Rosaria “Oceania”

Pizza Daddy has the BEST SICILIAN pie I have tasted in my life. Their Sicilian pie is not only tasty, but taste like fresh Focaccia baked bread like they make in Italy. I switched from regular pizza pie, to now ordering their Sicilian pizza pie since the first time I tasted their Sicilian pie. If you haven't tried their Sicilian pie, you must order one and I guarantee you will LOVE IT AND GET HOOKED ON IT. Their workers are respectful and friendly, including their two delivery guys that are the same two that always delivers my pie. I always tip them a custom tip (more than the app ask) because they deserve it. Pizza Daddy owner whatever you do, keep making them Sicilian pies just as is. Happy customer on 59th st 😃

Detective Pikachu

Hidden Gem with a Slice That Stands Out Pizza Daddy is one of those rare hidden gems you remember fondly. It’s tucked away just enough to feel peaceful — definitely not your typical busy NYC pizza spot. It gives off more of a calm, almost small-town vibe, which I find really refreshing in the middle of the city. The owners are always friendly and welcoming, and there’s a nice little counter up front where you can sit and eat. On a sunny day, the light pours in and it’s the perfect place to just relax with your slice. Now about the pizza — I’ve got to rave about this one particular slice. It’s square, thick-crust, focaccia-style, topped with fresh chopped tomatoes, olive oil, garlic, and melted mozzarella (maybe even some red onion and herbs in there). The flavors are bright, savory, and have that slightly tangy, garlicky finish that just hits right. It’s crispy on the bottom, soft inside — exactly how you want it. I don’t know the name of it, but if you see it, get it. It’s seriously one of the best slices I’ve had. Honestly? It’s better than most pizza joints in NYC. Definitely above average, especially for this style — and it’s the kind of option you won’t find at a typical corner slice shop. Overall: Friendly people, chill vibes, great space to sit and eat, and a slice that’s full of flavor and texture. Highly recommend checking this place out — it’s a real NYC hidden gem.

dasha matsneva

I been eating from this place for almost 10 years legit the best pizza there food is always bomb as hell never had nothing that wasn’t delicious I order from here to my business my moms house and my house never disappoints fire food always.

A R

Vodka pizza was fantastic! We also ordered a sausage and pepperoni which was great too. Note: the pic is of two different pizzas put side by side, I don’t think you can’t do a half vodka pie.

Michael K

Very comfortable and cozy pizza place with a relaxing atmosphere and comforting decor. I would definitely recommend eating in here, though ordering out is fine too. Staff is very friendly, it feels like home.

Really enjoyed the vibe and the service here! Both were definitely 4-star quality. The food was decent (3/5), making it a solid choice for a casual meal in a nice environment.

Corey Mack

One of the best Sicilian slices I’ve had in awhile. Staff was friendly, service was quick. Felt like a whole in the wall pizza spot in NYC. Their regular slices, not the best but not bad.

Steven Nechamkin

The restaurant is located in the Bensonhurst section of Brooklyn. They prepare Italian cuisine. Several seats are available for dining in but there are no servers. Wide variety of items on the menu include soups, salads, appetizers, wings, sides, rolls, calzones, entrees, heroes, wraps, burgers, pizza, desserts and beverages.I ordered the Siciliana square pizza pie which was well-prepared. The filet of sole with pasta was tasty. The restaurant has good prices. Friendly and helpful staff.

+2

Tony N

Good solid local pizzeria. Had a sausage roll. Was solidly good. Not a pizza I would travel out of my way to have but is reliably good like L'Industrie or Lucia's of Ave X.

Gaurav Shirodkar

Really chill atmosphere. There isn't much room to sit inside but the pizza is solid. I got the buffalo chicken slice and it was really good! The dough for the garlic knots were really good but it was a little less garlicly than id liked. The employees there were really nice and attentive too.

Henry

The Sicilian felt cheap like a piece of wonder bread with pasta sauce and a slice of brick, not fresh mozzarella. L&Bs is much better

Angela Rivera

My poor special needs aunt (literally the sweetest woman I know) called in an order for delivery and while she was on the phone with one of the guys taking her order, he was extremely rude. While she was stuttering to get her order out he was so rude and said “if you don’t want to make up your mind you can wait.” And proceed to put her on hold. She was so nervous she almost hung up. They need more patience here. The food is ok my the service needs to shape up. It’s crazy they just called back to cancel because of review. The order she tried really hard to place. I’m blow away by the extreme hostility towards special needs customers. They clearly heard her trying her absolute best to place the order and was so rude that I heard it over the phone. I was completely shocked at the tone and lack of patience they truly have here. I guess we should’ve know when we saw the 4 stars. Well. I wish the staff good luck. Even if they couldn’t be gentle with my sweet aunt.