Fayvenn

What a charming Greek spot! We thoroughly enjoyed our meal here, opting for the **Gyro platter** and the **Grilled Salmon**, both of which were wonderfully fresh and wholesome. Beyond the delicious food, the restaurant had truly lovely vibes. To top it all off, they even gave us complimentary Baklava, which was such a delightful touch. Highly recommend!

+1

Jayden Moore

Lovely little spot. I went for lunch on a hot weekend and it was so relaxing. I got the gyro and a peach juice. Delish! My gf got the Chicken and waffles. She liked that they don't skimp on the butter 😋

Christina Bernard

Came here looking for brunch , read the reviews online and they didn’t disappoint, the food was so good and fresh, will definitely be back such a chill/calm restaurant

Farnoosh Namdarpour

The owner was very warm and welcoming, graciously accommodating our large group of six. We had a wonderful experience and enjoyed the food. The moussaka, spanakopita, and baklava were my favorites.

Chaya Dewan

The owner, Isidoro, came to our table and took time to explain the dishes and made great suggestions. The fried feta with coating of honey was a great appetizer. We also ordered salmon and chicken gyros. I definitely recommend this restaurant for a taste of Greece.

Deborah Toniato

First time here, we had a great experience. It doesn’t offer only Greek food, you can chose among many different dishes and the food is amazing. The owner was super nice, extremely kind and friendly. We will come back for sure.

Marisa

Delivery came very quick. Ive been here a couple of times before and know the food is good. The spanakopita is outstanding. The lemon chicken is a large portion and delicious too. One recommendation is to ask them to wrap the container with the lemon chicken in foil or use a tighter container because most of the juices/sauce spilled out into the bag. They gave us 1 free baklava dessert which was nice and thanked us for the order. Great place!

Jeffrey Gross

Great meal and service! Octopus, ribeye, and shrimp dishes were all phenomenal. Free baklava for dessert was a really nice touch. Looking forward to coming back and trying more!

Katy Conrad

UPDATE June 2021: I was so excited to get to actually eat at Underhill after enjoying their delivery food through Covid, but I have to say I was shocked to dine in and find the lamb burger was overcooked and dry, the fries seem to have changed, everything was just a bit bland etc. I’m not sure if there’s a new chef or just a very off night but it was super disappointing. My original review is below, so I am only writing this in the hopes someone at Underhill takes it to heart, as I know it’s such a great spot. 2020: If you love Greek food, don’t miss this place! We have only had their delivery but it always comes quickly and the food is delicious. You HAVE to get the lamb burger — non negotiable. It is so good with crispy cheese on the bottom. Mmm. The spanikopita was a bit soggy but flavor is great. We love this spot.

+2

Ayinde Samuel

I rarely leave reviews, but my family and I had such a disappointing experience at Underhill Cafe that I felt it was important to share. From the moment we arrived, no one acknowledged us no greeting, no welcome, nothing. We patiently waited to be seated, only to watch multiple parties who came in after us get seated and served right away. It was disheartening and honestly infuriating to be treated as if we were invisible. We ultimately decided to leave and take our business elsewhere. I can’t say for certain if this was discriminatory, but it felt that way especially seeing white customers arrive later and receive immediate service. No one should have to question whether they’re being treated differently because of who they are. Do better.