Ben

Legit old school NY pizza place complete with Pac-Man arcade machine

My World

I wanted to take a photo of the pizza but it was so good I finished it before I could take one . Don’t walk run to Tony’s . The best in Williamsburg by far

Keegan Barone

Service was excellent— love ordering NY pizza from a spot where you hear “see ya later Paulie” from a regular as they leave the shop. The vibes inside are awesome, almost cinematic. I got the Vodka pizza, it was fire, the cheese pull was nice too!!

greatest obete

I have to give five stars I came here a few months ago for two plates of chicken fettuccine and boy did my daughter and I enjoy it I stopped by today for a couple of slices of pizzas and A spinach wrap I’m not pronouncing it correctly. I just saw it and wanted it. It was so good. The atmosphere is always beautiful. The service is always kind. The food is always great. They speak to us as we’re entering the store. I love that my dark skin didn’t matter. I felt welcome here, I love this place

Evan Douglas

We were headed to a different Tonys but this was a pleasant surprise. The service and recommendations from Paul were amazing. The Upside Down and The Cowboy slices were DELICIOUS! Definitely would come back and recommend. Slushy was good too!

+1

Latoya Roserie

Best pizza & Pasta Spot. The penne Alla vodka with shrimp is the best. What sets the restaurant apart is the staff. They all make you feel special and always ready to assist. My best Italian spot in Williamsburg. A big shout out to the BROTHERS. See you Soon 💪

Nino Cosoleto-Miller

Spectacular old-school New York Pizza! We were on a time crunch headed to a show at Brooklyn Steel, and this place is practically right outside the Graham Ave. L station. So we hopped off the train and scored some pizza. She got a slice of Grandma's, and I got two big Sicilian slices. They were heavenly, as I knew they would be, upon hearing the thick Brooklyn accents of the guys working there and the other customers. Love it. I would make it a point to go back here.

Angelina

Excellent! Thank you for preparing my catering meal and delivering it on time. We ordered 1/2 tray meatballs and 1/2 lasagna. It was delivered hot and attractively packaged. Additionally, we bought a quart of Pasta Figoli Soup. Freddy deliverered with a smile and was professional. Serving utensils, plates, and bread were supplied. Great first impression. We highly recommend for your next catering event!

+2

Daniel Pino

Tony’s Pizza Est. 1950 Layout/atmosphere *Green & white checker cloth tables; three seat wall counter; one TV; PAC Man arcade game; old photos on the wall Food/drink *Drunken Vodka slice - Good; cooked to a crisp/char *Grandma slice (square) - solid

Melissa Naja

Local Pizzaria and my brother favorite place. I don't know how long Tony's Pizza has been opened but my family order from this restaurant for long time and sometimes we sit outside the place. Pizza is good, my favorite is spicy oil pizza, simple and original. Sometimes in summer I also get Italian Icey and enjoy the weather.

Leonardo Torres

The Italian Flag slice had a firm crust which was good because the other ingredients were rather heavy. There was a good amount of cheese and the sauce and olive oil drizzled on top completed the pizza. This is more of a take out sort of place as seating is limited and there is no restroom available for patrons.

+2

Anthony L

I came here yesterday to get a "to go" slice. Girl behind the counter gave me a hard time because I asked for a "to go" pizza box instead of a "to go" bag. I walk far and when the pizza is in a bag, typically messes up the slice and the sauce gets all over the bag, so I prefer a box. Fast forward to today, I went back because the pizza is great, ordered two slices this time, but the order was given to me in a bag again. They're obviously very cheap with pizza boxes and little tiny things like that are annoying. Carmines across the way always gives boxes for to go orders

Giana M

Ordered a buffalo chicken wrap trying to be a little “healthier” was given just a wrap with chicken and buffalo sauce, no lettuce, no tomatoes extremely disappointed. Also paid extra for fries and they weren’t delivered. Won’t be ordering again.

Victor Ortiz

Man this place downgraded just like a lot of other spots from this area. Look at the image of my sandwich compared to the vodka sandwich from the photo on slice app. I just ordered this. They use to look like this all the time. My sandwich has no sauce and it’s literally bread and dry chicken. Tony’s was my spot for years…