Tony's Pizzeria

Beautiful, clean restaurant, delicious fresh food. Pizza is amazing. Very friendly staff.

Stopped in for slices. Was big slice lots of flavor and fresh will stop again.

The most amazing garlic knots and paninis. Love everything about this place from the food to the staff/owner

The dough the sauce the toppings all delicious💓💓💓

Excellent pizza!

Antonio's has the best prices, the food is DELICIOUS and staff is very friendly.

Best pizza place🫡🫡 Great people Fresh food Highly recommended 🤩

Great pizza spot and the owners are very nice!

Mama Mia, what a pizza! 🤌

Pizza that tastes like Italy! Yum.

Great pizza from a small shop in a small town. The way it should be.

Absolutely the best calzone that I have had.

Great customer service and hospitality, and of course, great pizza (and wings!)

It was so good I went back the next day

Big slice for the price!

My favorite pizza ever.

Friendly staff. Delicious white pizza!

Albanians and Pizza go hand in hand in hand

Always the best in food and service

Great place. I almost don't want to leave a good review because it will get crowded and I will have to wait!

One of the best pizzas I’ve had in a long time in the Kingston area. Ingredients fresh. Owner and staff pleasant and personable. Tony’s will be my go to for pizza.

Tony’s Pizza is the REAL deal!!! Authentic Italian!!! From stopping by for a slice on the go to delivery of a whole pizza, salad and wings!! Sooo great!!! Finally a great pizza in Port Ewen!! No photos, ate it fast!!! 💥💥🥰🥰🍕🍕

Very happy with this pizzeria- especially having it be 2 minutes from home. Slices are good, wings are good, place is clean, and service is always great. Always greeted with a smile.

I decided to try this place as I pass it on the way home from work and it has replaced other pizza places who went downhill. The owner and staff are friendly. The pizza, wings, and garlic knots are all great.

Nice clean local pizza place. Conveniently located right on 9W. And good prices too... O, did I mention the absolutely delicious slices that come out of that place

Pizza is great !! I got garlic knots and a pepperoni pizza.. price is great and food taste great! 100% recommend! Service was also amazing ! Great customer service!

The pizza was delicious! Great tasting sauce, and fresh tasting ingredients! 10/10 recommend this one! 💯

Friendly, prompt service and great slices!

Absolutely best pizza probably in NY!! The crust!!! The crust!!! Always a super nice delivery and also pick up. So grateful they are so close by. Sausage and peppers pizza for the win. ❤️‍🔥❤️‍🔥

Best sliice with eggplant around

Best pizza I’ve had in the area. Plus Tony himself is nice guy. Will be back!

Thank you, Tony! The meatball and the Eggplant heros were delicious, and they were only to bucks!

Super friendly owner, huge slices, great prices!

You cannot go wrong with this place. Very friendly people with amazing service and passion for pizza. Lovely all around.

Great subs bread so chewy and moist and they really pour on the meat and cheese. You get a hearty full sub. Best place in Port Ewen.

Super delicious big sliced pizza!!! All the food is amazing! Love the Eggplant Parm!

Excellent thin crust pizza and crispy Buffalo Wings! Although Tony's has a few tables, primarily, Tony's is a take out pizzeria and a damn good one! Tony's has become my go-to place for a perfect thin crust New York pizza and excellent authentic Buffalo Wings. The perfect New York pizza consists of extremely thin, light crisp crust, a thin layer of spicy sauce, and a thin layer of quality cheese that's baked to perfection. Tony's Pizza in Port Ewen fits that description. Excellent New York pizza! Tony's Buffalo Wings are also excellent. They're always cooked golden crispy, and they use classic Buffalo sauce of Red Hot and butter, not jarred sauce. There's parking around the corner that's convenient for pick up. It's my opinion that Tony's has earned high grades. Port Ewen has a few choices for pizza, but Tony's is my 1st choice.

The friendliest atmosphere in town. Owner recognizes and greets regulars. It seems to be open ALL the time and the pizza is delicious! Great crust!

Excellent pizza. Dough and crust delicious. Sauce Cheese flavor all very good. Highly reccomend their slice! (Also Tony is super nice) Gonna be my go to local pizza joint. Takes time to find the right one …

The Pizza was Absolutely Amazing. I moved to Kingston 6 years ago from The Bronx and have not been able to find a good slice of pizza to save my life. Today me and a friend were driving through Port Ewing and craving pizza. We seen Antonio's and decided to give it a try. The owner was super friendly and from The Bronx. The place was very clean and the Pizza was Delicious. It was like I got a slice of Pizza from Arthur Ave. In the Bronx. Definitely my new go to spot for Pizza.

Antonio’s is now my new favorite pizza shop! This place is hands down the best pizza in the area! I’ve just recently moved into town and had been going into Kingston to the normal spots to get my pizza crave fix but not anymore! This is pizza made just right! I’ve had many pizzas from many places all over the country and they’ve never been good enough to deserve a review but Antonio’s blew me away by hitting that special certain specific taste, texture, and just the smell of it had my mouth watering the minute the box was opened! I look forward to going trying more tasty delights that have to offer! Thanks again Tony you’re the best!!!

Ordered their Italian mix subs for delivery. I have to say they were hands down the best subs we’ve had in a long time. Perfect amount of cold cuts, veggies, mayo and oil and vinegar. Thank you

Pizza is one of the best in town. Garlic knots are the real deal with fresh chopped garlic ask for extra extra. Delivery is fast 30 min from port even to Kingston. Will be ordering again.

We visited this place on our way back from New York. We were impressed by the simplicity of the place and the delicious pizzas. We tried margarita pizza, mushroom pizza and cheesecake. The food was amazing and so was Tony. Highly recommend.

Most important their food is flavorful. The shop is welcoming both in decor and in service. I won't stop anywhere else!

Moved up from the city this Summer. I've been hunting for my new pizza spot for the past six months. I tried every pizzeria in and around Kingston. Finally found Tony's! Do your self a favor and check it out. Thank me later.

Fantastic pizza! The slices were thin and crispy and I love it how little and thin the crust was. The flavor was on point and the crunch in the crust was dynamite! The owner, Tony I guess was there making pizzas. He was super friendly and made me feel welcomed. I will definitely come back for a slice

Tony is creating MASTERPIECE'S. THANK YOU ALWAYS, YOU NEVER MISS!! Customer service always special. I well continue supporting my local neighbor!

Pizzeria was nicely decorated according to the season. You can tell they really care. Pizza was delicious. We enjoyed sitting outside. Overall excellent place for a quick bite.

Love his pizza.Really nice guy.He listens to what I ask for and gives me my food exactly how I ask for it.Im a picky person, and I don't have even 1 complaint.I go every week atleast once.So far I've ordered cheese pizza, calzone,and white pizza.All delicious. THANK YOU TONY.

Nolan Palmer-Smith

Fantastic pizza! The slices were thin and crispy and I love it how little and thin the crust was. The flavor was on point and the crunch in the crust was dynamite! The owner, Tony I guess was there making pizzas. He was super friendly and made me feel welcomed. I will definitely come back for a slice

Ty Collins

Tony is creating MASTERPIECE'S. THANK YOU ALWAYS, YOU NEVER MISS!! Customer service always special. I well continue supporting my local neighbor!

Free Child

Pizzeria was nicely decorated according to the season. You can tell they really care. Pizza was delicious. We enjoyed sitting outside. Overall excellent place for a quick bite.

leocat1959

Love his pizza.Really nice guy.He listens to what I ask for and gives me my food exactly how I ask for it.Im a picky person, and I don't have even 1 complaint.I go every week atleast once.So far I've ordered cheese pizza, calzone,and white pizza.All delicious. THANK YOU TONY.

Good pizza in port Ewan. Killer pepperoni slices (I don't normally eat pepperoni but this is different), cheese slice is amazing too. My personal favorite slice shop in area

Found Tony’s a few months back for a slice of pizza for lunch. Been back several times since. Tony and the staff are great, the food is fantastic and priced reasonably. Tried his entrees twice and both times the food was excellent.

I got 14 large pies for my work crew today. Spent a little over $300. All different kinds. Best pizza I've had in the Hudson valley. Thank you Tony!

Pizza is outstanding every single time, guys behind the counter are extremely outgoing and kind even when slammed. Best pizza in Port Ewen

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ 5-Star Review: A Taste of Heaven at Tony’s Pizzeria I’m visiting from Tennessee, and let me just say—I’ve never had anything like this in my life. If I could give Tony’s Pizzeria more than 5 stars, I absolutely would. This place is the real deal, and it's ruined every other pizza and sub I’ve ever had. I honestly don’t know how I’ll go back to my usual spots after this. Let’s start with the pizza—because OH MY LORD, it is next level. The crust is perfectly crispy on the outside, with just the right amount of chew on the inside. It tastes like it was made fresh in a wood-fired oven by someone’s Italian grandma who’s been doing this for 60 years. The sauce is tangy, rich, and clearly made in-house—it has this incredible depth of flavor that bottled sauce just can’t touch. I got the pepperoni and sausage, and I swear the sausage had that perfect balance of seasoning and spice—nothing too greasy, just savory perfection. Now, let’s talk about the meatball sub. I don’t even know if I have the words to describe how good it was, but I’ll try. The meatballs were tender, flavorful, and clearly homemade. You can taste the love and the slow-cooking in every bite. The sub roll was soft yet held everything together beautifully, with just a light toast on the outside. Then they smother it in marinara and melt a generous helping of gooey, bubbling mozzarella on top. I legit closed my eyes after the first bite—it was that good. Even the little details blew me away—the garlic knots, the house salad with the tangy vinaigrette, the fresh-grated Parmesan. The staff was super friendly and made me feel like family the second I walked in. You can tell they take pride in what they do, and it shows in every single thing they serve. If you're anywhere near this place, you HAVE to stop in. Coming from Tennessee, where we have our own great food traditions, I didn’t expect to be so completely blown away by a pizza joint. But Tony’s? Tony’s changed the game. I’d drive hours out of my way just to eat here again. This isn’t just food—it’s a whole experience. A slice of New York, a spoonful of Italy, and a warm welcome all rolled into one. I’m already planning my next visit, and you better believe I’ll be bringing friends. Do yourself a favor and get to Tony’s—you’ll never look at pizza (or meatball subs) the same way again.

The BEST pizza I've had in the area, really delicious!! Big slices, perfect crust, no flop, very flavorful sauce and toppings. My favorites are Pepperoni pizza, Sausage & mushrooms, and the White pizza.

Tony always makes my pie just the way I love it. Thank you bud

Thank you Tony you nailed it again, I ordered the meatball sub, House Salad & Fries. Let me tell you the food was absolutely delicious! And the portions are enough for 2people, keep up the great job, sincerely yours Susan Handschuh 👍🏻♥️

Tony's did an amazing job catering the food for my son's first birthday party. They were responsive, on time and the food was absolutely delicious. I highly recommend trusting them with any large order or catering.

Came to Tony’s pizza with a couple friends. Came in and got greeted by Tony, he is a very nice guy and made all the accommodations that we requested.. The pizzeria is very well lit and has plenty of space. The food was amazing the best I have had in a long time. Was quick to come out very delicious. Will definitely visit Tony’s pizzeria again when in the area

The pizza is awesome. Individual slices in the case are huge. Their dinners are also great. The Penne alla vodka is a go to for my family. The owner makes you feel welcome every time you go in. I can’t recommend this place enough.

patrick saddoris

Pizza is outstanding every single time, guys behind the counter are extremely outgoing and kind even when slammed. Best pizza in Port Ewen

Francis morelli

The pizza is awesome. Individual slices in the case are huge. Their dinners are also great. The Penne alla vodka is a go to for my family. The owner makes you feel welcome every time you go in. I can’t recommend this place enough.

savanna rose

Came to Tony’s pizza with a couple friends. Came in and got greeted by Tony, he is a very nice guy and made all the accommodations that we requested.. The pizzeria is very well lit and has plenty of space. The food was amazing the best I have had in a long time. Was quick to come out very delicious. Will definitely visit Tony’s pizzeria again when in the area

Angie S

Super delicious big sliced pizza!!! All the food is amazing! Love the Eggplant Parm!

Teresa Martello

The BEST pizza I've had in the area, really delicious!! Big slices, perfect crust, no flop, very flavorful sauce and toppings. My favorites are Pepperoni pizza, Sausage & mushrooms, and the White pizza.

Christian Baraiac

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ 5-Star Review: A Taste of Heaven at Tony’s Pizzeria I’m visiting from Tennessee, and let me just say—I’ve never had anything like this in my life. If I could give Tony’s Pizzeria more than 5 stars, I absolutely would. This place is the real deal, and it's ruined every other pizza and sub I’ve ever had. I honestly don’t know how I’ll go back to my usual spots after this. Let’s start with the pizza—because OH MY LORD, it is next level. The crust is perfectly crispy on the outside, with just the right amount of chew on the inside. It tastes like it was made fresh in a wood-fired oven by someone’s Italian grandma who’s been doing this for 60 years. The sauce is tangy, rich, and clearly made in-house—it has this incredible depth of flavor that bottled sauce just can’t touch. I got the pepperoni and sausage, and I swear the sausage had that perfect balance of seasoning and spice—nothing too greasy, just savory perfection. Now, let’s talk about the meatball sub. I don’t even know if I have the words to describe how good it was, but I’ll try. The meatballs were tender, flavorful, and clearly homemade. You can taste the love and the slow-cooking in every bite. The sub roll was soft yet held everything together beautifully, with just a light toast on the outside. Then they smother it in marinara and melt a generous helping of gooey, bubbling mozzarella on top. I legit closed my eyes after the first bite—it was that good. Even the little details blew me away—the garlic knots, the house salad with the tangy vinaigrette, the fresh-grated Parmesan. The staff was super friendly and made me feel like family the second I walked in. You can tell they take pride in what they do, and it shows in every single thing they serve. If you're anywhere near this place, you HAVE to stop in. Coming from Tennessee, where we have our own great food traditions, I didn’t expect to be so completely blown away by a pizza joint. But Tony’s? Tony’s changed the game. I’d drive hours out of my way just to eat here again. This isn’t just food—it’s a whole experience. A slice of New York, a spoonful of Italy, and a warm welcome all rolled into one. I’m already planning my next visit, and you better believe I’ll be bringing friends. Do yourself a favor and get to Tony’s—you’ll never look at pizza (or meatball subs) the same way again.

nathaniel schoettle-greene

Good pizza in port Ewan. Killer pepperoni slices (I don't normally eat pepperoni but this is different), cheese slice is amazing too. My personal favorite slice shop in area

Howie Hughes

Found Tony’s a few months back for a slice of pizza for lunch. Been back several times since. Tony and the staff are great, the food is fantastic and priced reasonably. Tried his entrees twice and both times the food was excellent.

Susan Handschuh

Thank you Tony you nailed it again, I ordered the meatball sub, House Salad & Fries. Let me tell you the food was absolutely delicious! And the portions are enough for 2people, keep up the great job, sincerely yours Susan Handschuh 👍🏻♥️

Jessie Webb

The friendliest atmosphere in town. Owner recognizes and greets regulars. It seems to be open ALL the time and the pizza is delicious! Great crust!

tyler maendel

I got 14 large pies for my work crew today. Spent a little over $300. All different kinds. Best pizza I've had in the Hudson valley. Thank you Tony!

Russell Booth

Excellent thin crust pizza and crispy Buffalo Wings! Although Tony's has a few tables, primarily, Tony's is a take out pizzeria and a damn good one! Tony's has become my go-to place for a perfect thin crust New York pizza and excellent authentic Buffalo Wings. The perfect New York pizza consists of extremely thin, light crisp crust, a thin layer of spicy sauce, and a thin layer of quality cheese that's baked to perfection. Tony's Pizza in Port Ewen fits that description. Excellent New York pizza! Tony's Buffalo Wings are also excellent. They're always cooked golden crispy, and they use classic Buffalo sauce of Red Hot and butter, not jarred sauce. There's parking around the corner that's convenient for pick up. It's my opinion that Tony's has earned high grades. Port Ewen has a few choices for pizza, but Tony's is my 1st choice.

Love the food, great little pizza place

Buffalo wings were good with BBQ sauce

Everyone has their own preference of pizza. Well, I love the way Tony’s makes it. I also love their salads. I have not had any of their entrées, but their prices are reasonable. Their services is good. I’ve had delivery and never had a problem with them.

Carol Rosa

Everyone has their own preference of pizza. Well, I love the way Tony’s makes it. I also love their salads. I have not had any of their entrées, but their prices are reasonable. Their services is good. I’ve had delivery and never had a problem with them.

I really like the Chicken wings

Updated: reduce from 5nto 3 stars. the first time was excellent the second was great, last time I ordered, the pizza was not like usual, alot oil and did not taste fresh it tasted like a pizza microwaved after being forgotten and stay a month in the fridge, my stomach was very very upset after eating one slice. 🗑️ the rest

New ownership and unfortunately the quality has gone down. Might try it again someday but very disappointed

I met the owner, and told him I was a new customer. He said "You're making me nervous. But it's ok, he's from da Bronx. (So what?) I ordered 2 regular slices to go. This is the worst pizza in town. Try Mario's, try LaRoma, try 440 Pizza on Broadway. They blow Antonio's away. The slices are small and too thin. Thin sauce that's bland and tasteless. I gave it 2 stars because the cheese was plentiful. But there were no seasonings at all. Reminded me of pizza they served in High School. Yick. Don't bother going to Antonio's. The slices everywhere else are twice the size and tasty.

Sicilian pizza very thick with some sauce thrown on...Don't bother. It was flavorless. Regular pizza is okay but nothing noteworty. The guy that runs it is very unfriendly ...like he was doing us a favor Go to Kingston Mario's has gone down as well . Karina is too pricey for what they give you

I won’t comment on the change of reviews, but I will say I will not be ordering again. Sadly, with our busy schedules it’s just easier to have a pizza night once or twice a week.

Original owners solid this place over a month ago. The new owners haven’t changed the name or signage but the pizza quality has dropped significantly. Original owners in rosendale are no longer affiliated. Until this new business lives up to the name, I’d recommend ordering from Mario’s instead.

New owner is rude to his employees and the food is not what it use to be.

👎

Pizza taste like cardboard. Over priced cake

They switched Owners Food is Terrible double the price.

Terrible omg

Online has one price, charged a completely different and higher price at the store. And the food was just ok. Never again.

I called at 20 minutes to 9 for a pickup order. Girl put me on hold and came back and told me they were closing and all I can get is slices they have out! All I wanted was a chicken parm sub and had twenty minutes to closing. Such a shame! I won’t order from them again and I loved there subs but this is crazy to me!

I placed an order this evening. I was told it would be an hour for delivery. An hour later at 9:30 at night when I called checking the status I was told “ my bad” and they would make it then. Needless to say I was frustrated and the person in the phone said” I said I was sorry”! I was told I had to pay by credit card. I have yet to receive a refund for the meals I didn’t receive. I work in healthcare and didn’t have time to make dinner. Tonight I didn’t have dinner:

I've ordered twice from this place. The food is garbage. The second time I waited hrs. Then after all other places were closed I was notified they canceled my order. Professionalism, out the door. Food a joke. Save your money and go else were.

First experience ordering was bad...wanted it left out on my porch table near my door because I wasn't able to be there in their time frame given, which was an option to do on their app. Delivery driver just kept knocking & knocking apparently. Missing a couple parts of my order that I was charged extra for. Not sure how you can mess up a few items. It takes 10 sec to verify.

Spent $90 and One star is generous. The owner is beyond rude and this place is not worth your time. From missing items in orders to behind yelled at in my face…not sure what’s worse. The food or management.

Brought me RAW chicken, with wrong sauce. I wasn’t even angry, I called and just tried to let them know they gave me uncooked CHICKEN, the man was Rude, disrespectful then hung the phone up on me. TAKE ACCOUNTABILITY and COOK YIUR DAMN FOOD!!!!

Got raw wings, cold pizza and looks like underaged kids working there and if you're really lucky their delivery driver will quit right before having to deliver your order and then you have to pack up the kids and go pick it up yourself but it's in the driver's car and they can't get a hold of him. Go to Mario's!

Expensive and pizza not taste as good as it used to. Their pizzas are now out of price. Never again. Almost 9$ for 2 medium slices. Cheee'z

Ordered a pizza online via Slice for an event. Waited for an hour after the expected delivery time and it never came. No phone call or anything, just a no-show. Very disappointing. I even pre-paid for a tip! Edit: They finally showed up 3 hours after I ordered it. Had to get out of bed…

I picked up an almost $90 order for 2 orders of BBQ wings, 2 Buffalo wings, mozzarella sticks and calamari. Upon inspecting the order we noticed there was hardly any sauce on the buffalo wings and we were missing our mozzarella sticks. After refusing to make it right via phone I drove the wings back and the owner added sauce onto my (now cold) wings. When I asked about the mozzarella sticks he insisted he gave them to me. He refused to give me my order or do anything to make it right. The conversation ended with him screaming across the restaurant at me until I left. This is by far the worst customer service I've ever received and will not go back after being a faithful customer for years. Super shady and disrespectful all around. Nothing like the previous owner.

This was the worst salad I ever had warm and soggy absolutely will never try again

Ben Schneider

I picked up an almost $90 order for 2 orders of BBQ wings, 2 Buffalo wings, mozzarella sticks and calamari. Upon inspecting the order we noticed there was hardly any sauce on the buffalo wings and we were missing our mozzarella sticks. After refusing to make it right via phone I drove the wings back and the owner added sauce onto my (now cold) wings. When I asked about the mozzarella sticks he insisted he gave them to me. He refused to give me my order or do anything to make it right. The conversation ended with him screaming across the restaurant at me until I left. This is by far the worst customer service I've ever received and will not go back after being a faithful customer for years. Super shady and disrespectful all around. Nothing like the previous owner.

Megss Love

This was the worst salad I ever had warm and soggy absolutely will never try again

Horrible!! We ordered two pies for our community center kids. It was never delivered. We called to confirm and they delivered it to the wrong place. Had a random person sign the receipt and argued with us about trying to get a free pizza. They didn't offer to replace the pizzas or refund our money back. Horrible customer service. The owner is messed up. Ww had hungry kids. Never again!!

We ordered from them twice. I should’ve learned my lesson the first time. The first time they had an elderly delivery driver from Greene county doing deliveries with no access to gps or a map so he was an hour late to our house and called me no less than 5 times for directions. Tonight we decided to pick up instead of deliver. Two pizzas , garlic knots and 20 wings. The prices online did not reflect the price of my total so when I called just to confirm I was met with the out of control owner who called me crazy and said “if you don’t like the prices on my menu, then merry Christmas” whatever that means. I was happy to pay my bill but I just wanted clarification. He was rude and made little attempt to be professional. The food was alright. Definitely not worth the trouble. I’ll be ordering from toscos in rosendale. Waaaay better food anyway. I would NOT recommend this place. I highly suggest taking your business elsewhere. Seriously. Do yourself the favor.

Larissa Alvarado

Horrible!! We ordered two pies for our community center kids. It was never delivered. We called to confirm and they delivered it to the wrong place. Had a random person sign the receipt and argued with us about trying to get a free pizza. They didn't offer to replace the pizzas or refund our money back. Horrible customer service. The owner is messed up. Ww had hungry kids. Never again!!