Carl S

One of the best pizza we’ve ever tried. The pasta and drinks is so good. Thanks to Gab and Coleen for making a dining experience way better.

Joanni Rodriguez

Pizza Secret has really good food with a great team. Everyone was happy to see us and treated us well. We had cacio e Pepe pizza which we devoured. Cacio e Pepe pasta and a different pasta which I didnt try. We all enjoyed everything we ordered but the biggest star was the Secret Salad. Simple, yet elegant, small but BIG flavor. It was so good we ordered another one so we wouldn’t have to share. Despite the intense heat outside and the trek to Brooklyn I will go there again… and again.

+1

Christian Hoehner

After a full day of exploring Brooklyn on foot we crashed here for a late lunch. The welcoming staff and service couldn’t have been friendlier or better. Fun atmosphere with plenty of breeze inside. Salad was crisp/fresh and the pizza was tasty. Would definitely recommend for a family looking for a nice, but quick, sit down lunch. Great job!

Javier Kohen

Excellent Neapolitan pizza in NYC. The crust was the right amount of chewy, the toppings in the pistachio and burrata pizza were generous and delicious. The montanara pizza with fried dough was lighter than expected and a new and unique experience for me. The pizza was enjoyable to the last bite and surprisingly filling! The waitress was very cheerful and check in regularly. The gnocchi Al quattro formagi were also very good. I haven't had gnocchi with such clear potato flavor in a long time. On the other hand the salad was quite weak and expensive. So much lettuce, and not enough flavor overall. The restroom smelled bad right at opening time and it was filled with flies. Yuck!

+3

Jayson Burton

An absolute movie! Brought my son here for his bday and the whole restaurant serenaded him. The patrons, the wait staff all sang Dean Martin classics. Oh the food… from the Marguerite pizza to the plated pasta dishes, everything was flavor filled and authentic. From the manager to the wait staff were attentive, engaging and knowledgeable. Highly recommended standout in a city known for its pizza.

Vinny DiBartolo

This place is at the top of my list. The pizza here is unbelievable. The service is just as good, and you could always trust having good dinner or lunch at this place. I have probably recommended quite a few people here myself, and everybody that has come here has enjoyed the food and keeps on returning for more without me, lol. I don't leave too many reviews but this place has me reviewing because it's so good, if you want a authentic neapolitan pizza and some antipasti that are classic or even pasta dishes are made very well, you definitely should come here and check it out for yourself don't believe me. Not to mention, the drinks are excellent here as well whether you're getting a sangria or a regular cocktail they're unbelievable here, and everything they do really just is high level, check it out yourself.

Justin Ragozzino

Authentic Napolitano style pizza and restaurant. The food was very delicious and the staff was very friendly and accommodating. The restaurant was very beautiful and looked like it was straight from Napoli. Try the zucchini pie it was super delicious !

+2

dave I

1/9/26 back for dinner with the guys. We had a margarita pizza for the table, asked to have it crispy, it was not done crispy! Thin and wet, not great. This seems to be the only way they know how to make it. No more pizza for me. For my main meal i had the ziti with short rib, it was ok, not much flavor. The temperature of the dish was inconsistent, parts hot and parts luke warm. Not good either. How can this happen? Service is great, that's the main thing they got going. HH specials are only $10 drinks, no food specials. 11/19/24 first time here as Pizza Secret. Good decor, good service. Electronic menus. I had a glass of Red, fine. Some bread. One of the guys ordered a HH pizza, i got one slice, it was ok, a bit thin, with wide crust. For my meal i had the Pappardelle Bolognese. It was good, I'd get it again but will try other dishes first. We will be back.

+3

Mundi S

One of the best pizzas! The dough is amazing and the balance between the ingredients is perfecto. Very Neapolitan style and decor. The serving staff is really depressing. The pizzaiolo are cool and smiling .

+6

David Q (davqh)

I actually learned about this restaurant from an Italian show that my Italian teacher mention to me. I absolutely love this place. the food was amazing. The fried calamari tasted fresh. What i love about fried calamari is that it had the right amount of flour and seasoning. the mariner source that comes with the calamari tastes homemade. Had a Margarita pizza and it was one of the best Neapolitan pizzas in NYC. The cheese, the sauce, and the dough were on point. taste like a pizza that you would eat in Naples. The pizza was crunchy but not burned. I was Rosario could make my pizza but I do think he was in the day I went. Hopefully next time. I highly recommend this restaurant.

+8