Marlon Blake

Let me tell you what ..I'm not a huge fan of pizza but I would eat this pizza daily. I had a slice of cheese pizza and a pizza with shrimp and spinach. The pizza was hot and delicious. I would highly recommend this place and the service was top notch. Please be aware it is cash only but they do have an ATM. If you are in the area stop by!

J

Forget fancy toppings and gourmet ingredients, at I Love New York Pizza in Troy, you'll find something truly special: authentic pizza done right with flavor at a price thats affordable. And let me tell you, their chicken marsala pizza is a revelation! This isn't your average pizza with a few measly chicken chunks and a drizzle of sauce. Juicy, tender chicken bathes in a rich, mushroom-infused marsala sauce that perfectly complements the tangy tomato base. Every bite is an explosion of flavor, perfectly balanced and oh-so-satisfying. I honestly believe it might be one of the best chicken marsala pizza I've ever had in the capital region. The crust is not too thick, not too thin, with a perfect amount of chew. It's the kind of crust that holds its own without overpowering the toppings, creating the ideal foundation for flavortown. Every slice is a masterpiece, and at their prices, you won't feel guilty ordering another (or two). Speaking of prices, let's just say I Love New York Pizza lives up to its name in more ways than one. You won't find a better deal for such high-quality pizza in the entire Capital District. This is probably one of the last bastions of true, classic pizza places left, where they focus on quality ingredients and delicious simplicity, not trendy gimmicks. And the service? Fast, friendly, and exactly what you expect from a classic pizza joint. No fuss, no muss, just good vibes and good eats. So, if you're looking for an excellent pizza experience that won't break the bank, stop searching and head straight to I Love New York Pizza in Troy. You won't regret it! Just be sure to try the chicken marsala pizza – it's a game-changer!

Kate

Great NYC style pizza. They offer 6,8,12,18 piece cut. Prices aren’t bad. A little greasy but the pizza was delicious. The men working were very nice and accommodating with bringing us napkins, plates and cups when we changed our mind from take out to eating there. We also got a free 2L soda with our 8 cut pizza! Would go back because it was also made to order very quickly.

Toni L Goodwin

After a night out with some friends we stopped at Troy's I Love New York Pizza. I got the deep dish seafood and spinach pizza and my hubby got the Philadelphia steak cheese pizza both of them were delicious.

Erich Faust

As usual, the pizza can't be beat here! Still my favorite...I live in CT so a treat to come through here and make a stop! Two of my favs in pic: lasagna and broccoli-ricotta!

SnackLikeShanice

My favorite place to grab a slice, I've been coming here for years. The staff is always fast and friendly. Very sketchy area though, that's downtown Troy for you...

Matt T

Best pizza around! I've been eating here regularly for about 25 years now and I can say I still enjoy the food. They offer a large variety of pies and toppings along with wings, hot subs and pasta. Great for a quick lunch or dinner. They're open late too!

+1

Lowkey spot, a bit greasy but good slices, okay wings and alright subs. Not a fan of brand blue cheese with wings takeaway. Good for a quick pick when downtown and with cash on hand.

N R

I stopped by I Love Troy Pizza for lunch and enjoyed the classic NY-style pizza atmosphere inside. I tried the mushroom & chicken slice, which was probably the best one, and the buffalo chicken slice, which was also very tasty. I also ordered the beef sausage pizza — flavorful but a bit on the greasy side. Overall, it’s a decent pizza spot with friendly staff. A nice perk is that you get a complimentary fountain drink with every two slices, which is a great deal. Plenty of seating space makes it a good spot to sit and enjoy your meal.

+6

Joao De La Cruz

This place is CASH ONLY. For ANYONE who expects actual NYC Pizza, this is NOT that. Yes, stylistically they can call it NYC style, but on the flavor department, it's not. The sauce is a bit sweet, I can't really taste the sauce much, it's low-med quality, and overall it's at best OK/DECENT. A bit expensive as well. One cheese slice is $3.25, which I'm assuming is because of the size. People on reddit recommend this pizza joint, just don't expect the best of the best, this pizzeria's just comfortable with what they have going on, more power to them but again, don't expect something amazing.

Angelo

Recommend putting a cash only sign somewhere in the establishment ,or letting customers know before you warm up their food and make them use the atm and charge the fee,ps if you’d like to pay with card just scan the QR code

T leak

Another place that I went to for over 20 years that I will never spend 50 buck at again. The anti pasta salad was pitiful and the extra cheese pizza actually had less cheese than normal. They just don’t care anymore. No celery with the wings and look at those big pieces of carrots. I paid 9.50 for that salad and I threw it away because it was just so garbage and dirty looking. I go there all the time and they still didn’t care about what they served me. I wanted to go to 3 BROTHERS across the bridge in Watervilet but they were close. If I ever go back to I Love out of convenience, I will only get a slice of cheese pizza.