Zimmi Coker

El Mitote is a casual but delicious Mexican restaurant located on the UWS. Every time I go, it never fails to disappoint. Don’t let the margs fool you, one will usually suffice. Personally, I prefer the frozen as they have the perfect consistency. I ordered the frozen coconut (which is out of this world) and my friend got the frozen blood orange marg which was also incredible. My one little critique is that what is labeled on the menu as a “quesadilla” is indeed NOT at all a quesadilla. It’s literally a soft taco with little to no cheese, but I will give them this- they are delicious. The chorizo is a big hit here and is full of flavor, but please just add more cheese!!! That’s the entire point of a (quesa)dilla, LOL. The service is great here and the atmosphere is relaxed, but it’s also very fun with the festive decor and upbeat tunes in the background.

Savannah Craig

El Mitote is the absolute best. I always love the food, I get a burrito bowl with chicken. And the drinks are delicious the watermelon juice is top tier!! Service is always amazing and everyone is so nice 💗💗

Ruben Ramirez

The best Mexican restaurant I've been to in NYC! Food was delicious! I just went yesterday for the first time and it exceeded my expectations in all categories! In fact, the food was so good that it tasted even better than the Mexican food I've had in Mexico and that's saying a lot! I'm Dominican but I've visited Mexico several times and while. Mexican food in Mexico is delicious (CDMX and several other parts of Mexico I've been to), the food at this restaurant was even better. The prices were reasonable too Will definitely eat here again soon!

Joe

Unfortunately, I did not try the food, but I wish I did. Looked so GOOOOOD. The cocktails were outstanding. The 32oz def what was worth of money because I was tipsy after one drink. I will definitely come back to this place. We ordered more drinks and they made the drinks in front of us and they’re really good drinks and authentic as hell this is legit.

Jordan Napolitano

Went here for dinner before a movie at amc Lincoln square, we sat in their outdoor area. Started with a couple margaritas and chips with guacamole, really good guacamole. We had the chiles toreados as an appetizer and it was delicious. It was caramelized jalapenos and onions with cubes of fresco cheese and tortillas. Not too spicy but a nice richness to it, like soy sauce maybe. I had the flautas and my wife had the tinga quesadillas. All so good! We also shared some Mexican rice. Would definitely come back

+1

Stephanie Richardson

Had an amazing lunch here!! one of the best meals we ate on our trip to NYC. The veggie tacos were delicious and we tried the esquites and it was AMAZING. on top of this the service was so quick and so friendly! Highly recommend this place (:

Alex T

El Mitote is a Mexican restaurant that offers a wide range of traditional Mexican dishes, including tacos, enchiladas, burritos, and fajitas. The restaurant has a relaxed and inviting atmosphere with colorful decor that gives off a festive vibe. The service is friendly and attentive, and the portions are generous, making it a great value for the price. The food is flavorful and made with fresh ingredients, and there are plenty of vegetarian and gluten-free options available. Overall, El Mitote is a great choice for those looking for delicious and authentic Mexican food in a welcoming and vibrant atmosphere.

I love this place. The staff is amazing & I became a regular since the first time I came. Food is delicious - posole soup is my favorite. Margaritas are the best in the city!

I love this place. The staff is amazing & I became a regular since the first time I came. food is delicious - posole soup is my favorite. Margaritas are the best in the city!

I love this place. The staff is amazing & I became a regular since the first time I came. Food is delicious - posole soup is my favorite. Margaritas are the best in the city!

Awesome staff , yummy food, this is not high end dining but more of the comfort food eating. having a great time with friends in a louder environment. Kid friendly and reasonably priced. I loved …

Awesome staff , yummy food, this is not high end dining but more of the comfort food eating. having a great time with friends in a louder environment. kid friendly and reasonably priced. I loved …

Awesome staff , yummy food, this is not high end dining but more of the comfort food eating. having a great time with friends in a louder environment. Kid friendly and reasonably priced. I loved th…

Awesome staff , yummy food, this is not high end dining but more of the comfort food eating. having a great time with friends in a louder environment. Kid friendly and reasonably priced. I loved th…

This place consistently has the best burritos I've had in NYC. Always very fresh tasting, not greasy. Friendly neighborhood vibe. Is a bit expensive, but well worth it.

This place never fails. It's so casual, the food is delicious. The drinks are strong, the staff is accommodating, friendly, attentive. It's a great hang.

One of my favorite spots for tacos and margaritas on the upper west side. I usually order the shrimp tacos but have enjoyed their other menu items as well. There is often a short wait outside for…

Had a great tacos and skirt steak with friends so good and the drink is so refreshing , love it and reasonable price, staff is excellent and friendly

The food is so dang good! The service is amazing. The place is cute with a very laidback atmosphere

Really lovely Mexican restaurant staffed by very friendly Guatemalan people. Food is great and the atmosphere is very down to earth with fabulous music playing.

Really lovely Mexican restaurant staffed by very friendly Guatemalan people. Food is great and the atmosphere is very down to earth with fabulous music playing.

Really lovely mexican restaurant staffed by very friendly Guatemalan people. food is great and the atmosphere is very down to earth with fabulous music playing.

AMAZING and a MUST!!! We were so impressed with the staff and food options at this restaurant. The food was excellent and the service was top notch. They were very accommodating and Marco was the BES…

AMAZING and a MUST!!! We were so impressed with the staff and food options at this restaurant. The food was excellent and the service was top notch. They were very accommodating and Marco was the…

AMAZING and a MUST!!! We were so impressed with the staff and food options at this restaurant. The food was excellent and the service was top notch. They were very accommodating and Marco was the…

Excellent authentic Mexican food , great service, good drinks, super atmosphere. We go again and again and are never disappointed

Excellent authentic Mexican food , great service, good drinks, super atmosphere. We go again and again and are never disappointed

Excellent authentic mexican food , great service, good drinks, super atmosphere. We go again and again and are never disappointed

Excellent authentic Mexican food , great service, good drinks, super atmosphere. We go again and again and are never disappointed

Excellent authentic Mexican food , great service, good drinks, super atmosphere. We go again and again and are never disappointed

Friday night in New York, after enjoying the central park, visited this place. Food: amazing, in my top 3 Mexican Restaurants in the USA. service: very quick. Servers are helpful. Location: near…

Nick Felker

I got some great tacos when I came here on a date in late October. They came with some salsa on the side which was too spicy for me but eating them plain was great too. We ate outside, as it was unseasonably warm, but it did seem like people inside had good vibes too.

Meera Mohan

Perfect evening weather led us to El Mitote, and the outdoor seating didn't disappoint. Pleasant, well-spaced, and lovely ambience. Our server, Guel, was attentive, kind, and friendly - even offering a taste of different mezcals for my partner. Drinks were top-notch: Passion Fruit Margherita and Alipus San Andres Mezcal were really good. The El Tecate beer was a nice complement. Food was decent, if not spectacular - Carnitas Platter and Spicy Chorizo Burrito were enjoyable, but not the most flavorful Mexican food we've had. Given the great ambience, exceptional staff, and excellent drinks, we're willing to overlook the food's shortcomings. Pet-friendly outdoor seating is a bonus. If you're looking for a great spot for outdoor drinks, El Mitote's a solid choice.

+5

Christobel Gomez-Garcia

This is a nice spot to hang out after work, have a few drinks, and eat some good food. The portions are decent and the food quality is good. However the pricing is a bit expensive for Mexican food. $13 for guacamole… what ! Despite the inflation it was a nice experience and I enjoyed myself. Fast service even during the busy hours.

+4

The service was good but there's limited seating. The food was good but was pricey for what we got

The service was good but there's limited seating. The food was good but was pricey for what we got

The service was good but there's limited seating. The food was good but was pricey for what we got

Pretty solid fish tacos here, perfectly battered and paired nicely with the sauce. The chips and salsa was okay--not my favorite type of chips as they were on the harder side, but still good. The…

I like the ambiance here - it's a fun and festive atmosphere. Good steak tacos, shrimp tacos, chicken tinga tacos. I also like the churros with chocolate sauce, margaritas, and sangria. Decent pr…

I like the ambiance here - it's a fun and festive atmosphere. Good steak tacos, shrimp tacos, chicken tinga tacos. I also like the churros with chocolate sauce, margaritas, and sangria. Decent …

There is no happy hour here despite what the waitstaff may say. My friend and I specifically asked about happy hour last week and we were told it was happy hour outside and inside, so we sat do…

We enjoyed a weeknight dinner — shrimp tostado and mushroom tacos. The food arrived quickly and exceeded our expectations. Our server allowed us to stay long after the meal, a nice touch on a cold …

We enjoyed a weeknight dinner — shrimp tostado and mushroom tacos. The food arrived quickly and exceeded our expectations. Our server allowed us to stay long after the meal, a nice touch on a cold …

Food was good BUT the prices were much higher than their website when I called in to place my order. I did not realize the large price discrepancy until I was presented with the bill.

Christine Betts

Fun atmosphere (even in the rain). I had the mushroom tinga tacos, which were pretty good. The chips and salsa was delicious, but we assumed it was standard 'free chips and salsa' and it turned out to be $9 for a little basket of chips and some (albeit extremely delicious) salsa. Not that big of a deal but when the waiter offered I wish they'd mentioned they were nine bucks.

Arturo Franco

Inviting atmosphere. Food was mediocre but for a spot near Central Park, it's not a bad sit down option. Service was decently attentive. Prices are what you should expect in NY.

Jack Neal

Overall there is nothing too special at El Mitote. From other reviews, I was expecting to be blown away when in reality, this place is just good. The atmosphere: is a small place with limited seating inside and a more extensive outdoor area. The aesthetic is nice but nothing special. The staff: were nice. Besides taking my order and giving the check, there wasn’t much interaction or service. The food came reasonably quickly. The food: was good. The guacamole was a bit wet. In my opinion, the pork tacos seem a little dry. The platter I had was tasty but needed a sauce. Cleanliness: Good

Three stars is a stretch, I was debating giving it two. Not sure how the reviews are so good on google, with 4.3 stars and over 1,400 reviews at the moment. The reviews on here are much more accurate…

Randomly went to this Mexican spot with friends fora meal and drinks. No happy hour. The red sangria was OK and so was the food. I found the portions small including a $15 guacamole. This cozy rest…

Randomly went to this Mexican spot with friends fora meal and drinks. No happy hour. The red sangria was OK and so was the food. I found the portions small including a $15 guacamole. This cozy rest…

A classic - bit pricer for your hometown Mexican food that's leveled up a bit. Perfect spot for a beer and a bite!

Service is fine. Tacos were good. Frozen margarita - worst I've ever had. 15 dollars - happy hour btw - for a glass full of guava purée and very Lil tequila - if any at all. Im not a big drinker so…

Had outside seating on a busy evening. Service was efficient. Fish tacos (3) fresh and tasty, not a big portion but well worth the price This would be my regular Tex-Mex if I would be residing i…

Had outside seating on a busy evening. Service was efficient. fish tacos (3) fresh and tasty, not a big portion but well worth the price This would be my regular Tex-Mex if I would be residing…

I cannot express how awful the food was. The salsa was flavorless. The margaritas were okay. We ordered the chorizo tacos and the fish tacos. The breading on the fish was limp and there was very little fish inside. The taco was mostly cabbage. The chorizo was just… foul. I was hesitant to pay $18-$22 for three tacos and should have trusted that instinct. All in all including tax and tip that was a very regrettably spent $100. Service was pretty quick though, so we were able to leave swiftly.