Gus's Pizzeria

Honestly, I was skeptical to try this place. I saw some bad reviews under the new ownership, there were a lot that turned me off for a while. So I’d always go out of my way to try other pizza shops. I’m convinced it’s some sort of personal vendetta lol. What the hell?! This pizza is great. Service is great they’re super nice. Untruthful reviews hurt businesses. I love good food, I leave lots of reviews. This place is great!!! As great as any quick bite pizza eatery can be. Lots of options and the pizza is made great, crunchy, sturdy slice, full of toppings, even single slices are packaged well to go in a box, so you can carry it with you comfortably. they even have dipping sauces which is not too common in america but a Canadian gurl like me loves that. Needed to support with a good review. Try it out!!

Nicky's is our family's favorite pizza! No matter what we order we are never disappointed. Definitely the best garlic knots around. Been going there since I moved to the neighborhood 9 years ago. Staff is very pleasant and food is always delivered fast!!

Very tasty pizza — quick and delicious. Ordered delivery to the office — everything was great!

My husband and I, has been coming to this location for many many years, and it has always been AA+. Always friendly, always going above and beyond.

everyone was happy with their order. so that keeps me happy.

I must say for pizzeria based in Brooklyn in this day and age they're very good at what they do. With a variety of different foods and menu options you are sure to find something to satisfy even the most finicky eater in your family. The environment is clean and we'll managed and the staff is friendly and treat you like family as opposed to just another customer. Each table is clean and stocked with hand sanitizer and is family friendly. I would highly recommend Gus's pizzeria and challenge anyone to leave without a smile on they're face and a happy belly. Come hungry and leave with an awesome wholesome experience.

Best pizza Bath Avenue can offer. Great staff and owner is one of a kind. Stop by and get the Chicago Pizza or the Regular Round thin crust...

Stephen C

everyone was happy with their order. so that keeps me happy.

Foxy Team

It’s a good place for pizza and Zeppoli And chicken

Дмитрий Довнар

Very tasty pizza — quick and delicious. Ordered delivery to the office — everything was great!

Darwin Cheverez

I must say for pizzeria based in Brooklyn in this day and age they're very good at what they do. With a variety of different foods and menu options you are sure to find something to satisfy even the most finicky eater in your family. The environment is clean and we'll managed and the staff is friendly and treat you like family as opposed to just another customer. Each table is clean and stocked with hand sanitizer and is family friendly. I would highly recommend Gus's pizzeria and challenge anyone to leave without a smile on they're face and a happy belly. Come hungry and leave with an awesome wholesome experience.

v

Honestly, I was skeptical to try this place. I saw some bad reviews under the new ownership, there were a lot that turned me off for a while. So I’d always go out of my way to try other pizza shops. I’m convinced it’s some sort of personal vendetta lol. What the hell?! This pizza is great. Service is great they’re super nice. Untruthful reviews hurt businesses. I love good food, I leave lots of reviews. This place is great!!! As great as any quick bite pizza eatery can be. Lots of options and the pizza is made great, crunchy, sturdy slice, full of toppings, even single slices are packaged well to go in a box, so you can carry it with you comfortably. they even have dipping sauces which is not too common in america but a Canadian gurl like me loves that. Needed to support with a good review. Try it out!!

Theresa Velez

Nicky's is our family's favorite pizza! No matter what we order we are never disappointed. Definitely the best garlic knots around. Been going there since I moved to the neighborhood 9 years ago. Staff is very pleasant and food is always delivered fast!!

Best Cesar salad slice I have ever tasted!! The crust was crunchy but a soft texture . I love the Cesar dressing it was delicious and the grilled chicken was so soft and fresh !! Was far from chewy or that weird texture. I recommend it most definitely!

Decent pizza, ziti was okay not my fav Staff is very friendly! Pizza taste good!

Jacqulyn “Jackie Green” Horowitz

Best Cesar salad slice I have ever tasted!! The crust was crunchy but a soft texture . I love the Cesar dressing it was delicious and the grilled chicken was so soft and fresh !! Was far from chewy or that weird texture. I recommend it most definitely!

Nasrin Y

Decent pizza, ziti was okay not my fav Staff is very friendly! Pizza taste good!

Pretty good pizza. Soft crust on the thick side, which I love. The staff is always really nice. Ive only tried their regular pie, garlic knots and mozzarella sticks. All were good and fair price. My only complaint is that the pizza is a little on the salty side.

Jennifer flores

Pretty good pizza. Soft crust on the thick side, which I love. The staff is always really nice. Ive only tried their regular pie, garlic knots and mozzarella sticks. All were good and fair price. My only complaint is that the pizza is a little on the salty side.

The restaurant is located in the Bensonhurst section of Brooklyn. They prepare Italian/Mexican cuisine. Several tables are available for dining in but there are no servers. Pizza, burgers 🍔, hot dogs, salads, sandwiches 🥪, heroes, appetizers, entrees, pasta, rolls, sides, special family specials, desserts and beverages are available. I ordered a pizza, garden salad and pasta with clam sauce. The food was average in taste and flavor.

Nicky's is a pretty average pizzeria. The pizza isn't bad, but this is not a destination location. The garlic knots are excellent. The service is fast and the staff is pleasant. Nicky's is just an ordinary, neighborhood pizza joint, so if you're hungry you can't go wrong.

D A

Nicky's is a pretty average pizzeria. The pizza isn't bad, but this is not a destination location. The garlic knots are excellent. The service is fast and the staff is pleasant. Nicky's is just an ordinary, neighborhood pizza joint, so if you're hungry you can't go wrong.

Trying to figure out howwwwww they missed these mold spots on the bread before literally wrapping it in Aluminum foil. The fact that you guys are serving people this is absolutely disgusting. I will no longer order from here and will definitely be reporting this. Stop serving old and stale food!!!

ashley

Trying to figure out howwwwww they missed these mold spots on the bread before literally wrapping it in Aluminum foil. The fact that you guys are serving people this is absolutely disgusting. I will no longer order from here and will definitely be reporting this. Stop serving old and stale food!!!

Horrible… just horrible… I used to come here almost everyday back when it was Nicky’s. The owners were amazing, kind, and knew their way around dough. I thought I’d roll the dice on the new ownership and let me tell you; i would’ve had a better slice at papa John’s compared to this place. I don’t know if it’s the nostalgia of remembering glass Snapple bottles and $1.75 for two slices and a drink; but this place was just awful. The prices are insane for the terrible quality and portion size. I hope they either turn the business model around, change the ingredients, or whatever else they have to do to improve quality or just close down so a better pizza maker is able to take over. South Brooklyn has gone through a lot of changes over the years but in my opinion; this has been the worst one. If I could give this place zero stars I would. RIP Nicky’s 🍕🕊️

Avoid this place at all costs, low quality pizza for absurd prices. Owner also charged me extra for my pure leaf tea by charging me for a gatorade which costs more and when confronted about it all he could say was cause of credit meanwhile on the refrigerator it clearly says the tea is $2.70 for credit and $3.90 for the gatorade. Place has gone severely downhill since it changed owners from Nickys. If I could give this place less than 1 star I would.

Alex

Horrible… just horrible… I used to come here almost everyday back when it was Nicky’s. The owners were amazing, kind, and knew their way around dough. I thought I’d roll the dice on the new ownership and let me tell you; i would’ve had a better slice at papa John’s compared to this place. I don’t know if it’s the nostalgia of remembering glass Snapple bottles and $1.75 for two slices and a drink; but this place was just awful. The prices are insane for the terrible quality and portion size. I hope they either turn the business model around, change the ingredients, or whatever else they have to do to improve quality or just close down so a better pizza maker is able to take over. South Brooklyn has gone through a lot of changes over the years but in my opinion; this has been the worst one. If I could give this place zero stars I would. RIP Nicky’s 🍕🕊️

Justin Chung

Avoid this place at all costs, low quality pizza for absurd prices. Owner also charged me extra for my pure leaf tea by charging me for a gatorade which costs more and when confronted about it all he could say was cause of credit meanwhile on the refrigerator it clearly says the tea is $2.70 for credit and $3.90 for the gatorade. Place has gone severely downhill since it changed owners from Nickys. If I could give this place less than 1 star I would.

joe ru

Nicky's used to be a 4 star place Apparently under new ownership and the place has gone to trash. Slice too thick and doughy, way too much cheese, and of poor quality (think Brooklyn pizza at 86&14) and sauce too acidic. Slice not oily at all. Also took forever after I was sitting down for them to even put the slices into the oven.

Joey Ye

My mom has been taking my nephew to this place once a week after his school is over. For a few times, she saw one of the staff use his hands to grab the pizza after touching the bills. Did anyone else notice this? This staff should be fired! We won’t go eat at this place any longer.