Chris P

Great pizza shop in the Lower East Side. Large slices, good variety of toppings (if you choose), quality dough, sauce, and cheese, and cooked to perfection. It does get busy, but moves quick, and the outdoor table are usually open for seating.

Thomas the White

Williamsburg Pizza I’d always a great idea for a fantastic slice. Hands down my favorite place to get a slice of pizza downtown. Always perfectly cooked. Everything is good. (The Margherita is probably the best I’ve ever had.)

+2

Juan Lima

Been here several times. Surprised I haven't posted a review. The paesano, Cup and Char Grandma sicilian slices were crunchy and exceptionally delicious. This is a place to stop by for a quick bite to eat. Lots of goodies and friendly service.

RC

Love the Margherita pizza especially because bet crust is so crunchy. Fresh ingredients. I can’t get enough of it. On the other hand, the tartofu was aromatic with truffle oil but in my opinion it needed a little salt to taste. Great place to get a slice of quality pizza. From cheese slice to grandma.

+2

CIRCUIT TREE

My opinion of whether pieces is classic cheese and sauce. These two ingredients are essential for me when eating a pizza. I don't always need cheese and sauce on my pizza to call the pizza. And this was a great example of a unbelievably good non-traditional Pizza especially considering the fact that it is a vegan Square. I don't know what kind of creamy sauce they had on here but it was unbelievable and all the caramelized veggies just made it so good that I couldn't stop eating for a second. I was contemplating on getting another Square that's how good it was. I just couldn't because I was in a rush. If you are vegan then this pizza is perfect for you. If you are not a vegan then this pizza is also perfect for you.

+3

carlos borges

Solid slice of pizza. They're open late on the weekends which is a life saver. I had the plain slice. It's good. I had the Margherita which was ok. Nice size to the slices. The staff was friendly. I appreciate the good service. The dining area can use some cleaning. It's a little grimey in some areas.

+1

Taurus Michel

Stumbled on Williamsburg Pizza while looking for a pastry place. I'm in NY, gotta get a slice, right? But the meatball sandwich caught my eye. So glad it did. Good portion for the price. Big, juicy meatballs. Tomato sauce was chunky, savoury with the right amount of sweet. Held in place by toasty roll with a generous helping of melted mozzarella. A pair of buttery homemade chocolate chip cookies and I have to say, good lunch.

+3

Raisa Raha

Was craving a slice, so I came by for the fist time. Always walk by it to/from work and they have decent reviews so I thought why not. Granted, I came in a bit late, so the pizza was not fresh. But it was so tough and dry. It tasted like it was heated over and over again that it hurt the roof of my mouth. I couldn’t eat the crust, and crust is (weirdly) my favorite part of a pizza slice. Disappointed, but it just happens sometimes I guess

Irene Jayma

Probably won’t repeat a trip there, but still ate most my pizza. Had a regular slice, grandma slice and a mushroom. None of them were great. The staff was nice and diligent. The ambiance was dingy and there were people inside panhandling. Vegan and vegetarian options.

Maurice Mizrahi

Pizza as floppy as it gets! I got a reg slice and it had pepperoni which I am highly allergic to, when I said and showed them the pepperoni before I even ate it I asked for a refund. From there they got very disrespectful telling me I cannot get my money back. I asked for a refund becouse my Uber was outside at that point. They told me it’s a fixable mistake… not if I ate it tho. Very bad service, horrible in fact

David M

I usually love the pizza here, and the pizza quality was fine. The service I received was absolutely abhorrent. While in line, I noticed that they had a new pie cooking in the back oven… Curious to know what fresh pizza was cooking, I inquired about the type of pie getting freshly baked in the back and was told “that is a pizza” (period) — as though I was too dumb to notice that pizza was being made at a pizza restaurant. Worst, however, was when I didn’t notice my order being called out (it happens). Instead of getting my attention like any other human being (for example “hey,” “bro,” “man,” “amigo,” or anything humane), he slammed the metal pizza tray repeatedly on the glass pizza case right next to me and in my direction to tell me that my order was ready. He knew exactly whose order it belonged to; it was not an unknown person. Moreover, it was not busy at the time with no one in line and only two others dining in. Truly unnecessary and demeaning. If you want to go to a place that treats you like an animal, this is your place. If not, steer clear, as there are plenty of excellent pizza restaurants elsewhere that treat customers like human beings, not animals.

Brian Cox

By far the worst pizza I’ve had in the city. Got a grandma slice around 7pm. Tasted old, like it had been sitting since the afternoon. Took 10 mins for the immature, obnoxious backwards hat guys working the counter to stop man-flirting and actually start heating up the pizza. Once they did, they left it in for maybe 30 seconds, so it was cold. Chewy, old, and cold. Ate half, threw away the rest. It’s harder to make a bad slice, and these guys worked really hard at doing just that.