Shelby Busby

Ordered 6 pizzas for a birthday party. They were delivered exactly on time (on a holiday weekend) hot and ready. The nice delivery driver even offered to leave the bags to keep them warm. Pizza was delicious! Nice locally owned pizza place.

Ron Smith

Now that is pizza. First time pizza with new management and it tasted great. Only had one pizza from previous owners and it was dreadful. Sauce had right depth of flavor, nice garlic, and flavorful. Crust was nice and chewy without being tough. Good level of cheese and plenty of topings. On-line order was easy. Thank you

Conor Loberg

Classic pizza was an amazing experience from the wonderful staff to the great pizza and grinders. Atmosphere is great representing northern Michigan well. I highly recommend trying this pizza spot out if here on vacation or are a local. 10/10!!

krista wollam

I can't say enough about how amazing Classic is! Classic pizza is my son's favorite, and when I requested a large order for his wedding, Cliff and the rest of the staff were able to make it happen seamlessly! And the pizzas were as delicious as I always remembered! It made the evening of the wedding even more perfect, and everyone enjoyed the pizza so much there were only a few pieces left at the end of the evening (that were quickly consumed the next day!)

Mike Harris

Stopped in Central Lake on my way thru and found this little gem. I got the Steak and Onion Grinder and… Wow! Every bite is a delicious taste of heaven!!! Cool atmosphere inside and the owner was extremely nice. Make sure to stop in when in town.

graham cracker

The pizza is truly amazing. It is one of the best I've ever had. Would definitely order from there again.

They are genuine, from the owner to the ingredients. Pizza is Hot, fresh and as ordered. Not a robot in sight just genuine small town goodness.

Bear Tron

Overall very satisfied with the pizza that Classic Pizza has to offer. The pizza was well balanced, was not floppy, had decent flavor, slices were huge, and had an adequate amount of sauce. There’s not much to complain about, honestly. The sauce was ok but could be better. A nearly perfect pizza. I almost couldn’t stop eating it. Absolutely will return and I cannot wait to try out more!

Chris Hoekstra

A small town pizzeria. There are about 10 tables inside. They have a very extensive menu. I've had their pizza before, and it is good. However I wasn't in the mood for pizza. So I ordered a pulled pork sandwich, some mac n cheese, and a small onion rings. The Sandwich was good but ovet priced. It wasn't an $8 or $9 dollar sandwich, more like $5 or $6. Still good though. The Mac was a little soupy which worried me, however it tasted excellent. Lastly the onion rings were good, nothing special, but still very good. Overall a solid 4 stars. Would I return? Yes I will.

Christian B

It’s not good after new ownership took over, the pizza taste super bland. The sauce is all watery now and the toppings are skimpy. This is not classic pizza anymore. Used to be my favorite now I won’t be returning. On top of all that you could at least have the courtesy to fill the sauce cups up more than half full.

Elizabeth Huffman

The owner screams at the employees, the food is absolutely disgusting! And They employed a minor child who stated she was emancipated without proof or paperwork. Have 16, 17 year olds hanging up on people and allow them to disrespect anyone. They allow them to make up lies and make false accusations/reports. I have proof of everything I've said. I'll also be going to the better business bureau

David McGuire

In town for an event and a group of us stopped in for dinner. Place looked promising and the interior was nice. Went to order three simple things. Burger basket with fries, loaded potato wedges and a Boss 302 (chicken, bacon, ranch). I was one of the first to order. The older gentleman at the register appear to be unable to operate the cash register and ordering was extremely painful. I had to explain the order several times and even showed him their own menu. I then paid for our meal. Then waited and waited, we had arrived about 6:00 pm, the others in our group placed orders after ours. They all starting receiving their food before me. Finally delivered the burger basket with nothing on it even after telling the incompetent gentleman who took the order to put everything on it that the menu described. Then the loaded potato wedges came plain. Still no Boss 302 grinder. Took the potato wedges back to have them corrected. Reminded them again about the grinder. Over an hour later the potato wedges returned along with a sandwich I did not order. Went up to the incompetent gentleman and a younger male and asked them again about the grinder. Sometime later they brought out a chick bacon ranch pizza. I finally ended up leaving without the grinder. This was one of the worst experiences I’ve ever had at any location in Central Lake. Been coming here for years and you can guarantee that we will never return and I will pass along to all of my friends and acquaintances, who come here every year, to stay away from this place. Also, the young man with the attitude should find a another job that’s not in the service industry.

Brandy Marter

Horrible experience. Drove to try somewhere new. First customer of the day. Taco pizza was so greasy I have a video of it literally dripping. I opened it and it was missing the lettuce and tomatoes and salsa. We went back in and they gave us lettuce and told us to cut it up ourselves. They didn’t cut the tomato at all until we asked them to. It was about half the amount needed for the full pizza. They gave us maynoise and when we asked about that he said it came with that and one sour cream. Who eats maynoise with taco pizza. The breadsticks that were ten dollars- had six pieces. Shocked by this whole situation. 45 minute wait. Disgusting food and rude service. I’m a local business owner and I would be embarrassed to serve the community in this manor. Spent $65.