Plaza Pizza

My go to pizza place 2 times a week. Pasta dishes on Thursday Pizza pie & hero sandwich on Saturday Never disappointed

The Margherita Pie is absolutely amazing! I highly recommend you try it! Zeppoles are top notch as well. Actually, we've never been disappointed when ordering from Plaza Pizza! Fast delivery, nice people... highly recommend!

Best pizza in new Dorp no doubt about it. Almost here 24/7 don’t believe them ask them lmaooo

I eat here at least once a week. The food is always good. The lasagna slice is one of my favorites. Definitely would recommend.

Legend

Great local pizzeria Food is always good and the staff is great

Ryyn Dickerson

It was good quality pizza and nice service

Michael Rios

I eat here at least once a week. The food is always good. The lasagna slice is one of my favorites. Definitely would recommend.

Sidney Mansueto

Plaza Pizza is the best you’re going to get in Staten Island for a true-tasting classic New York slice. Every borough does the NY slice their way, but in Staten Island, Plaza Pizza is the place for that piece of pizza you’re craving!

TC C

My go to pizza place 2 times a week. Pasta dishes on Thursday Pizza pie & hero sandwich on Saturday Never disappointed

Nilsi Qyrku

This place is very comfy, and the place is very nice. The food is very exquisite and cheap- students get two slices of cheese pizza and a soda can for only $6! I come over here after school often, and the people who work there are always friendly and reasonable. I will definitely come back to this establishment!

Katie Dougherty

I dont normally review places but Plaza Pizza was a great experience! Friendly and helpful staff and the food was delicious. My 3 kids gave them 6 thumbs up and said this was the best pizza joint we have been too and we look forward to coming backing!! 😀

Michelle Coyle

The Margherita Pie is absolutely amazing! I highly recommend you try it! Zeppoles are top notch as well. Actually, we've never been disappointed when ordering from Plaza Pizza! Fast delivery, nice people... highly recommend!

Michael DeFillippo

Been eating there since I first moved to Staten Island 20 + years ago ! Pizza is Delicious .. Dennis in that store always and he does most of the cooking himself .. nothing bad ever to say about this place ! One of new Dorps hidden treasures…

Foos is good however they charge for using a debit card which is ilegal in NY State. As do most businesses on the island. Im not saying they do it maliciously but it is done.

A LEX

Foos is good however they charge for using a debit card which is ilegal in NY State. As do most businesses on the island. Im not saying they do it maliciously but it is done.

ASmartPerson

Good food but could use some more workers

Pizza was decent. Didn’t like the guy in the fronts attitude. I went back in for plates and he basically flung it down in front of me instead of handing them to me. He had a passive aggressive vibe about him I didn’t like and I was confused because I was being polite the whole time. It was a bit passed their closing time, so it could’ve been him just wanting to go home. Still, there was no need for that. BUT! The lady working there was a sweetheart and made me feel comfortable and she is well appreciated.

Tavane Buchanan

Pizza was decent. Didn’t like the guy in the fronts attitude. I went back in for plates and he basically flung it down in front of me instead of handing them to me. He had a passive aggressive vibe about him I didn’t like and I was confused because I was being polite the whole time. It was a bit passed their closing time, so it could’ve been him just wanting to go home. Still, there was no need for that. BUT! The lady working there was a sweetheart and made me feel comfortable and she is well appreciated.

Worst Pizzeria in Staten Island. Takes 45 minutes to get a pizza and they use substandard products.

Darren Smith

Worst Pizzeria in Staten Island. Takes 45 minutes to get a pizza and they use substandard products.

I ordered a Chicken Francese by far the worst one I have ever tried. Chicken n pure Lemon Juice. My pasta came in Red Sauce ask to have the Franchese sauce I should have kept the red sauce. Pure Lemon Juice. Not sure where this recipe came from but Please take this off the menu definitely Needs more work. Not worth the $26 I paid for this. Best part of the meal the bread with butter.

the owner is rude And Then I try to return the sodas Because they where expired And the owner said then he Check the Dates of the soda he said that it's is there Price

I do not recommend this place. I asked for vodka to add something meat to my pasta. He brought me a bowl of round 4, carelessly put only pasta and burnt chicken with some sourness. I paid $18. And the chef, the owner, was constantly laughing. I highly do not recommend this place.

Food is very tasty but the rolls are the size of a small egg roll from a Chinese restaurant. I didn’t realize until I got home and by then it was too late I didn’t have enough food to eat and first had to start cooking. I called to complain and was offered no resolution. Never going back.

I’ve been coming to Pizza on the Plaza for years, but I can confidently say I won’t be returning after my most recent experience. The owner has always come off as unpleasant, but this last interaction was truly the last straw. I called to place a simple order—just a couple of pieces of chicken cutlet and eggplant. My plan was to also order an eggplant hero for myself. The reason I was asking for the individual items was because my grandmother, who isn’t feeling well, had a craving for just the fried cutlet and eggplant on their own. Instead of being understanding, the man on the phone grew irritated with me, raising his voice and making me feel like I was doing something wrong by asking. It was completely unnecessary and unprofessional. To make matters worse, the owner even charges for things like red pepper flakes and Parmesan cheese—something most places offer as a courtesy. It’s just another example of the nickel-and-diming attitude that makes the whole experience feel unfriendly and unwelcoming. It’s disappointing to be treated rudely at a place I’ve supported for so long. I would not recommend coming here, especially if you expect decent customer service.

Rosa Cruz

the owner is rude And Then I try to return the sodas Because they where expired And the owner said then he Check the Dates of the soda he said that it's is there Price

Liad Darmoni

I’ve been coming to Pizza on the Plaza for years, but I can confidently say I won’t be returning after my most recent experience. The owner has always come off as unpleasant, but this last interaction was truly the last straw. I called to place a simple order—just a couple of pieces of chicken cutlet and eggplant. My plan was to also order an eggplant hero for myself. The reason I was asking for the individual items was because my grandmother, who isn’t feeling well, had a craving for just the fried cutlet and eggplant on their own. Instead of being understanding, the man on the phone grew irritated with me, raising his voice and making me feel like I was doing something wrong by asking. It was completely unnecessary and unprofessional. To make matters worse, the owner even charges for things like red pepper flakes and Parmesan cheese—something most places offer as a courtesy. It’s just another example of the nickel-and-diming attitude that makes the whole experience feel unfriendly and unwelcoming. It’s disappointing to be treated rudely at a place I’ve supported for so long. I would not recommend coming here, especially if you expect decent customer service.

Danny Gomez

I ordered a Chicken Francese by far the worst one I have ever tried. Chicken n pure Lemon Juice. My pasta came in Red Sauce ask to have the Franchese sauce I should have kept the red sauce. Pure Lemon Juice. Not sure where this recipe came from but Please take this off the menu definitely Needs more work. Not worth the $26 I paid for this. Best part of the meal the bread with butter.

Vitaly Minaev

I do not recommend this place. I asked for vodka to add something meat to my pasta. He brought me a bowl of round 4, carelessly put only pasta and burnt chicken with some sourness. I paid $18. And the chef, the owner, was constantly laughing. I highly do not recommend this place.

Frank Bello

Food is very tasty but the rolls are the size of a small egg roll from a Chinese restaurant. I didn’t realize until I got home and by then it was too late I didn’t have enough food to eat and first had to start cooking. I called to complain and was offered no resolution. Never going back.