Paddy's Pub Cortland

This new Paddy's Pub reboot is by far the best. It's like they checked off a list of things that would make this place feel just right. Great atmosphere and considerate workers. Food was quick... Nothing to complain about.

Truly excellent food! The wings are awesome with homemade sauces, even the 'hot' sauce has a twist! The Smashpaddy burgers are awesome, and also available in unique combinations! They also have a few craft beers...if they get more interest, I'm sure there will be more in the future!

Picked up. Food was outstanding! Wings were the best I’ve had in a while. Burger was great, pretzel came in a small pizza box (it was huge) and that with the dipping mustards was great as well.

First ever visit and loved the wings, go for the Irish sauce! Brought a burger home and that was fantastic even toaster oven reheated the next day! Plan on trying the giant pretzel next visit -

A whole new look at what a burger should be, try any of their paddy's you wont be disappointed! The cooks know what they are doing and are consistent, they will accommodate to your taste and special diet like thay always do for me. The staff is great and always friendly.

This place is awesome! Bartender Chad made the best Alabama Slampig EVER! Was delicious and was very fashionable. Food is good and the chairs are soft. I would reccomend this to anyone!

Tony was great and his bar was great. The food selection is very good and diverse. I ordered the boneless wings they were very crispy on the outside and juicy on the inside. I would recommend Paddy's to anyone looking for nice pub food.

Great experience and ambiance. The Reuben was very good. Make sure to get the wings with "Sweet Irish Whiskey" or "Chad's Pot o' Gold" they were fantastic.

If you like wings, burgers, and other bar foods they do it better than anybody in town. Truly a local spot that flies under the radar. Became our goto wing joint when COVID hit, and I cannot wait until we're back to normal to experience the bar.

Bar tenders are friendly wouldn't call it cheers where every one knows your name but it's a cool spot to grav a drink n food.

Amazing smashburgers! Kind of a small place, but the food is amazing. Have not been dissatisfied yet. The owner definitely cares a lot about the food and he is a super nice guy. I highly recommend this place.

Delicious burgers and chips. We ordered the garbage wings as well with the homemade blue cheese. Highly recommend! We will be going back!

Lilly was the best bartender ever!! Loved her will return.

First time! The Smashpatty and fries were excellent. Very nice family run establishment taking extra care that we all stay healthy with their drive up service.

The owner greets us every time we go. Great bartender and the hamburgers are amazing. Looking forward to our next visit.

This is your absolute best burger and wings going anywhere in CNY!! Super friendly staff too! If you’re local GO NOW and if you’re from afar DO VISIT!! THANKS TONY💚💚

The food was delicious, and the service even better 👌👌👌 Great spot to have a break from NYC to Niagara Falls!

Nice people good service food is very good we had the wings and the Irish nachos. Goo atmosphere. We will be back next time we come up from SC.

My wife and I stopped in for dinner and drinks, and as always, the bartenders were fantastic. We tried the Bavarian pretzel, garbage plate, and chicken wings—everything was delicious. The food and service both get a solid five out of five. Highly recommend if you’re looking for amazing food, great service, and a laid-back, relaxing atmosphere.

Amazing wings! Nice pub type atmosphere. Clean facility and nice staff.

Grand place even through the Covid-19 precautions. Can’t ask for better food from the wings, burgers and frequent yet perfect Guinness pours. Would encourage you to pop in should you find a need for good company between the hours of 4pm-8pm.

Wings and fries are excellent

Always wonderful. It's our "Cheers". Great owners, staff, patrons and food. The best wings anywhere!

Great service. Bar tender was patient and friendly. Crowd was welcoming. Drunken Fries!

Kevin Parker

My wife and I stopped in for dinner and drinks, and as always, the bartenders were fantastic. We tried the Bavarian pretzel, garbage plate, and chicken wings—everything was delicious. The food and service both get a solid five out of five. Highly recommend if you’re looking for amazing food, great service, and a laid-back, relaxing atmosphere.

Thomas Hayduk

Amazing wings! Nice pub type atmosphere. Clean facility and nice staff.

Laurence Walsh

Grand place even through the Covid-19 precautions. Can’t ask for better food from the wings, burgers and frequent yet perfect Guinness pours. Would encourage you to pop in should you find a need for good company between the hours of 4pm-8pm.

Andre Barnes

Wings and fries are excellent

Laura Rozelsky

Always wonderful. It's our "Cheers". Great owners, staff, patrons and food. The best wings anywhere!

Jed Myers

Great service. Bar tender was patient and friendly. Crowd was welcoming. Drunken Fries!

Edit: The owner reached out and offered to make it right. ‐-----‐--------------------------------------------------------------- Dissapointed with my order from Paddy's Pub tonight. Called and ordered a garbage plate and discovered when we got home it had no mac salad. I would've ordered another order of wings if I'd know they didn't have the essential base of the garbage plate. Called back and was told they've been "out of Mac Salad all day because it's been a busy few days". It would've been nice to have been told that when I ordered rather than pay full price for potatoes, chicken tenders and sauce. I'll be back for the excellent wings and to hopefully try the garbage plate for real, just disappointed in the service with no offer to make it right in the future.

The boneless wings were perfect, nice and crispy. The blue cheese was so thick and creamy, which I prefer. 100% recommend to anyone who loves wings. I haven't tried anything else yet, but apparently, the burgers are great too!

My lady and I ordered food from here tonight and let me just say that it was some of the best food I’ve had in a while. From their fries to the Ruben sandwich it was all made perfectly and it was by far the best Ruben I’ve had in years!

Nice, small pub....good beer and spirits selection. Menu is pretty small, but doing a few things well is better than doing many things mediocre. Pub favorites; comfort food. Bartender was sweet and does an awesome job on the menu board. Wish I had taken some pictures, but alas I forgot. Next time, there will be a next time!

This place earned five stars the second I bit into one of those wings. Best in Cortland hands down, and among the best I've had in general. The atmosphere here is very "townie" and I mean that as a compliment. It's a very no-frills kind of place where you get good bar food and beers at a fair price, and people seem to know one another. A good, honest bar. Gotta respect it.

Good food and nice selection of draft beers!

This was our first time visiting. The wings were exceptionally good, I especially liked the parmesan garlic, but the Alabama white was also great. It's obvious that the owners, Tony & Terry, take great pride in their business, they personally greet you & take time to check on you throughout your meal. The dessert pretzel was huge & fed 4 of us easily. There's so much camaraderie at the bar, everyone was cheering for their favorite team & enjoying their beverages of choice. We're looking forward to our next visit for more great food & such a friendly atmosphere.

Jessica DeLuna-Phillips

Edit: The owner reached out and offered to make it right. ‐-----‐--------------------------------------------------------------- Dissapointed with my order from Paddy's Pub tonight. Called and ordered a garbage plate and discovered when we got home it had no mac salad. I would've ordered another order of wings if I'd know they didn't have the essential base of the garbage plate. Called back and was told they've been "out of Mac Salad all day because it's been a busy few days". It would've been nice to have been told that when I ordered rather than pay full price for potatoes, chicken tenders and sauce. I'll be back for the excellent wings and to hopefully try the garbage plate for real, just disappointed in the service with no offer to make it right in the future.

T Werdt

Good food and nice selection of draft beers!

Lucas Sullivan

My lady and I ordered food from here tonight and let me just say that it was some of the best food I’ve had in a while. From their fries to the Ruben sandwich it was all made perfectly and it was by far the best Ruben I’ve had in years!

DiamondKnight

The boneless wings were perfect, nice and crispy. The blue cheese was so thick and creamy, which I prefer. 100% recommend to anyone who loves wings. I haven't tried anything else yet, but apparently, the burgers are great too!

Daniel Boshart

I was at dart league I ordered 210wings.they were cooked perfectly and tasted amazing.the bartender was outstanding,and polite.the best wings I've ever had

Shawn Murphy

Nice, small pub....good beer and spirits selection. Menu is pretty small, but doing a few things well is better than doing many things mediocre. Pub favorites; comfort food. Bartender was sweet and does an awesome job on the menu board. Wish I had taken some pictures, but alas I forgot. Next time, there will be a next time!

Nicholas DeLessio

This place earned five stars the second I bit into one of those wings. Best in Cortland hands down, and among the best I've had in general. The atmosphere here is very "townie" and I mean that as a compliment. It's a very no-frills kind of place where you get good bar food and beers at a fair price, and people seem to know one another. A good, honest bar. Gotta respect it.

Micki Farino

This was our first time visiting. The wings were exceptionally good, I especially liked the parmesan garlic, but the Alabama white was also great. It's obvious that the owners, Tony & Terry, take great pride in their business, they personally greet you & take time to check on you throughout your meal. The dessert pretzel was huge & fed 4 of us easily. There's so much camaraderie at the bar, everyone was cheering for their favorite team & enjoying their beverages of choice. We're looking forward to our next visit for more great food & such a friendly atmosphere.

Food is 5 star, BUT they need to update their hours. 1230 on a Friday night and their doors are closed..

We went here thinking it was more of a restaurant. It is a bar that has food. But the people were nice and we stayed. We tried 2 different kinds of wings and a Reuben Dog. I would definitely come back.

Love coming to this place! Small town pub with a nice staff and decent food and a great beer selection. Definitely worth a stop for lunch or evening snack and a beer.

Sharie

We went here thinking it was more of a restaurant. It is a bar that has food. But the people were nice and we stayed. We tried 2 different kinds of wings and a Reuben Dog. I would definitely come back.

JP TV

Love coming to this place! Small town pub with a nice staff and decent food and a great beer selection. Definitely worth a stop for lunch or evening snack and a beer.

It's a local pub with a pool table, bar and food. Get the garbage plate! Service was pretty good.

It was pleasant and noise level was easy enough for my mom with hard hearing.

Jesse Wixson

It's a local pub with a pool table, bar and food. Get the garbage plate! Service was pretty good.

Jan C

It was pleasant and noise level was easy enough for my mom with hard hearing.

I don't see anywhere on my receipt that I ordered tater tots. I even specified french fries. The description says that it will feed 4, yet not even enough for 1. Or the advertisement is wrong, and it's the full order that will feed 4 for $6 more but as you can see I didn't get much for $9 so I doubt that's accurate. Other than that it was good. I probably won't order again because it's not worth the money, especially to not get what I wanted. Nowhere does it state that you have to add $6 to feed 4. It says prepared to feed 4 for the cost. So why would I upgrade?

Anthony Southworth

I don't see anywhere on my receipt that I ordered tater tots. I even specified french fries. The description says that it will feed 4, yet not even enough for 1. Or the advertisement is wrong, and it's the full order that will feed 4 for $6 more but as you can see I didn't get much for $9 so I doubt that's accurate. Other than that it was good. I probably won't order again because it's not worth the money, especially to not get what I wanted. Nowhere does it state that you have to add $6 to feed 4. It says prepared to feed 4 for the cost. So why would I upgrade?

We just ordered 2 orders of wings and an order of fries. We hadn't tried food from Paddy's since the last owners. The garlic parm wings were dried out and had little flavor. The Buffalo wings were overcooked and also lacked flavor. There was no one in the parking lot which seemed odd for a Friday night. We definitely will not be returning. It's sad considering how good the wings used to be at Paddy's under the old ownership.

My daughter and I was going to try this place out for the first time but I couldn't get in. I'm a double BKA (below the knee ampution) and in a wheelchair. They have no wheelchair ramp. Just to make sure we wasn't missing something my daughter went inside and asked if they were wheelchair accessible and they said no. Very disappointing.

Came here because of reviews. We were told to pick a table. We chose in back table and ordered drinks, appetizers and food. To begin with food came before appetizers The server couldn’t find salt . In the meantime the drunk younger people from the bar decided to come play games in back. They were ballerina dancing and bumping into us and cursing loudly. We continued to sit there as long as we could tolerate it. Then decided to wrap everything up, When asking for containers and bill I told the waitress what was going on and she replied “It is a bar”. which I definitely understand. However, in this economy when people spending 100. For food . I think we should expect better. Clearly the reviews from earlier don’t apply any more. It’s a red flag when your server doesn’t care what’s happening to their patrons. What I shame but I suggest you chiise a different place.

barbara quigley

Came here because of reviews. We were told to pick a table. We chose in back table and ordered drinks, appetizers and food. To begin with food came before appetizers The server couldn’t find salt . In the meantime the drunk younger people from the bar decided to come play games in back. They were ballerina dancing and bumping into us and cursing loudly. We continued to sit there as long as we could tolerate it. Then decided to wrap everything up, When asking for containers and bill I told the waitress what was going on and she replied “It is a bar”. which I definitely understand. However, in this economy when people spending 100. For food . I think we should expect better. Clearly the reviews from earlier don’t apply any more. It’s a red flag when your server doesn’t care what’s happening to their patrons. What I shame but I suggest you chiise a different place.