Zuri

Great little dinner in the Catskills! Friendly service and delicious food!

Mike Saccone

My daughter stopped had breakfast on way back to Long Island and left her wallet there. I called spoke to owner who was very nice and he asked the waitress who had the wallet to call us same day and she did. She took it to post office same day and sent it back to us. You could tell by speaking with both of them how nice and honest they were. It’s really nice to know that people like this still exist. We thanked her appropriately. My daughter said food was great also. If you get the chance stop in and have some good food and meet some nice people. 🍳🍔🥩🍟🙂

DiM 1

Great spot for food if you don't want to cook at your camp site...lol

Lexi C

Eggs Benedict was delicious. They have a huge menu and a ton of selections including an entire pizzeria as well. Could’ve spent the entire weekend eating here for each meal with the variety they have. Sister said the French toast was amazing too. Good prices.

+6

Kate Dunn

Yes, this is an older authentic diner on the mountain top and it shows. However, the food will amaze you. We stopped in here twice on our recent trip to Tannersville and greatly enjoyed our meals. For dinner we had their triple decker ham and cheese club sandwich and the patty melt. The club was insanely fresh and well put together. Both were excellent but the patty melt took the cake! BEST beef patty we've had anywhere in a long time. The quality of the burger meat was excellent! We highly recommend! The cole slaw and fries were delicious. Their ice tea is delightful. On our second trip we had breakfast. We got two scrambled eggs with bacon, home fries, and toast. Fantastic breakfast!! You definitely need to stop in at Selena's if your visiting or driving through Tannersville.

Giorgi Battinelli

Amazing food and service! Fall off the bone charred chicken! One of the best chicken's I've ever had. The staff is super nice and the diner atmosphere is truly welcoming! Will definitely come back in the future. If I had to give it a more accurate rating definitely 9.45/10!

Jun Simons

Nice people and a convenient location if you are hiking or skiing on the catskills. They kept the coffee coming and portion sizes are large. The food is nothing special, typical diner breakfast as you would expect.

Edna L

Had the pleasure of stopping by here during a snowboarding weekend at Hunter Mountain. The menu is very extensive so if you’re craving anything from a typical diner, they probably have it! I ordered the Roast Beef BLT triple decker and it was pretty good and very filling. I didn’t touch much of the coleslaw but I’m pretty picky with that. The pickle and the fries were good though! Pretty standard for $15! The staff here are also kind, patient, and friendly. The interior is like a typical old school diner- booths style.

Dion Rupa

The family and I decided to try Selena's based on the Google reviews, and I'm glad we did. We arrived at Selena's before the dinner crowd (for an early dinner), and we were the only customers in the restaurant at the time. Our orders were taken, and the food was served very quickly. I enjoyed the Parm Panini, and my wife had the French Dip Sandwhich. Both dishes were delicious and piping hot. I have never heard of a diner that had a pizzeria menu mixed in with their diner menu, so I had to try a slice of their pizza. I come from NYC, and it was a decent slice! The overall cost of the food was pretty good. I've paid significantly more at diners on Long Island. I would definitely eat at Selena's again!

+2

Maria Oishee

The visit to Selena’s was mainly for lunch after a group tour, based on one member’s recommendation. Since there were around 20 people in the group, seats were reserved in a private room. The staff were very helpful, and among the halal options, the Tuna Sub sandwich seemed the safest choice. There were also some vegetarian items available. Those who ordered omelets specifically requested that ham and bacon be excluded, and the person serving food reassured them that those ingredients would not be used. Speaking of the food, the Tuna Sub with fries tasted great,(added Tomatoes & lettuce) and the tomato ketchup & cos law enhanced the flavor even more. Many people also enjoyed the seafood items, especially the fried calamari, which was crispy and delicious (though it’s best to double-check whether it’s fried in beer batter). Overall, the restaurant was quite busy during lunchtime, and although it was a bit chaotic, conversations went smoothly. Since there was some leftover food, it was packed to take home. Most likely, when there’s a large group (15 or more people), a 20% gratuity is automatically added to the bill.along with the regular tax.

J Alicia

Waitress was great!!!! Only two stars though because my coffee and pancakes were good but eggs had way too much cheese. Took away from the taste. Potatoes, some were soft, some were hard as a rock, and corned beef was dry. Looked and felt like card board in my mouth. Just being real with my review because there are not too many restaurants up in the mountains to enjoy. The ones there should be up to standard not lackluster.

Never order food from this place . They partner with the worst delivery people around. They make your pizza and deliver it two hours later when a driver shows up. Disgusting!!!!!!!! Pizza is like cardboard. I’m totally disgusted with this place. How they can operate like this is beyond my thought process.

Elvin Frias

Honestly, I’m really disappointed with how this place is run. From the moment we walked in, the energy was off. My group and I came in friendly and polite — “Hi! Good morning! How are you?” — and got nothing back. No smile, no welcome, just a flat “How many people?” We said “eight,” and the host looked instantly tired and unenthusiastic. It was still morning! Was it really that bad for a group of people to come in after church to enjoy breakfast together? The diner looks nice in the front, but they seated us all the way in the back, where it felt like a plain storage room — four walls, a ceiling, lots of tables and chairs, and zero charm. The front had open space, but for some reason, we were placed in the back. At first, we brushed it off. But then we noticed something that didn’t sit right — the only other groups seated in the back were non-white, like us. That made the whole situation feel even worse. The service didn’t improve. We waited around 45 minutes just to place our order. When the server came by, we said clearly, “Just water for now, we’re ready to order our food.” They didn’t even acknowledge us — just dropped off the waters and walked away. When the food finally came, it was terrible. I ordered steak and eggs (medium) and got an overcooked steak and one scrambled egg. That was it. Overall, it was a disappointing experience from start to finish. The atmosphere might be nice if you’re sitting up front — but if you’re not white, don’t expect the same treatment. Save yourself the frustration and order somewhere else.

Andrea Pinto

I came here with friends and my partner last Saturday around 7 pm. The service was good as it was almost empty, but they took a few mins to take our order. The diner looked that someone of us was gonna get a stomachache. I got the Californian burger, apparently, the last one. It looked good and the fries too. Overall it was okay. However, that burger gave me the worst food poisoning. At 3 am I was in the bathroom non stop. The worst part is that I was at a campground. I wouldn’t recommend this place to anyone.

Sanji Azad

We visited Kaaterskill Falls and stopped at a diner on our way back, hoping for a cozy experience. Unfortunately, it turned out to be a poor choice. The food was undercooked or overcooked and below par, and waiting 40 minutes for soup, salad, a sandwich, and appetisers felt excessive. We didn't want to complain since they were about to close, but we felt it was important to warn others: avoid this place during your visit. It’s a waste of money, and you won’t find the warm atmosphere or food you need after a hike.