Pinocchio's Pizza

Verna Wortman

I really like their food. They make the best pizza in town.

NickatNite Nelson

Best pizza in town and maybe in the Bay area, great service great food. We go there at least once a week.

Best pizza in town. The entire family is so friendly. They appreciate any tip you leave, even a genuine Thank You when there isn't a tip being left. We order to-go from here at least once a week. Our food is always ready in the amount of time they give us. It is always delicious. Pinocchio's Pizza #1 is never a let down. If you aren't from here (or even if you are) and you want good pizza and great service, you have to visit this spot!!

Best pizza in either Morgan hill or gilroy! As close to NY as I’ve had in California.

Pinocchio’s pizza: fresh ingredients, family owned and operated, and a unique flavour & quality only found in Gilroy California. The only drawback is that they are not open 24/7. This is the top quality pizza that I wish I could find all over the states on my travels. Let’s hope someday they will expand. 🍕😋

Best New York Pizza on the West Coast! The Stromboli is also my favorite with extra sauce! Yum! 😋

Long time customer, first time reviewer for this wonderful pizza joint. Decades old, family run, hella good, and crazy nice. Pizza and positivity flow from this local pizzeria, and the people of Gilroy are blessed to have such a killer spot to support….especially since the pizza is hands down the best in Gilroy. Pepperoni with black olives all day. Long live Pinocchio’s Pizza!

We ordered the dairy-free cheese Stromboli and a Pepperoni and Jalapeño pie for carry out. It tasted amazing! The crust was perfectly crispy and the seasoning in the sauce is wonderful. The staff were super friendly when I picked up. We will be ordering from here more often! Very glad they have a lactose free cheese option.

Our first time to order pizza from here. We loved it! It's fresh and favorable. Nice and friendly service. Best of all, they don't use any seed oil on their pizzas, which my son loves. Thank you!

The food was amazing!!!! Good prices and very good customer service. We were from out of town only thing we wish is they had seating vs take out only. But we sat at the park and enjoyed our meal. We will definitely be going back everytime we are in town. My 2 year old ate the Supreme pizza veggies and all.

Adam Brown

Best pizza in either Morgan hill or gilroy! As close to NY as I’ve had in California.

Norm

Best New York Pizza on the West Coast! The Stromboli is also my favorite with extra sauce! Yum! 😋

Erin Woram

We ordered the dairy-free cheese Stromboli and a Pepperoni and Jalapeño pie for carry out. It tasted amazing! The crust was perfectly crispy and the seasoning in the sauce is wonderful. The staff were super friendly when I picked up. We will be ordering from here more often! Very glad they have a lactose free cheese option.

Angie Castañon

The food was amazing!!!! Good prices and very good customer service. We were from out of town only thing we wish is they had seating vs take out only. But we sat at the park and enjoyed our meal. We will definitely be going back everytime we are in town. My 2 year old ate the Supreme pizza veggies and all.

Edward Richert

Pinocchio’s pizza: fresh ingredients, family owned and operated, and a unique flavour & quality only found in Gilroy California. The only drawback is that they are not open 24/7. This is the top quality pizza that I wish I could find all over the states on my travels. Let’s hope someday they will expand. 🍕😋

M S

Our first time to order pizza from here. We loved it! It's fresh and favorable. Nice and friendly service. Best of all, they don't use any seed oil on their pizzas, which my son loves. Thank you!

K. M. S.

Best pizza in town. The entire family is so friendly. They appreciate any tip you leave, even a genuine Thank You when there isn't a tip being left. We order to-go from here at least once a week. Our food is always ready in the amount of time they give us. It is always delicious. Pinocchio's Pizza #1 is never a let down. If you aren't from here (or even if you are) and you want good pizza and great service, you have to visit this spot!!

We had pizza from Pinocchio's at a friend's house for a football watch party. They had all had Pinocchio's pizza many times, but this was my first. We had 2 pizzas, a pepperoni and a combination. It was good, similar to Round Table in my opinion.

SeeTheWorld

We had pizza from Pinocchio's at a friend's house for a football watch party. They had all had Pinocchio's pizza many times, but this was my first. We had 2 pizzas, a pepperoni and a combination. It was good, similar to Round Table in my opinion.

Place looks cute! Ladies taking orders at the desk (I think they run the place too ) have to a do a better job welcoming people! Ordered a veggie supreme pizza, it had way too many garlics in it ( nearly 30 cloves on a single pizza). Didn’t appeal to my taste.

Take out only. We got the meat lover and hot honey pepperoni. Both were good. Would order again if I was in the area and craving pizza. Update: went back again. The pizzas were super soggy/oily. All the toppings are more toward the middle so it doesn't hold its shape when you pick up a slice.

Pizza was ok. Got some garlic knots it was just some bread in a pan with melted cheese and garlic no knots. Little on the pricey side for the quality of food

sahithi t

Place looks cute! Ladies taking orders at the desk (I think they run the place too ) have to a do a better job welcoming people! Ordered a veggie supreme pizza, it had way too many garlics in it ( nearly 30 cloves on a single pizza). Didn’t appeal to my taste.

Shone Mathew

Take out only. We got the meat lover and hot honey pepperoni. Both were good. Would order again if I was in the area and craving pizza. Update: went back again. The pizzas were super soggy/oily. All the toppings are more toward the middle so it doesn't hold its shape when you pick up a slice.

Jose Almanza

Pizza was ok. Got some garlic knots it was just some bread in a pan with melted cheese and garlic no knots. Little on the pricey side for the quality of food

Update May 2024: I am so sad that their pizza has changed in my opinion. It doesn't taste the same as before. I have tried and tried thinking maybe it was just that day but no. Maybe they have changed their vendor for their ingredients? This was my favorite pizza in South County, but for now I don't feel it's the same. Best New York style pizza in the South Bay! We have been enjoying their pizza since 2003! Our favorites are the pepperoni pizza and pepperoni and sausage calzone. Their sauce and dough is so delicious can’t get enough! Friendly family owned pizzeria. I only eat their pizza out here!

Monica S

Update May 2024: I am so sad that their pizza has changed in my opinion. It doesn't taste the same as before. I have tried and tried thinking maybe it was just that day but no. Maybe they have changed their vendor for their ingredients? This was my favorite pizza in South County, but for now I don't feel it's the same. Best New York style pizza in the South Bay! We have been enjoying their pizza since 2003! Our favorites are the pepperoni pizza and pepperoni and sausage calzone. Their sauce and dough is so delicious can’t get enough! Friendly family owned pizzeria. I only eat their pizza out here!

Jared Snyder

As a native Gilroyan, I grew up with Pinocchios. Most Gilroyans will say it's a must. It's been 20 plus years since I've had their pizza. My wife and I were in town and decided to get their pizza. My wife lives a low carb lifestyle so she only eats cauliflower crust pizza. Pinocchios unfortunately was the worst she ever had. The pizza, a pepperoni, sausage and garlic I believe, lacked flavor and the crust was so soggy that the pizza was inedible. As far as location goes, since I hadn't been in 20 plus years, I was not aware that the location was pickup only. Luckily we were invited to my sister's, so we had a place to eat our terrible pizza. I'm sorry Pinocchios but this just wasn't an enjoyable experience.

First time ever coming here i ordered a pizza and they only gave me 1 spicy packet and no cheese smh and the lady one the phone was a lil rud

Elva G

First time ever coming here i ordered a pizza and they only gave me 1 spicy packet and no cheese smh and the lady one the phone was a lil rud