Fire on Main

Shelby

Our first time here and we absolutely loved it!! We have been wanting to check out this place out for awhile and finally went tonight for our anniversary dinner. We have nothing but fantastic things to say. Our server Leanna was outstanding! She was so kind, friendly, attentive and made us feel very comfortable. The food was delicious. She had a great sense of humor as well! We ordered the calamari and June pizza special. We look forward to returning soon and will be recommending Fire on Main to all our friends & family. Excited to have a new favorite restaurant in the Victor area!

David Sherburne

Great little place, stopped in for lunch with a friend and we had an excellent time. Ruben was very good with thinly sliced lean corn beef. Ordered the Garbanzo Bean Salad which was a great alternative to fries! Wedge salad was basic but good. Wait staff was helpful and nice.

Mike F

First time, but definitely not the last time. Small style restaurant without feeling cramped. The kitchen is right in front of you as soon as you walk in, so you get smacked in the face with lots of wonderful smells. We had a couple minute wait at 5:30 for a party of 4. The hostess was very pleasant and brought us right over when it was out turn to sit. The waitress followed shortly after for our drink order. Drinks came out in just a couple minutes and she brought waters right after that. The menu isn't huge so it was easy to go through, but hard to decide with a great variety of starters, salads, handheld sandwiches, woodfire pizzas, and pastas. We started with the bourbon glaze wings which were fantastic. Well balanced with sweetness and just a hint of spice. I wish they were a little crisper but the flavor more than made up for it. Our pizzas were the Rocco, a special that was based off a Chicago beef sandwich with gardenia, and the pesto which i added grilled chicken and balsamic glaze. The pizzas were all delicious on a crispy and chewy crust. The service was fantastic and very friendly. Everyone on the staff seemed happy at work, and the customers were all having a great time from what I could tell. Table turnover was quick without seeming rushed. I can't wait to go back and try different dishes, especially the pizza Cesar.

Alex Carfora

Stopped in for lunch today. Nice on the inside and it’s clean. Started with the bruschetta pizza. Very good. My wife got the muffleta I believe it was called and she said it was good. I got the meatball sandwich. It was out of this world best I’ve ever had. After she tried mine she didn’t even want to eat her own it was so good. The service was good as well. Will definitely be back to try more food. Very reasonably priced in this day and age.

Brenda Richey

We stopped for lunch at Fire In Main. This was our first visit. We had a lovely lunch: wood fired veggie pizza 🍕 was delicious! Made to perfection. French onion soup 🍲 for my daughter and a bean soup for myself. Both were incredible. The restaurant was lovely, cozy, full house for lunch, but order came promptly Wait staff were very caring, kind, upbeat. The entire atmosphere was serene and beautiful. You absolutely need to experience Fire In Main ..it's 🔥 fire!

Kimberly O'Connor

The food was perfect in every way. It was all hot fresh and soo delicious 🤤 I wish I lived closer so that I could be a regular. Kayla (I hope I spelled her name right) was a wonderful attentive server. It was nice to see everyone working together well too. Thanks for a great experience!

Krista Shaw

Clean, warm and inviting atmosphere. Staff was very polite and attentive. The food was delicious.

Fred Knowlton

Incredible little restaurant in a small town. Great food and amazing service! We'll be back!

My first time there. Waitress was awesome. Very clean and nice interior. Food and drinks came quickly and were very good. Definitely I'll be going there again.

I have to say that I'm beyond impressed with today's meal! I understand it is a bar style restaurant but 2-4 more options for appetizers and burgers/wraps would be ideal as those categories of food are extremely minimal. Otherwise, great place to dine in at. Great atmosphere, great/attentive waitress and fair pricing! Will be back!

B

I have to say that I'm beyond impressed with today's meal! I understand it is a bar style restaurant but 2-4 more options for appetizers and burgers/wraps would be ideal as those categories of food are extremely minimal. Otherwise, great place to dine in at. Great atmosphere, great/attentive waitress and fair pricing! Will be back!

Stephanie Karley

My first time there. Waitress was awesome. Very clean and nice interior. Food and drinks came quickly and were very good. Definitely I'll be going there again.

We ordered the bruschetta pizza and cobb salad. The pizza tasted very good, was a little small for the price IMO but it was the right size for 2 adults with the salad. The salad was huge, very fresh. Went in to pick it up, staff was super friendly, the food was ready on time. The atmosphere seemed cozy and welcoming, little snug.

Came in for dinner on a Friday night, the atmosphere is beautiful both inside and out. Our server, Marley was incredible. She engaged in just enough small talk to make us feel welcome and shared laughs with us the entire time. We ordered shrimp appetizer, calamari and a bruscetta pizza. The presentation was beautiful! My only complaint was the pizza, as it was slightly undercooked and overloaded with too much cheese to hold such a thin crust. Embarrassingly, I asked for it to be reheated. Marley was more than accommodating and we received another pizza that was more crisp and had great flavor to it. The bill was very affordable and I will absolutely be back.

Brittany Rupert

We ordered the bruschetta pizza and cobb salad. The pizza tasted very good, was a little small for the price IMO but it was the right size for 2 adults with the salad. The salad was huge, very fresh. Went in to pick it up, staff was super friendly, the food was ready on time. The atmosphere seemed cozy and welcoming, little snug.

Lizzy Trott

Came in for dinner on a Friday night, the atmosphere is beautiful both inside and out. Our server, Marley was incredible. She engaged in just enough small talk to make us feel welcome and shared laughs with us the entire time. We ordered shrimp appetizer, calamari and a bruscetta pizza. The presentation was beautiful! My only complaint was the pizza, as it was slightly undercooked and overloaded with too much cheese to hold such a thin crust. Embarrassingly, I asked for it to be reheated. Marley was more than accommodating and we received another pizza that was more crisp and had great flavor to it. The bill was very affordable and I will absolutely be back.

The service and atmosphere were good. The fried calamari was good. One of our pizzas was pretty good. The other was bland and soggy.

Food was great and the waitress was super sweet and attentive. Large portions! They had a full service bar, high top tables, and regular table and chairs.

Fun date night with yummy food and excellent service. We were greeted and seated quickly and took some time to choose between the many options available. My girlfriend had zitti with meatballs and I got a meatball sandwich with chips. Her pasta was perfect el dente with a rich well seasoned sauce. I enjoyed my sub that was crisp outside and flavorful inside with mozzarella and banana peppers. The chips were house made and very crispy. Really enjoyed it and we will be returning.

Bethany Phelps

Food was great and the waitress was super sweet and attentive. Large portions! They had a full service bar, high top tables, and regular table and chairs.

Rufus Bynum

Fun date night with yummy food and excellent service. We were greeted and seated quickly and took some time to choose between the many options available. My girlfriend had zitti with meatballs and I got a meatball sandwich with chips. Her pasta was perfect el dente with a rich well seasoned sauce. I enjoyed my sub that was crisp outside and flavorful inside with mozzarella and banana peppers. The chips were house made and very crispy. Really enjoyed it and we will be returning.

Stopped in to see the new place and try out some of the Brick Oven fired pizza. The atmosphere is a little confusing. A lot going on with multiple themes. If you have not been a long time Victor resident or visitor, then the McGhans references mean nothing. Add a little history to the menues or table flyers. Add a short back story on the procurement of the awesome wood tabletops. The food was fine. The Brick Oven fired pizza was somewhat plain, yes the dough was fresh but the sauce and toppings were plain. The service was top notch, quick and very attentive. I will revisit again in the near future especially when out of town alumni return for the holidays.

Timothy Delaney

Stopped in to see the new place and try out some of the Brick Oven fired pizza. The atmosphere is a little confusing. A lot going on with multiple themes. If you have not been a long time Victor resident or visitor, then the McGhans references mean nothing. Add a little history to the menues or table flyers. Add a short back story on the procurement of the awesome wood tabletops. The food was fine. The Brick Oven fired pizza was somewhat plain, yes the dough was fresh but the sauce and toppings were plain. The service was top notch, quick and very attentive. I will revisit again in the near future especially when out of town alumni return for the holidays.

Pizza was very mediocre. Thick crust, not much flavor. We had meatball and cheese. Did not finish it and did not take a doggy bag. Burger was large and good.

I have enjoyed the pizza here in the past, and today decided to order the Wedge salad. A wedge salad is always made with a half head of iceberg lettuce with bacon, Bleu cheese, both creamy and crumbly, and red onion. This “Wedge” salad was not a wedge at all. It was a bunch of dark green, leafy , big romaine leaves. I should have sent it right back; I don’t like big leafy romaine leaves. Bottom line- the cooks would not stand by the fact that this is not a Wedge salad, and I basically did not eat dinner. They also would not take $17 if romaine leaves off the bill. This was a big mistake IMO. not only, did I not have a meal, I did not get customer service. The waitress tried talking with the cooks, but they wouldn’t budge. Guess that’s that, and a lost customer.

Jeanne

Pizza was very mediocre. Thick crust, not much flavor. We had meatball and cheese. Did not finish it and did not take a doggy bag. Burger was large and good.

Jo Hussion

I have enjoyed the pizza here in the past, and today decided to order the Wedge salad. A wedge salad is always made with a half head of iceberg lettuce with bacon, Bleu cheese, both creamy and crumbly, and red onion. This “Wedge” salad was not a wedge at all. It was a bunch of dark green, leafy , big romaine leaves. I should have sent it right back; I don’t like big leafy romaine leaves. Bottom line- the cooks would not stand by the fact that this is not a Wedge salad, and I basically did not eat dinner. They also would not take $17 if romaine leaves off the bill. This was a big mistake IMO. not only, did I not have a meal, I did not get customer service. The waitress tried talking with the cooks, but they wouldn’t budge. Guess that’s that, and a lost customer.

I used to love ordering pizzas here they were always so good. I haven’t been in a while and tonight I ordered a pepperoni pizza and a cheese pizza well done. It had zero flavor it was definitely not well done as soon as you picked up a slice all the toppings fell off onto the plate along with the cheese. The server came back to our table about two minutes later and we asked for Our bill with all the pizza except for two bites taken out sitting there untouched and she didn’t even ask if anything was wrong. Definitely not worth the 40 some dollars we spent on two pizzas and two sodas. I’m not sure if they changed how they cook their pizzas or ingredients but it was not good.

I was extremely disappointed with my experience yesterday. My sister and I ordered salads, the lettuce was not fresh. The calamari had 0 flavor. I ordered dressing on the side and the waitress did not put in the order correctly. My granddaughter ordered pizza which was soggy and tasteless. Definitely not the same experience the first time I visited. I’m not sure if they changed cooks or just cutting corners. Definitely will not be back or recommend to anyone

Megan Payne

I used to love ordering pizzas here they were always so good. I haven’t been in a while and tonight I ordered a pepperoni pizza and a cheese pizza well done. It had zero flavor it was definitely not well done as soon as you picked up a slice all the toppings fell off onto the plate along with the cheese. The server came back to our table about two minutes later and we asked for Our bill with all the pizza except for two bites taken out sitting there untouched and she didn’t even ask if anything was wrong. Definitely not worth the 40 some dollars we spent on two pizzas and two sodas. I’m not sure if they changed how they cook their pizzas or ingredients but it was not good.