Nathan's

I highly recommend the Manhattan burger and the hot dog nuggets, but the best part was the ice cream. I went for the hard serve and apparently it’s made in house. The staff was very nice and we even saw Mister Softee himself! My son had so much fun.

Went in close to closing for some Mr. Softee and Curtis was phenomenal! Absolutely amazing to talk to, what a great guy! Will definitely be back soon for more Softee and probably making an ice cream truck call very soon!

Been here a few times. Great food. Super clean place. Super clean bathroom. Lots of menu options. I'm glad this came nearby.

Crispy Nathan's hot dogs just like I was craving. Next Time Arthur Treacher's. :)

Went in for the first time the other day and was soooo happy I did. The ice cream is delish and the Nathan's offerings is like being at Coney!!! And the lady who served me was super nice! Look forward to my next visit!

I was very excited to see two of my favorite foods as a child combine forces . Definitely a great idea. The Nathans food was delicious just as I remembered. Topped it off with Mr. Softy ice cream afterwards. As always best ice cream hands down. The staff is great very friendly . It's a neat place. Great atmosphere. Happy to see additional seating outside. Will Definitely be back with friends.

Overall nice experience, food was as good as expected and staff were friendly. The dining section did seem a little dirty however, the high chair for example, was too slimy to use. Prices are too high.

kimberly pagan

Crispy Nathan's hot dogs just like I was craving. Next Time Arthur Treacher's. :)

Troy Payson

Been here a few times. Great food. Super clean place. Super clean bathroom. Lots of menu options. I'm glad this came nearby.

Kathleen S

Went in close to closing for some Mr. Softee and Curtis was phenomenal! Absolutely amazing to talk to, what a great guy! Will definitely be back soon for more Softee and probably making an ice cream truck call very soon!

Andy Tolbert

Went in for the first time the other day and was soooo happy I did. The ice cream is delish and the Nathan's offerings is like being at Coney!!! And the lady who served me was super nice! Look forward to my next visit!

Betty Casey

Highly recommend! Had the hot fudge sundae and it was the best Ive had in a long time! Can’t wait to try the food at Nathans. Service was also excellent. Love the outside picnic area.

Esther Gladys Zenon

I'm an ice cream fanatic! I stopped in to get a banana split and noticed not only do they serve ice cream but they have a huge assortment of smoothies. Service was great. Team members were courteous and cool. Next time you're in Yorktown, stop by this place. You'll be glad you did.

Cynthia LaForgia

I was very excited to see two of my favorite foods as a child combine forces . Definitely a great idea. The Nathans food was delicious just as I remembered. Topped it off with Mr. Softy ice cream afterwards. As always best ice cream hands down. The staff is great very friendly . It's a neat place. Great atmosphere. Happy to see additional seating outside. Will Definitely be back with friends.

Megan Kuklevsky

I highly recommend the Manhattan burger and the hot dog nuggets, but the best part was the ice cream. I went for the hard serve and apparently it’s made in house. The staff was very nice and we even saw Mister Softee himself! My son had so much fun.

Best tasting Nathan's I've had. And I'm originally from Brooklyn. So I have been to Coney Island a bunch. This place cooks it as needed. Not ready to go under a heat lamp.

Rob Hehner

Best tasting Nathan's I've had. And I'm originally from Brooklyn. So I have been to Coney Island a bunch. This place cooks it as needed. Not ready to go under a heat lamp.

I was super excited about this place but ended up really disappointed - came with my family, sat down to eat at a filthy table, nothing was wiped down..they were all like that. I didn’t not feel like I was in a new establishment .. it just felt dirty. I understand that they’re busy and would like to give them some slack but that’s just a huge turn off for me. Maybe leave some wipes out if you don’t have staff to clean ? We ended up sitting down anyways because we had to eat, the garbage was toppling over and leaking milkshake all over the floor. $50 for hot dogs with my bun falling apart,fries, chicken fingers - not worth it. I will say the ice cream was good tho! I will go back for ice cream but will take it to go unless they clean their tables and chairs :)))

Food was absolutely gross. Ordered 2 cheese steaks. The sandwich was soggy and both tasted like had jelly. Little children were running around kitchen. Smoke alarm kept going off. This was an experience that I don't wanna experience again

kenneth papp

Food was absolutely gross. Ordered 2 cheese steaks. The sandwich was soggy and both tasted like had jelly. Little children were running around kitchen. Smoke alarm kept going off. This was an experience that I don't wanna experience again

Amanda

I was super excited about this place but ended up really disappointed - came with my family, sat down to eat at a filthy table, nothing was wiped down..they were all like that. I didn’t not feel like I was in a new establishment .. it just felt dirty. I understand that they’re busy and would like to give them some slack but that’s just a huge turn off for me. Maybe leave some wipes out if you don’t have staff to clean ? We ended up sitting down anyways because we had to eat, the garbage was toppling over and leaking milkshake all over the floor. $50 for hot dogs with my bun falling apart,fries, chicken fingers - not worth it. I will say the ice cream was good tho! I will go back for ice cream but will take it to go unless they clean their tables and chairs :)))

First time going to this new spot and I am extremely disappointed and don’t think I will be returning again. I asked for a small cup of ice cream with hot fudge and the server told me he needed to put it in a larger cup so it did not over flow. I was given the smallest single scoop of melted ice cream that I was charged 6.50 for. I should have handed it back and walked out! Completely shocked. This was a joke. Was basically the size of a pup cup from Starbucks.

nicolette rose

First time going to this new spot and I am extremely disappointed and don’t think I will be returning again. I asked for a small cup of ice cream with hot fudge and the server told me he needed to put it in a larger cup so it did not over flow. I was given the smallest single scoop of melted ice cream that I was charged 6.50 for. I should have handed it back and walked out! Completely shocked. This was a joke. Was basically the size of a pup cup from Starbucks.

All I wanted was a scoop of ice cream in a cup and the girl didn’t even come help us. Waited 30 minutes, kept making eye contact with the worker. She completely ignored us and served customers who came in well after us, not even acknowledging us. Left without anything. Awful service. Do not recommend.

Arthur Treachers fish and chips and chips sucked. The bag was wet from the Uber driver. It sucked. Are you comedians.

We ordered six takeaways of vanilla Mr. Softee; however, the flavor did not match the original Mr. Softee taste. This suggests the machine mix was not prepared properly.

Imran Khan

We ordered six takeaways of vanilla Mr. Softee; however, the flavor did not match the original Mr. Softee taste. This suggests the machine mix was not prepared properly.

Giuliana Calogero

All I wanted was a scoop of ice cream in a cup and the girl didn’t even come help us. Waited 30 minutes, kept making eye contact with the worker. She completely ignored us and served customers who came in well after us, not even acknowledging us. Left without anything. Awful service. Do not recommend.

jacklyn martin

The people working in the place were nice and helpful. The chicken tenders were disgusting!!! They are not made with real meat like Nathan’s chicken normally is. They were basically chicken nuggets mushy meat! I called to speak to someone about them bc I spent 10 bucks on mushy nasty meat and no one got back to me! Everything else was pretty good. The chicken shouldn’t be labeled as tenders bc they are not tenderloins it’s mushy nugget meat.

Christina Vicinanza

Absolutely the worst Nathan's experience. Was soo excited that Nathan's opened in town was eager to go. Finally decided to treat ourselves to our long loved hot dog nuggets, chili dogs, and fries. The nuggets were so bad my husband kept insisting I send them back. Coated in excessive amounts of batter that was crumbling apart and must have been fried in what could only have been dirty greasy oil as the nuggets were almost black in color. French fries which are supposed to be golden brown same thing came out dark dark brown laying in the container with all oil. My husband said that the chili and cheese on his hotdogs tasted far from any other Nathans hotdog hes ever had. He actually stated that the hotdogs at 711 up the road have better cheese.I simply dont understand how a chain restaurant can taste so different than other locations. My only regret other than going was not taking a picture to be able to explain how far from typical Nathan's quality our food was. I am not one to ever right google reviews but $35 on terrible food needs to be noted.