Talia Nastacio

My first ever NY pizza! The deep dish wasn't doughy and the thin crust was just perfect crisp 🤩🍕

Evelize Jaimes

Nothing hits quite like a good pepperoni pizza from METRO PIZZA — and this one was absolutely perfect. My brother and I shared this cheesy, golden-crusted masterpiece, and every bite was just so satisfying. The mozzarella was perfectly melted, gooey in all the right places, and stretchy enough to make every slice feel like a mini cheese pull moment. The pepperoni had that slight crisp around the edges and added the perfect touch of salty goodness. Crust? Lightly crisped on the outside, soft and chewy inside — exactly how we like it. This is our go-to spot for a reason, and this box was pure comfort food magic. 🍕✨

Ana Rojas

Stopped by to get some pizza after getting my nails done & I have to stay it’s very delicious! The sauce the dough super fresh ! Definitely recommend!

Charly

This place is amazing, my first time here & I didnt want to leave. I will be making this my new go to spot for pizza. Best place in all staten island!!! Tony is the nicest guy, didnt expect it but made me feel at home.

Bena

Loved that I was immediately greeted when I walked in the restaurant. BEST PIZZA IN TOWN! I got a slice of BBQ, slice of Chicken Alfredo and slice of Margherita.

ken stole

The moment you walk into Metro pizza, they treat you more than just a customer. They treat you as part of the family. The atmosphere and environment is wonderful. •The BEST on Staten Island• Especially on Forest Ave which is closer to home. Parking is always good too😊 The Bbq pan pizza is out of this world. It’s like an orgasm in your mouth. Could eat an entire pie by myself because of how great the taste is! I keep coming back for more! This is my go to place. I Highly recommend this establishment. Trust me, you won’t regret it.🍕🍕🍕🍕🍕🍕🍕🍕🍕🍕🍕🍕🍕🍕🍕🍕🍕

Alfonso Rosario Jr.

I come here as often as I can. The staff, including ownership has always been friendly and provide excellent customer service. The restaurant is always very clean. I usually get regular pizza, but today I ventured into having a Grandma and a Vodka slice, both were savory, with the perfect amount of sauce and cheese. I’ve also had their buffalo chicken roll, and it’s soooo goood!

Andre Cirilo

I'm not sure why I hadn't submitted a review before this... Metro Pizza is my favorite overall pizza shop on Staten Island! Always fresh and consistently tasty. My favorite is the deep dish buffalo chicken, but every slice or dish I've had has been good. Recently, they've added a Grandma square pizza (AKA sicilian) that is absolutely delicious! In the style of Brooklyn's Famous L&B Spumoni Gardens, they put the cheese down first, then the sauce, and top it off with fresh basil! The sauce is sweet and vibrant and not like any other sauce I've tasted... It is really good. Staff are always friendly and welcoming. Also, this place is always busy so you can be sure that your pizza hasn't been sitting around for too long.

Metro Pizza is the real deal when it comes to pizza! The food is absolutely incredible — perfectly crispy crust, rich sauce, generous toppings, and just the right amount of cheese. Every bite is a winner and it's clear they take their pizza seriously. The service is solid and friendly, with just a little room for improvement on consistency. The atmosphere is enjoyable and comfortable, a great spot to sit down and enjoy a proper slice. If you're a pizza lover, this place needs to be on your list!

Jennifer

I stopped in today and had 3 slices of pizza. My favorite was the white with broccoli. It was SO DELICIOUS! The margarita was very good too! The sauce was so flavorful and delicious! The chicken, artichoke, and spinach pizza was a pan pizza. The toppings were delicious, but in general I prefer regular slices over pan. I recommend Metro Pizza in Staten Island!

Mateo

I ordered the lasagna and, unfortunately, it had an unsettling smell and tasted a bit off. The dish also felt dry, as there wasn’t enough sauce throughout the layers, which took away from the overall experience. I want to note that I haven’t tried any of the other food dishes here. So this review is based solely on this one lasagna and my personal experience with it.

Emily V

I frequently order a personal grandma pie. This time, when I placed an online order, there was no option for grandma, so I selected a fresh mozzarella and tomato sauce pie and immediately called to clarify that it needed to be made as a personal grandma. The person I spoke to confirmed it was entered correctly and even told me I could continue to order that way in the future. When my delivery arrived, the order was wrong. I called right away, since I had already clarified this right after placing the order. The girl I spoke with put me on hold because I had to ask to get a new pie. When she came back, I heard in the background that she had to personally offer to pay for my untouched order just so they would agree to make the correct one for me. That is beyond disappointing. Having worked at a pizzeria for years, I know that whether the mistake was ours or the customer’s, we never asked the customer to pay again to fix it. That is simply not good service. Do better, Metro. And to the girl who went out of her way to resolve this for me—thank you.