Caterina Pizza
Pizza · Brooklyn
Über Caterina Pizza
At Caterina Pizza in Brooklyn, we're proud to serve up a taste of comfort and community. Our warm and inviting atmosphere makes you feel right at home, whether you're meeting with friends or catching up with family. Our menu features a variety of delicious options, from classic pizza to healthier ch...
At Caterina Pizza in Brooklyn, we're proud to serve up a taste of comfort and community. Our warm and inviting atmosphere makes you feel right at home, whether you're meeting with friends or catching up with family. Our menu features a variety of delicious options, from classic pizza to healthier choices, all made with fresh ingredients and love. We're known for our signature pies, which are cooked to perfection in our brick oven, giving them that perfect balance of crunch and flavor. Our friendly staff is always happy to help you find the perfect slice or plate to suit your mood. Whether you're a local or just visiting, we can't wait to welcome you to Caterina Pizza and share some of our favorite Brooklyn traditions with you.
Was Kunden über Caterina Pizza sagen
Caterina Pizza is a neighborhood spot loved for its friendly service, especially from Vito, and its pizza. Many reviewers have been going for decades. Recent negative reviews mention inconsistent quality and delivery issues.
Beliebte Gerichte
Ideal für
Tip: Order online to avoid potential service issues. If dining in, be prepared for a small space.
Services
Sehenswürdigkeiten in der Nähe
Daten von Wikidata
Entdecken Sie die Umgebung von Caterina Pizza
Caterina Pizza befindet sich in Brooklyn, umgeben von kulturellen und historischen Sehenswürdigkeiten. Hier sind einige der bemerkenswertesten Orte in der Nähe.
Historisches Erbe
- Andrews United Methodist Church (A 691m) — church in Brooklyn, New York Lugar inscrito en el Registro Nacional de Lugares Históricos
- Empire State Dairy Company Buildings (A 694m) — landmarked dairy in Brooklyn, New York Monumentos Históricos de Nueva York
Religiöse Gebäude
- Blessed Sacrament Church (A 779m) — church in Cypress Hills, Brooklyn
Parks und Gärten
- Sperandeo Brothers Playground (A 398m) — park in the United States of America
- Sam Leggio Triangle (A 480m) — park in Kings County, New York, United States of America
- Highland Park, Brooklyn (A 562m) — public park in Brooklyn, New York
- City Line Park (A 594m) — park in the United States of America
- Public School 4 Paradise Garden (A 691m) — park in the United States of America
- Highland Park (A 929m) — park in Queens County, New York, United States of America
Daten von Wikidata
Häufig gestellte Fragen zu Caterina Pizza
Bewertungen von Caterina Pizza Brooklyn
So good and love their pasta
This is the pizzeria of my childhood. Vito is a gem and a legend! The best pizza ever and the owner Vito treats you like family.
Food is as Groovy as the Staff!!! First time in with my Sun and we ate our little Hearts out! Positive Energy, MAGICKAL staff, and great food? YES!!! Run, don’t walk to this Brooklyn Legacy! You’ll thank me later❤️🥹❤️Peace!
Best pizza hands down , cheese is perfect sauce is amazing and u get a big slice for a good price , this will b my new spot every time now 🙌🙌
I've tried many famous pizza spots around NYC, but none like this one. Best pizza in Brooklyn around East New York. 100% recommended!!! It's tasty, cheesy, and crispy. I always order from this place and get a large regular and reheat leftovers 😋 The space is small for a sit down and a little run down, but It's always clean. Must try!
I’ve been coming here since I was in P.S. 108 - almost 30 years ago now! Vito has been great. The new guys are great, although I feel some ingredients are different, I can’t complain. I don’t order anything out of the ordinary - plain slice, pepperoni slice, chicken slice, mozzarella sticks, beef patties with cheese, etc. and I’ve never had any issues. It tastes great to me ! I recently started ordering a Greek salad with grilled chicken and it comes with like a red wine vinaigrette and I’m OBSESSED. Highly recommend.
Been eating pizza here since I was in elementary school in 1995. Always hits the spot whenever I get a slice of a full pie. Definitely give them your support!
This place is so friendly and I love their food. Wait time is always reasonable and usually short but even if it’s not I enjoy sitting down at the table and waiting because the atmosphere is easygoing and comfortable. Their calzones are my absolute favorite but their pizza is also probably one of the best kinds of pizza I’ve had in Brooklyn. They also take cards which is a plus for me since I rarely carry cash. I would come here everyday if I could honestly, and 5 stars doesn’t seem to be enough stars.
The pizza is decent. I like it..
Update while I do think the pizza at this establishment is great. I ordered a buffalo chicken pizza special on New Year's eve and it was a disappointment. $28 for a large pizza pie that tasted disgusting 🤢 the cheese was hard, the buffalo sauce added to the disgusting taste of the pizza. The chicken is suppose to be crispy according to the description I got grilled chicken that tasted outdated. The pizza was inedible and disgusting 🤢
Pizza is decent but the service is shady. They say pickup is about 20mins but serval times they flaked on me bc they gave my pie away. Going to have to shop elsewhere for the disrespect! You feel me? Edit: order online now! No regrets.
Caterina isnt the same... Pizza ingredients don't taste good, nothing about the pizza is Italian. No ice for the beverages. I would not return anymore 😕
The reviews are misleading this taste like $1.00 slice. Not good at all. One man was very rude behind counter. $10 min on card this 2025 no one carries cash
I had the worst delivery experience . I had ordered 2 pies for delivery and it never arrived. The first red flag was the rude attitude. The second was i had to call back twice to make sure they had my card info correct. They were being dismissive and stated that if the card info was wrong I had to pay cash. Last i had called them many times within 2 hours of placing my order to get an update. They only gave me excuses about the driver and i never got a call back. I called a last time with it being an hour after the place closed only to find out the delivery driver went back to the pizzeria with our food. We were only left with dishonest excuses and empty stomachs. They were very unprofessional and rude. I wouldn’t recommend ordering from this pizzeria.
Sad to say but the service here was horrible, despite the multiple reviews that say otherwise. Ordered pizza with my husband and his friends for delivery and we never received our order. Waited 2 hours and called the restaurant several times to get a status update, only to be met by rudeness and attitude from the delivery driver, who made multiple excuses regarding why our order didn’t arrive and even when my husband offered solutions to resolve the matter, there was still no way for us to get our pizza. I think what’s worse than this is that I am currently 7 months pregnant and I did not get to fulfill my craving. There’s way too many places in Brooklyn that have better pizza and service than this place, and I highly recommend that Caterina hires a better delivery person that can take accountability for their actions and knows how to do their job.
Order pizza here with friends and had an absolute nightmare. We called a few times about the status of the pizza that we had been waiting for for 2 hours. They couldn't get anything correct, card number, address, and even where the driver was for an eta only to find out the driver was headed back. Not to mention the attitude they had when we were able to get them on the phone. Absolute worst experience I recommend no one order here
Ordered pizza early evening, called 6 times to try to get an update 2 hours after we ordered, just for them to let us know that the driver went back to the restaurant without having called us. It was the absolute worst experience ever and no one should ever order from this restaurant if they need something to eat.
Got a buffalo pizza delivered from here and i actually just had to throw out the whole pie it was that bad. Insane amount of oil and i couldnt even pick up a slice without everything sliding off. Sad, had to go buy something else. Ordered at 9pm 10/12 so whoever was making pizza that day clearly didnt give a shit
Anmelden, um eine Bewertung zu schreiben
AnmeldenWerbung entfernen und Menü verwalten
Entdecke deine Gegend
McDonald's
El Puerto Mexicano
Crown Fried Chicken
Bridge and Tunnel Brewery
Geordie's Joint
Wo Hop Kitchen
Kennedy Fried Chicken & Pizza
Salud bar & grill
Panda House
Little Caesars
14 Fotos
Entdecke Fotos von Caterina Pizza
Informationen über Caterina Pizza
Anfahrt
3035 Fulton St #1FL, Brooklyn, NY 11208
Highlights
Dienstleistungen
Speisemöglichkeiten
Restaurant-Infos
Ausstattung
Die Nachbarschaft
Standort
3035 Fulton St #1FL, Brooklyn, NY 11208
📍 Die Nachbarschaft erkunden
Kommende Veranstaltungen
The Kid LAROI - A Perfect World Tour
18 Mai 2026, 18:30
Brooklyn Paramount
Earth to Eve
18 Mai 2026, 19:00
Baby's All Right
James McCann
18 Mai 2026, 19:30
The Bell House
MUNA: Dancing On the Wall Album Release (16+ Event)
18 Mai 2026, 21:00
Music Hall of Williamsburg
park in the United States of America
park in Kings County, New York, United States of America
public park in Brooklyn, New York
park in the United States of America
church in Brooklyn, New York
park in the United States of America
landmarked dairy in Brooklyn, New York
church in Cypress Hills, Brooklyn
Spiele
🎮 Sammle Punkte beim Entdecken!
Spiele Find Me und löse Punkte gegen Rabatte bei Caterina Pizza und anderen Restaurants ein
Sammle Punkte bei Caterina Pizza!
Spiele Find Me und löse Belohnungen hier ein
Sammle Extrapunkte und löse sie gegen Belohnungen von Caterina Pizza ein
🏆 Belohnungen von Caterina Pizza
10% Rabatt
Bei Caterina Pizza
Gratis Vorspeise
Bei deinem nächsten Besuch
VIP-Tisch
Premium-Erlebnis
um Belohnungen einzulösen und Punkte zu sammeln
📋 Wie funktionieren die Belohnungen?
Spiele Find Me
Alle 100 Scorepunkte = 1 Belohnungspunkt
Sammle Punkte
Worker erhalten 2x Punkte pro Spiel
Löse Belohnungen ein
Rabatte, Gratis-Essen und VIP-Erlebnisse
Gehört es Ihnen? GRATIS beanspruchen!
Werbung entfernen und Menü verwalten