Matt C.

We have lived in St. Pete for 5 years and have been in pursuit of a good quality pie and salad that can satisfy. Well we found it here. You start by ordering your items at thr counter and then seat your self at an empty both. Gives you a vibe of an original pizza restaurant from the 80's and 90's. Ordered a side sald with cheese. It was thinly shredded iceberg with tomatoes and onions. Homemade vinaigrette dressing was delicious, but was very heavy ( we will order on the side next time). Pizza was huge and delicious, cheese was high quality and pepperoni was flavorful. It was finished off with a very thin hand tossed crust that was perfectly cooked and not burnt as many competitors are. Will be back soon, and can't wait to try again. As of now #1 pizza in St. Pete. I still have more places to try.

Blank

This is THE best pizza I have ever had in my life, including the best garlic knots. I always think about how good this pizza is whenever I go anywhere else, I am not kidding. Pizza has a crispy crust and holds it's form perfectly. The garlic knots are extremely garlic forward and come with a nice amount of olive oil you can dip your pizza crust into, and the atmosphere of the restaurant is super fun, there's a little arcade in the back! I moved away from Pinellas Park a few years ago, so sadly I can't always go here, but whenever I'm in the area, THIS is THE spot.

Crystal S

Went for the 53rd anniversary for their 53cent slices and 53cent beer. They handled the huge crowd like champs! Great pizza and definitely going to make this a regular stop for pizza nights!

Five

I ate here a couple months ago. This place is so good im coming back months later to write a review, this is the BEST pizza ive had in my LIFE. BEST IN TAMPA ST PETE AND CLEARWATER. GO HERE. IF YOU WANT GOOD PIZZA GO HERE. Ive had nothing else like it ever. They actually care and are amazing at making it. Super nice and friendly. There is no other pizza place like this in Tampa, St pete, anything with probably 1000 mile radius from it.

B Green

Best cheese steak hoagie and pizza in all of Pinellas county! A taste of Philly and New York in your own back yard. Pizza size is either small "Big" or large "Bigger"! Salads are fresh and crisp and the house made Italian dressing is excellent. A must stop for lunch, dinner, or just a snack. I dare you to try their garlic knots!

+5

Arlena Powers

Amazing steak and cheese!!! Hot and steamy with fresh soft bread. Really fun quick lunch spot! They’ve even got a few games in the back and the restaurant was very clean. The staff were wonderful, best sub in Florida!!!

Alicia Montalvo

My daughter and I came across this pizza joint and I must say the garlic knots are delicious and the pizza slices are delicious and big. We have eaten there 3x this week

Orlando Mejia (JR)

Great little Italian pizza restaurant! Friendly service with a smile. The slices of pizza are huge! Not bad for the price! The bathroom is very clean and presentable. 5 stars for service, food, and hospitality. Keep up the good work guys!

N L

Best pizza and garlic knots! I'm sure their other options are good as well, but we love the pizza and knots too much to not get that! Walk up ordering and self-service to refill drinks and grab your order.

Ra

Excellent New York style pizza I enjoyed every bite. I love my pizza hot and crispy, and this is how they served it to me So good, atmosphere was warm and relaxing, service awesome. Most importantly the pizza was delicious. This place beat my expectations I’m from Brooklyn New York Visiting St. Petersburg I’m so glad to have found this pizza place Five stars ⭐️ all the way Grazie

Ibet Lopez

If you love Italian food you're gonna love this place! You Must visit this spot. Well worth the drive. Come with an appetite as they are generous. Greeted with smiles, what an experience. The place smells amazing. From the moment you walk in the garlic bread is calling you. I was torn between the Lasagna or Calzone. Ended up getting the Calzone with sausage, pepperoni, and green peppers. The mozzarella was so fresh I wouldn't be surprised if they made it themselves. And the sauce.... Wow! It was one customer after another that came in, non-stop. Whether Dining In or Take Out the waiting time and price $$ was extremely reasonable and everything was fresh, clean, and friendly atmosphere. I Highly recommend!

My family has been going here for decades and it is a fantastic place. Recently visited from out of state for the first time in 6 years and it was just as good as I remembered. The food is so much be…

Wow! Like Dave Portnoy from Barstool Sports said, this is the best pizza in St. Pete! We agree!! The pizza we ordered was as close to New York as you can get! We had a half sausage and half cheese pi…

Wow! Like Dave Portnoy from Barstool Sports said, this is the best pizza in St. Pete! We agree!! The pizza we ordered was as close to New York as you can get! We had a half sausage and half chee…

The pizza was amazing! The service was good! The garlic knots are beyond amazing. They are even better the second day!

Fun atmosphere for their anniversary to get 52 cents pizza! Really awesome, thank you!

Great food and fun today.\nPrizes and contest \nGreat pizza for 52cents\nAnd drinks also.

Good food for a good price. Love there anniversary specials. Best anniversary deals in town.

one of my favs!! pizza and subs are so good! always friendly and good atmosphere and staff.

Love Toby's! The pizza is wonderful! And the workers are very nice. I go here for lunch when I have the time, and it is so busy. But worth the wait.

Looking for a great pizza joint come and check out Toby’s. Great service and the pizza and the philly all the way was delicious. Second time to dine here and we will be regulars for sure.

Best pizza in town. Reminds me of Home New York City Pizza. Great staff for the place is always busy. Great location. Check it out.

Best pizza around, the cheese steaks are also very delicious and worth the commute, 10/10 do recommend.

Ate here after a beach day. I’ve had NYC pizza & this was just like it. Garlic knots delicious. Customer service excellent. prices were great too. If I lived in the area, I’d be a regular!

That was the BEST philly cheesesteak I’ve ever had! Small place but a ton of locals coming in for take out! Just go! You won’t regret it!

We are in St Pete about once a year and this is our “go to” pizza place. Great NY style pizza. Fast and convenient. priced right! We wish we had this at home in PA

Thank you for staying open so late to feed us intoxicated fools! ATMOSPHERE: If you've seen one, you've seen them all. Big dining area, all you can eat roasted peanuts, messy by closing time. FOOD: Cheeseburger With everything! That includes mayo, lettuce, pickles, tomatoes, grilled onions, grilled mushrooms, ketchup & mustard. The patty was tender & juicy and has a real homemade taste to it. Fries They're thicker cut shoestrings natural fries, served hot and crispy. SERVICE: Fast and efficient. OVERALL: Pricey ala carte menu with great taste.

TheWildMan2469

As a transplanted New Yorker who has had NY pizza for decades, I’m striving to find the best pizza in Florida… I ordered one of my go-to pizza’s, pepperoni, sausage & jalapeños… It was almost very good, but still, I enjoyed it… The crust was a bit thin and didn’t hold the toppings when it first came out of the oven, but for what it was, it was good… A little light on the sauce and cheese, but still I enjoyed it… The toppings were pretty good, I prefer a crumbled sausage and I’ve had better pepperoni, but again, it was still good… A decent place that would fit in with what you might find at a decent NY pizza parlor… Friendly staff, too… Oh, and I’ve got to say, for a 16” small, it was pretty large… close to 18”. Curious to see what size their large is… Crust: B+ Sauce: B Cheese: B Toppings: B+

Brock Grady

Went here because of the rating. Overall idea would say this is a safe bet for New York style pizza. Got a 1/2 cheese & 1/2 pepperoni, would say the pepperoni was a bit better. Enjoyed the pie, but will also consider trying other pizzas in the area if this is considered a 4.7+ star parlor. I liked the inside/atmosphere a little more than the pizza.

I had been told many times that this place did authentic NY style pizza. I finally got there. It was as advertised. I'll go back again soon. And if it is good again, I will add that star.

I had been told many times that this place did authentic ny style pizza. I finally got there. It was as advertised. I'll go back again soon. And if it is good again, I will add that star.

Friendly service, good pizza and drinks, reasonable prices and nice atmosphere, worth a try. I would certainly return.

Friendly service, good pizza and drinks, reasonable prices and nice atmosphere, worth a try. I would certainly return.

Friendly service, good pizza and drinks, reasonable prices and nice atmosphere, worth a try. I would certainly return.

Friendly service, good pizza and drinks, reasonable prices and nice atmosphere, worth a try. I would certainly return.

Friendly service, good pizza and drinks, reasonable prices and nice atmosphere, worth a try. I would certainly return.

Great place for pizza and subs. Beware for takeout. They gave us the wrong take out order TWICE in the last two weeks. Suggest that you check the takeout order carefully before leaving.

Great place for pizza and subs. Beware for takeout. They gave us the wrong take out order TWICE in the last two weeks. Suggest that you check the takeout order carefully before leaving.

Cannot take away from the food as it’s always great and top notch!! But I feel this location don’t have enough staff and during this season should have at least 15 guys working the kitchen. When customers leave they must have a dedicated person cleaning tables to maintain the global standard as in Dubai it’s 5 starts for sure

We came to the place following a recommendation and we can say that we were disappointed. However, the gaps we experienced can be easily fixed. We did not experience the service as required, we even felt disrespected as a customer, we each received a paper bag with the food and into it as if they had intentionally thrown the chips and it was not because there was no room in the chip cup, it was ugly, again it can be fixed, you just need to guide and explain. The area behind the counter where the employees were was dirty and a shame. The smoothie was delicious and the vegetarian dish too, I wish you luck and I would be happy to come back

I had three cheeseburgers to go and carried all the way to jersey. When I opened sandwiches ,they forgot to put patties in one of them and only put the toppings in it . It was a busy time for dinner but after paying a full price, I was unhappy ㅜㅜㅜ wish they pay more attention when they make burgers.

They never get a chance to clean the grill . So you be the judge? I definitely don’t recommend this one location .

Trisha Miller

Great and friendly service. Reasonable prices. Was not a fan of the pizza. Maybe overcooked or stale. Never seen pizza break apart before. Very crowded and narrow restaurant. Some of the seating was occupied by pizza boxes and other supplies. Very busy.

Guy Moulton

The actual place has style and is unique. The food however... Not so much. It's a solid OK. If you're looking for ok pizza parlor food that's safe and inoffensive this is your place. They don't try to make it unique or special, but it's pretty good. The pizza was short of cheese, the meatball sub was short on sauce. The sauce does not have a lot of flavor. The pizza crust and the sub bread were good. They are very fast and very efficient though

+1

Pizza was Delicious. The best we found in the last 4 years here in Florida. The customer service was horrible the worst customer service we've had in the last 4 years. This is an honest review so…

Went to Toby's based on reviews and was disappointed. It was crowded, noisy and had the table where everyone stands next to you to get their soft drinks. It seems super busy, needs some renovatio…

Pizza is good, very busy but not much of a wait time. My only complain is that the seatings are horrible, tables too high and benches too low and I can never find a clean table. Everyone is too b…

One bite brought me here. Very busy place, as the prices are reasonable, and portion is huge. However, the sauce, cheese are a bit blend to me.

My husband is from New York and his overall assessment was… This pizza was kind of flat. The little Italy large pizza did not have a lot of toppings and definitely didn’t have extra cheese. The calzo…

My husband is from New York and his overall assessment was… This pizza was kind of flat. The little Italy large pizza did not have a lot of toppings and definitely didn’t have extra cheese. The…

The pizza is the best I've had in Tampa Bay. Unfortunately, the service was disappointing, earning less than a 3-star rating. The staff at the counter were unfriendly. When I returned to ask for some…

The pizza is the best I've had in Tampa Bay. Unfortunately, the service was disappointing, earning less than a 3-star rating. The staff at the counter were unfriendly. When I returned to ask for so…

The pizza is the best I've had in Tampa Bay. Unfortunately, the service was disappointing, earning less than a 3-star rating. The staff at the counter were unfriendly. When I returned to ask for …

A complete misunderstanding. I don't understand how this chain can stay in business. The burgers are tasteless, the chips are useless. My son took us there because he wanted to visit an American chain he knows from games. The atmosphere is like a slaughterhouse. I admire the absolutely friendly staff who have to work there. Respect, gentlemen.

We visited this Five Guys location in New York, and unfortunately the experience was disappointing. While we are familiar with the brand and usually enjoy the food, this time it was only average and did not meet our expectations. What really ruined the experience, however, was the service. The employee at the register was extremely rude and ironic, clearly in a hurry, and offered no help at all with our order. On top of that, the atmosphere of the restaurant was very poor, as the space felt dirty and unkempt. Overall, despite the fact that Five Guys is generally a reliable fast-food chain, this particular location failed in terms of service and cleanliness, and it is not a place we would choose to visit again.

Countess

Philly does not look like the images. I called and requested marinara sauce (didn't get it), also requested green peppers (didn't get this either). Doubt I will be coming back. Third time isn't the charm.

Tyler Brady

in my opinion I've had better pizza elsewhere. I personally am not the type of person who likes my dough of my pizza to be thin and have a thin amount of sauce on a pizza. if that's the type of pizza you like then this is the place for you. I personally like my dough to be on the thicker middle side of things where the pizza can substantially handle itself when you pick it up. The pizza was also extra greasy and everything. Went here on a lunch type date and she was recommending how great the place was and I could only myself eat one slice of the pizza... this place is on my top places not to visit again. Every place has there perfect crowd of people that there business is tailored too it's just a me thing and I love pizza I just know exactly what I like exactly and I have a very good moral compass of what it is I like. because I have eaten out at a lot of pizza places.

E L

Listen, I was so excited for a yummy pizza Friday night. I’m blown away at all the 5 star reviews that had my hopes so high. Either everyone here is so desperate for a good pizza that they don’t know one, or we had a truly off night experience. Either way, it was inedibly bad. We were so excited to try Toby’s. The only redeeming thing was the garlic knots. Yum! The pizza was sooooooo bad. For multiple reasons. It looked like someone slopped it into a box at an angle too hot and in a hurry. This is how it looked in the box when we got it. We should have gone back inside but I was hurry and worried about the dogs at home in thunderstorms. Got it home and just got more annoyed at myself for now going back inside before driving away. I used 2 paper towels to sop up the puddles of grease. The crust under the toppings was limp, soggy, and I wish I could say tasteless but no, it tasted gross, even the fluffy edges were gross and reminiscent of soggy cardboard. I am bummed. What a flop. The garlic knots were scarfed down and delicious as the only edible thing. This was dumped in the trash after a few bites we tried to salvage. Still hungry and out the money for this. Sorry Toby, it was not your night.

+1

Jeff Ennis

So im going to start this off with im BORN and Raised in Philadelphia. Also lived in NYC for many years. This place is nice. It's clean and above average style and customer service. No issues what so ever in that regard. As for the pizza there putting out. This is absolutely garbage 🗑. I dare say I would rather eat Papa Johns. 1. The toppings. First, caned? Canned mushrooms 🍄? 2. A whole can? Did you think this customer will think im giving them an extra by adding the whole can 🤔 3. The process on this cheese must have been a process to learn to understand the process of process to process itself. 4. Why does this dough bounce off the roof of my mouth like Aunt Juamama? 5. The sauce straight out of a jar. Skip this place and head over to Joey Brooklyns ✌️

So I see this place on Dave Portnoy pizza review as one of the best in the city. I waited all week until the weekend to try it. I arrive and encounter the most unfriendly cashier I ever met in my l…

Stopped by the Five Guys at 253 West 42nd Street near Times Square for a quick evening snack. As vegetarians, our options were limited, so we ordered a large Cajun fries and a soda, accompanied by the complimentary peanuts.  While the food and service at the counter met our expectations, our experience was marred by an unsettling interaction. As we were finishing our meal, a cleaning staff member approached our table and, without any prior conversation, asked, “Are you Indian?” We responded affirmatively, and he walked away without further explanation. This unsolicited question felt intrusive and left us uncomfortable, especially given the lack of context or follow-up. In a city as diverse as New York, such interactions can be disconcerting. It’s unfortunate that this incident overshadowed our visit. We hope the management addresses such concerns to ensure a more welcoming environment for all patrons.

This place is aweful. There was a staff member vaping right at the door so you had to walk through a cloud of smoke to get in. Secondly, it was dirty, filthy, smelly, just dreadful. Order two burgers, fries and a drink. We couldn't get near the pick up due to delivery drivers. They had bags on the rebacks and helmets on and blocked everyone. They just moved people to get to area. Eventually people like ourselves realised we were being called. When we found a table, it hadn't been cleaned in at least an hour or more. Two other reciepts and food was still on it. It would of been better to eat the food of the ground outside, than eat it at the table. It was uncomfortable to eat here. The staff were working non stop but cleaning is obviously not high priority on the managers list. The amount of people and very little space. Burger was bland, lacking proper flavour. Honest, I wouldn't go near any five Guys after seeing the state of this place.

Threw up the food after 30 mins. The top bun is cold bottom bun wet and doesn’t hold up, really bad fries no peanuts on there. This is Times Square by the way, if people think this food is good they are straight up delusional.

This was honestly one of the worst experiences I’ve ever had at a Five Guys. I was excited to come to the Five Guys in Times Square last Wednesday night November 12th because it was my first time visiting NYC and I’d heard so much about this location. Unfortunately, the manager could not have been more unprofessional if she tried. I don’t know her name but she was kind of slim light skinned and prettyish. Her attitude was nasty, and she acted like helping a customer was the biggest inconvenience in the world. My food took forever..way longer than it should have. Five Guys needs to seriously reevaluate who they put in charge, because her attitude is definitely driving customers away.