Station Pizza

Eggplant parm slices were excellent! I have been a fan of station pizza since 1981!

I once brought a block of pepper Jack cheese to them and they hand grated it on my pie. Plus the owner has a nice custom Harley he parks out front occasionally

Best buffalo chicken hero around. The garlic knots are also really good.

Great pizza by the slice or pie. Best Buffalo chicken pizza I have ever had.

Best pizza I’ve had and service is amazing

Food is always fresh and delicious. Staff is friendly and food comes out quick. Prices are cheap for what you get.

All good

Honestly one of the best pizza places on Long Island I’ve ever been to

Great pizza. The white pizza was the best I ever had.

The best buffalo pizza slice I ever had

Great Pizza and sit down dining. Good pricing on sides as well.

best pizza 🍕 family owned many many years to live close, thank you!

Best buffalo chicken pizza you can find. All the other slices were good too.

Buffalo chicken hero was great - large portion, quality chicken, and fresh bread. Reasonable price. The staff were nice too!

Friendly, great prices, service & amazing full flavor fresh garlic knots, & pizza. Would always travel out of my to eat here.

Best pizza I ate for a long time. If you love Pizza like me you will enjoy eating here.

No one does it better than Station Pizza!!!! Lots of people drive a long way for some station. These guys have been killing it for longer than I’ve been alive, so make sure to pop out if you’re ever in the area!

3.5 years and SBU and station pizza is one of my fondest memories. Hot and cheesy pies at its best. Buffalo wings are to die for!

Great Pizza and the owner is friendly and hospitable. Made us a fresh Pizza right away.

Best Pizza in Stony Brook. Often a popular stop for students from the school. Garlic knots are a great little snack as well.

they have been here 20÷ years at least, the guys who own it worked there then bought it, all in all, still great pizza and knots.

Staple of the area. Great food, service and owners!!! Big fan!!!

Delicious pizza and friendly service! I go here every week with my friend and we love coming here!

They have the best Chicken Bacon Ranch slices ever. The chicken was so soft and flavorful.

Top Rated Pizza. Eggplant Slice is awesome. Buffalo chicken slice and awesome heroes too.

Buffalo chicken pizza is just as good as they say.

Same owners 40 years I’ve been going there for 25 years great pizza!!

love the everything pizza, its like a slice of heaven! the garlic nots are always soft and hot and the cheese is always melted and gooey! the salads are also amazing! :)

Awesome pizza the best around since 1985!! All the others are pretending to be real pizza the only one that comes close is Colissio’s in Port Jefferson

GREAT PIZZA ! You can't get pizza this good unless you want to drive to Brooklyn or lower Manhattan. No pretense...just REALLY good NY pizza. Best in the area.

We catered pizza and hot dishes from Station Pizza for our daughter’s birthday party this past Saturday. It arrived on time, hot and ready to serve. We got rave reviews from our guests. Will be our go to spot for future get togethers!

It's a small, cozy resturant with an excellent staff. Perfect for college kids and passerbys who want to enjoy a nice pizzeria style menu. It's located on a small strip mall type area. So it's convenient to shop and eat there, or eat there and shop at the other neighboring businesses. Friendly staff.

This place has the best plain cheese slice I have ever had. From there it only gets better with buffalo chicken and their knots. Been going here for years and in my opinion has the best slices in Setauket.

Can't get better than Station. I get their sausage rolls with extra sauce. Huge. The only negative is you have to order an hour before you want to eat if you get delivery.

Best pizza in new York hands down. I purchased my home in close proximity to this place it's that good. Always nice pleasant people working there. Thank you for your continued service station pizza!

Went in late for a quick slice of Buffalo Chicken. Perfectly crispy crust and juicy chicken definitely hit the spot. By far the best around.

Awesome mom & pop pizza parlor that has stood the test of time. Great place to grab a slice and relax.

One of the best pizza places in the area, my mothers favorite Sicilian Pizza, and absolutely, hands down, the best garlic knots in the country, at least that I ever had.

I simply had two plain spices but they were amaaaazzingggg. Nice people work there too.

So good, I always crave it and it never disappoints. Favorite pizza in town

Ate here today for the first time with my husband and we both loved it I have tried almost every pizza place in Suffolk and this is #1. The guy was so nice I love this place can't wait to go back

Ordered a large cheese pie and garlic knots for some friends and I and it was delicious!!! Was not too expensive either. Staff were friendly and efficient in making the orders. Will be back.

Yummy pizzas at a good price. We have gone back multiple times. And make sure to try their killer garlic knots too!

There pizza is by far better than any of the pizzerias in our area. Very tasty pies.

Good pizza, small place but pretty clean. Monday and Wednesday $2 off a large pizza has been my go-to for a while now, have yet to be dissapointed

Coming from south Jersey…the buffalo chicken pizza was delicious! Just a little chilly inside!

Been going here since my college days, great buffalo chicken pizza and heros. The knots and wings are good too, and this is coming from someone who eats wings out of Buffalo, NY.

When I miss NY style pizza this Station Pizza is the place I go to 💯. I have been going to this place since 1990 and it’s my favorite place on Long Island! The cheese is fresh and chewy and the sauce is just right w lots of tomatoes and flavor and the crust ID thin and crispy but chewy. Everywhere I go in the US I crave Station Pizza. You have to try it. Always happy and satisfied every time and so do all my friends.

OMG SO GOOD Large pie 1/2 Pineapple & Bacon, 1/2 Mushroom & Sausage, plus garlic knots Every bit was incredible! Delivery took 30min and when I received the food I immediately noticed that the pie was a lot heavier than any other local establishments. It's nice to get more for your money. But even more impressive was how tasty everything was. It's like eyes roll back in your head tasty! WOW

omg best white pizza I’ve ever had(better than nyc) 10/10. The plain cheese side was very good. The staff was very sweet and personable. My new go to pizza spot ❤️❤️❤️❤️

Big meals. Eating pasta for two days. Perfect for dinner for two or more.

Jul L

Coming from south Jersey…the buffalo chicken pizza was delicious! Just a little chilly inside!

Eric Fan

Been going here since my college days, great buffalo chicken pizza and heros. The knots and wings are good too, and this is coming from someone who eats wings out of Buffalo, NY.

karina k

When I miss NY style pizza this Station Pizza is the place I go to 💯. I have been going to this place since 1990 and it’s my favorite place on Long Island! The cheese is fresh and chewy and the sauce is just right w lots of tomatoes and flavor and the crust ID thin and crispy but chewy. Everywhere I go in the US I crave Station Pizza. You have to try it. Always happy and satisfied every time and so do all my friends.

Tom Ph

OMG SO GOOD Large pie 1/2 Pineapple & Bacon, 1/2 Mushroom & Sausage, plus garlic knots Every bit was incredible! Delivery took 30min and when I received the food I immediately noticed that the pie was a lot heavier than any other local establishments. It's nice to get more for your money. But even more impressive was how tasty everything was. It's like eyes roll back in your head tasty! WOW

Juliana cardoza

omg best white pizza I’ve ever had(better than nyc) 10/10. The plain cheese side was very good. The staff was very sweet and personable. My new go to pizza spot ❤️❤️❤️❤️

Polina S

Big meals. Eating pasta for two days. Perfect for dinner for two or more.

My family and I have been going here for decades for a classic NY slice. Same guy has been running this place for the whole time, serving huge slices for a great price. The place itself isn't great for groups (a little small) but the pizza is perfect to take out. Great garlic knots too, for cheap as well. Come here for good, cheap pizza.

Many places charge an arm and a leg for a slice of pizza. Station is fair with pricing, the pies are made well, and I love the old school vibes. Their other dishes are good too. Get out of your comfort zone!! Been coming here for 11 years.

Oh, man. This pizza is slammin!!!! Plain cheeze'll do ya! Hot, gooey, and yummy sauce. Thank you, Tom, the owner! All the best!! (Debbie the customer. ) Delicious meatballs, too!!!

A great, reliable local spot easily accessible from Stony Brook University. Pizza tastes great and don't forget to check out their heroes too! They've been around forever and you can't go wrong with Station Pizza.

Great food. It has changed owners over the years but the first time I went there was in 1980. The prices are still good and the portions are decent sized. The parmigiana heroes are good for two meals and are really good. When the garlic knots are fresh, they are really good. The best part is the pizza. While they sell it by the slice, it is best to get them to make a whole pie so it is fresh and hot. They deliver and take great pride in making sure that the food is hot when it gets to your house.

My family has eaten at or taken out from this spot for years. I can no longer at big-chain pizzerias because I have been spoiled by the flavor. Don't let this tiny place fool you. The employees have always been kind, and the pizza always tasted amazing. The price isn't too bad either.

This was my "every other week treat" while I was at Stony Brook U. Walking distance from campus, good prices for non-chain pizza, friendly crew, and great food. I like the feel of the shop itself. It's not fancy; it's clean but still has a cool "hole in the wall" vibe that makes it feel like a real local NY neighbourhood pizza joint. If you're on campus and you're getting Dominoes instead of going to Station, you should just admit that you hate pizza.

Great folks! As far as the pizza goes, it is perfectly serviceable as a local option (maybe an 8/10?). You will find objectively better elsewhere (9/10), but I think this place shines in particular for the quality of their proteins, like the meatball and sausage. My go-to is a Sausage and Pepper hero, hold the cheese, and probably a side of meatballs. I've had iffy results ordering these early in the day, but at night like 9 PM is when they've always been amazing. I think it slow-cooks or marinates? Though, my subjective correlation isn't causation and I might be wrong. The last meatballs I had were incredible. And, to be constructive, I think the sauce on the pizza is a little unusually sweet. I think the dough and cheese are perfect, the cook is perfect, but the sauce asserts itself a little much. Might try light sauce on my next pie!

Scott Rodriguez

Many places charge an arm and a leg for a slice of pizza. Station is fair with pricing, the pies are made well, and I love the old school vibes. Their other dishes are good too. Get out of your comfort zone!! Been coming here for 11 years.

Debbie

Oh, man. This pizza is slammin!!!! Plain cheeze'll do ya! Hot, gooey, and yummy sauce. Thank you, Tom, the owner! All the best!! (Debbie the customer. ) Delicious meatballs, too!!!

Adam Zeng

A great, reliable local spot easily accessible from Stony Brook University. Pizza tastes great and don't forget to check out their heroes too! They've been around forever and you can't go wrong with Station Pizza.

Saccillia Pendina

My family has eaten at or taken out from this spot for years. I can no longer at big-chain pizzerias because I have been spoiled by the flavor. Don't let this tiny place fool you. The employees have always been kind, and the pizza always tasted amazing. The price isn't too bad either.

Sonal Temburni

We catered pizza and hot dishes from Station Pizza for our daughter’s birthday party this past Saturday. It arrived on time, hot and ready to serve. We got rave reviews from our guests. Will be our go to spot for future get togethers!

Jonathan Evenboer

This was my "every other week treat" while I was at Stony Brook U. Walking distance from campus, good prices for non-chain pizza, friendly crew, and great food. I like the feel of the shop itself. It's not fancy; it's clean but still has a cool "hole in the wall" vibe that makes it feel like a real local NY neighbourhood pizza joint. If you're on campus and you're getting Dominoes instead of going to Station, you should just admit that you hate pizza.

Danny Pavao

My family and I have been going here for decades for a classic NY slice. Same guy has been running this place for the whole time, serving huge slices for a great price. The place itself isn't great for groups (a little small) but the pizza is perfect to take out. Great garlic knots too, for cheap as well. Come here for good, cheap pizza.

Sanjay Kapur

Great food. It has changed owners over the years but the first time I went there was in 1980. The prices are still good and the portions are decent sized. The parmigiana heroes are good for two meals and are really good. When the garlic knots are fresh, they are really good. The best part is the pizza. While they sell it by the slice, it is best to get them to make a whole pie so it is fresh and hot. They deliver and take great pride in making sure that the food is hot when it gets to your house.

Great location, the garlic knots are amazing and offer the lowest prices around. Happy customer

Good pizza not a Lotta variety on display always delicious tho

Good, reasonably priced local pizza, free delivery, close to campus and the train station. Weekday pick up specials.

Ive only tried their meatball subs, it was very good but it needs more parm!!!!!! Free delivery tho which is nice.

The Sicilian pizza, stuffed pie and garlic knots are all great. Small store with decently prized pies.

I have been going to Station Pizza since the mid-80s and it hasn't changed a bit. It's still very good pizza and if you're in the area I do recommend it I get it for lunch a lot as I work in the area. Could use a little updating however it still has that old feel to it brings me back to the mid 80s

Some pizza good, some eh, great loc nice people and fast, oh no brew, not a beer to be had

biiiiiiiig portions and that’s the only reason i added an extra star. the food is mid

Had a pizza. Kinda expensive... But taste is good. And the place is ok ok in hygiene.

It's a hard core college town pizza place. A little shabby, but the pizza was good

This place is filthy and the man is rude. But good/ok pizza though 3/5

Only pizza place in area open late when selections are meager and some items look left out longer than others. Still, the meat layered pizza type item with sauce on the side was super delicious and the employee was very personable.

Went at about 9:45pm they close at 11pm. All they had was 3 old nasty dried up slices. Gave me the look like "please don't make me work" which is frustrating. I worked at places like this and I never understood why my coworkers would get upset when people wanted to give us business. If you close at 11 and are all ready to stop working at 9:45 then don't work. Collect welfare. Also, every surface looked dirty and the environment was unwelcoming. I'll pass next time. I guess they got lazy knowing they're the only place in the area and can get away with it being so close to SBU and the only gig in town.

Great pizza. The place, especially bathroom could use some cleaning. And we were initially overcharged, but when we caught the mistake the cashier apologized - could have been an honest mistake. Will probably go there again.

The good: Easily the best bang for your buck pizza in the area. The sides are always good, too and even if its not the best tasting food you can find you definitely get what you pay for. The mozzarella sticks are probably my favorite in the area. If you know what to avoid on the menu then the place is great. The bad: The place could be cleaner. Everything is pretty greasy. If you get delivery then they'll probably forget your drink. (Usually they come back and bring it on their own. I've never called about a missing drink though.) The ugly: Some menu items are flat out disgusting. Any pizza with a ton of meat (Such as the stuffed meat pizza.) Will have so much grease that it cant hold together and will drip absolutely everywhere. Any cooked vegetable is mushy and flavorless. Especially the eggplant. (I think they cut it way too thick.) They close at 10pm and the one time I ordered something around 9:30 I got complained to.

When I go to Station Pizza & Brew, I get the white slice and a plain slice. The plain slice is good, but the white slice is just alright. It's good enough for the price, and is student friendly. The inside atmosphere isn't the best, but it's acceptable.

Ashley -

When I go to Station Pizza & Brew, I get the white slice and a plain slice. The plain slice is good, but the white slice is just alright. It's good enough for the price, and is student friendly. The inside atmosphere isn't the best, but it's acceptable.

TheRock OfShame (TheRockOfShame)

The good: Easily the best bang for your buck pizza in the area. The sides are always good, too and even if its not the best tasting food you can find you definitely get what you pay for. The mozzarella sticks are probably my favorite in the area. If you know what to avoid on the menu then the place is great. The bad: The place could be cleaner. Everything is pretty greasy. If you get delivery then they'll probably forget your drink. (Usually they come back and bring it on their own. I've never called about a missing drink though.) The ugly: Some menu items are flat out disgusting. Any pizza with a ton of meat (Such as the stuffed meat pizza.) Will have so much grease that it cant hold together and will drip absolutely everywhere. Any cooked vegetable is mushy and flavorless. Especially the eggplant. (I think they cut it way too thick.) They close at 10pm and the one time I ordered something around 9:30 I got complained to.

Just so happened to stop for a slice... really needs a makeover inside. Pizza was ok, bit their appearance is awful

Pasta there is okay but not worth it for the unkind experience. Take your food to go

Mushroom Pizza Pie. Not a pizza I would recommend. I dont know how this place received 4.5 stars. I dont feel the love in the pizza, Felt lazy, thrown together instead of a bit of work, such as sauteing the mushrooms. The sauce is a bit sweet for my taste. Good luck if you go there. Probably a hit or miss place.

Dave Lee

Mushroom Pizza Pie. Not a pizza I would recommend. I dont know how this place received 4.5 stars. I dont feel the love in the pizza, Felt lazy, thrown together instead of a bit of work, such as sauteing the mushrooms. The sauce is a bit sweet for my taste. Good luck if you go there. Probably a hit or miss place.

I made a 5 star review last year because I love the food, however, management goes a long way. There’s two people who I often see at this shop, one a very sweet man and the other not so much. Tone and patience go a long way when addressing people and you want to make people feel welcomed. I will still return, but just for food. There are other comments of staff seeming upset just by you being there.

Stella Osita

I made a 5 star review last year because I love the food, however, management goes a long way. There’s two people who I often see at this shop, one a very sweet man and the other not so much. Tone and patience go a long way when addressing people and you want to make people feel welcomed. I will still return, but just for food. There are other comments of staff seeming upset just by you being there.

One of the worst pizza's I ever had. And the guy behind the counter had the personality of a tree stump.

Gross pizza guy was smoking outside comes in dosent wash his hand and serves me pizza. When i confronted him, his answer was he used a spacula. Wrong answer GROSS

Not a fan at all. Chix roll was horrible and felt uncomfortable even being there, will not be back

Being right next to Stonybrook University, this place has so much potential. Unfortunately, their pizza was not very good. It was soggy and didn't have a lot of flavor. I really wanted to love this place. ☹️

1 hour Late delivery and rude behavior They were late to deliver and the pizza got cold and my soda turns into tepid water. I talked on the phone and their way of talking was so rude like delivery was late because of my fault. When food came, the driver apologized to me it was their fault which made me relief little bit. but I am pretty sure I won't order from you guys forever

I was in Stony Brook last week for a work trip and tried Station Pizza. I have to say this is the worst pizza to ever exist in NY. It tasted like rubber and was extremely undercooked. I would never recommend them to anyone.

Leaned on the glass and owner threatened to punch me in the mouth because I didn't hear him. I wish I was kidding but the guys who work there are entirely disrespectful. I wish I could give a lower rating cuz I'm never going back.

Didn’t feel like leaving a review but wanted to address the collective experience of rudeness in this restaurant. I don’t know if he’s an employee or the owner of this shop but kindness goes a long way, especially during the holidays.

We placed an order and were told it would come in about 30 minutes. An hour and 45 minutes later we got a call from the driver. We were already gone. The owner was arrogant abrasive and rude when we called and we certainly did not get an apology. We were blamed for not answering our phone however does not show any missed calls . Never again!!!

The worst customer service ever. The person behind the counter taking calls doesnt know how to talk. Very rude and arrogant. Also he abused me over the phone. Idk how this place is still doing business with such people working.

The staff seemed very angry and not pleasant at all. Pizza was not what I remembered it to be. The crust was very thin. Not enough cheese. The sauce tasted horrible. I went there when I was a kid and the pizza was amazing. I won't be returning there anytime soon.

Kamlesh Kewlani

The worst customer service ever. The person behind the counter taking calls doesnt know how to talk. Very rude and arrogant. Also he abused me over the phone. Idk how this place is still doing business with such people working.

Matt Brower

The staff seemed very angry and not pleasant at all. Pizza was not what I remembered it to be. The crust was very thin. Not enough cheese. The sauce tasted horrible. I went there when I was a kid and the pizza was amazing. I won't be returning there anytime soon.