Classic Pizza

Staten Island has the best pizzerias in the world, and this is one of the best in Staten Island. I stop in whenever I pass by. Only a couple of tables, and a very small parking lot. No napkins when I was there last, but great pizza.

Best pizza on staten island. Closest thing I've had to a good brooklyn pizza in forever. Good prices, friendly staff, amazing food

Just ordered a pepperoni pizza, asked for well done. Good job! Was very good. Nice crisp. Welcome to the neighborhood.

Pizza is great, employees are kind, and prices are fantastic! Super happy to live by this place!

One of the best pizzas I've ever eaten, I'm very happy to have discovered this place.

Great overall pizzeria and they are very generous with extras!

If you have not tried Classic Pizza, start now. Tremendous menu and plenty to choose from. Your biggest problem will be deciding what you want to eat. The white pie, the Sicilian and my new favorite, chicken bruschetta.

My 7 year old said this pizza is 10 out of 10! The zeppoles were soft and FRESH!!!! The pizza was excellent very tasty and soft dough. Minestrone soups was delicious! Definitely coming back here ! Customer service was great also very friendly!

Fior

Pizza is great, employees are kind, and prices are fantastic! Super happy to live by this place!

Mark Russo

Great overall pizzeria and they are very generous with extras!

J Ricci

Just ordered a pepperoni pizza, asked for well done. Good job! Was very good. Nice crisp. Welcome to the neighborhood.

Cristiana Araújo

One of the best pizzas I've ever eaten, I'm very happy to have discovered this place.

Thomas Tracy

Best pizza on staten island. Closest thing I've had to a good brooklyn pizza in forever. Good prices, friendly staff, amazing food

Mike Remini

If you have not tried Classic Pizza, start now. Tremendous menu and plenty to choose from. Your biggest problem will be deciding what you want to eat. The white pie, the Sicilian and my new favorite, chicken bruschetta.

Giselle J

My 7 year old said this pizza is 10 out of 10! The zeppoles were soft and FRESH!!!! The pizza was excellent very tasty and soft dough. Minestrone soups was delicious! Definitely coming back here ! Customer service was great also very friendly!

steve rossiter

Classic is the best. My family & I have been customers for over 30 years. Incredible pizza & food and phenomenal & friendly customer service... a neighborhood staple and the best around. I no longer live in Staten Island but whenever I come back home the first thing I do is order from Classic.

Joseph Raspa

Staten Island has the best pizzerias in the world, and this is one of the best in Staten Island. I stop in whenever I pass by. Only a couple of tables, and a very small parking lot. No napkins when I was there last, but great pizza.

Anthony Bobo

One of the best pizzerias in Staten Island. Always fresh and the pies are huge. Their rolls are also delicious so are their salads. My favorite are the garlic knots with vodka sauce and mozzarella you must try it.

They make very good pizza. Ot could be 5 stars if their cheese pizza was a bit thicker

Pretty good pizza at a good price. Also worth trying are the mozzarella sticks and zeppoles. Parking lot is a little on the tiny side. Definitely more of a take out or delivery spot.

brendan kane

Pretty good pizza at a good price. Also worth trying are the mozzarella sticks and zeppoles. Parking lot is a little on the tiny side. Definitely more of a take out or delivery spot.

aziz bahh

They make very good pizza. Ot could be 5 stars if their cheese pizza was a bit thicker

I don't usually leave any reviews under 4 stars, and I'm not going to be unfair to the establishment and leave a 1 star, but I was really disappointed with what I got. I ordered a few slices of buffalo pizza and a Caesar salad. The pizza was fine enough. The salad that I was charged $8 (for a small) was extremely lazy and disappointing. It was quite literally lettuce with Caesar dressing. No croutons, no black olives, no fresh Parmesan cheese. Lettuce and Caesar dressing for $8. There's no excuse for that.

Andrew

I don't usually leave any reviews under 4 stars, and I'm not going to be unfair to the establishment and leave a 1 star, but I was really disappointed with what I got. I ordered a few slices of buffalo pizza and a Caesar salad. The pizza was fine enough. The salad that I was charged $8 (for a small) was extremely lazy and disappointing. It was quite literally lettuce with Caesar dressing. No croutons, no black olives, no fresh Parmesan cheese. Lettuce and Caesar dressing for $8. There's no excuse for that.

Just received my order from you guys and we ordered baked ziti and it tastes absolutely horrible. The sauce is seriously orange and it doesn’t even taste like baked ziti at all. Taste more like mac & cheese with Parmesan mixed in. Not tasteful at all. So upset I had to waste this, because it’s surely not edible. Never ordering this again smh

No restaurant should have groups of men in dark clothing approaching cars at night, especially when it puts drivers—particularly women alone—into such a frightening position. Stop doing this to advertise your business. I’ve never been to this restaurant, so I can’t comment on it. My review is strictly about their shocking and unsafe way of advertising. The other night (Sunday around 9pm), I was driving down Woodrow Road when three or four men dressed in dark clothing were standing in the middle of the street, trying to flag me down. I could barely see them and had no idea why they would be standing in a line in the middle of the road. I had to swerve into the opposite lane just to avoid them. Unfortunately, I got stuck at a red light shortly after. That’s when they started approaching my car from behind. As a woman alone at night, I was terrified. I inched my car forward, debating if I should risk running the light, but there was too much traffic. I was screaming at them as they approached my car to get away from my car but they still kept coming closer. Their response? “We have a menu.” Even as I was yelling and clearly distressed, they didn’t stop. One of them even got close enough to stick a menu into my rear window. That means they ignored me screaming the entire time. This is an incredibly unsafe and inappropriate way to advertise. No restaurant should have groups of men in dark clothing approaching cars at night, especially when it puts drivers—particularly women alone—into such a frightening position. It is a known thing that this is how a trafficking scenario plays out. I would have to be an idiot to roll down my window for a group of men as a women in the car alone at night. Please stop doing this. Maybe do something a little safer for those guys in the middle of the road, like make a TikTok.

My partner and I had business nearby so we parked outside and left for about 30 minutes with the intention of coming back for a slice. What we came back to was our car defaced with a sticker on the window claiming we were parked illegally (not filled out, probably ordered from amazon) and two people (presumably the owners) outside sitting in chairs looking smugly. They decided to confront us, asking if we were stupid and if we thought the parking lot was for general use. (There are multiple businesses that share the lot) and claimed it was their parking lot and not to park there. Needless to say, with the attitude of the owners and the frankly dilapidated look of the building, we decided not to give them any business. If this is how you decide to treat potential customers, it doesn't matter how good your pizza is.

Christina Torres

Just received my order from you guys and we ordered baked ziti and it tastes absolutely horrible. The sauce is seriously orange and it doesn’t even taste like baked ziti at all. Taste more like mac & cheese with Parmesan mixed in. Not tasteful at all. So upset I had to waste this, because it’s surely not edible. Never ordering this again smh

Cynthia

No restaurant should have groups of men in dark clothing approaching cars at night, especially when it puts drivers—particularly women alone—into such a frightening position. Stop doing this to advertise your business. I’ve never been to this restaurant, so I can’t comment on it. My review is strictly about their shocking and unsafe way of advertising. The other night (Sunday around 9pm), I was driving down Woodrow Road when three or four men dressed in dark clothing were standing in the middle of the street, trying to flag me down. I could barely see them and had no idea why they would be standing in a line in the middle of the road. I had to swerve into the opposite lane just to avoid them. Unfortunately, I got stuck at a red light shortly after. That’s when they started approaching my car from behind. As a woman alone at night, I was terrified. I inched my car forward, debating if I should risk running the light, but there was too much traffic. I was screaming at them as they approached my car to get away from my car but they still kept coming closer. Their response? “We have a menu.” Even as I was yelling and clearly distressed, they didn’t stop. One of them even got close enough to stick a menu into my rear window. That means they ignored me screaming the entire time. This is an incredibly unsafe and inappropriate way to advertise. No restaurant should have groups of men in dark clothing approaching cars at night, especially when it puts drivers—particularly women alone—into such a frightening position. It is a known thing that this is how a trafficking scenario plays out. I would have to be an idiot to roll down my window for a group of men as a women in the car alone at night. Please stop doing this. Maybe do something a little safer for those guys in the middle of the road, like make a TikTok.

Brad Christie

My partner and I had business nearby so we parked outside and left for about 30 minutes with the intention of coming back for a slice. What we came back to was our car defaced with a sticker on the window claiming we were parked illegally (not filled out, probably ordered from amazon) and two people (presumably the owners) outside sitting in chairs looking smugly. They decided to confront us, asking if we were stupid and if we thought the parking lot was for general use. (There are multiple businesses that share the lot) and claimed it was their parking lot and not to park there. Needless to say, with the attitude of the owners and the frankly dilapidated look of the building, we decided not to give them any business. If this is how you decide to treat potential customers, it doesn't matter how good your pizza is.