Helene Gelman

The soup! I had Escarole and Bean and my Mom had the Minestrone. It was spectacular. Our server was lovely and Sam’s is a warm and inviting place. We will be back.

Dan Carazo

I had an incredible dining experience at Sam’s Italian Restaurant in Dobbs Ferry, and it was all thanks to Gary! From the moment we sat down, Gary made us feel welcome with his warm personality and attentive service. He was incredibly knowledgeable about the menu, offering excellent recommendations and ensuring our every need was met throughout the meal. His timing was perfect, always checking in without being intrusive, and his genuine enthusiasm made the evening even more special. If you’re looking for top-notch service to match the amazing food, be sure to ask for Gary – he’s truly the best!

Michelle Altland

My husband and I went here for dinner and the food was absolutely amazing. We really enjoyed it. Since we've both had gastric sleeve surgery, we're not able to eat the entire meal and I always have left overs to take home. I didn't want them to feel like we didn't like our food with as little as I/we ate but it was quite the opposite. The food was really REALLY good. If you're looking for a good Italian restaurant, visit this one.

Colin R

I used to come here with my family when I was a little kid. I've grown up now and so has this Dobbs Ferry staple. I had the halibut special. Totally delicious. David made the evening really great. The service was 100%. I'm looking forward to when we come back.

Geoff S

We are here with our family while on vacation and loved it. The service is absolutely phenomenal. The food was top notch! I highly recommend this restaurant for the entire family.

Beth Frank

Food was delicious and service wonderful. This restaurant is always great. We go whenever we are in town.

Zo

Excellent food and customer service! Warm friendly staff that is very helpful! This is definitely the best spot in Westchester! The pizza and calzones are mouth watering! I can’t wait to try the rest of their menu.

Bob S

Took my wife there for a get together with her cousins. There were 8 of us total. I ordered the veal parm along with 2 of the other guests. After the meal, as we were leaving, the 2 cousins both asked me how my veal was and I told them it was horrible. It was very tough and chewy. They both said the same about theirs. Everyone else enjoyed what they had. Other than that, the service was great and the appetizers were delicious. So if you go, just avoid the veal at all cost. It ruined the dinner for me.

Sharon Goiz

Ordered the rustica pizza (broccoli rabe, sausage & mozzarella) and tortellini meat Alfredo with grilled chicken. Both dishes were great and of appropriate serving size. The waiters were attentive and friendly. We also got dessert, the Italian cheesecake and gelato which were delicious! Prices were of an average Italian restaurant in Westchester.

S S

Ordered out one day this week. There “carbonara” was just pasta with butter and Romano cheese. No sign of an egg base anywhere to be found. So I paid $20 for pasta with butter and cheese and a few pieces of bacon, they didn’t even spring for the guanciale. The salad tasted like it wasn’t washed. I’ve been coming since I was a kid and this meal was a major disappointment

Juana Gonzalez

We’ve been regulars at your restaurant for our work group dinners, but I’m very disappointed by the way we’ve been treated during our last two visits. Despite being loyal customers, the service was unwelcoming and rushed. Staff members were standing around watching us, and within barely an hour and a half of being seated, we felt pushed out. While we were still enjoying our wine and coffee, the owner and staff began moving tables around us—making it clear that we were no longer welcome to stay. This behavior was disrespectful and unprofessional. It left us feeling unwelcome and uncomfortable. After such poor treatment, I will not be returning, and I can no longer recommend this restaurant to others. It’s incredibly disappointing, especially considering the support we’ve given your business over time.

Billie Jean

From formally managing restaurants in Manhattan this is my review, I walked in with my family and the whole staff looked at us like we didn't belong there.. the waiters don't even know what the specials are, They brought a big chalk board out with the specials written on them . Throughout my history from working and managing numerous establishments and going to any restaurant that says they are rated 4.4 knowledge of the menu is a must. I was very disappointed with this place