcoming, super attentive, and so on her game. The flexibility on the sauce was a big deal and made for an even better meal. The atmosphere is classic old nyc brick and wood with pizza related cultural artifacts. Oh, yeah, easy street parking! Are you kidding me? C'mon. Loved it and will absolutely be back.

+1

Vincent Yap

Great atmosphere and pizza. The pizza tasted so fresh and we loved the recommendations given by the server. Would come back again! Highly recommend getting the Hellboy's Pizza. The hot honey was such a game changer.

Sonia T

Excellent pizza and vibes! I was able to make a reservation for re-opening day which was a super busy and fun atmosphere. It took a little while for a server to take our order but we were patient and the pizzas came out quickly. We ordered the Hellboy (fave), Ricky Ricotta with vegan sausage, and added the Grapeful Dead because we were curious about the pickled grapes (unique flavor). All very delicious pies with perfect crust and unique flavors/toppings.

Fun vibe and great pizza\n\nFood: we tried 4 different slices. The Sicilians are the way to go - so flavorful! I also recommend the vodka slice! \n\nService: good and fast\n\nAmbience: such a fun and…

Fun vibe and great pizza\n\nFood: we tried 4 different slices. The Sicilians are the way to go - so flavorful! I also recommend the vodka slice! \n\nService: good and fast\n\nAmbience: such a fun a…

Fun vibe and great pizza\n\nFood: we tried 4 different slices. The Sicilians are the way to go - so flavorful! I also recommend the vodka slice! \n\nService: good and fast\n\nAmbience: such a fun a…

If you're looking for late-night pizza in Greenpoint, Paulie Gee's is hard to beat -- especially at 1am on a weekend.\n\nThe Hellboy slice is my go-to here. Spicy, balanced, and packed with flavor, i…

Terrific spot with great pizza, fast service, lovely interior, and nice staff. We've come in a few times when we've been in the neighborhood doing other things and are never disappointed. Love that…

Terrific spot with great pizza, fast service, lovely interior, and nice staff. We've come in a few times when we've been in the neighborhood doing other things and are never disappointed. Love th…

Tasty, fairly priced, and kind servers. Got my pizza slice to go and was super happy with it. \n\nNice vibes for eating in, drinking and watching sports.

Staff were super friendly. Service was quick. The pizza!!!! Please send me a pie to thr Bronx. That sesame crust. The sauce. Loved it all!

Staff were super friendly. Service was quick. The pizza!!!! Please send me a pie to thr Bronx. That sesame crust. The sauce. Loved it all!

Really fresh pizza. The king harry classic was so good (tomato sauce, prosciutto, basil). The hellboy is good if you like a savory/sweet combo.\n\nThe staff are kind, but they can be kind of busy s…

Live music on Fridays in this cozy casual pizza shop. Love the atompsphere here and the pizza was amazing and cooked to perfection. Highly recommend the neffys white pie and the hellboy so you get …

We had three different pizzas and all were delizioso... the arugala schmugala, Hellboy, and King Harry classic. I ordered the last and loved it the most!! The Hellboy was a scrumptious combination of…

Pizzas are amazing and really creative. Beer is good too. But service is best - very attentive and friendly. I’d personally go with hard copy menus, as it’s all online right now. But otherwise, gre…

Pizzas are amazing and really creative. beer is good too. But service is best - very attentive and friendly. I’d personally go with hard copy menus, as it’s all online right now. But otherwise, gre…

We went for takeout. The square pepperoni pizza was unusual and excellent. It wasn't because it was square but because of the crust thickness, the sesame seed under coating and just great flavor.

Glenda Cortez

I’ve been going to Paulie Gee’s for years, which never disappoints me. Lately, I’ve mostly just grabbed slices from their little joint around the corner for a quick fix, which is always solid. But with family in town this weekend, I finally made a proper reservation to sit down at the OG spot in Greenpoint and have a whole pizza experience. And still so good! Paulie Gee’s makes Neapolitan-style pizza, and it does it right. In a city flooded with pizza hype and constant “best-of” lists, crowning one king is impossible. But judging by the original Hellboy pie, it’s up there. It's sweet, spicy, crispy, and soft—just a perfect combo. The restaurant itself is super chill. There is no scene, just good vibes, good pies, and a cold beer. It's the perfect spot to hang with friends or show off NYC pizza culture to visiting family. Depending on your crew, they’ve got different pie sizes, and while they have other menu items, my advice is to skip the distractions and stay focused on the pizza. One standout worth calling out: their fennel vegan sausage. Even if you don’t usually go for meat alternatives, give it a try. It’s packed with flavor and a perfect option if you’re trying to stay veggie without missing the “meatiness.” Again, NYC pizza is a crowded game, but Paulie Gee’s has been consistently great for years, and that says everything. If you haven’t been, go. If you’ve been, go again.

Santiago Garcia

Okay, I just had dinner here and must confess that I have mixed emotions. I’ve dined here dozens of times so will try to be balanced here. On the positives, the service was very good and friendly and the atmosphere remains generally intact from the ‘old’ Paulie Gee before the mgmt. change. The Hellboy pizza continues to be a showstopper! The expanded menu looks interesting, though we sticked to the classic pizzas that we generally order. That being said, there were a few things that were unusually below par. One of the pizzas was significantly burned. I know that Neapolitan pizza will generally have a little burn on the edges but this one was just too much. We order a vegan pizza but it was extremely dry, it clearly needed more tomato sauce. Finally, the dough in general felt more dry than it used to be, giving the pizza a more crunchy feeling vs the more chewy and puffy dough it once had.

Rowena Ma

Super vibey at night and has all the makings of a cozy, warm, casual bar and late night spot. The pizzas are fantastic, but pricey. Each is the size of a personal pie and around 20-25$ which seems expensive for the area and NY in general. Service is fantastic and the atmosphere is nice to hang out with a group. Will definitely try the slice shop but this is also a nice option to dine in with some friends, if you’re looking for that kind of spot.

Jesse Yuan

Above average wood fired Neapolitan. I just wished crust could be bit more crispy. Must get the “Hellboy” and their OG Arugula salad. Good choices of cocktail and wine. My server, she was extremely polite and responsive. Parking in the area is somewhat difficult and meters up till 10pm.

+13

When I have friends visiting from out of that want a great NYC style pizza yet want to have a sit down experience, Paulie Gee's always comes to mind. The service is alway welcoming and the vibe is …

Pizza that is definitely worth your time! A little over hyped and a little overpriced but definitely solid!

Overall, the neopolitan pizzas are fantastic. They were the right crisp, the crust was fluffy, and the sauce/topping/dough ratio were pretty even. The Hellboy (we added arugula) was delicious espec…

Pizza - hellboy. I don't get the hype of this hot honey. Meh, not a fan of sweet on my savory. With the meats, it actually ended up being too salty.\nPizza - white porky pie. I usually don't like w…

Came here with my son March of 2017 sorry I'm late on this review but it came up on my Facebook memories and wanted to share, I will post pictures of the pizzas we had, had great memories, pizza was …

We ordered a Pepperoni and Pepperoni with honey pizza for dinner. Very tasty with fresh ingredients. We truly enjoyed this and will order from here again.

The food is excellent, no question there but the fact that you have to order from the app and there is no interaction with a server ruins the whole experience. We pulled up at 7:30 on a Monday nigh…

The food is excellent, no question there but the fact that you have to order from the app and there is no interaction with a server ruins the whole experience. We pulled up at 7:30 on a Monday nigh…

Trenton Borders

The pizza was good but a huge cockroach started crawling across the wall right next to our table (we were by the kitchen). The staff didn’t seem very concerned and lacked urgency as the cockroach slowly made its way across the wall and disappeared behind a wooden beam.

jonathan baetens

We arrived there while Tuck Decker was singing Frank Sinatra songs (every 1st/3rd Tuesday of the Month). It was cozy but very loud, it would have been more enjoyable if the sound system was a tad lower. Anyway about the pizzas, the taste was actually pretty good, ingredients were solid. The only sad thing, big parts of the curst were burned which is a pity. Therefore a 3 star review, decent but wouldn't come back

Owen Hutchinson

I’ve been here many times over 10+ years, it was always very good…sad to say but it seems to have fallen off. I’m seeing in other reviews that they changed mgmt, which probably explains it. I recently went with some family visiting from out of town for lunch and got two pies, a ricotta/arugula and a magherita that the menu said came topped with fresh basil. Check out the pic to see how much actual basil the pie came with 😂 Also the tomato sauce was super bland. There was four of us, our server recommended we get three pies but we figured we’d start with two and take it from there. Suffice to say nobody was really interested in a third. Service was decent but we were one of only two tables and our server forgot one of our drinks. Unless you’re craving a vegan pie there’s better pizza options nearby these days.

pizza is solid! drinks are quite strong as well. only gripe is that there was a rat behind our table (my friend is scared of rats) and when we told the other table beside us the waiter overheard us…

pizza is solid! drinks are quite strong as well. only gripe is that there was a rat behind our table (my friend is scared of rats) and when we told the other table beside us the waiter overheard us…

pizza is solid! drinks are quite strong as well. only gripe is that there was a rat behind our table (my friend is scared of rats) and when we told the other table beside us the waiter overheard us…

Nice ambiance , good service , pizzas were decent could use more flavor though , drinks were very good .

overrated and over reviewed... most people don't have good taste buds chicken wings and pizza is good but not really flavorful...it's a date spot not a gigantic friend gathering....service is gentr…

The staff was disrespectful nasty rude the pizza looks nothing like it does in its pictures THE NASTINESS OF THE STAFF CAUSE NO TIP ON MY TAKE OUT ORDER BUT WAS GOING TO TIP IN CASH as a business own…

The staff was disrespectful nasty rude the pizza looks nothing like it does in its pictures THE NASTINESS OF THE STAFF CAUSE NO TIP ON MY TAKE OUT ORDER BUT WAS GOING TO TIP IN CASH as a business o…

The staff was disrespectful nasty rude the pizza looks nothing like it does in its pictures THE NASTINESS OF THE staff CAUSE NO TIP ON MY TAKE OUT ORDER BUT WAS GOING TO TIP IN CASH as a business…