Menu
Moonlight Creamery
PosDo

© 2026 PosDo · v3.0

Fairport

Moonlight Creamery

★★★★★ 4.7 · 100 reseñas

At Moonlight Creamery, we're passionate about crafting exceptional ice cream experiences in the heart of Fairport. In our cozy storefront, you'll find a variety of classic and specialty flavors made with love by hand. Our customers rave about the rich flavors and creamy textures...

Moonlight Creamery

Ice cream · Fairport

4.7 · 660 avaliações Google
www.moonlightcreamery.com
Yelp 4.5 (143) TripAdvisor 4.5 (36)

Sobre Moonlight Creamery

At Moonlight Creamery, we're passionate about crafting exceptional ice cream experiences in the heart of Fairport. In our cozy storefront, you'll find a variety of classic and specialty flavors made with love by hand. Our customers rave about the rich flavors and creamy textures that transport them...

At Moonlight Creamery, we're passionate about crafting exceptional ice cream experiences in the heart of Fairport. In our cozy storefront, you'll find a variety of classic and specialty flavors made with love by hand. Our customers rave about the rich flavors and creamy textures that transport them to a state of pure delight. We've perfected the art of creating an inviting atmosphere, where friends and family can gather to indulge in sweet treats and warm conversations. From our signature flavors like Strawberry Balsamic Swirl and Honey Lavender Dream, we're dedicated to serving up more than just ice cream - we serve memories made with every bite.

O que dizem os clientes de Moonlight Creamery

Moonlight Creamery is a highly-rated ice cream shop known for its creative flavors, homemade waffle cones, and friendly staff, especially Mikey. Customers rave about the generous servings and unique flavor combinations. Some dislike that they don't offer samples.

Pratos populares

roasted strawberry Annie Wants S'mores brown sugar oatmeal Pb fudge swirl praline ice creams girl scout cookie piece of cake Sow Your Wild Oats

Ideal para

Famílias Turistas Locais Casual

Tip: Enjoy your ice cream with a walk along the canal, located right next to the shop. They also offer dairy-free options.

Services

🚗 Delivery Accessible Coffee
🎯 Casual 🛋️ Cozy 🤫 Quiet 👥 Groups

O que ver nas proximidades

First Baptist Church of Fairport
Patrimônio
A 130m

First Baptist Church of Fairport

iglesia

Ver detalhes
First Congregational Church of Fairport
Patrimônio
A 443m

First Congregational Church of Fairport

iglesia

Ver detalhes

Dados de Wikidata

Explore os arredores de Moonlight Creamery

Moonlight Creamery está localizado em Fairport, rodeado de locais de interesse cultural e histórico. Aqui estão alguns dos pontos mais notáveis nas proximidades.

Património Histórico

  • First Baptist Church of Fairport (A 130m) — church building in New York, United States of America Lugar inscrito en el Registro Nacional de Lugares Históricos
  • First Congregational Church of Fairport (A 443m) — historic building in Fairport, New York, United States Lugar inscrito en el Registro Nacional de Lugares Históricos

Dados de Wikidata

Perguntas frequentes sobre Moonlight Creamery

Moonlight Creamery está localizado em 36 West Ave, Fairport, NY 14450, Fairport.
Perto de Moonlight Creamery encontram-se locais de interesse como First Baptist Church of Fairport, First Congregational Church of Fairport.
Moonlight Creamery oferece cozinha ice_cream.
Moonlight Creamery tem horário de funcionamento. Consulte o perfil para horários atualizados.
Moonlight Creamery oferece os seguintes serviços: comer no local, para levar, entrega.
Os pratos mais recomendados no Moonlight Creamery segundo as avaliações dos clientes são: roasted strawberry, Annie Wants S'mores, brown sugar oatmeal, Pb fudge swirl, praline ice creams.
Moonlight Creamery é ideal para famílias, turistas, locais, casual.
Moonlight Creamery is a highly-rated ice cream shop known for its creative flavors, homemade waffle cones, and friendly staff, especially Mikey. Customers rave about the generous servings and unique flavor combinations. Some dislike that they don't offer samples.
Enjoy your ice cream with a walk along the canal, located right next to the shop. They also offer dairy-free options.
660
Avaliações

Avaliações de Moonlight Creamery Fairport

4.7
660
5★
84%
4★
11%
3★
3%
2★
2%
1★
1%
Avaliações (100)
M
Mark Sorensen

Amazing. The ice cream is phenomenal and the staff is wonderful too. Heidi, the owner took great care of The Corning Museum of Glass staff while we were in town. Highly recommended.

S
Stacey A

Instead of cake for desert at our wedding reception we had ice cream sundaes and cookies. Moonlight Creamery’s ice cream and servers were great! The ice cream was a hit and it was a pleasure working with Heidi and Mikey at Moonlight to select our menu. We also did small ice cream tastings during cocktail hour, ice cream and flavored olive oil or vinegar. When these options were first suggested we were hesitant to even try them, but they were great! I think Mikey and Greg even got everyone to try some!

V
Vince Badali

Excellent home made ice cream, wonderful staff and great location. I brought a pint home to my wife and we thought it was some of the best ice cream we've ever had! Worth every penny!

J
Jessie

Love this place! Ice cream is good, waffle cones are so fresh they are still warm! Service is great. Highly recommend.

J
Jessica Herondale

Absolutely love this place. It's a very cute environment with custom touches. The ice cream selection is amazing, it's hard to choose just one. The staff was friendly and the place is clean. Ice cream is delicious too! They also have cakes, milkshakes, wine, and wine ice cream.

N
Nina Koski

Moonlight makes the creamiest, most luscious ice cream! They also have unique flavors, such as Honey Lavender, my favorite! The interior has cute tables to sit at, or you can go outside and wander by the canal.

J
Just Me

I love the environment here and the icecream is delicious. I appreciate that I was able to sample icecream on my first visit! The staff is also pretty cool. I will try every flavor, if possible lol. My overall favorites are the oatmeal and kraken flavors. Yum and yum🥰 nice hidden treat in Rochester

N
Nicholas Scinta

Homemade ice cream! Great selection, large serving sizes. A little pricey, but not so bad that I wouldn't go back. The quality of their ice cream is top notch. Their shakes are also amazing, but again, a little pricey.

M
Megan Derrick

Moonlight is a family favorite! The location is lovely- right on the canal. They almost always have MULTIPLE vegan and dairy free options, all of which are delicious. They can be a tad pricier than other ice cream places around, but it is nothing unreasonable and worth every penny, in my opinion.

C
Code Monkey Todd

Truly amazing ice cream. Many unique flavors. Open late!

G
Georgiana Knapp

Love the frozen custard there. It beats Abbott's in my opinion. Other ice cream is delicious but I favor custard. A very clean and adorable addition to Fairport with specialty chocolates and confections. I bought an ice cream cake for my granddaughter's birthday and it was adorable.

N
Noah Kalinowski

Tons of flavors of all varieties. As it was our first time there, the employee working the register was extremely helpful in explaining everything about the ice cream, the process of making it, and letting us try samples. Ice cream tasted delicious and natural.

C
C C

Some of the best ice cream around. So many choices to choose from, while having a relaxing environment to relax in. The seasonal flavors are some of the best! They also have other desserts to such as truffles to huge rice krispy treats. Once your are finished a nice walk by the water is ideal.

J
Joe Small

Referred to the creamery by Heidi after she visited my food stand. This is a excellent natural creamery with exceptional customer service!! Mikey was great in explaining the different flavors and pairings. We will definitely visit this establishment again!!!

A
Amy Avery

I wish I got the name of the guy that served us. He was so friendly and attentive. He answered all our questions and made for a welcoming experience. Also the ice cream was so good!

M
Melissa McHenry

Such a great place. Amazing flavors and friendly staff. The bowls and spoons are biodegradable too!

R
Rich Northrop

This place is amazing. Kind of hidden from the main street in fairport, but I kid you not they have the best oatmeal ice cream ever. I also really like that they are right next to the canal so you can walk right outside with your ice cream and sit near the water. It's pretty nice that they have coffee options here as well, and a high end espresso machine which they use to make affogato. A must try if you live nearby.

E
Ellie

Really cute little ice cream place, kind of hidden away but worth visiting. It's easiest to park in the underground library parking and walk over, as there's only street parking otherwise. It's well-positioned to walk to/from the rest of Fairport as well, and in the summer it's nice to stop here and pick up a milkshake before walking around. If you want to sit and enjoy the weather there's also some great outdoor seating right out in front - next to the canal and shaded.

C
Christine Badillo

Great variety of homemade ice cream! All flavors tasted so great that it was hard to choose which flavor to go with. We’re definitely coming back next time we’re in the area.

K
Kyla Burst

Made from scratch ice cream is amazing! Even the basic chocolate and vanilla are great. It's a cafe as well so they also offer a shot of espresso over ice cream which is delightful.

S
Sarah Smith

It's a little hard to find, back away from most of the other restaurants and shops, but well worth the hunt! There are plenty of flavors to choose from and even some dairy-free ice cream options, as well as fine chocolates and other interesting things. Also, their bowls and spoons are compostable!

J
Jennifer Miskell

Such a cute creamery! Love the location, right on the canal. The waffle cones are better than any others I've had and the ice cream is "to die for". Just tried Second Date and it's my new fav. My other fav is, To Sow My Wild Oats. Mmmmmm. But honestly you can't go wrong with any of them!

m
mariah tate

They are so wonderful. Every flavor is uniquely made. Absolutely delicious. We live 45 mins away, and we drive all the way just to get our ice cream.

C
Chad Naus

Love the unique ice cream options as well as the standard favorites. The staff meets you with a smile even with walking in minutes before closing. The location next to a small park gives you the opportunity to walk and enjoy your ice cream.

J
Jessica Minhinnett

I love ice cream! I have a little everyday. I am picky about my flavors. I don't mind spending a little more for good quality ice cream. This is by far the best ice cream in Fairport of course and also in Rochester! The flavors, sow my wild oats and I can't remember the name but it was a butterscotch and had Harry Potter in desciption anyway amazing. If you like coffee ice cream the coffee beck is for you if only I could describe how decadent it is. My 8 year olds favorite one. I can't get past those 3 to try a different one. I have sampled a few more flavors which were amazing as well. The staff even the owners are so friendly, they will take a few min if they aren't busy to talk to you and your family ask for opinion and thank you for coming in. It is a bit pricey compared to most places but in my opinion I would rather pay a little more for quality. I used to go to Brusters, then I found this place! Always tell people how wonderful it is and they have to try it

m
makenna cooper

I was worried id spend more then what i wanted or read about for ice cream waffle cones but it wasnt bad priced it was a nice store , clean, and the guy working earlier today was friendly and polite and gave me 2 cups that prevented ice cream waffle cone spill for free! For the people saying the empolyees suck well not all of them do apparently. :) this was our first time there eill be back again

C
Catherine

This place is such an enjoyable experience, and I cannot wait to return every time I walk out the door! Don’t be afraid to try some of the crazy flavors or toppings, they are so well crafted and you can count on the staff’s expertise to guide some new tastes. You can taste the difference in quality, there’s probably no such thing as healthy ice cream but if you care at all about what goes into your body, at least get ice cream here. once you have Moonlight’s ice cream, nothing else compares.

J
Jes S

The ice cream here is phenomenal and the people who work there are genuinely nice people. The flavors are amazing and switch up which will make you want to come back. 10 out of 10 would recommend everyone check out this place.

C
Caitlin Hart

Wow! Great homemade ice cream. The blackberry rose was phenomenal. We also got some rainbow cake pops that were awesome. The staff was friendly and knowledgeable. Great location if you want to get some ice cream and sit by the canal (or stay inside in the air conditioning and just enjoy a view of the canal). This will definitely become a recurring favorite for us.

N
Nolan Smith

Best Ice Cream in New York! This was my favorite spot before I had to move out of state. Definitely recommend this place to anyone.

A
Adam Snow

This is our go-to place for ice cream. We live in Fairport, and they always have a unique selection of top quality ice creams. They also sell truffles, and some other unique items (sodas and cookies). Highly recommended.

M
Mary Kirchgessner

Such a cute place in great atmosphere! The ice cream was amazing!!

M
Mike Bond

Great ice cream. All hand made by the staff. Very unique flavors. Like I had honey lavender...omg it was good. Amazing service and it over looks the canal. Only slight downside is a dish and a waffle cone regular was $14.. but you get what u pay for!

M
Matthew Krais

After being here only once, this is a yum rating of amazing. They make their own ice cream and not just normal flavors, they extend into thoughtfulness with "Lime in the Coconut". This is worth going over and trying. Even if ice cream isn't your thing, there is more including pie and desserts. First impression is that they are amazing, I will be going back.

A
Allison D

Great little ice cream shop in the heart of Fairport. Love that there’s a nice outdoor seating area overlooked the canal

M
Michelle King

I bought my Mom the dairy free ice cream, hoping it would be decent. It was beyond fantastic! So rich and creamy, without any funky texture or aftertaste. She's thrilled to be able to enjoy her favorite dessert again.

A
Aisha E K

Amazing ice cream! Just make sure you get one of the flavors in the white tubs which they make in house with local ingredients. I got the oatmeal ice cream which, if you like oatmeal, was so delicious. Very creamy, not too sweet and very satisfying. My kids were drawn to the truffles in animal shapes which were good as well. They have seating inside. And best part is that they are open during the winter as well.

J
Jamie H

Love homemade ice cream! There are so many unique varieties (my favorite...Oatmeal cookie), and everyone there is always so friendly. The price is comparable to any other ice cream place.

A
Alyssa Montgomery

Delicious creamery serving their own ice cream and Gifford's. Their ice cream was delicious, and their shop is cute. Staff is knowledgeable and very courteous. I had the cookie dough ice cream, and the cookie dough pieces were very sweeter and vanilla-y. Definitely worth a visit.

r
racerpoet

Moonlight Creamery is hidden gem in Fairport, tucked between the back of the Fairport Parking Garage and the Erie Canal. My friend and I accidently stumbled upon this place back in 2020 when we were cruising in our cars and decided we wanted to get ice cream. I've been coming here fairly regularly now. It's a great place to get ice cream and either go for a walk when it's nice out or sit inside on a colder day. I love the peaceful hum of freezers and the cozy atmosphere inside. It's a perfect place to go on a date for ice cream or coffee. They offer a wide variety of flavors, including many that are made in-house. (white ice cream buckets) The owner and staff are all pleasant. I highly recommend Moonlight Creamery! Tasty homemade ice cream flavors. Convenient hours. Friendly staff. Perfect location to walk along the canal.

A
Anders Wahl

Moonlight creamery has some great ice cream, and even better customer service. Mikey went above and beyond all expectations - the fact that he is not the owner was semi mind blowing. I have had worse customer service when ordering at 4 star restaurants, let alone a hidden Ice cream gem tucked away in the village of Fairport. Looking forward to coming back and continuing to explore all the awesome flavors. PS - get a waffle cone. 10 out of 10 would recommend!

S
Sandy Welch

We love ice cream, and indulge in it only when we find homemade. We were on a 4 day ride on the canal and got ice cream in every port we stopped. Moonlight creamery was not only the best ice cream on our trip but the best ice cream we have ever had. We are planning the 2hr trip back just to get it again. Hope they have our favorite flavor. I would like to add to my review...over 6yrs later, I have done nothing but dream about this place and tried to find an excuse to drive over 2hrs just for this ice cream. Low and behold, had to go to U of R for an MRI and was driving back when we saw the sign for Fairport. OMG, am I so glad we took the 3mi detour! Even more amazing than I remember. The frozen cocoa and to sow my wild oats are the best! So creamy! Only wish I could have it shipped! Here's hoping it's not another 6yrs before we get here again!

A
Aysel Akbas Yeniyildiz

Very nice and hygienic shop in the village of fairport with a beautiful canal view. Also very friendly customer service. Definitely worth every penny!

M
Matt D

Staff is always friendly and the ice cream is amazing. They also have great nondairy sorbet and other treats. You pay an extra buck or two here, but it's in a great spot on the canal, plenty of indoor and outdoor seating, and easy parking. Grab an ice cream and walk Main Street or the canal. We love this place!

I
Isabella H-A

I LOVE THIS PLACE. I get my ice cream cakes for my birthday every year now and try to make excuses to come whenever I can. They make the most beautiful cakes I've ever had. The store also has a wide variety of flavors at all times. All delicious. Please come here, I'm begging you!!

E
Enmanuel Hernandez

Love the chocolate ice cream. The flavor combinations are amazing and staff is very friendly. I think their chocolate ice cream is better than Pittsford dairy. It has 7 chocolates in it.

D
Derek Means

Always delicious and just as wonderful and friendly!

e
ella johnson

such a cute little ice cream place! i was very excited to see they had gluten free cones. it's important to note they rotate through the flavors on the website, so what you see on there might not be what they have in store!

R
Ramzi El Hassan

This might be the best ice cream I've ever had. So many fantastic flavors. They don't let you sample the flavors but I have never had a flavor I don't like. The owner is local and is frequently in the shop. He's a super nice guy.

J
Julie Chapus

This was an amazing find. Homemade ice cream, homemade truffles, specialty coffee and teas with lots of variety. Never even knew this place existed until tonight. We will definitely be back. The owner was very kind and took time to answer our questions about these tasty treats. I love supporting local business and when quality and kindness combine, I know I’ve found a favorite place. You will not be disappointed here, highly recommend checking moonlight creamery out.

K
Krista Khan

Really fabulous ice cream place. New owner is amazing, almost too many flavors to choose from and each one made in house and delicious! There are also dairy free and gluten free options, just ask. Looking forward to many more years filled with ice cream from here 🤩

K
Kelsey C.

Wonder flavors and very nice workers! If you are in the area I recommend stopping in!

S
Suzanna Law

Both of the times I have been to the Moonlight Creamery, I have had the best time. Staff are friendly and helpful, the ice creams have been enticing and delicious. Specifically, we love their oatmeal ice cream - creamy, decadent and soothing to the soul. They always have new and interesting flavours that their ice cream maestro is constantly developing - charming and delightful! Some may say that it may be a little pricey for ice cream. I say it's worth every penny. We're huge fans.

H
Haley Camp

Stopped by moonlight creamery during our visit to upstate New York. Delicious ice cream and great service. Spoke to an owner who was very kind and generous when my son ordered a flavor before realizing it wasn't what he wanted.

O
O

So when we came in the line was kind of really long and going slow however I really can't complain because there's a reason why there is a line and the ice cream and the employees were amazing very helpful I wouldn't change anything about this place really the waffle cones are awesome and one of the best I've ever had. My wife accidentally dropped her ice cream and the owner was nice enough to change it thank you so much I would highly recommend this place and I would come here again

C
Craig McMurtry

My family loves the ice cream! There are so many good flavors. Unfortunately for me, I can't eat it anymore due to a new legume allergy. The worker was very helpful and kept trying to find something that I could eat. He even brought the ingredient labels for me to see.

V
Vipul Agrawal

Mikey is amazing!!! 🤩 A lot of variety in flavors which are all good and oat meal was surprisingly outstanding

R
Rhonda Roberts

Me and my boyfriend came in on Valentine's day and the man working that night was an absolute sweetheart. I stood in front of the truffles for at least 5 minutes (no one else was there at the time) and he just talked to us like we where old friends of his. I got 3 of them and loved every single one. Absolutely wonderful food and that man working was fabulous.

D
Dani Doi

Looooooove this place! Their flavors are both insanely creative and delicious! They are completely made in house! There is always something new to try. I fell for their NY Sugar Maple & Candied Bacon - HARD. Also, don’t be afraid to try their balsamic vinegars on your ice creams. It sounds wild, but pair them just right and your ice-cream taste buds will never be the same again! And the owner, Mikey, has the warmest smile. He could easily melt an igloo with it. Ask him for recommendations!

J
Joann Lentz

Very nice ice cream shop. Kind of hidden, but worth the find. I was able to find an almondmilk ice cream so I could have a sundae. It was very good. Chocolate Almond Cherry ice cream. Yum!

B
Bat Woman

This a small place, packed with good taste and charm. I enjoyed the Wicked Chocolate and my friend had Peanut butter cookie dough. Both were very delicious! Nicely decorated and clean. The service was excellent and he knew all the flavors. It is a nice place to grab a few candies as well. So drop by and make some happy moments with family, your significant other, or friends. Won't be disappointed!

B
Bj Strong

Amazing ice cream shop in the village right on the canal. 90-95% of their ice cream is made in the shop. They have so many choices of flavors to choose from, they have something for everyone, including a few non dairy options. Prices are extremely reasonable and the people who run is are extremely accommodating.

J
Jan Prescott

Delicious! Right across from the public parking and a green space along the canal.

K
Kathryn VanKuren

I called to ask for a special treat for my nephew. It was very last minute and they were so busy when I called. I live in Florida and couldn’t be there to celebrate with family…. Mikey took my order and was so kind and sweet and willing to help me make my nephews day special. I was blown away at his kindness and willingness to help me out. 10/10. Thank you Mikey in the red shirt!

K
Kelly Chan

Such a great experience overall. The person I worked with was kind, helpful, and easy to communicate with, and you can tell they really care about the people who come through their doors. I wouldn’t hesitate to recommend them and would happily order again.

Lauren Hinett
Lauren Hinett

One of my favorite places in Fairport! Amazing flavors and the friendliest staff. Nothing better than getting some ice cream and then walking along the canal in the summer.

lord rom
lord rom

Excellent flavor to their home made icreams! Went up to Rochester to see my son at college and stopped in for desert. The owner is a great guy and has a beautiful shop right by the Erie Canal Bridge. Was an awesome experience. He found out my son loved rubber ducks and gave us a large NY duck for him(which he loved). We will be back next trip up!

Kenna Kelley
Kenna Kelley

We stopped from out of town just passing through for impromptu ice cream and it was amazing!! Freshest ice cream and waffle cone we’ve ever had! Workers were sweet, great vibes, reasonable prices. I wish we weren’t driving far so we could bring some home with us!

Huntz Shaikz
Huntz Shaikz

Creative flavors, great service- lady at the counter walked us through our first time and gave us perfect recommendations. The ice cream is airy but thick at the same time with such a rich taste. Tried strawberry, oats, mint, and cherry which were all stellar. We did an ice cream sampler which let us try one scoop of 4 flavors for $9. They have other desserts and drinks available as well.

David Deroo
David Deroo

Really good ice cream and little chocolates. Staff was really nice. Recommend to try if you haven't already.

Lisa Zoller
Lisa Zoller

Simply the best, most natural, authentic, and creative ice cream there is. First note, I am not even an "ice cream kind of person". My hubby and I are visiting friends who live in Fairport and they know my husband is an ice cream enthusiast and wanted for us to experience Moonlight Creamery. We had already tasted it when said friends brought samples to Philadelphia ( our home) last year. We loved it then but live and fresh surpassed our expectations. Mikey ( the owner) heard our story, and the fact that ice cream is not my "thing", and quickly converted me with his genius recipe's, exposure to various variations, and w/ creativity one can only experience w/ the finest chefs. Mikey's wild stories and crazy kindness made my night a special treat that will not be forgotten. Thanks Mikey, we will be back!!!

Kayte Engelman
Kayte Engelman

This place is fantastic! Not only were our treats amazing but the staff were wonderful and the place is so cute! Our crew of 5 had 3 with celiac and Mikey who helped us (I would assume is an owner or manager because he clearly loves his job) was so gracious and accommodating. This is rare for us to not seem like an inconvenience and to have someone who seemed pleased to be able to help us and others with food allergies. He was so patient as we wrangled 3 kiddos and figured out what everyone wanted. He suggested a modification in order to please a celiac kid and really made her feel great. They had 2 different gluten free cones which never happens! With celiac, soft serve is typically the only thing we can have and often feels disappointing but their in-house made soft serve was incredible! It wasn’t settling at all and I would continue to get it even if I could have the flavored ones. We recently went to the other ice cream shop by the bridge (with only one celiac person) and the experience stunk. I definitely felt like a nuisance when I asked the staff if they had anything GF for me to get and was handed a package to read myself. Mikey clearly works to make everyone feel included and welcome- and goes the extra mile to see smiles on all faces! Thank you Mikey and team :)

Patrick Cicchetti
Patrick Cicchetti

Amazing ice cream, amazinger customer service! We came here a couple weeks ago with family and the ice cream was so good that we just drove back from Brockport for more. To the guy who served us brown sugar oat around 8pm on Friday 7/12/25--you're the best!

Natalie Suflita
Natalie Suflita

Amazing. You know the homemade waffle cones are going to be good when you can smell their vanilla-y freshness when you walk in the door! Plus the ice cream flavors are out of the box enough to be creative w/ a touch fancy but simple enough to win on taste alone. I got a mini w/ half "Sow Your Wild Oats"; brown sugar ice cream with whole grain oats through out- it was the best, I'd definitely get it again. Also got half scoop Cherry Blossom which had chunks of frozen cherries without being soggy. A waffle cone on the side to keep my ice cream portion mini was perfect 😋

Fred vanhouten
Fred vanhouten

Nice out of the way artisan ice cream shop, located next to a small park with views of the canal. Staff is friendly and accommodating. Coffee and a large variety of chocolates are also available. Highly recommended.

Laura Elia
Laura Elia

I LOVE that I can get homemade creamy ice cream and some of my favorite higher end brands here. I can never decide, but they're always good. Absolutely my favorite place! Also, if they have the girl scout cookie or piece of cake, try them! Drool worthy!

Amanda Timmerman
Amanda Timmerman

So many yummy choices. Coffee, espresso, milkshakes, homemade ice creams including dairy free options, rice crispy treats and chocolate truffles. Definitely recommend

Synthia Simonsen
Synthia Simonsen

We were sooooo impressed with our experience here! The owner took amazing care of us and our six kids. He even gave our son a brownie of his own, as a gift, which had come from his mother’s for Valentine’s Day! We loved the chocolate, brown sugar oatmeal, Pb fudge swirl and praline ice creams. Thank you for being so kind and welcoming to us! We felt so welcome and cared for! There were tables and it is such a cute and cozy shop.

Teufel Hund
Teufel Hund

What an awesome location! Right next to public parking garage, right next to the canal. Clean location, fantastic ice cream and staff. Ice cream is 'home made' not commercial ice cream resold.... Selection was extensive. What's not to 💕?

Elizabeth Wilson
Elizabeth Wilson

They had dairy free options and were very good! These cones are the smallest size, just an FYI. Right by the canal it made for the perfect end to the night!

ashley harman
ashley harman

Moonlight is the cutest ice cream place with a great selection of both classic & creative flavors and fantastic customer service. Already can’t wait to come back and try their next round of rotating flavors. Mikey is phenomenal and will be sure to answer all your questions and treat you like royalty. Thanks for a great experience!

Desirée Adams
Desirée Adams

Amazing and generous ice cream servings! They have a huge variety if flavors, many are unique. Staff are warm and efficient. We recently tried the roasted strawberry and Annie Wants S'mores and they were excellent.

K
Kyle Flow

A bunch of flavors with a nice location next to the canal.

L
Linda Liu

Move over Pittsford Dairy! Moonlight Creamery is the place for ice cream for me. In my opinion, the ice cream here is a lot more flavorful. For instance, the pistachio ice cream here tasted like popping pistachio nuts right into your mouth, and the wild blueberry flavor tasted like blueberries straight off the vine. Both were really rich and creamy. I really recommend getting the waffle cone. I love that they let you get two flavors even in the smallest cone. Definitely more on the pricey side though. They also sell Moonstruck chocolates and other goodies.

B
Brendon Thomas

Ice cream delicious, but service is on the slower side every time I’ve been there. Great location though.

J
Jae

The positive: The quality of the ice cream is amazing. I got a milkshake made with 4 scoops of ice cream, my choice. I did 2 black raspberry and 2 vanilla and it was incredible. There are lots of flavors to choose from, their website lists them with certain flavors in their shop daily. Plenty of parking across the street in the parking garage and a small park nearby that faces the canal. The seating is limited outside as well as inside, I imagine on a busy day you would either need to take it to go or eat it on the run. The staff is nice and cheerful and make sure your order is correct. The negative: Very slow wait time. There were 4 people ahead of me with 2 people working and I must have waited 10 minutes just to order. I tried to order a Creamsicle float and the girl asked me what that was and after confirming she went to see if they had any orange soda in stock and they didn't. After moving down the line to the check out I noticed a case of orange soda on the floor behind the counter. The price is a little high, $7.50 for a milkshake but considering the quality I would be willing to pay that amount for a special treat. I would go back again but am hesitant to on a nice day because I think I would have to wait upwards of 30+ minutes to get an order of ice cream if it was busy. The seating also concerns me as there are only a few tables in the park and inside. But overall the quality was really good and the staff was nice and I did have a good experience.

J
Jen Groot

This place is beautifully located right next to the canal. Of the weather is nice, most of the people get an ice cream and then go hangout by the canal.

D
D. Sanchez

Lady, would not give us our chocolates until we checked out. Not sure if we looked like we were going to run away without paying. However, the ice cream was very good we had tiramisu. After we paid, all was good.

B
Bernie Allen

The ice cream is good but who is the genius who assigned only 2 workers on a Saturday that has a temperature of 80?! There was lots of customers and the owner should have anticipated that! A bit of a stubbed toe on April 15th.

S
Steven Vandevander

Can’t get a sample?!?! They have 20 + flavors and most sound unique, but you could never tell because they don’t allow the customers to sample. I had to get a flavor that was familiar to me. I asked the guy if the orange cardamom was any good and he said “ I wouldn’t get it”. I got black raspberry, it was okay, nothing special, but for the price you would have thought it would have been better.

R
Ryan Bates

Overpriced, $1.25 each for three stale waffle cones, AND to top it off, they no longer offer samples. So be prepared to potentially regret your decision. An itty-bitty is $5, that's their smallest size! Seriously save yourself a trip, they don't even make their own ice cream 🫤. My daughter wanted to try the strawberry sorbet and the strawberry ice cream, to see which one she liked better. The scooper of ice cream told us one is made with dairy and the sorbet is not. My daughter simply wanted to taste which had the most flavor. There are countless other ice cream places in the area that make their own ice cream AND allow you to taste the flavors before paying for it. I will not be coming back for ice cream anytime soon. Sadly, we used to like this place. Bottom line I left disappointed. Stale waffle cones and meh ice cream left a really sour taste in my mouth.

Kristin Dona
Kristin Dona

The ice cream itself was solid, nothing special but fine. However, the staff was extremely rude. They refused to give out samples (which is honestly part of the ice cream-buying experience) and when I asked for a cup instead of a cone, the employee acted like he didn’t know what I was talking about and said he “couldn’t put it in a coffee cup.” There are plenty of other great ice cream spots around, so I’d avoid supporting this place in the future. The ice cream isn't good enough to justify such poor customer service.

John Jack
John Jack

The ice cream was fine. I have never been to an ice cream shop that didn't offer samples tho. Weird take. One of the joys of going to an ice cream shop is trying a couple flavors to figure out what you want.

EA M
EA M

Good ice cream, but they deprive you of the age-old sampling experience. The flavor names don't always reveal what the flavor profile will be. Getting a few samples is how customers choose flavors and enjoy broadening their horizons. The owner even defended the practice to me as some sort of sustainability initiative. He seemed put off that I would have even expected to sample the flavors. Weird.

D
David Cook

Love the ice cream. Service was subpar. I don’t blame the kids working there. They were working their tails off. One teenage handling the whole operation. Shame on the owners.

C
Colleen Aschman

Not good. Ordered for delivery- They forgot a portion of the order, the “hot fudge” is actually just chocolate pudding, and the mint chocolate ice cream just tasted like peppermint schnapps. Completely inedible and would not recommend.

H
Hassina Sultani

I walked in today at 4:50 October 10. My daughter asked for a cone and three flavors. The worker there heard 1 flavor so she gave her all of one flavor. My daughter then politely told her that she had asked for mango, vanilla, and pineapple. She snatched it back from my daughters hand and huffed and sighed and just created a big deal. Rolling her eyes at us because she misheard us. Then she proceeded to hive her back all three flavors she wanted but purposely giving her the tiniest amount.

W
Warren

Bad service today. Rude and inappropriate. No reason they couldn’t be nice.

j
jake seagle

One star for the simple fact that they don't make their own ice cream but go out of their way to make it sound like they do. Maybe most of their stuff is homemade and they just happen to have some Gifford's to fill in some space? Either way if I go to a shop expecting homemade ice cream there shouldn't be some mix in flavors from a regional creamery. And be up front about it. I won't be back.

C
Cherish Allen

My husband and I were driving through the area and were up for some coffee. This place had great reviews and we wanted to try somewhere local and not a chain so we stopped in here to try it out. It seemed like a nice place and they seemed to have a great selection of coffees, teas, ice cream, and chocolates. The man behind the counter seemed to be changing out ice cream flavors or something of that nature when we walked in. He didn't look up or even acknowledge we had walked in or were at the counter looking at the coffee menu. He said nothing to us and continued to work on ice cream. No one else came to the counter. Four other patrons were there but at tables drinking coffee and talking. We decided on what we wanted to order. The man never greeted us, continued not to acknowledge we were even there, and continued to work with the ice cream even after my husband walked passed him to the other end of the counter. After about 5 minutes we ended up leaving not buying anything because we couldn't get the guy's acknowledgement to even place an order. Maybe it is good, if one can actually receive service. We understand he was busy working on something but even a simple "hi, I will be with you in a few minutes" would have been something.

Faça login para deixar uma avaliação

Entrar
👑 É seu? Reivindique GRÁTIS!

Remova anúncios e gerencie seu menu

Explore sua área

Mais restaurantes em Fairport →
📸

37 Fotos

Explore as fotos de Moonlight Creamery

Moonlight Creamery
Moonlight Creamery
Moonlight Creamery
Moonlight Creamery
Moonlight Creamery
+32 Mais
📍

Informações sobre Moonlight Creamery

Como chegar

36 West Ave, Fairport, NY 14450

Carregando mapa...
Moonlight Creamery
Toque para direções

Destaques

Muito bem avaliado
4.7/5 estrelas
💬
Muitas avaliações
660 avaliações
💰
Preço moderado
Nível de preço
👨‍🍳
ice_cream
Tipo de cozinha

Serviços

Café
🥡 Para Viagem
🚚 Entrega
🍴 Comer no Local

Opções de refeição

🍽️ Comer no Local
🥡 Para Viagem
🚚 Entrega

Info Restaurante

Estado
Verificado pelo proprietário
🕐 Horario Hoy
11AM-10PM
Avaliação
4.7/5
💬 Avaliações
660
💰 Nível de preço
$$
⏱️ Visita típica
People typically spend 15-45 min here
📞 Telefone
+1 585-223-0880
🌐 Site
moonlightcreamery.com
📋 Cardápio
Ver Cardápio

Comodidades

Acessível para cadeiras de rodas
💳 Cartões de crédito
📱 Pagamentos móveis
🏘️

O Bairro

Localização

36 West Ave, Fairport, NY 14450

📍 Explorar o Bairro

Weather
11°
Clima atualizado a cada hora · Empregos e eventos atualizados diariamente
First Baptist Church of Fairport Patrimônio

church building in New York, United States of America

A 130m
First Congregational Church of Fairport Patrimônio

historic building in Fairport, New York, United States

A 443m
🎮

Jogos

🎮 Ganha Pontos Enquanto Exploras!

Joga Find Me e troca pontos por descontos em Moonlight Creamery e outros restaurantes

🎮

Ganha Pontos em Moonlight Creamery!

Joga Find Me e troca recompensas aqui

Ganha pontos extra e troca-os por recompensas de Moonlight Creamery

🏆 Recompensas de Moonlight Creamery

💰

Desconto 10%

Em Moonlight Creamery

1000 pts
Disponível
🍽️

Aperitivo Grátis

Na tua próxima visita

2500 pts
Limitado
👑

Mesa VIP

Experiência premium

5000 pts
Exclusivo

para trocar recompensas e ganhar pontos

📋 Como funcionam as recompensas?

1

Joga Find Me

Cada 100 pontos de score = 1 ponto de recompensa

2

Acumula Pontos

Os workers ganham 2x pontos por partida

3

Troca Recompensas

Descontos, comida grátis e experiências VIP

Ligar
Deixar avaliação no Google
👑

É seu? Reivindique GRÁTIS!

Remova anúncios e gerencie seu menu

Inicia sessão e joga

Verifique seu email!

Sem password — enviamos-te um link por email

Enviamos um link de acesso

Verifica a pasta de spam se não o vires