Menú
A J's Pizzeria
PosDo

© 2026 PosDo · v3.0

West Sand Lake

A J's Pizzeria

★★★★★ 4.5 · 134 reseñas

At A J's Pizzeria, we're passionate about serving up classic New York-style pies that feel like a taste of home. Our casual, vibrant atmosphere is the perfect spot to gather with friends and family for a delicious meal. We've perfected our recipe for the ultimate pizza experience...

A J's Pizzeria

Pizza · West Sand Lake

4.5 · 1,808 ressenyes Google

Ofertes disponibles

Sigues flexible, estalvia més

Sigues flexible, estalvia més

www.ajsnypizza.com
Yelp 4.0 (230) TripAdvisor 4.4 (133) Yellowpages 4.0 (5) Bringfido 4.8 (4)

Sobre A J's Pizzeria

At A J's Pizzeria, we're passionate about serving up classic New York-style pies that feel like a taste of home. Our casual, vibrant atmosphere is the perfect spot to gather with friends and family for a delicious meal. We've perfected our recipe for the ultimate pizza experience, from our signature...

At A J's Pizzeria, we're passionate about serving up classic New York-style pies that feel like a taste of home. Our casual, vibrant atmosphere is the perfect spot to gather with friends and family for a delicious meal. We've perfected our recipe for the ultimate pizza experience, from our signature wings to creative ravioli options. Our friendly staff are dedicated to providing top-notch service, ensuring every visit feels like a warm hug. Whether you're in the mood for a classic margherita or something new, we can't wait to share it with you.

Què diuen els clients de A J's Pizzeria

A J's Pizzeria is a local favorite known for its delicious pizza, calzones, and garlic knots. Customers rave about the friendly staff and quick service. The margherita pizza and outdoor seating are particularly popular.

Plats populars

calzones garlic knots margherita pizza (4) side salads

Ideal per a

Famílies Grups Locals Informal Ràpid

Tip: Pizzas can be ordered by the slice, making it a great place to grab some lunch. There's plenty of indoor & outdoor seating for big groups.

Services

📶 WiFi 🌳 Terrasse 🅿️ Parking 🚗 Delivery Accessible 🍽️ Déjeuner 🌙 Dîner 🥗 Vegetarian
🎯 Casual 🛋️ Cozy Trendy 👥 Groups

Què veure a prop

Community House
Patrimoni
A 161m

Community House

edificio

Veure detalls
Bethel A.M.E. Church
Patrimoni
A 481m

Bethel A.M.E. Church

edificio

Veure detalls
iglesia de los Siete Dolores
Patrimoni
A 501m

iglesia de los Siete Dolores

iglesia

Veure detalls
Battery Park
A 562m

Battery Park

parque

Veure detalls
First Congregational Church
Patrimoni
A 638m

First Congregational Church

iglesia

Veure detalls
Riverside Park
A 787m

Riverside Park

parque

Veure detalls

Dades de Wikidata

Explora els voltants de A J's Pizzeria

A J's Pizzeria es troba a West Sand Lake, envoltat de llocs d'interès cultural i històric. Aquests són alguns dels punts més destacats als voltants.

Patrimoni Històric

  • Community House (A 161m) — historic building in Manhattan, Kansas, United States Propiedad contribuidora
  • Bethel A.M.E. Church (A 481m) — historic building in Manhattan, Kansas, United States Lugar inscrito en el Registro Nacional de Lugares Históricos
  • iglesia de los Siete Dolores (A 501m) — church building in Kansas, United States of America Propiedad contribuidora
  • First Congregational Church (A 638m) — church in Manhattan, Kansas Lugar inscrito en el Registro Nacional de Lugares Históricos
  • Second Baptist Church (A 938m) — historic building in Manhattan, Kansas, United States Propiedad contribuidora

Parcs i Jardins

  • Battery Park (A 562m) — park in Riley County, Kansas, United States of America
  • Riverside Park (A 787m) — park in Riley County, Kansas, United States of America

Dades de Wikidata

Preguntes freqüents sobre A J's Pizzeria

A J's Pizzeria es troba a 301 Poyntz Ave, Manhattan, KS 66502, West Sand Lake.
A prop de A J's Pizzeria es troben llocs d'interès com Community House, Bethel A.M.E. Church, iglesia de los Siete Dolores, Battery Park.
A J's Pizzeria ofereix cuina pizza.
A J's Pizzeria té horari d'atenció. Consulta el perfil per horaris actualitzats.
A J's Pizzeria ofereix els serveis següents: menjar al local, per emportar, lliurament.
Els plats més recomanats a A J's Pizzeria segons les opinions dels clients són: calzones, garlic knots, margherita pizza, side salads.
A J's Pizzeria és ideal per a famílies, grups, locals, informal, menjar ràpid.
A J's Pizzeria is a local favorite known for its delicious pizza, calzones, and garlic knots. Customers rave about the friendly staff and quick service. The margherita pizza and outdoor seating are particularly popular.
Pizzas can be ordered by the slice, making it a great place to grab some lunch. There's plenty of indoor & outdoor seating for big groups.
1,808
Ressenyes

Opinions de A J's Pizzeria West Sand Lake

4.5
1,808
5★
70%
4★
21%
3★
5%
2★
2%
1★
2%
J
Jeffrey Barker

Got the hot wing pizza (number 8 I think). Didn’t wait long and our server was attentive. Really couldn’t ask for anything else. Will definitely do again.

J
Jeff Goff

We had slices (and spaghetti for the kids) and were quite impressed with the quality, friendliness of the staff, and decor; AJ's is one of best pizza places we've ever visited! Great work!

e
ejkchance

Affordable and Delicious pizza, order at the counter. Minimal Interaction with staff.

T
Travis Trachta

Fantastic pizza, available by the slice or the entire pizza, with a great outdoor seating area. The staff was very friendly and took care of our needs.

A
Adrianna Liebert

At AJ’s you can either order a slice or full pizza, so everyone can get what they want. Order and pay at the counter then sit and wait for them to bring your pizza to you. Very chill and family friendly environment. We haven’t been disappointed yet, all the pizza tastes so good, our favorite being the Meatball Parm.

M
Margaret Stokes

We often go to AJs for a quick late night bite on the weekends. The pizza is always so good. We've had the chicken bacon ranch, BBQ chicken, margherita, and their version of a combination ( it has a lot of meat on it so we took a few off). It doesn't matter the flavor, the pizza is always on point. We even eat the crust ( if the crust isn't good we won't eat the ends). My son loves the pepperoni bricks too. The staff is always so friendly and service is fast. They have a shuffleboard table in the corner so we played while we waited for the pizza.

C
Caleb May

Great atmosphere and excellent pizza!

M
Megan Mcfarland

Super cute 🥺 very friendly staff super cute seating and nice music I am hard of hearing so I had a bit of a hard time hearing my bf, but other then that everything was super good!

T
Tarra Gray

AJ's is one of my favorite casual downtown restaurants. They have great pizza, they have a balanced ratio of pizza dough to sauce to cheese/toppings, huge salads and their garlic knots are always great. Lots of speciality pizzas, but if you just like cheese and pepperoni they do that well too. Always good service and fun atmosphere.

M
Marcelline Ritz

Always perfect place for lunch. Tons of options, great food, perfect every time. Too delicious to take a photo before .

P
Paul Kitchen

Great pizza at a really reasonable price. The service was awesome! Thanks for a wonderful experience.

C
Curtis Bryant

Great pizza, and they made it quickly

A
Amber Schlesener

For my first time here I love the food and an amazing experience everyone was kind

S
Sabrina Reiswig

I’m so happy with this place. It’s not often we find a Gluten-free pizza that doesn’t taste like cardboard. This place hit it out of the park. There regular pizza is also VERY good. We’ll be coming back again and again.

H
Hunter B.

This pizza ........holy hell....looks amazing.....tastes amazing. New York style pizza... Costs me 16.46 after tip. Slices bigger than Sbarro. I am so glad I stopped in. The reviews were so right. Always eat local! I'm in town from St Louis for a few days and couldn't stay in the hotel room so I was wanted to walk around and love pizza. Saw the place and Checked the reviews on Google before I went in.

C
Christopher Gillespie

Got it to go, but all was legit. The toppings clearly quality, killer sausage. Got the pesto slices too, they were good but the big apple definitely would have me going back.

J
JA

Really good pizza! We has a large Manhattan Margherita and it was delicious! Add some garlic knots, Buffalo wings, and a cold beer, and you're good to go!

T
Thomas Peterson

I got a meatball canzone and it was really good. One of the best canzones I've had in a long time

R
Robyn White

Excellent pizza, great choices and good beer selection.

K
Kimberly Burnett

This pizza place sells a huge variety of pizzas and you can buy by the slice too! The single slices are huge and the crust has the perfect crunch.

A
Alaina Kaufman

Our favorite pizza place in Manhattan! My daughter loves the garlic knots.

S
Sam Chav

Worth every penny! Cozy and unique atmosphere with authentic New York pizza. Wings were quality as well. Wait staff was helpful. Best pizza in Manhattan (KS)!

T
Teodoro Gray

Great date night place, very welcoming and honestly all the food is spectacular 😁

M
Micah Linville

Best slice of pizza in town.... and the knots are worth going for by themself too. The patio is really cool too

C
C. E.

Loved the pizza, toasted raviolis and cold draft beer. Order pizza with favorite toppings or by specialty pizzas.

Q
Quanda Minor

Pizza was good as well. Lol The staff was amazing. It was my first time there and service was more than good. Will definitely go back when I return to work there again.

T
Tiffany Kemph

Great place! We love the food! We love about an hour away but have been driving over about once a week. Parking can get difficult so we try to go when they first open or between 2-4. I wish they offered speciality pizza by the slice on Saturdays. The specialty pizzas are a must try!

A
Aaron Bucy

This is my favorite place to go when we are in Manhattan. The pizzas are the best, but don’t sleep on the wings either!

M
Michael McCorkle

Location and the pizza are incredible. I really enjoy being able to relax downtown and know that I can just walk down the street and grab some pizza any time I want 😋. The other thing I didn't know is they have the best salads in all of Manhattan! They allow you to substitute by removing and adding anything you desire. My personal favorite is the Bay ridge without the pepperoncinis and olives and then adding chicken, bacon, and eggs ❤️

C
Cheryl B

Excellent pizza with high quality ingredients. The dining area is nicely organized with lots of room and a great staff. I highly recommend AJ’s in Manhattan.

T
Torey Johnson

Best pizza in Manhattan! Awesome experience

L
Lee Smith

Delicious pizza! Anything you order will be great here. One of our favorites to visit while in Manhattan.

B
Bryan Smith

Nice staff took my order and did fantastic. I was in town visiting friends and we were downtown and hungry slice of NY pizza in Kansas with beer...yes & yummy... Did order from front counter- got my food and it was piping hot after a short wait. My order was accurate and I definitely will return when in the situation of hunger and in the area. I really felt valued with my interaction with the staff. They were pleasant and smiling....that goes a long way! Thank you again for being awesome. Respectfully, Bryan Yukon Oklahoma

T
Tam Henders

Had takeout. Tasty pizza. Fulfilling. You can add additional toppings to which initial pie you select, they have an array of choices. Would recommend if you want to try something different then the chain pizza joints.

G
George W.

A nice visit on a cold Kansas night. My wife and I shared a small order of Buffalo Wings, and then we each had our own large slice of pizza. The slices weren't traditional NY Style pizza, but they were hearty and filling none the less. Oh, we both also had side salads, which, again, were hearty, filling, and tasty. The beer menu was appealing also, but maybe next time. Next time I'm in Manhattan, KS I will gladly stop by AJ's again. I strongly recommend them.

m
mhclark1983

Came in here on a whim to try this place out. Intended to be a carry out order, but showed up earlier than anticipated. Sat down and decided to grab a drink. Turned into eating my dinner and having a couple more. Enjoyed the conversation with the bartender and those at bar. Pizza was tasty at bar, next day cold out of fridge, and reheated in the oven. Will try to make it back to this facility and grab another pie and good company!

A
Andrew Otto

Aj's pizza is a great local place to grab some pizza. They have a great atmosphere to hang out and talk to family or friends. I had the chicken bacon ranch pizza and it was amazing! The garlic knots are also buttery and garlic-y! I would definitely go back for either a slice or a whole pie. They also have a nice selection of alcoholic drinks on tap and bottled.

A
Anna B.

One of our favorite pizza places in MHK. Great for take-out and also dine-in. Also recommend their cheesecake 💖

M
Michael Black

Such amazing pizza! My wife and I each got a slice and shared a side salad which was more than enough for us. A little garlic bread roll came with our salad and it was absolutely amazing. Apparently they make them into sliders with pepperoni and cheese. Next time I go I'm going to ask if they'd make them with Canadian bacon, cheese and some white onions for me. That'd be an amazing lunch! The staff is very friendly and even brought out a bowl of water for our dog!

a
aliyah melendez

The BEST restaurant in Manhattan, KS. Hands down. I’ve been a couple times, but I recently ordered the large spinach chicken alfredo. The pizza crust was crunchy but perfectly cooked, and the sauce was creamy. Their ranch is the best I’ve ever had! Definitely recommend trying this place out. I will always visit when I’m in the area.

V
Victoria Solano (v.s.)

The classic pizzas and the pizza bricks are amazing! Definitely a wonderful environment for some casual dining.

J
Jaron Rodriguez

They brought our food out in 5 minutes and it was so good, I forgot to take a picture of it. Little to no grease in the pizza, I'm surprised Pizza Hutt or Domino's haven't been shut down yet

E
Ellie Evans

Probably the best pizzeria around here. The food is delicious and you get lots of it for a cheap price. I absolutely enjoyed the atmosphere and the management. You don't wait too long for your food. Good for groups. I definitely recommend it.

J
Jon Klimek

Best pizza in Manhattan, you need a hot oven to make the crust crispy. They are really busy with the students now in town, but it's worth it. 18th and 8th is the second one on the menu and I get it every time.

K
KC D

I was staying in mhk for a week and ended up going to AJ's three times while I was there. The place is fantastic. Great pizza, wings, and salads. I did pickup and dine in. Food was always hot and fresh. Great place and for sure the best pizza in the area!

M
Meme

OUTSTANDING PIZZA! GARLIC knots on point. Deffinitely recommend this place for some yummy pizza. 😋 Its so good words dnt describe how happy I am to be able to indugle in greatness.

L
Lauren Squires

We got a slice of Doctors Delight and the Margherita pizza. Both were AMAZING. 10/10 Reccommend A++

D
Dallas Goracke

Good Pizza. I go for the specialty pies XL. Ravioli and pepperoni bricks are also nice. Big salads. Nightly specials. Dog friendly patio on Wednesdays. A good spot for sure. Nice selection of cans and bottled beers.

h
hotbeer josh

Since I have been stationed at Fort Riley this has been a solid staple. I love the pizza, it has a chewy new york style crust, and the salads are a great deal. Usually my wife and I eat for under 20 dollars and have plenty left over.

B
Bradly Kunberger

The baked Zita was amazing. 11.99 for this huge portion, which practically fed us all. The cheese in it was super yummy

m
mariam Uddin

Im from new york and I approve of this place. Pizza taste like the dollar pizza in Manhattan !

S
Sean M. Matthews

One of the best pizza joints in Manhattan. All of the options that I've ordered has been great. Highly recommend if you're craving pizza.

A
Alicia Martinez

Pizza delicious, subs amazing. If you haven't gone already I'm judging you. The meatball sub is honestly the best meatball sub I've had. It's also the most messy but my stomach was happy and hey there's napkins. If you get a whole one make sure you are hungry. The bun gets lathered in like this garlic butter. The meatballs are seasoned so well and are Hella juicy. The marinara sauce- thick and delicious. The cheese? Stringy and needed. The Pizza crust is chewy and has a nice crunch. The amount of sauce and cheese ratio is excellent. We got the meatball parm pie. If you cant tell I really love their meatballs. Had the meatball sub and sat down outside. It was on a Saturday afternoon so the wait time was long! But so freaking worth it for that food. The pizza was ordered to go on a Wednesday Night and I ordered it drove there and it was ready. 15 minutes. So that was perfect! Parking on a Saturday or Friday is hell I do not recommend trying to park at their designated space on those days. Weekdays tend to be easier. But Friday and Saturday? Forget about it park a bit aways and just walk there.

Tim Cassel
Tim Cassel

Had the 18th & 8 meat pizza, cheesy bread & my wife had a salad with feta cheese on it. All the food was very good. Staff was friendly. Has a good atmosphere to line up with New York theme.

David Higgins
David Higgins

Great parking, great food and great staff! Was working out of town in Manhattan and everyone I spoke to raved about this place! Now, I get it! I’ll be working there again this week and plan on visiting again. GREAT Pizza! Definitely a must go!

Hayden Haake
Hayden Haake

This was a wonderful pizza place! The food was piping hot and the calzones we got were stuffed full of toppings. The flavor was spot on and is now a new favorite place for us to stop when we are in town. The bathrooms were clean and the staff was friendly. Can't wait to come back soon!

Vincent Duncan
Vincent Duncan

AJ’s NY Pizzeria hit all the right notes quick service, friendly staff, and hot, flavorful slices with that perfect New York–style crust. We tried the Hawaiian Delight, Pizza Blanco with Spinach, and Manhattan Margherita, and each one was spot on. The sauce was amazing...rich, a little sweet, and full of basil flavor that ties it all together. Honestly, if you come to Manhattan and don’t eat at AJ’s… did you even go to Manhattan?

Deborah Moege
Deborah Moege

Loved our friendly service, pizza and salad. Grateful for the gluten free options as well.

KATY S
KATY S

We love pizza so when we were in Manhattan, KS we read all the reviews to find the best pizza in this town! AJ's Pizza had the most positive reviews on GoogleMaps, so we tried it. AJ's Pizza was very good pizza. The garden salads were big and very fresh and the ranch dressing was very good! The staff were very helpful and friendly. The place was pumping when we arrived and the atmosphere was great. Our family loved the pizza! We will be back to AJ's Pizza the next time we are in town!

Megan Yem
Megan Yem

Get the garlic knots!!! I like to get the individual slice with a couple different toppings. The calzones are good also. The cheesy bread has good flavor. The staff is friendly but sometimes it’s hard to hear then when it’s busy and crowded. Tonight, we were sitting at the table tonight and a young worker came over to restock the napkins, it was a very odd interaction. She literally leaned it within 6 inches to our face and didn’t say excuse me or anything……. Just very odd….

James Bentivegna
James Bentivegna

We came in one afternoon to grab a quick bite to eat after touring Kansas State. We quickly ordered at the counter and found a spot to sit. The service was good and the pizza was great. Everything tasted fresh.

Nate Bernklau
Nate Bernklau

The pizza was excellent and the staff was friendly the bowling alley lane table tops and checker cab decor give a feel of the Big Apple in the Little Apple. Crust was a bit on the done side but it has a great taste and crunch. Just what you need for big NY style slices.

Ed Halasz
Ed Halasz

Five Thumbs Up! My wife had the Large Ziti Pasta w/Alfredo sauce, I had the Large Romaine Salad Nolita and slice of Manhattan Margarita pizza, everything was excellent! 👍👍👍👍👍

Kellie Swain
Kellie Swain

Nice local pizza place. Single slices are LARGE. Our eyes were a little bigger than our stomachs, we ordered several slices of different things we wanted to try and ended up lots of leftovers. The BBQ Chicken, 18th and 8, Big Apple and Hawaiian were good. Our daughter got the grilled cheese and enjoyed it as well. She barely finished her slice (she's a pre-teen). It was pretty busy, but we didn't wait very long. Staff was excellent and helpful. The NYC theme everywhere was cool, but the pizza was more brick oven type. The thing that really surprised us was the affordability. We'll be back the next time we're in town for sure.

Kain R Heinlein
Kain R Heinlein

Good place and setting. Can choose to eat inside or out. Pizzas, pastas, calzones and sliders are create your own. Few choice of things to eat but plenty of ingredients! P.S. tried it again, and the food is quality. The cheesecake is one of the richest I've had. Could not finish it in one sitting. Delicious

R
Rich F.

AJ's is always great, my local go-to for pizza. Love the atmosphere there as well, staff is always friendly and prompt.

R
Rich F.

AJ's is always great, my local go-to for pizza. Love the atmosphere there as well, staff is always friendly and prompt.

R
Rich F.

AJ's is always great, my local go-to for pizza. Love the atmosphere there as well, staff is always friendly and prompt.

R
Rich F.

AJ's is always great, my local go-to for pizza. Love the atmosphere there as well, staff is always friendly and prompt.

E
Elton M.

Great pizza. Defiantly a stop when in Manhappiness or at least take it to go and have when we get home

E
Elton M.

Great pizza. Defiantly a stop when in Manhappiness or at least take it to go and have when we get home

D
Dylan K.

Absolutely amazing guaranteed coming back to this place again. Good service good pizza well done. Especially with the brick oven they while walking through in the place I knew right away it was bri…

S
Stacy T.

Great NY style pizza. Very friendly and a very spacious dining room. \nWe ordered the 14" manhattan margarita and 14" with green olives (don't see that very often) mushrooms, pepperoni & Italian sa…

S
Stacy T.

Great NY style pizza. Very friendly and a very spacious dining room. \nWe ordered the 14" manhattan margarita and 14" with green olives (don't see that very often) mushrooms, pepperoni & Italian sa…

T
Tucker S.

Great food, Friendly Service. Good atmosphere. I would rate it a 7.2 on the Dave's scale. Nice undercarafe on the pizza. Not to much flop, little grease. Wonderful taste

T
Tucker S.

Great food, Friendly service. Good atmosphere. I would rate it a 7.2 on the Dave's scale. Nice undercarafe on the pizza. Not to much flop, little grease. Wonderful taste

E
Erik E.

Never tried AJ's before, but friends from the shop talk about it all the time. Went in on Saturday afternoon, good crowd. Pretty cool inside. Nice outdoor area. Pizza was very good and very afforda…

R
Regine R.

Pizza was delicious! We came with our kids and they loved the outdoor seating. The customer service was wonderful, we'll be coming back!

K
Katie F.

Always a great place to eat in Manhattan with plenty of indoor & outdoor seating for big groups. They have a large menu full of special topping pizzas. The service is always very friendly and quick…

E
Elizabeth J.

I love this place. The margarita pizza is my favorite. The slices are huge and it's just a great place to grab some lunch.

6
624shantip

I cannot say enough how awesome AJs is!! Adam the owner really cares about people having a great experience and then you have the food!!!! Oh my god … who would have thought that besides the deliciou…

6
624shantip

I cannot say enough how awesome AJs is!! Adam the owner really cares about people having a great experience and then you have the food!!!! Oh my god … who would have thought that besides the delici…

B
Braden M

This is the best pizza in america with great service. would come back and eat again, maybe with family this time.

B
Braden M

This is the best pizza in america with great service. would come back and eat again, maybe with family this time.

B
Braden M

This is the best pizza in america with great service. would come back and eat again, maybe with family this time.

D
Dream53271440963

It's the best pizza I've ever eaten. This taste is fantastic beyond reproducibility. If you want the best dinner, go here. Even though I am a foreigner, I can guarantee the taste!

D
Dream53271440963

It's the best pizza I've ever eaten. This taste is fantastic beyond reproducibility. If you want the best dinner, go here. Even though I am a foreigner, I can guarantee the taste!

t
torib169

This place is amazing! It has a lot of options, the side salads are big, and the prices are terrific! We all had side salads and all the pizzas can be ordered by the slice.

7
757CCC

Great pizza place right in the heart of downtown Manhattan. Always busy but the waitstaff is efficient and gets the orders out pretty quickly and delicious. You order at the counter and pick up the…

7
757CCC

Got the margherita pizza with additional toppings at lunch and ate on the large outdoor patio. Some of our part also got a salad. Everything was delicious

R
RyanWilch

We ordered the calzones which were excellent and the garlic knots which also were good. The girlfriend normally doesn't dip her stuff in marinara but she loved the sauce so much that she couldn't …

J
Jonathan Chacon

For new york style pizza its as close as you can get being so far from the source. Will say it does have a good flop need a bit better cheese pull solid crust. Will say some of their other pies are also pretty good!

t
toddnks

Cool place that serves a decent pie. The lack of use of a pizza oven is the only reason it gets 4 instead of 5 stars. If you expect NY style, it's expected it's done on a flat steel pizza oven, not a conveyor belt oven. The smooth metal adds the best crust treatment. These guys miss that one element which is huge.

T
Tori Foust

So the pizza is really good and the atmosphere is great, but the napkins are SO small and that kind of really sucks! I request they invest in some larger napkins so I don’t have to use 20 napkins for just one slice of pizza

A
Ally Luna

I really feel like my pizza could've been cooked longer. The white sauce was quite flavorless and I was disappointed there wasn't spinach 😋. The bricks were quite good and properly cooked. The cashier was also very helpful and nice.

R
Ryan Peacock

Good pizza at a resonable price. They had several beers on tap including the Lagunitas IPA which is one of my go to beers with pizza. They offer table service after you order at the counter. If you go with your family like I did it is cheaper to go ahead and order a full pizza rather that buy by the slice. My family of four ordered the Large Hawaiian pizza and we all ate our fill and even has one slice left. They have a nice patio and plenty of window seating to sit and people watch.

K
K !

The single slices are huge and very tasty! The garlic knots were also really good!

L
Lila Johnson

Local Tastes Great Sometimes, its great to try something that’s not the run of the mill or part of a restaurant chain. At times, you have to shake up your taste buds to something new. AJ’s NY Pizzeria did just that. After work, I decided to give this local shop a chance. I ordered one cheese brick stuffed with pepperoni, and one slice of Chicken Bacon Ranch pizza. The brick arrived fresh from the oven served with a side of sauce. Let’s just say next time I’ll order a set of four! The pizza slice was satisfying not only in taste but in size for the money. Those two items filled me up. Overall: I will return, not only for more bricks but to try the BBQ Chicken Pie.

D
Damien Green

Menu is very vast and unique. I had the hardest time deciding which slices to get. I settled on the grilled cheese pie and jalapeño popper. Both excellent choices. Had the toasted ravioli also. Very reasonably priced, excellent customer service as well. I generally look for pizza whenever visiting a different city and AJ’s did not disappoint. That’s the reason both pizzas have been bitten, lol.

M
M Lawrence

AJ’s Pizza has great customer service and a great atmosphere. Everything is New York themed and the pizza is good. They have plenty of menu options. I recommend you walk to the restaurant and park elsewhere because there is limited parking.

C
Corey Whitworth

Great NY style pizza joint with order by the slice available with a ridiculous amount of custom toppings. Convienent location just off of Poyntz, close to shopping and upscale drinking establishments.

D
Daniel Barthold

Tried out just a cheese pizza and The 18th and 8th. Solid pizza, crust had a good crisp to it and held up when folding a piece. Good flavors, maybe just a little over cooked. Definitely better than any of the big corporate chains.

G
Gennie English

So let me start by saying it's a college town. It's at the edge of that part of town verses smack dab in the small tight streets. The staff were very friendly . Now it was slow when I came in so not sure how they are when it's a game night or weekend which I'm sure they are slammed. Now Hunter took my order and was so helpful and informative and didn't let my eyes be bigger than my stomach lol. Jackson was friendly and listen to me chatter and explain about the RFTW (comes to junction City every May) . Friendly open environment and family friendly. My food smelled great and looked great. I'd give 4.5 if they existed cause my only complaint was the sauce was a tiny bit too sweet for NY style and tiny bit off spice level wise. Other than that wasn't burnt bottom and folded (the NY style test!) the inside was nice but the outside patio was great on a beautiful weather night. Music and lights all around. A mural on the wall to see and people watching ability. There's parking on the back and front sides. I can't compare to other 'local' pizza places in the area but I'd recommend AJs to anyone no matter who you are! I took a video of the outside and the patios and street since not much on Google but seems to need to be cut in half it's too long. Will add later

Maggie Milam
Maggie Milam

Pizza was pretty decent. Sweeter sauce, so if that's not your thing, know that going in. The staff was... a mixed bag lol. I asked for silverware and was told just "no". I thought she was joking as I'd literally just watched her walking with some, so I explained why I needed it. Then she finally explained that they didn't have any clean (which happens, it was just off-putting the way she answered initially). Super cool looking place, though! If you want pizza that isn't a chain restaurant, give this spot a try. Not crazy priced, decent food, and neat decor.

Ben Wilhelm
Ben Wilhelm

Love the pizza! Always worth the wait, but do be prepared for a short wait. If you're ordering carry out I would recommend calling. I have not had good experiences ordering online. Just collected a pizza tonight without my toppings but sadly didn't check until I got home. Also when going to pickup, plan to arrive early because you will wait before someone can serve you to pick up. Edit: business reached out to let me know they're updated their online ordering process soon, so that's really great to hear! Dude was great to talk to and solution oriented. Great business!

Travis Truong
Travis Truong

The garlic knots were delicious and so was the pizza despite the pizza sauce being a bit sweeter than what've I liked to be. The calzone was delicious and it was worth the 15-minute wait. The inside is decorated like a NY-subway station sort of since the staff will bring out signs with NY street signs to mark your order if you dine-in.

Nathan Goodwin
Nathan Goodwin

This is a counter service pizza shop. Pizza is available by the slice or the pie. It has a ton of topping options at a reasonable price. The food was great, fast, cooked fresh. My wife and I enjoyed our lunch very much

Tania Galindez
Tania Galindez

The food wasn’t bad, but the pizzas didn’t really do it for me I’ve had way better. The calzone, though? Super tasty.

Jason Sargent
Jason Sargent

Had lunch at AJ's. I knew when we got out of the car we made a great choice! We could smell the pizza immediately. We had a half "8 & 18" and half "Hawaiian ". So good! It came out quicker than I expected and we were happy. Sitting there smelling the pizzas while hungry built the anticipation. The pizza was so good. Staff was friendly, the place was clean. They also have a large outside dining area. I recommend AJ's and would return for sure.

T
Travis T.

The garlic knots were delicious and so was the pizza despite the pizza sauce being a bit sweeter than what've I liked to be. The calzone was delicious and it was worth the 15-minute wait. The inside …

T
Travis T.

The garlic knots were delicious and so was the pizza despite the pizza sauce being a bit sweeter than what've I liked to be. The calzone was delicious and it was worth the 15-minute wait. The i…

T
Travis T.

The garlic knots were delicious and so was the pizza despite the pizza sauce being a bit sweeter than what've I liked to be. The calzone was delicious and it was worth the 15-minute wait. The ins…

T
Travis T.

The garlic knots were delicious and so was the pizza despite the pizza sauce being a bit sweeter than what've I liked to be. The calzone was delicious and it was worth the 15-minute wait. The insid…

F
Fay L.

Pizza is good, beer is cold, service is ok, atmosphere inside isn't top notch but courtyard dining is pleasant.

H
Herman02

A local pizze place with a few locations in Topeka as well. wood fire pizza in every way possible you might like pizza. It's really good. They have salads that can be a meal themselves, a…

M
Matthew Ball

Ok pizza. I wouldn't go out of my way to get it but it was alright.

B
Brenden Ingargiola

Cool place, garlic knots were good, but could’ve done without red sauce on a chicken bacon ranch pizza.

M
Michelle Johnson

I went in this restaurant several months ago to pick up an order. I was ignored. Another customer came in and they went to help him. I said I was here waiting. The only think I could say is- it was because of the color of my skin. I wouldn’t not return to a place whose staff doesn’t want to serve minorities.

M
Matthew Wall

Food was ok. Pizza was a bit over done on the crust and soggy in the middle, but had good flavor.

R
Rachael Asbury

So, not my favorite pizza place, but I've only been there twice. The garlic knots are excellent, very large and buttery, and a decent price. The pizza is ok, inconsistent on taste. The crust is crispy and very plain, which I like. They have a decent sized menu and a nice, casual atmosphere. It's located just across from the mall on the west/Poyntz Ave side and has a large shaded outdoor eating area.

R
Rich Taggett

Pizza was ok. Staff was friendly. The whole place was clean. Two slices and a fountain drink was 14 before tip. They do slices of any of their pies. It seemed odd that they would have every pie on the menu available every day. Turns out they can cook them a slice at a time. They have pre-made doughs with sauce on them in big racks visible. It is probably efficient that way, but it certainly affects quality. I will likely not go back, but if someone invited me there, I wouldn't turn it down. If your in the mood for a single slice of a very specific pie, this might be your place.

Rommel Nateras
Rommel Nateras

I didn't get the chance of trying the food here, but service is horrible. The live music brought me here because you can hear it when walking on streets

Maile Tatman
Maile Tatman

You order at the counter. I asked how the drinks worked since I have never been here. She said they are all the same. They ask you if you want to tip when you pay. I opted to tip and when our pizza was brought to the table we asked for ranch. The waitress then brought two tiny containers for a table of 5. We asked for some more and she was awfully sassy. I can see why they ask for the tip ahead of time. The food was good but the service is not great.

B
Bill J.

Not quite NY style pizza. Maybe with a Midwest twist. But it was good. The sauce was ok, service was adequate

A
Antonio L.

Pretty mid pizza. I mean there really isn't a good pizza option in Manhattan so AJ's is really the only choice. sauce is sweet which i dont personally enjoy but the rest of what they offer is good …

N
Noah

Very aggressive asking for tips even on carryout orders. Very tacky and weird. The pizza is average at best. Pizza in Manhattan is all fast food quality.

B
Ben M.

I was disappointed. We had a takeout order for a large John Stamos pizza and a large Taco pizza. The toppings on both were pretty pathetic and they were really dry. To be fair, we were late at picking up our order. See pics

C
Chauna Johnson

Came from out of town to visit family and stopped in this local shop. Nice atmosphere but by far the worst pizza I ever had. The crust was comparable to frozen Ellios pizza from the market. The sauce was horrible. We also ordered garlic knots by far the worst garlic knots ever. This place has the right atmosphere and they are welcoming but the name shouldn’t have anything with NY in it. The owner needs to go to NY and taste real pizza.

T
Tait Wharff

Tastes like cardboard. Rather have a tortilla with sauce and cheese

R
Rivera Yari

Everything was reheated and the pizza crust was too thin; it was mostly cheese and sauce. Very disappointed.

E
Eric Shaffer

I'm here and super disgusted by the absence of masks, hand sanitizer, and generally anything hygiene related (by both post and PRE COVID standards). If I didn't have hungry, tired kids with me I'd have walked out immediately. Food looks fine, but the BBQ Chicken Pizza tastes like pre-cooked frozen-aisle grilled chicken with KC Masterpiece dumped on it. Icing on this cake was complete disregard for the shuffleboard rules and allowing 2 sniveling, unmasked pre-tweens to play the game without adult supervision; all this AFTER I had denied my own children because I wouldn't be able to supervise. I wish I had more hands, so I could give this place 4 Thumbs Down. Would be better if it was still a shuttered Schlotzky's.

B
Brenda Heard

Dont eat here if you like food with taste. Thank God they sell alcohol because you have to be drunk like most of these customers were to eat this mess. Horrible food. No taste. Left hungry. Refused to give a refund on all the food we couldn't eat. How do you refund $10 for a $12.99 order of wings?

F
From Kansas

Blue cheese was one of the toppings I picked. A few cold bits were put on my pizza after it was already cooked. Besides that, the pizza was not good in general. Easily the worst pizza I have ever bought at a restaurant.

C
Chris Steinke

The pizza is horrible. Not sure what style they are trying to capture but it's a complete miss. Their dough is soft and chewy, their margherita/cheese pizza is horribly drenched in so much garlic (and I love garlic) that it overpowers anything else. They should learn to make pizza before selling it. Easily the worst pizza place in town.

Inicia sessió per deixar una ressenya

Inicia sessió
👑 És teu? Reclama'l GRATIS!

Elimina anuncis i gestiona el menú

Explora la teva zona

Més restaurants a West Sand Lake →
📸

176 Fotos

Explora les fotos de A J's Pizzeria

A J's Pizzeria
A J's Pizzeria
A J's Pizzeria
A J's Pizzeria
A J's Pizzeria
+171 Més
📍

Informació sobre A J's Pizzeria

Com arribar

301 Poyntz Ave, Manhattan, KS 66502

West Sand Lake, NY 66502

Carregant mapa...
A J's Pizzeria
Toca per direccions

Destacats

Altament Valorat
4.5/5 estrelles
💬
Moltes Ressenyes
1808 ressenyes
💰
Preu Moderat
Nivell de preus
👨‍🍳
pizza
Tipus de cuina

Serveis

🍽️ Dinar
🍾 Sopar
🍰 Postres
🥗 Opcions Vegetarianes
🥡 Per Emportar
🚚 Lliurament a Domicili
🍴 Menjar al Local

Opcions de Menjador

🍽️ Menjar al Local
🥡 Per Emportar
🚚 Lliurament a Domicili

Informació del Restaurant

Estat
Verificat pel propietari
🕐 Horario Hoy
11AM-10PM
Valoració
4.5/5
💬 Ressenyes
1,808
💰 Nivell de Preus
$$
⏱️ Visita típica
People typically spend 25 min to 1 hr here
📞 Telèfon
+1 785-587-0700
🌐 Lloc Web
www.ajsnypizza.com
📋 Menú
Veure Menú

Comoditats

📶 WiFi Gratuït
🅿️ Aparcament
🌿 Terrassa
Accessible amb Cadira de Rodes
🚻 Lavabo
💳 Targetes de Crèdit
📱 Pagaments Mòbils
🏘️

El Barri

Ubicació

301 Poyntz Ave, Manhattan, KS 66502

West Sand Lake, NY 66502

📍 Explorar el Barri

Weather
28°
Temps actualitzat cada hora · Feines i esdeveniments actualitzats diàriament
Community House Patrimoni

historic building in Manhattan, Kansas, United States

A 161m
Bethel A.M.E. Church Patrimoni

historic building in Manhattan, Kansas, United States

A 481m
iglesia de los Siete Dolores Patrimoni

church building in Kansas, United States of America

A 501m
Battery Park

park in Riley County, Kansas, United States of America

A 562m
First Congregational Church Patrimoni

church in Manhattan, Kansas

A 638m
Riverside Park

park in Riley County, Kansas, United States of America

A 787m
Second Baptist Church Patrimoni

historic building in Manhattan, Kansas, United States

A 938m
📰

What people say about A J's Pizzeria

🎮

Jocs

🎮 Guanya Punts Mentre Explores!

Juga a Find Me i canvia punts per descomptes a A J's Pizzeria i altres restaurants

🎮

Guanya Punts a A J's Pizzeria!

Juga a Find Me i canvia recompenses aquí

Guanya punts extra i canvia'ls per recompenses de A J's Pizzeria

🏆 Recompenses de A J's Pizzeria

💰

Descompte 10%

A A J's Pizzeria

1000 pts
Disponible
🍽️

Aperitiu Gratis

A la teva propera visita

2500 pts
Limitat
👑

Taula VIP

Experiència premium

5000 pts
Exclusiu

per canviar recompenses i guanyar punts

📋 Com funcionen les recompenses?

1

Juga a Find Me

Cada 100 punts de score = 1 punt de recompensa

2

Acumula Punts

Els workers obtenen 2x punts per partida

3

Canvia Recompenses

Descomptes, menjar gratis i experiències VIP

Trucar
Deixar ressenya a Google
👑

És teu? Reclama'l GRATIS!

Elimina anuncis i gestiona el menú

Inicia sessió i juga

Revisa el teu correu!

Sense contrasenya — t'enviem un enllaç per email

T'hem enviat un enllaç d'accés

Revisa la carpeta de spam si no el veus