Mary Caroll’s

Awesome service by Matt!!! Very attentive.

Matt and Nick took great care of me. I love a good dive bar and this is the best one you could find in Babylon!!

We hosted a birthday party in the back beach area and it was amazing! Great and personal service from Connor, Francis and Matt and Mary Carroll’s was extremely accommodating and helpful in planning our party to be exactly what we wanted! Everyone had a great time and the food and drinks were fantastic! Could not recommend them more to host any event

matt and josh are the best!! very friendly always and good vibes all around :)

Love this place. Food is great, drinks are great, service is the best and everyone is friendly and chill. Highly recommend for a night out

Norajean Felix

My favorite bar with my favorite bartenders <3

Chris Gabriel

Great atmosphere, awesome decor and live music vibe. It is a constant party.

Debra Domino

Was a quaint bar went with family the night of Babylon town Christmas outing was nice but not alot of vendors thats why we went to bar.

Nick B

Love this place. Food is great, drinks are great, service is the best and everyone is friendly and chill. Highly recommend for a night out

Mariel Hunerberg

Awesome place to have a beer on a sunny day in the backyard space. Kid friendly!

Kyle Abele

We hosted a birthday party in the back beach area and it was amazing! Great and personal service from Connor, Francis and Matt and Mary Carroll’s was extremely accommodating and helpful in planning our party to be exactly what we wanted! Everyone had a great time and the food and drinks were fantastic! Could not recommend them more to host any event

Clare

I love everything about this Irish pub. Most importantly though, it’s actually ran by an Irish person unlike another so called Irish pub in Babylon…but anyway! The food is so good, like it’s not shitty bar food. I order take out from them because I love their food so much. It’s the perfect spot for young people to have fun and hang out! It has a real Irish pub atmosphere. The back with the tables is fantastic and great for the night life. I always have a fantastic time and it’s a nice to support an Irish pub that is actually owned by an Irish person.

Carrie OFarrell

Great comfort food at very fair prices. Delivery was faster than expected on a Friday night - prime time. Homerun!

It was good, bartenders were great! Food was good, for bar food. The fish and chips were a little soggy on one side, and the guiness beef pot pie was slightly watery, but overall good. Drinks were solid.

After a long day of work, this is a great spot for friends to hang out, the drink selection is adequate, and the bartender is friendly.

gothic01

It was good, bartenders were great! Food was good, for bar food. The fish and chips were a little soggy on one side, and the guiness beef pot pie was slightly watery, but overall good. Drinks were solid.

Les Lane

After a long day of work, this is a great spot for friends to hang out, the drink selection is adequate, and the bartender is friendly.

elena rodriguez

Good food! Interesting concept you order at the bar and pick up at a window next to the fireplace. All 7 of us enjoyed the food. Traditional pub menu... burgers/philly cheese steaks/wings/ sliders & nachos!

A bar that looks as old, traditional and Irish as the name sounds. Great amount of space both indoors and out to hang around. Drinks and food are decent but nothing to write home to mom about. They've got a ton of TVs playing any and all sporting events in case you're looking to watch a game. Parking is only metered on the street right in front so I might recommend walking a bit. Overall, you can do better, but you can do a whole lot worse too.

The cheesecake that they charge 14 dollars for is not worth the price! You can get a better piece of cheesecake at any local diner for half the price! It’s not even a slice. It comes in a small round container. A good NY cheesecake from a diner is 100 times better! Other than that it’s a great atmosphere.

Joey

The cheesecake that they charge 14 dollars for is not worth the price! You can get a better piece of cheesecake at any local diner for half the price! It’s not even a slice. It comes in a small round container. A good NY cheesecake from a diner is 100 times better! Other than that it’s a great atmosphere.

Mathon van Eekhout

I order food from here fairly regularly. My last large order of chicken wings came to me burnt and hard as a rock. Whats up with that? Change my mind with my next order, and gain another star. You got the ball.

Tom Garcia

A bar that looks as old, traditional and Irish as the name sounds. Great amount of space both indoors and out to hang around. Drinks and food are decent but nothing to write home to mom about. They've got a ton of TVs playing any and all sporting events in case you're looking to watch a game. Parking is only metered on the street right in front so I might recommend walking a bit. Overall, you can do better, but you can do a whole lot worse too.

My wings are black. I didn’t even know it was possible to burn wings so bad. Completely inedible. You try and call to complain and then hangup the phone everytime.

Justin Knowles

Hi ! I was assaulted by the bouncers at Marry Carrols. Great bartenders, good atmosphere but it seems that the bouncers use excessive force and the place is corruptly interconnected within the First Prescient of the Suffolk Police Department. Unfortunately after being the victim of a crime where my Gold was stolen, I called the police department and they went off who was friends with who and not based on the truth. That night I was a victim of a crime and I was beaten savagely by the bouncers there. It’s a place where people relax and have a beer. I must have spent approximately 80K in this establishment since I started going in 2011. Unfortunately, my daughters chain is missing it’s from Ireland and I received it when my daughter was born in the United Kingdom in 2019. If any of the staff knows the whereabouts of my chain please call me. Thanks, Justin

Darren

My wings are black. I didn’t even know it was possible to burn wings so bad. Completely inedible. You try and call to complain and then hangup the phone everytime.

Food was delicious but took no kidding 45 minutes to come out. bartender was more interested in talking with his friends then serving us. We had a bunch of drinks and charged for every one no buybacks I said to him we got no buybacks he said we don’t do that here. Will never be back again and that’s a shame so much potential

Harry Walsh

Food was delicious but took no kidding 45 minutes to come out. bartender was more interested in talking with his friends then serving us. We had a bunch of drinks and charged for every one no buybacks I said to him we got no buybacks he said we don’t do that here. Will never be back again and that’s a shame so much potential

tatiana iacuboi

"We entered the place at about 5 pm when the place was moderately busy. It was the 25th anniversary so there was a celebration planned later in the evening. About an hour later, the waiter asked us to move out from the table to make space for the musicians performing that night. That seemed really rude and out of place as we had to hastily arrange for a different place. The staff also didn't have the courtesy to offer us another table as a backup and we had to find one by ourselves. On top of that, we were asked to move a second time to make even more space! That was a truly negative experience and out of place for the location. We had previously had a good experience with the service and were not expecting such an unprofessional attitude towards customers. I understand the requirement for setup but that doesn't mean interfering with the customers' privacy, and even so not caring about a backup plan. A better place would have facilitated the musicians prior to assigning or occupying tables. It was not impressive or acceptable on the part of people in charge of making these decisions. About the food, we had ordered barbq chicken wings which were very dry and not upto the mark or expectations. All in all, it was a really poor show by the event management and even so from the working staff at the time. I encourage them to be on point with the organization and upkeep of the place and take measures to improve customer satisfaction.

Ruth Brown

I was visiting here from DC. I accidentally spilled my first drink after immediately getting it and I asked the bartenders to replace it. One of them laughed at me and kept my card and made me pay for it. I then asked the other bartender if he would replace it and he immediately ignored me and didn’t give me anything else. They are rude. I was a bartender for 7 years. It was my first drink of the night. 14$ they charged me for nothing. I wouldn’t recommend. They treated me like dirt.