Jerry's Pizza
Pizza · Middletown
Slice by slice, since 1985
Horário de Jerry's Pizza
Sobre Jerry's Pizza
Long-running pizzeria serving large, thin-crust slices & Italian grinders in unassuming digs.
O que dizem os clientes de Jerry's Pizza
Jerry's Pizza is known for its pizza with crispy crust and fresh ingredients, and their wings. Customers praise the friendly bartenders and staff. Some report slow service, especially with delivery, and inconsistent food quality.
Pratos populares
Ideal para
Tip: The business is large enough to have the bar and band in its own area, making it a great place for live music.
Perguntas frequentes sobre Jerry's Pizza
Avaliações de Jerry's Pizza Middletown
We had the large pepperoni pizza and the medium wings and the food was excellent. And the waitress was very nice. We will come back again
Middletown, CT has two locations: South Main St. Has been there over a decade menu is good. New spot on Washington St @ old biker bar Red Dog Saloon. Nice outdoor tables 2 eat out there. They deliver.
Had a white pie with ricotta, garlic, and a few different cheeses. Awesome pizza,,and the live music by Vinyl Countdown was a bonus. The business is large enough to have the bar and band in it's own area. Great food, great band, great time. Gotta get back there for another custom pizza soon.
Ashley made my first trip here fun and memorable. She's a pro, and being in the service industry myself I make a point to recognize excellent service when I experience it. Looking forward to trying some of the other things on the menu the next time I come in, but the pizza here is great!
Absolutely love this place! The pizza is hands-down some of the best I’ve had—crispy crust, fresh ingredients, and just the right balance of flavors. But what really sets this spot apart is the atmosphere and the incredible staff. The bartenders are not only talented but genuinely friendly, making you feel right at home whether you’re a regular or it’s your first visit. The entire team goes above and beyond to ensure everyone is taken care of, with fast, attentive service and great vibes all around. Whether you’re grabbing a slice, enjoying a full meal, or just hanging at the bar with a cocktail or cold beer, you’re in for a great time. Highly recommend this place for anyone who appreciates great food, awesome drinks, and top-notch service.
Maybe because it was busy but I felt as if I was a Bother to the bartender everything I ordered . She seemed stressed and grumpy. On the up side... The wings were the best that I have EVER had. The pizza ,although I did not have ,any,looked amazing and had that perfect pizza smell. The stage area for the band was perfect and provided cool lighting that just went along with the whole vibe of the night.
Was my first time here and glad I came in.. our server was vary nice and always checked on us asking if we needed anything. My friend got 2 slices classic cheese pizza and I had 2 slices of the Buffalo pizza (she did inform me ahead of time they add the chicken and sauce on top of the slices of cheese pizza which was fine with me) and they did not disappoint we ate both our slices leaving happy and satisfied. I will be returning again.
The drinks, Apps, and pasta were good. The service was lacking though. There were only 2 barkeeps with a full bar! They were asked to make drinks and service the tables! Insane... our bartender was so busy she kept forgetting our requests or to come back. I hope they can make a small change and add a couple of wait staff to cover the tables. Especially during their busy nights. That would have made our visit so much more enjoyable. The music bingo on Thursday night was fun and we would like to go back but only when they get the help. Hopefully, that will be soon!
It was okay. Had the salt and vinegar wings and they were very crispy but lacked much flavor. I asked for their hottest wing sauce and though it wasn't very hot for me it had a much better flavor than the salt and vinegar dry rub.
This place has amazing wings!! However the chicken ceasar wrap was absolutely atrocious. It was soo dry and just not good at all honestly. Not enough dressing in the slightest . I couldn't even finish it , it was disappointing but the wings definitely saved my meal !!! 10/10 wings and 1/10 for the wrap . I've had their pizza before as well it's amazing
ive ordered from Jerry's handful of times.the food is usually pretty good even if it typicclly takes 90 min from order for food to arrive. tonight I called after 2hrs of waiting and was told food was on its way. after another 30min I called back, get put on hold for 10 min. call back to tell them not to bother delivering to be told its out for delivery and walking up now. another 30 min and still no one. Unacceptable
As a former food service manager I wont be returning. The staff was great but the girl who took my order didnt take her gloves off between handling food and using the pos, didn't take them off after and from what I can tell didnt take them off in the 15 to 20 minutes I was waiting. I get food service is fast paced but the hell if I know what she touched in all that time without changing gloves and washing hands.
The sauce tasted like it came out of a jar… like great value sauce. The waitress was very grouchy. Service was very slow. No one at the table was happy with their food.
I ordered a large pizza half cheese half chicken well done through the Slice app. I was told 15-20 minutes the pizza would be ready. Upon arrival to pick up the pizza (25+ mins after order was placed) the pizza was not ready. It was being placed back into the oven and not ready. After 5 minutes it was ready. Upon getting it home and opening my half chicken half cheese pizza was not that. Only 2 slices had chicken on it and the rest was cheese. Also the pizza seamed much more in line with a medium and not a large. For $29 I expected so much more. Such bad value for what you get. To make makes worse it the quality was awful. It had no flavor, none. The chicken was bland. Barely any sauce or cheese. It was all so minimal and just tasteless. As I said I asked for well done and it was not even close to that. Barely done if you ask me. I contacted Slice app to let them know and see what they could do. The restaurant said they could offer 15% back. That’s just over $4. When I said that was not acceptable I was told that “the pizza was ready upon pickup (it was not) and that it was made up to their quality as they typically make it”. If this is their standard quality to how the typically make it then many will be disappointed, because that was not good. I won’t be ordering from them again as not only has this experience been bad but the last two have been sub par. I only gave them another shot because prior to the last two times they where great. I had been ordering from them since 2020. Clearly things have gone downhill and with all the other great spots in town this is no longer an option sadly.
They need to change there DoorDash so you know your not getting your food for 1 hour when you order it. They also only use one driver for DoorDash when they should be allowing other drivers to help with the hold up. Better not get my food cold.
Jerry’s used to be good pizza. Now? It’s like they gave up and decided “lazy and disgusting” was the new recipe. The meatballs tasted like they’d been rolled by someone who hates their job, and the pizza… my God. A gooey, slimy, greasy mess where everything slides off the second you pick it up. I’ve seen toddlers hold their diapers together better than this pizza holds its toppings. Update: The owner wanted me to “give them another chance.” No. My father—an authentic Italian who knows real pizza—took one bite and said, “This is the worst pizza I’ve ever had in my life.” I agree. I’m not out to ruin your business, I’m just telling the truth. People on Facebook backed me up—sure, a few said “eat in” is better, but delivery shouldn’t be the trash-tier knockoff of your in-house food. Jerry’s, you’ve gone from being a local favorite to a sad, greasy shadow of what you used to be. If this is you “trying,” I’d hate to see you on autopilot. 🤦🏽🤷🏽
for the price is could taste better. way to expensive. it also doesn't even look like the photos of the pizza's that they have displayed. it looks like i got this at a Chuck E. Cheese. the cheese look and taste plastic. it's so is not worth $21.00 because i got a medium cheese pizza with extra cheese in this looks like a small, not a medium! i'm so not happy!! i know good pizza. this is not it.
Faça login para deixar uma avaliação
EntrarRemova anúncios e gerencie seu menu
Explore sua área
Stella D’oro
Sliders Grill & Bar - Middletown, CT
Puerto Vallarta Middletown
Moonlight Sushi Bar & Grill
Big Cheese
Aroy Thai Garden
Dunkin'
Wayback Burgers
Niuda Noodle & Sushi
Shah's Halal Food - Middletown
7 Fotos
Explore as fotos de Jerry's Pizza
Informações sobre Jerry's Pizza
Como chegar
635 S Main St
Middletown, Connecticut 06457
Destaques
Info Restaurante
Comodidades
O Bairro
Localização
📍 Explorar o Bairro
Eventos Próximos
The Mandalorian and Grogu
29 mai. 2026, 19:30
The Paramount Theatre (Middletown, NY)
The Mandalorian and Grogu
30 mai. 2026, 13:30
The Paramount Theatre (Middletown, NY)
The Mandalorian and Grogu
02 jun. 2026, 13:30
The Paramount Theatre (Middletown, NY)
The Mandalorian and Grogu (Open Caption Showing)
03 jun. 2026, 13:30
The Paramount Theatre (Middletown, NY)
Jogos
🎮 Ganha Pontos Enquanto Exploras!
Joga Find Me e troca pontos por descontos em Jerry's Pizza e outros restaurantes
Ganha Pontos em Jerry's Pizza!
Joga Find Me e troca recompensas aqui
Ganha pontos extra e troca-os por recompensas de Jerry's Pizza
🏆 Recompensas de Jerry's Pizza
Desconto 10%
Em Jerry's Pizza
Aperitivo Grátis
Na tua próxima visita
Mesa VIP
Experiência premium
para trocar recompensas e ganhar pontos
📋 Como funcionam as recompensas?
Joga Find Me
Cada 100 pontos de score = 1 ponto de recompensa
Acumula Pontos
Os workers ganham 2x pontos por partida
Troca Recompensas
Descontos, comida grátis e experiências VIP
É seu? Reivindique GRÁTIS!
Remova anúncios e gerencie seu menu