Love it, it’s Long Island’s best

I order a soup this thing came in a small container for 11.00 are you kidding me. That soup that you have there must cost you at a maximum 1.00 per customer and you are selling it at 11.00 if this is not price hiking i have no idea what it.

This brings me back to my first pizza ever eaten! I'm sure you all know how a first time experience feels like e especially if it's a good one. The pizza I got reminds me of the wonderful taste & texture. I try not to be bias to any region pizza but by far fresh NYC pizza is #1 in my book & this restaurant continues to proof me right! I got the classic cheese, "grandma" & garlic knots & all of them are terrific! Again, going back to taste & texture, I love it!

My family has been coming here my whole life. My parents think it's the best pizza on Long Island. I don't know about that, but it's very good! I love their Italian ices too.

Absolutely love this place! I take people to experience and ALL end up taking others!! Sometimes a wait. BUT Worth it!👍🩷. Friendly! Clean! Superb Service! Portions are huge!!

I love the hot cold salad.😋😍

Pizza here was awesome just like I remember. Was good to be back!

The food here is always delicious, always hot and always fresh. If you arrive to find a line across the service area, don't panic as you will probably still be seated within 15-20 minutes. The portions are generous and the food is delicious. Prices are very reasonable. The servers are very attentive and if you are doing take out, they always double check your bags before you leave to insure that nothing is missing. The restaurant is clean, including the bathrooms.

Great place for dinner. Food was good and tasty. Service was timely

I am not a big " foodie" and I'm not a big fan of restaurants or sauce so you are probably wondering why I'm here but just ignore alI of that and read my review. My friend works in the area and we were meeting for a Birthday lunch ( both of us are December babies) and she suggested this place and I'm sure glad she did. It had been quite a long time since I've seen my friend so of course we were chatting and not looking at the menu but the waitress was so patient and a pleasure to work with. She came back a few times and we finally placed our order. The place was not as crowded as I thought it was going to be but as time went on the dining room started to fill up. My friend ordered two specialty 🍕's, a 🐃 🐔 and a 🥗 slice. I ordered a meatball hero with very little sauce ( I don't like red sauce; don't send me hate mail.) The meatballs were amazing, so tender and tasty. The portion was very large and I was able to take some home and enjoy the rest for dinner. We had a lovely time and I highly recommend stopping here for a bite to eat. The environment is nice, the waitresses are friendly, the food is delicious, the prices are reasonable ( don't raise them now,) and the selection is very good.

Stopped in for a slice had a buffalo chicken and a regular cheese slice and the pizza was delicious. The bread, cheese, sauce and everything was great quality and you can taste the charcoal oven flavor on the pizza it’s excellent. I’ve ate here before and the food is incredible as well in their restaurant area. If you’re stopping in just to grab a quick bite there’s also a lot of seating and everything is really nice, clean and good quality.

One of my all time favorite restaurants since I was a kid. The fact that this place has stood the test of time is proof enough that its deserving of this rating. The food is always amazing, and the place looks almost exactly the same as it did 20 years ago - which is a nice Italian vibe. The service at the counter can be a little sub-par, I'd guess because the employees are younger and don't know how to be as friendly. But servers are always 10/10. I go back every time I'm nearby.

My husband and I come here at least 1-2 times a month , have been for years. My absolute favorite place. I even had them cater my baby shower ! Lunch or dinner the service is absolutely fantastic. 10/10. Love these guys

Delicious pizza! All sorts of pies made to order. Had a huge get together and asked for my Grandma pies to get cut into smaller pieces. Done with no problems.

Had a 60th bday lunch. They were great. Food was great. They didn’t rush us. We did make sure we weren’t holding up diners. We’ve been there since they opened!

The food is amazing and reasonable my favorite Italian restaurant.

Best pizza! Best garlic knots! Best salads! I can’t say enough about these guys! Any time I’m in the area I’m in here! The flavor is unmatched - and we are talking LONG ISLAND PIZZA AT ITS FINEST here people! If you haven’t tried it, I expect a ‘thank you’ after!

Amazing pizza! I often go here when I'm on the Island visiting relatives. I've never had a bad experience in the dozen or so times I've been there. Grandma slice is very, very good. Sicilian slices are huge and delicious.

Best pizza in the area. Menu has not changed in years. Does not have to. Gets crowded around 6 pm ,for good reason. Great Italian food. There are 6 people making pies and 6 people up front serving slices then 3 people handing out take out and 3 cashiers. So all those people cannot be wrong.

I have been going to Branchinellis my whole life dating back to the original location in Commack. Amazing food without a doubt and very consistent. But what has happened to the house salad dressing that has always been a closely guarded secret and extremely delicious? Did they lose the recipe or change the primary ingredient of quality olive oil? I am very suspicious that they are not using olive oil. It looks different and taste awful. I did question both locations in Miller Place and Hauppauge and I feel like they are not being honest. Very disappointed with this horrible new dressing. Still I think they deserve 5 Stars as a lifelong patron of my favorite Italian restaurant.

Always super food, good fast service, easy to find a seat. Co-worker has been going there since he was a kid, and I can see why. I love the hustle of this place at lunch time! Also has a nice large dining room on one end where you could enjoy a quieter meal. Pizza is great, lots of other options too! Still got it guys, love the Antipasto Salad!

Great food always! Service was fantastic. Since I had ordered a large amount they walked the order to my car with me. I ordered a regular pie which was cooked to perfection. Their chicken Ceasar salad is delicious with fresh salad and a marinated grilled chicken. Yum! And the mozzarella balls with their home made marinara sauce is a great appetizer.

Best Pizza in Hauppaugue, the food is outstanding and the service is top notch. We eat there everytime we visit New York.

Best Italian we have ever had in NY/Long Island.

Always good food & good service. Our family has been going here for over 30 years. Love that you get wine with dinner if you ask for it. You get soup & salad OR pasta with dinners. I love their chicken parm & eggplant parm. Their pasta fagioli is delicious. We always go with family & friends & everyone meals are always good. They don't take reservations.

In town for a football game and my wife discovered this gem of an eatery! Oh my goodness - the pizza was PHENOMENAL, but the Pasta y Fagioli was DYNAMITE! Took me back to dining at my friend's grandma's house! I need to come back for more.

A classic pizzeria restaurant with gilded panache. If it's got cheese and sauce, it's on the menu. A good, crisp Neapolitan slice with the right amount of cheese and red sauce, coupled with a toothsome Sicilian slice, makes for a pizza one-two punch. Finish with a lemon Italian ice and you're in great shape.

One of the best authentic Pizza loving, cheezy, perfect crispy doughs I have come across. The stuffed pizzas are stuffed just right, the portions are a nice size, shareable as well. The prices are reasonable and the staff are super friendly. 👌 Their pizza is delicious dinning in or at home and reheated the next day.

My new favorite pizzeria. Been coming here a lot for my lunch breaks and it always hits the spot. Since I’m in the hauppauge area a lot I come here. I’ve had the miller place location but this location is way better since it’s original. This place is always a busy crowd even on weekdays. On TripAdvisor this is ranked number and it deserves the number 1 ranking. The workers are very friendly and I always have a great meal. If I’m in the area I’ll one day order a full pie. Overall a 10/10 pizzeria.

My favorite, just love their plain slices!!

Branchinelli's is a staple! It warms my heart to walk in and people at the tables give a shout and a wave hello. The food is always fresh and it's delicious to boot! Will continue to visit this restaurant and reccomend to all! Keep up the delicious food!!

Great atmosphere and even better pizza! My favorite is their grandmas pizza.

As always their Eggplant Rollatini was delicious & the sauce amazing...always a family favorite!!! 💕

I’ve been going to Branchinelli’s for over 30 years and they have hands down the best Sicilian pizza on Long Island! Not mention the classics! The quality of the food hasn’t Wavered what so ever! A must visit

Great tasting pizza clean and neat

Certainly! Here's a concise and positive review for an Italian restaurant: --- **5/5 – Authentic & Delicious Italian Dining!** I recently dined a Branchinelli's and was thoroughly impressed! The pasta was perfectly al dente, and the flavors were rich and authentic. The [specific dish, e.g., *Carbonara* or *Margherita Pizza*] was a standout. The service was warm and attentive, and the cozy ambiance made the experience even better. Highly recommend for anyone craving true Italian cuisine! ---

The buffalo chicken pizza is amazing! The service was a little more to be desired. Because we walked in to get a slice to sit in and eat. They didn't provide us napkins and or an open table. The waitress just ignored us because we didn't ask for a sit down service.

By far the best pizza joint on LI! There is no other place on a packed Friday night where you can get a large pie to go in under 15 minutes. Not only are they super fast, but it is consistently the best pizza I have ever had, every single time.

Great food..can ALWAYS be sure that my meal will be top notch and a pleasant experience..LUCA 😎

Pizza is awesome. Don’t live that close but definitely worth it.

They should write a how to manual and sell it for a million. I travel to Long Island once a year. How this restaurant provides you $50 worth of food for $25 to include a glass of wine is magic.

I love this establishment. They have the best pizza. The sauce on the pizzas is impeccable. Sometimes I go there to dine inside. The waiters and waitresses are all friendly. They have lots of delicious choices on the menu.

Branchinelli's Pizza & Restaurant is a solid local choice for reliable Italian comfort food in a casual setting. The portions are quite generous, making it a good value for families. The Chicken Marsala is a satisfying dinner pick, and their thin-crust pizza remains a consistent staple.

I’m from Illinois and stopped in here while on a family trip. The food and service was absolutely amazing. I had the vodka pasta and it was truly the best I ever had. My son and husband had a pepperoni pizza and it was delicious! Very thin and crispy. My husband is originally from the area and always has to get pizza any time we are in New York. Our waitress was so kind and the whole atmosphere of the restaurant was very pleasant. We will definitely be back the next time we are in town!

Mike Perrotta

One of our favorite spots to grab casual dinner with the family. Service is good and price is pretty good too. The chicken parmigiana dinner comes with choice of soup or salad or pasta. Pasta Fagoli is some of the best around reminds me of my Nana’s. Go check it out they don’t take reservations but even on busy nights the wait is no longer than 15-20 mins.

Tamara Foster

The food was great! What should be noted is the only have a red and white wine as an offering. There Is No Beer. But very delicious food as always.

Michael Tims (Memphis Mike)

Spinach Cannelloni w/white sauce was outstanding. Save some of the bread you get for dipping in that sauce. The rim of crusted cheese.......... forget about it. 🤌

Evan John

Branchinelli's doesn't look like much on the outside but that whole, "don't judge a book by its cover" proverb fits quite well in this regard. Speaking of which, if I am to partake in Italian dining, I figured what better book to read here than 'The Godfather'? "Leave the gun, take the cannoli." I was actually going to order a cannoli until I saw the price of my meal: Chicken Parmigiana with Ziti alla Vodka. Next time I'll order a cannoli though. Even though the prices are higher than what I'm used to, the portion sizes are very large, larger than another pizza place I frequent. That Chicken Roll was almost the size of a small chicken. It made the other pizza place's Chicken Roll look like a hot dog in comparison. I never had Chicken Parmigiana so I have no other experience to compare it to but it's definitely my new favorite dish and I will be asking for it at the other pizza places I frequent to see if they can measure up to the standard of Branchinelli's. I did get a Chicken Roll to go, which is what I usually get at the other places, but I also can't give a good enough review of that since I ate it a day later, not fresh. The portion sizes are so large that I ate the Chicken Parmigiana and Ziti for both lunch and dinner. Regarding the wait time and staff: no complaints from me. I didn't have to wait too long for my meal and the staff was friendly and patient. The atmosphere was welcoming and you didn't have that feeling you have at some places where you want to just get your food and get out as quickly as possible. It was a relaxing enough environment to enjoy reading in. I definitely recommend this place and I will be returning soon for my cannoli.

Ryan Loper

I was in town for business for one day. We stumbled upon this place and instantly knew we had found a winner. The young ladies at the counter were warm and welcoming. They didn’t hesitate to make suggestions and help us decide. The Chicken Parm was one of the best I have ever had and the portions are huge. The pizza was amazing (highly suggest the buffalo chicken). If you are looking for a true small town restarting, this is your place. Thank you. I will definitely Be back if given the chance.

Walt Rodriguez

2nd time at this place and I have to say the pizza is phenomenal. Fresh bread great flavor and rich sauce. I don’t normally review pizza places but man was this place good and super fast service. When I got in the line was long within 5 minutes I ordered paid and had my slice with 10 people in front of me. The garlic knots where a little small and at first glance I was disappointed and after eating them they were super crunchy covered in flavor and not “doughy” .. 8.3 for my One Bite Score

Mike Slagle

I loved the atmosphere and the service was fantastic. The place is well staffed and they care which are both rare these days. I had a Neapolitan pizza with half pepperoni. The pizza would probably rate a 7.0 on the one bite app, but it has so much potential. The sauce is a 10, the crust was a little thin in the middle which made it very floppy. I would reduce the cheese amount by 30% because it was way too heavy for the crust and was very greasy. The flavor though was 10/10. I loved it and will order again. Keep improving the pizza a little and you really got a great pie.

Bengüsu ARSLAN

Their pizza is fantastic. Best pizza I've eaten recently. It's similar to what I ate in Italy.

Mark Rumney

I am probably biased as coming back to Long Island, my home for a good part of my life, must include Branchinelli’s. The veal parmigiana always perfect in both taste and portion and since leaving I try to find the replacement. Yet to be found. What I love most is you can experience a nice casual sit down meal or order one fantastic pizza to your liking. Until next time…

Steven Lance Levine

The food here is the BEST!!! Can't say enough good things about this Italian Pizzeria and Restaurante!!! Whenever we are down from upstate NY, we always make a point at having dinner here... and the prices are extremely reasonable. ❤️

+8

lucy lu

We came here with family for an early dinner. The place was really nice inside . Very Italian. Food and service was great!

+2

Rand Ahlgren

Amazing food. Have been coming here for decades. Even after I moved across the country I still make sure to go when I visit. Baked ziti is killer and hands down the best pizza ever. Google wants me to update this (years later)... Branchinelli's is still amazing. Service was great and food is always good. It feels like prices may have gone up a bit, but that's the way things are everywhere.

Christian Mai

Very tasty and great variety of pizza. The Pin Wheel was fantastic. Ask for some tomato sauce on the side;) location is great, and the carry out really quick.

Was in the area so figured we'd stop in for dinner after a friend's recommendation. My husband had the chicken parm which came with soup and salad. I had the homemade manicotti. Both were amazing! Ou…

Was in the area so figured we'd stop in for dinner after a friend's recommendation. My husband had the chicken parm which came with soup and salad. I had the homemade manicotti. Both were ama…

Was in the area so figured we'd stop in for dinner after a friend's recommendation. My husband had the chicken parm which came with soup and salad. I had the homemade manicotti. Both were amazing…

I absolutely LOVE their Sicilian Slice and Eggplant Parmesian. OMG delish!! Great local spot for yummy food.

I absolutely LOVE their Sicilian Slice and eggplant Parmesian. OMG delish!! Great local spot for yummy food.

I m sure with all the pizza in NY someone will not like this post but this is some GREAT pizza. Service was quick and efficient. Someone suggested the place I am so glad they did. Was not sure how to…

I m sure with all the pizza in NY someone will not like this post but this is some GREAT pizza. Service was quick and efficient. Someone suggested the place I am so glad they did. Was not sure ho…

I m sure with all the pizza in NY someone will not like this post but this is some GREAT pizza. service was quick and efficient. Someone suggested the place I am so glad they did. Was not sure how …

Visited LI last weekend and really enjoyed our meal. it was packed but food was worth the wait which was not terrible for a Saturday night. the garlic bread was amazing as was the food. Will recomm…

Brancanelli's is the go-to pizza spot for kids after school... and for good reason! Their garlic knots are perfectly baked, soft inside with just the right amount of garlic and butter. They are rea…

Food is so so good. service is quick and easy. The chicken parm is so so good I love this place.

Fantastic pizza. Love to stop for a slice, a complete lunch or dinner. Fantastic staff.

I've been here a few times and it's a great pizza place! The staff is friendly and helpful, the ambiance is amazing, they have such cool lighting! It's also in a convenient location as well!

Always hits the spot. Try their chicken roll. The bread is so good. Service always on point and their ambiance is fancy yet casual. Good spot for friends and family alike

Best italian food i highly recommend to all my friends and family quick service freshly made food and atmosphere keep up good work !

Pizza is amazing. Service is amazing. Unbeatable prices. Been around for a while for a reason. Thank you!

Have been a regular at Branchinelli for years. Food is always great. Service is good. Even when there is a line to wait, you are called within a reasonable time. Would recommend to everyone. If it …

Excellent! Got the manicotti special with 3 different fillings. Love the complimentary wine and $3.25 for a 2nd glass. "Red or white." LOL

Excellent! Got the manicotti special with 3 different fillings. Love the complimentary wine and $3.25 for a 2nd glass. "Red or white." LOL

Hadn't been to this restaurant in a long time. Certainly worth the wait on line. Tried a few different things. The chicken parm delicious the 3 type manicotti superb the baked clams perfection salad …

Hadn't been to this restaurant in a long time. Certainly worth the wait on line. Tried a few different things. The chicken parm delicious the 3 type manicotti superb the baked clams perfection sa…

Hadn't been to this restaurant in a long time. Certainly worth the wait on line. Tried a few different things. The chicken parm delicious the 3 type manicotti superb the baked clams perfection sala…

Great food at reasonable prices! Have always loved everything we ordered. staff is attentive. Casual dining. Will definitely go back.

Great food at reasonable prices! Have always loved everything we ordered. Staff is attentive. Casual dining. Will definitely go back.

We hadn't been here in quite a while and were glad to find it even better than before. The service is efficient and friendly and the complementary glass of wine is always welcome. They offer choic…

We hadn't been here in quite a while and were glad to find it even better than before. The service is efficient and friendly and the complementary glass of wine is always welcome. They offer choic…

We have been here a couple of times primarily because we take my dad out for lunch. Since he is at a local assisted living facility it is close and convenient. The food was good. I especially like the dining room where you could have half of a hero and soup. They also give a complementary glass of wine (and is NOT a small amount). The tomato sauce is acceptable (not the best) but for the money is durable.

Food is great. Pizza is way overpriced. 38 dollars for a 2 topping pizza I'm not asking for two tomahawks on top.

Best local pizza by a lot

+6

Good service, good pies, nice dining area! It works!

+1

I enjoy their Pizza and pinwheels. The garlic knots are inconsistent, but when they are good, they are really good.

Dinner for 4 with friends… pasta dishes were flavorful, cooked al dente as expected, salads were crisp and fresh, ravioli was excellent, eggplant rollatini was an overcooked mess but very tasty… their sauce is excellent. Garlic bread with mozzarella was as expected. Very limited dessert options and no cappuccino was very disappointing.

Lovely experience — calm, comfortable, and very well organized.

Food was great. Service lacking.

Best pepperoni slice I've had on Long Island! Not the best plain slice, but there's something about their pepperoni that's amazing. Had their chicken parm which was pretty good but very expensive for a lunch. Ended up paying over 30 dollars for lunch! Good parm, but not $30 for lunch good. I'll be back for the pepperoni.

The food quality and service were excellent. I'm knocking a star off for not having an alcohol license (There was a complementary glass of wine available, but who doesn't want a beer with their pizza) and their policy of not allowing customers to sit until everyone in their party is present (I know this has become common practice, but it's still unacceptable to me).

c v

For the love of pie, PLEASE clean the bathrooms. The Mount Sinai location is spotless, always! Hauppauge is down right gross. It’s a disappointment to your patrons and your staff! We’ve been coming to both locations for over 30 years. It’s about time someone inform you of this. The manager isn’t friendly ie, walks by patrons without a simple hello and puts his hands in his mouth right behind the counter. It’s a wonder I gave four stars. I mean come on bro. Bigger problem is the food is outstanding and we’ll keep coming.

Aupair with Anh Pham

Very busy Pizza restaurant. There was a long line waiting for tables when I walked in. Luckily I only got 2 slides of pizza to go so my waiting time was about 5-7 minutes. The pizza cannot be 5 star but it's better than other pizza place. Lots of options to choose. Recommend to call them for a table before you go here if you plan to have a dine-in meal

Food was good, but didn't care for plastic cups and plastic silverware considering that the prices were on the high side.

We came here with friends for lunch. The portions were huge and the food was great. I definitely will be coming back soon.

I love this place! Their pizza is truly a work of art! They make an amazing stuffed meat slice filled with pepperoni, sausage, and meatball. I recommend getting it with a side of red sauce. I ord…

I stopped off for a couple of slices on the way home from work. Branchinelli's is one of my favorite places to get pizza in Suffolk County. I had the eggplant parmesean slice and everything slice…

Branchinelli’s offers good food, great Bruschetta bread as an apple, and a decent customer service. I ate Alfredo pasta and my friend ate a chicken parmesan meal. We ordered the eggplant rollatin…

I grabbed a quick dinner during the week. chicken parm Slice was amazing. Plenty of cut up chicken cutlet with a hearty marinara sauce. Very firm undercarriage with crunch. Stuffed Slice was ju…

We ordered for pickup: one special pie and two extra slices for my toddler who only likes regular cheese pizza. We got there and they had forgotten to set aside the two slices and the store was closing. My child was extremely disappointed and I had to do my best to remove all the extras from my pizza and convince him to eat it. I would recommend ordering from another nearby pizza joint if possible, I really tried to like this place but the taste was never the best and after what happened, I can’t trust they won’t mess our order again which is what we always go for, it would pain me to see my child going thru this again.

The food is ok. I ordered a chicken roll it was ok but it didn't have enough chicken.

So I was told to come check this place out next time we were gonna get a pie. I ordered a regular pie with garlic knots. The pie & knots to me were very light & undercooked. The sauce was decent but I feel I’d rate it higher if it wasn’t so floppy. The knots barely warmed up by counter staff were tiny as opposed to other local pizza places. In their defense I was told their Sicilian was exceptional but my daughters insisted on “triangle slices” (regular pie ) so I will come back another time to test the Sicilian to be fair. I’ll return to try some other stuff but thus far not impressed.

Been here a couple times, it was ok last time, thought we'd give it another try. My wife's Chicken parm was good, though the cutlet was too thick, but good. I ordered the Grilled chicken Primavera. It wasn't good. Overall the chicken & vegetables weren't very flavorful. It said the chicken was in Balsamic,it did seem soaked in something, but not much flavor, nor did it seem grilled. The vegetables had way too much celery & carrots mixed in. I love Primavera dishes but I ended up not eating it.

m m

Moved from Nassau County and Huntington Village to Smithtown. Looking for a good slice. Although , I haven't tried the dishes , I tried the pizza and its different. For myself, it was soggy, lift the slice up and everything falls off. The crust wasn't crispy very soft. Many places around the area, in Suffolk are the same. It has to be crispy firm. biting into a crispy bread crust. Cooked. My choices in Suffolk are Rosa's in Huntington Village, and Carlos's Pizza in Manorville. Again. It's up to the individual. but a good crust for me is a must.Working in N.Y.C and the boroughs, the pizza is good. Nassau has good spots as well, few but good. Bake bread first then add toppings. If it isn't firm it isnt good. All the best to them. I'm sure their meals are great as reviewed. Be well.

Thomas Liantonio

Outdated decor, food is nothing special. Order chicken parm with pasta. Typical frozen breaded cutlet everyone seams to be using. Runny salty tomato sauce. No desire to return.

Lee

We have not been here in a few years, but the food is still pretty good. We usually end up paying around $70 to $80 whenever we eat at an Italian restaurant because we usually grab our favorite entres wherever we go, and most Italian restaurants charge about the same. This restaurant charges a bit more, and our bill came to about $100...I hadn't seen that high a bill in a while. The waitress came by twice..once to take our order and once to give us the check....I had to walk to the front counter to pay the bill. In my opinion, The food is a 4 our of 5 the service and pricing were a 3.

Average food. Pizza was phenomenal. Very high prices. Definitely worth it for the pizza and homey Italian cheesecake but chicken dishes aren't great.

Average food. pizza was phenomenal. Very high prices. Definitely worth it for the pizza and homey Italian cheesecake but chicken dishes aren't great.

Average food. Pizza was phenomenal. Very high prices. Definitely worth it for the pizza and homey Italian cheesecake but chicken dishes aren't great.

Pizza and food here just not very good here folks.Very inconsistent! Pizza all dough sometimes not cooked enough.How is this good pizza??? Food portions tiny, order spaghetti and meatballs they fi…

pizza and food here just not very good here folks.Very inconsistent! pizza all dough sometimes not cooked enough.How is this good pizza??? food portions tiny, order spaghetti and meatbal…

pizza and food here just not very good here folks.Very inconsistent! pizza all dough sometimes not cooked enough.How is this good pizza??? Food portions tiny, order spaghetti and meatballs t…

I've always had great experiences here. That's what keeps me coming back, again and again. Today's experience fell short of the typical experience. service at the counter was excellent. The gentlem…

Was a regular here for many years and have company in from Florida and they would not seat us , lost a customer for life. Sad Anthony could not accommodate. All because they sat incomplete groups breaking the long standing policy they have

Used to be the best place in Suffolk for Italian… it’s just not the same anymore. Food is alright , service is horrible. Won’t be coming here again.

Jon W

Was pretty unhappy with my server. Very inattentive, not cheerful or even interactive at all. My mom loves this place, so we took her for her birthday. The server hardly said hello. At some point we literally mentioned we were there for mom's birthday because she loves the place; the woman said "Oh. Are you ready to order?" Like...not even a quick happy birthday? Nothing? After dropping off the food, she disappeared and never checked in with us again. After a while, she came over out of nowhere and practically threw leftover containers and the check on our table. Didn't say thank you for coming or anything. Honestly, I shouldn't have even tipped after that. The food was all great. I see why Mom likes the place, but I'm never coming back because of the service.

They refused to add eggplant to my salad instead of chicken. they tried to sell me a 15 dollar eggplant meal when i wanted a salad. i decided to order the salad plain and one with chicken. my hus…

Service was brutal. Sat and waited to be served. Sat with dirty dishes throughout the meal. Food was Luke warm. Place used to be good. There was nothing redeeming about this spot. SKIP!!

Had a horrible experience with racist waitress. Came here to have dinner with my family, we got this waitress who treated us so rudely from the moment she laid eyes upon us. She was also taking care of the tables around us and it was was SAD AND INFURIATING to see how she interacted with all the white patrons, smiles, laughing, kindness in her eyes, but then when she came to our table she treated us so rudely, condescending and with hatred in her eyes. I started to get angry but didn’t want to make a scene with my family there so I just gracefully let the lady be her horrible self and at the end I gave her a huge tip just to see if she would act differently and boy oh boy did her eyes light up and a smile suddenly emerged from her previous begrudging face. I will never step foot in this racist establishment again. Train your employees better, it’s 2024, no room for ignorante tiny brained racism.

Did they change the cheese on the pizza? Why change? Brachanelli’s is reason we travel so far for the pizza we think is one of the best in Suffolk county? Please reconsider your change. I know inflation is crazy but we pay for your amazing pizza! Don’t change the formula .

Very Disappointed in Branchinellis. I'm a long time customer of over 20 years and my visit for takeout Friday was horrible. The new policy is they make customers wait in a line outside to pick up your take out, including in the rain apparently. OK, fine, met some nice neighbors also waiting in the rain. My turn to get inside and pick up and I walked to the counter only to get scolded by a young man saying "go wait outside, I didn't see you waiting!" I said, "Yes I did wait 20 minutes outside after you told me on the phone my order will be ready in 15 minutes." He said "NO! You weren't called up to the counter either!" I said, "You called next and I was next in line." He looked at me like I was a criminal then asked for my name. Now, he cant find my order. I looked at the man who I assume is the Manager and he comes over, he said "what's the problem?" I said "He cant find my order and harassed me for 5 minutes accusing me of not waiting on line and I did! Can I get my order now? He cant find my order either. He told the boy to get a plain pie! I didn't order a plain pie!My order was over $60 and they must have given it to someone else who waited in the rain. After 45 minutes of waiting, I said forget it! The Manager says, Good! Forget it! No apology, No courtesy, No appreciation to a long time customer. So if you are in the mood to wait outside for an order you never get after 45 minutes and like to be mistreated and have your integrity questioned and spend your hard earned money without appreciation or respect, go and enjoy. I will be going to the many other great Pizza places near here instead. Obviously they don't need my money. PS. My Daughter went with her friend for pizza after school a week ago. They gave her a slice in a box and told her and her friend she can't eat there at a table at 3 in the afternoon. So she walked with her boxed slice to sit on a bench to eat it cold by Shoprite. Nice management right? Obviously they don't appreciate anyone's business anymore.

Went to this place with my brother, and first they gave our table to someone that got there after us, no reservation or nothing, idk why. Immediately thought it was because we were speaking spanish and they were not, but we still waited for our table. After that, we noticed we were being served on paper plates, and that’s ok, if we were having pizza, but we got lasagna and a stuffed pie that was so hard to cut on a freaking paper plate, so idk if it was subtle racism or what but the tables next to us were eating on normal PEOPLE plates, and they were being disgusting, saying they couldn’t understand the waiter. Food was cold and we waited way too much for a lasagna. I didn’t like this place.

I can walk to this place but I have been going to mammas not because of the food but because of mgmt. how do you go into a PIZZA PARLOR at 4:45 pm on a Friday and they have 2 slices of stuffed pizza everything else is 10 minute wait I never heard of a pizza place running out of pizza this is a joke there was no regular no Sicilian no Buffalo no white no nothing obviously they like losing business! Losing me might not be a big deal but if you keep losing people like me overtime it adds up I can’t recommend anything because they didn’t have anything Best of Luck!!!

Been going there for over twenty years on and off,pretty much order a pie or two every two weeks. In the past I always had too many issues with my orders being incorrect so I would walk away for a while. Today I ordered a Sicilian well done and they told me it was not made well done and put it back in to the point of burning it. To be honest the last few pies we’ve ordered have not been good and we’re now done with them for good.

Ordered 2 heroes. Chicken parm and meatball parm for pick up. The bread wasn’t toasted just dry. There was no sauce on the chicken and very little on the meatball,which were flavorless with too bread in them. Couldn’t find any cheese on either. For the prices they charge I expected a lot more!

Always having to wait on line at this place. My bf on the way. Less than 10 mins ok so I asked for a table for 2. They told me I had to wait for him to walk in or I wouldn't be seated. At 8:30pm....??? I literally said he would be right here I just wanted to order drinks and get the bread going. They immediately told me sit off to the side and started sitting other people behind me. Just like that. No decency or speaking skills at all. Not coming back. We went to another Italian place close by with brick oven pizza. Horrible people.

Have eaten here several times as well as gotten takeout. My in-laws (Hauppauge natives) adore it, so does my one very dear friend and her family, and also my former supervisor who is super cool. But their pizza tastes like paper to me, and the salad is also not delicious either. They have finally renovated the front takeout counters and gotten rid of the aging Formica which is exciting. But I just can’t figure out why everyone says it tastes so good 🤷‍♀️🤷‍♀️

This pizzeria did not not want to support li pizza strong. They said “didn’t they raise enough money already for that Officer.”disgusting.

Bella

purchased a pie w chicken, $10 for a topping, inflated price....pizza had hair in it, will not be going back. I didn't find it so great either, also, not such a clean environment. I had to wait 4 min t o find out the price. will stick with mamma sabaros, cleaner, way better price, and way better food. would not recommend branchinellis. not sure what the hype is.