Keys & Heels

My girlfriends & I finished our delicious dinner @ UVA & wanted to continue our evening & had been suggested to go to the bar next door! Perfect! Love the Name & Bar Front! So glad We did! First: the decor, lighting, music! A+! So inviting! Once seated- we were greeted & served water & presented with a drink menu that was filled with cool drinks! Very delish as well! Service A+ - Servers were very attentive & genuinely friendly! James the Manager paid us a visit & We couldn’t have made a better decision than visiting this Hotspot! James invited us to come the next night because Uncle Mike The DJ would be spinning the Tunes & promised to be a Great night! James was right! Friday night was even better than night before! We met some great people from other US cities- all ages ! James & The K & H Staff were very gracious & welcoming ! Definitely will visit next time in NYC & suggest to visitors check this Bar out! We had a great visit from Toronto! Cheers ! Until next time! 🩵🍸🎶🗽

I had a Pretty Little Psycho and Keys Spritz Bomb. I loved them both. Thanks for the dj <3 I really enjoyed my night.

Fun bar! Space is a little tight if it’s a busy night. Staff is attentive and nice. The drinks are strong and tasty!

What a good atmosphere, it was a pleasant experience. I was walking around the neighborhood and noticed this place. It's worth it. Nice drinks and music . My favorite place to have fun .

The manager was really friendly and the drinks were great. It’s a nice space!

+3

Made a reservation around an hour before going in on a Friday evening, we got great service and the drinks were good! Fun ambience

Amazing spot! Such a good speakeasy! Delicious cocktails. The staff have always been the kindest. And our servers have made an effort to get to know us and make us feel welcome.

10/10! My cute little place :) drinks on spot yes you get what you pay for so it is on the expensive side but you will de glove it!

+1

Recently been to this hidden gem on UES for a friend's birthday. Swanky place and great service combined with unique, expensive cocktails and food. Got barefoot/topless- light and refreshing summery drink, adulting - got a nice kick from this drink. We requested for a specific whiskey and the waitress went above and beyond to get it for us. There's a DJ who spins 80s music. Had a great time!

Went here with a bunch of girlfriends and loved it. Getting into a speakeasy can be a little intimidating but the staff here was so kind and welcoming, impressive, and professional. One thing I’ll say is def reserve a table if you want to have seating! A little loud for a first date but so fun and great music. We even met the manager and he was so lovely and kind!

Amara is so lovely! We had such a great time thanks to her.

Fantastic place, 10/10 experience! We went for the Magic Show and it didn’t disappoint. Such a fun evening, kind staff, and delicious drinks.

Worked with Jayne on a private engagement party for 30+ people. Everything was awesome and there were no hiccups at all. Food. Drinks. Bartenders. Servers. Music. The best. Would do it the exact same way again if the opportunity presents itself.

Keys & Heels was INCREDIBLE—truly the highlight of the weekend. The Friday night DJ was perfection and set the exact vibe you want for a fun night out. The playlist was ROCKIN! It’s the perfect spot for a date night or a girls’ night on the town. The vibe is cool, fun, and a little spunky in the best way. The staff was super nice, the bartenders were excellent, and the drinks were absolutely delicious. Truly a hidden gem. A must-visit spot in NYC!

Absolutely loved this bar, playlist and vibe! They have fun coasters, cocktails and matches! Shoutout to Jo the server ! Especially difficult to do a walk-in even with just 2 people. Highly recommend a reservation.

Professional level cocktails - love the mezcal options, plus the Espresso Martini is their own unique take on a classic. It’s amazing. Well executed speakeasy vibes and a must visit for UES.

💯💯💯💯💯 Just discovered this hidden gem on the Upper East Side — a true speakeasy with an incredible cocktail list and an unbelievably sexy vibe. Every drink was a masterpiece, the lighting and music set the perfect mood, and the whole place feels like a secret you’re lucky to know about. Definitely one of the coolest spots uptown.

The drinks here are no joke—bold, intense, and full of personality. If you’re into strong cocktails with a creative twist, this is the spot. Alter Ego is smoky and complex, while Little Pretty Psycho might just be the spiciest cocktail I’ve ever had—seriously, it’s wild. As a speakeasy, the vibe is dark and crowded, with menus hard to read in the low light. The space feels intimate, but the live DJ keeps the music loud—so don’t expect deep conversations or a first-date-friendly setting. If you want a table, definitely book ahead.

Love the aesthetic here so much we took our engagement photos here! Jayne was so great to coordinate with and the staff is so nice. Such a fun spot on the UES with a cool vibe and amazing cocktails

Super cool Speakeasy on the UES. A Cocktail bar located directly behind a locksmith. There’s a covered entrance with a hostess. Reservations are highly recommended if you’re going later in the evening. They open at 6 Wednesday through Saturday and close at 1 weeknights and 2 on weekends. Cocktails are fun and creative. Such a unique concept, and so much fun.

Thought I’d get my keys fixed but got my cocktail fix instead, shoutout Mana for the drink recommendations and hospitality <3

Catherine Dougherty

Keys & Heels was INCREDIBLE—truly the highlight of the weekend. The Friday night DJ was perfection and set the exact vibe you want for a fun night out. The playlist was ROCKIN! It’s the perfect spot for a date night or a girls’ night on the town. The vibe is cool, fun, and a little spunky in the best way. The staff was super nice, the bartenders were excellent, and the drinks were absolutely delicious. Truly a hidden gem. A must-visit spot in NYC!

Jessica Bachansingh

Absolutely loved this bar, playlist and vibe! They have fun coasters, cocktails and matches! Shoutout to Jo the server ! Especially difficult to do a walk-in even with just 2 people. Highly recommend a reservation.

Novice New Yorker

Professional level cocktails - love the mezcal options, plus the Espresso Martini is their own unique take on a classic. It’s amazing. Well executed speakeasy vibes and a must visit for UES.

酒酣时分When Wine

The drinks here are no joke—bold, intense, and full of personality. If you’re into strong cocktails with a creative twist, this is the spot. Alter Ego is smoky and complex, while Little Pretty Psycho might just be the spiciest cocktail I’ve ever had—seriously, it’s wild. As a speakeasy, the vibe is dark and crowded, with menus hard to read in the low light. The space feels intimate, but the live DJ keeps the music loud—so don’t expect deep conversations or a first-date-friendly setting. If you want a table, definitely book ahead.

Alexandra Roat

Love the aesthetic here so much we took our engagement photos here! Jayne was so great to coordinate with and the staff is so nice. Such a fun spot on the UES with a cool vibe and amazing cocktails

A.L. Harris

Super cool Speakeasy on the UES. A Cocktail bar located directly behind a locksmith. There’s a covered entrance with a hostess. Reservations are highly recommended if you’re going later in the evening. They open at 6 Wednesday through Saturday and close at 1 weeknights and 2 on weekends. Cocktails are fun and creative. Such a unique concept, and so much fun.

Kamesvari Weathers

Thought I’d get my keys fixed but got my cocktail fix instead, shoutout Mana for the drink recommendations and hospitality <3

Natalia Suarez

Made a reservation around an hour before going in on a Friday evening, we got great service and the drinks were good! Fun ambience

super cute speakeasy. I went for their magic show and really enjoyed it! Small, intimate setting. Tasty drinks. It was great to see tricks so up close and personal.

Love this place so much — easy 5 stars ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Keys & Heels is hands down one of the chicest, most special spots in the neighborhood. From the moment you walk in, the speakeasy vibe just hits — moody, stylish, and effortlessly cool without trying too hard. The cocktails are so good (like, the kind you think about days later), and the music is always on point — fun, energetic, but still perfect for actually talking and enjoying the night. The staff truly make it though. They’re welcoming, fun, and somehow always know how to read the room. Whether you’re there for a casual drink or celebrating something big, they make it feel like an occasion. The crowd is great too — it’s the kind of place where you actually meet interesting, friendly people. This place means even more to me personally because I met my fiancé here on our first date 🥹 We’ve come back over the years to celebrate promotions, new jobs, and big life moments, and they’ve always made those nights feel extra special. Recently, they even let us take some engagement photos there, which meant the world to us. Having those memories tied to a place that’s already such a part of our story is something we’ll treasure forever. If you want incredible drinks, amazing energy, and a place that feels both cool and meaningful, Keys & Heels is it. Could not recommend more.

We hosted a private party at Keys & Heels, and everything was perfect. The staff was incredibly responsive and flexible during planning, and the night of the event they went above and beyond. There were plenty of staff helping with everything, the bartenders were fantastic, and the food was excellent. The space itself is beautiful and ideal for an intimate gathering. Everyone commented on how great everything was from start to finish. I’d host another event here in a heartbeat!

I've been to Keys & Heels many times and it always delivers — the drinks & bites are excellent, service is great, and the atmosphere is fantastic. I recently went for their Magic Unlocked show, and it was outstanding! Highly recommend for a great night out on the UES.

Giving an extra ⭐️ for service, all thanks to Jovanya! (I hope I spelled it right!) We came in with a group of friends and the place was already heaving, but that didn't seem to phase our lovely server. She was not only knowledgeable about the menu, but also provided great entertainment with her sharp wit! Our glasses were never empty for long. Incredible service and a great night out. Cocktails, to die for. We will definitely be back!

Great space with a lovely lounge and comfy seating. The cocktails were quite good, really loved that they were booze forward on the palette and not overly sweet. Definitely would recommend a visit here. Several in our group really loved the Upper East Side

Alexandra Kiernan

Love this place so much — easy 5 stars ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Keys & Heels is hands down one of the chicest, most special spots in the neighborhood. From the moment you walk in, the speakeasy vibe just hits — moody, stylish, and effortlessly cool without trying too hard. The cocktails are so good (like, the kind you think about days later), and the music is always on point — fun, energetic, but still perfect for actually talking and enjoying the night. The staff truly make it though. They’re welcoming, fun, and somehow always know how to read the room. Whether you’re there for a casual drink or celebrating something big, they make it feel like an occasion. The crowd is great too — it’s the kind of place where you actually meet interesting, friendly people. This place means even more to me personally because I met my fiancé here on our first date 🥹 We’ve come back over the years to celebrate promotions, new jobs, and big life moments, and they’ve always made those nights feel extra special. Recently, they even let us take some engagement photos there, which meant the world to us. Having those memories tied to a place that’s already such a part of our story is something we’ll treasure forever. If you want incredible drinks, amazing energy, and a place that feels both cool and meaningful, Keys & Heels is it. Could not recommend more.

Brynja S

I've been to Keys & Heels many times and it always delivers — the drinks & bites are excellent, service is great, and the atmosphere is fantastic. I recently went for their Magic Unlocked show, and it was outstanding! Highly recommend for a great night out on the UES.

Lauren Genshaft Cohen

We hosted a private party at Keys & Heels, and everything was perfect. The staff was incredibly responsive and flexible during planning, and the night of the event they went above and beyond. There were plenty of staff helping with everything, the bartenders were fantastic, and the food was excellent. The space itself is beautiful and ideal for an intimate gathering. Everyone commented on how great everything was from start to finish. I’d host another event here in a heartbeat!

Emma Barron

super cute speakeasy. I went for their magic show and really enjoyed it! Small, intimate setting. Tasty drinks. It was great to see tricks so up close and personal.

Fabrizio Uberti Bona

💯💯💯💯💯 Just discovered this hidden gem on the Upper East Side — a true speakeasy with an incredible cocktail list and an unbelievably sexy vibe. Every drink was a masterpiece, the lighting and music set the perfect mood, and the whole place feels like a secret you’re lucky to know about. Definitely one of the coolest spots uptown.

Christopher McDonald

Giving an extra ⭐️ for service, all thanks to Jovanya! (I hope I spelled it right!) We came in with a group of friends and the place was already heaving, but that didn't seem to phase our lovely server. She was not only knowledgeable about the menu, but also provided great entertainment with her sharp wit! Our glasses were never empty for long. Incredible service and a great night out. Cocktails, to die for. We will definitely be back!

Kaitlyn Kline

Great space with a lovely lounge and comfy seating. The cocktails were quite good, really loved that they were booze forward on the palette and not overly sweet. Definitely would recommend a visit here. Several in our group really loved the Upper East Side

Cute! A very fun "speakeasy" vibe. I only got a mocktail, which was overly sweet, but the mocktail michelada was tasty and the other people I went with liked their cocktails.

Fun ues spot - just had cocktails, keys spritz bomb and a tequila margarita-esque drink which was the favorite of the two

Great speak easy. Really nice environment. Drinks are awesome food is just okay. I was really tempted to try the sandwich but it was disappointing. It’s better to be inside but it’s usually crowded.

Is it a club? A speakeasy? Both? I'd say it's more club than speakeasy like 2nd Floor nearby on 75th, but not nearly as intense as the other 70s themed place on the UES, Ethyl's. It's more sophisticated both in vibe and in menu. I only stopped in to see what's happening in the neighborhood and got a single cocktail (the Weekend Upstate) which wasn't *bad*, but it certainly wasn't $18 good. I'm hoping that other drinks on the menu are a little better, but at the price, it's difficult to taste test everything. Maybe next time! Overall seems to be a really cool addition to the neighborhood, and the theming is great. Will be back to try some of their other drink options!

Overall rating 4.3, average is valid. This is not a speakeasy.. I feel like in order to be a speakeasy, you actually have to have a “front” (see PDT, bathtub gin, back room, garrett, etc). This is a bar with a key-making window. There is a bouncer & a hostess outside. Drinks were good. I got the barefoot & topless which was very light / borderline tasted like water. Not pictured, I also got the Good Night Negroni which was more my speed. Arrived around 7 on a Thursday & was able to “walk in” by 7:30. Reasonably crowded, but mostly women. I could come here again if I was in the area, but won’t be seeking out or recommending.

Ahmed Gewiley

Is it a club? A speakeasy? Both? I'd say it's more club than speakeasy like 2nd Floor nearby on 75th, but not nearly as intense as the other 70s themed place on the UES, Ethyl's. It's more sophisticated both in vibe and in menu. I only stopped in to see what's happening in the neighborhood and got a single cocktail (the Weekend Upstate) which wasn't *bad*, but it certainly wasn't $18 good. I'm hoping that other drinks on the menu are a little better, but at the price, it's difficult to taste test everything. Maybe next time! Overall seems to be a really cool addition to the neighborhood, and the theming is great. Will be back to try some of their other drink options!

Olivia N

Overall rating 4.3, average is valid. This is not a speakeasy.. I feel like in order to be a speakeasy, you actually have to have a “front” (see PDT, bathtub gin, back room, garrett, etc). This is a bar with a key-making window. There is a bouncer & a hostess outside. Drinks were good. I got the barefoot & topless which was very light / borderline tasted like water. Not pictured, I also got the Good Night Negroni which was more my speed. Arrived around 7 on a Thursday & was able to “walk in” by 7:30. Reasonably crowded, but mostly women. I could come here again if I was in the area, but won’t be seeking out or recommending.

I had a great time with a group of friends. My only complaint is that the manager was very rude and hostile to me when I sat down. But the cocktails are great and so is the rest of the staff. They were very accommodating to my large group.

For the area it was what we were looking for. We couldn't sit down, standing room only. My drink wasn't out of this world but the bar tender was very friendly and hard working. At first I thought the music was too loud, but by the time the disco ball came on we were loving the music selection. Lots of 60s-80s. Live DJ.

The cocktails here were well presented and made. Got to taste 5 different cocktails and while none were bad, none blew my socks off either. The music was also a bit too loud. Had to constantly yell to hear each other. All in all I’d say it’s still worth the experience of a cool speak easy.

In love with Speakeasies!!! Love to find a cocktail bar hidden behind a locksmith/shoe repair store. The crown was pretty rude and snobby. The only ckcktail i tried was good. Reserve via resy, tables releasing every Tursday

Alana Smith

For the area it was what we were looking for. We couldn't sit down, standing room only. My drink wasn't out of this world but the bar tender was very friendly and hard working. At first I thought the music was too loud, but by the time the disco ball came on we were loving the music selection. Lots of 60s-80s. Live DJ.

Josue Cifuentes

The cocktails here were well presented and made. Got to taste 5 different cocktails and while none were bad, none blew my socks off either. The music was also a bit too loud. Had to constantly yell to hear each other. All in all I’d say it’s still worth the experience of a cool speak easy.

Kiariladyboss

In love with Speakeasies!!! Love to find a cocktail bar hidden behind a locksmith/shoe repair store. The crown was pretty rude and snobby. The only ckcktail i tried was good. Reserve via resy, tables releasing every Tursday

I want to preface this review by saying that I have worked in restaurants before. We all have “off” days, but we only have one chance to make a first impression. After a year of wanting to visit this spot, I was finally able to get a reservation for myself and fiancé. Due to multiple train delays my reservation was for 7:45 PM, but I was running 15 minutes late. I called the restaurant multiple times but no one answered. I had read their table policy and that they only hold reservations for 15 minutes so therefore, I knew there was a strong chance I would not be able to be seated or would have to wait. I was OK with this because I knew that was their policy. I arrived at the restaurant. I was greeted by a rude standoffish hostess. I informed her that I had a reservation, but unfortunately was running late and was OK with waiting. She rolled her eyes and said”you know we only hold tables for 15 minute’s, right?” To which i politely said yes and noted I would be happy to be put on a wait less. She DIDN’T even respond and just walked off. This was our first time at this place and we weren’t sure if she was going inside to check on tables or what. We waited and then she came to us and said “here” and pointed at a random Table. My fiancé and I were taken aback. We STILL ordered over $100 in drinks and snacks. Our server was amazing and the manager on duty (Saturday night) was also really pleasant. However, that interaction left a really bad taste in our mouths. Times are tough, but I would rather spend my money in a place where I feel welcomed from beginning to end. Very disappointing.

My girlfriend and I was there around 2 weeks ago. We had fun the drinks were great however it looks like the staffs were drinking as well especially our Busser seemed off with slurring speech nice skinny tall guy told us his name was Jay or JJ. I’m not one to judge but creates lack of service and becomes a safety issue for their establishment. I would recommend this place to friends and family for great cocktails.

Last friday I went to visit this place on my vacation because my friend recommended visiting if I on NYC but when arriving there, the bartender had an attitude and I received a awful service, I’m order three times my drinks and I never receive my drink I was waiting and waiting and him bring me my drink after a long time in my personal opinion this place has a good presentation a good drinks everything is good but the bartender was drunk and is not a good impression for a customer …I tex to my friend and I’m explaining that situation and I told him I never come back to this place …! I DIDN’T GET A GOOD SERVICE FROM THE BARTENDER!

The drinks were not so good, they were okay. We decided to order some food, and we ordered the Focaccia for $12 plus tax. When it came to the table we were very disappointed to find out that it is two pieces of bread, that wasn't even fresh!!! The kind of bread you buy at the grocery store and sits in your kitchen for a few days, and they are giving only 2 pices of it for $12! (Uploaded picture of the food) How are they not ashamed to give it to their customers?! And why the hell 2 pieces cost $12 dollars?!?! Overall, we were disappointed and upset. We won't go back and we will recommend all of our friends not to go there!!