Confessions of a Food Freak

No frills just good pizza. A staple in bay ridge that’s been around since I was a child. Same place same pizza that is consistently good.

Colin Gordon

Best slices in Brooklyn! Perfect if you’re looking for no frills, quick stop, truly authentic New York pizza! Very reasonably priced too!

John Lambda

Old school pizzeria. The pizza was very good but just a bit salty. Parking in the area is tough.

+1

Zeke

Definitely not the best pizza in the area but if you need pizza to grab and go, then it’s worth visiting. Our pizza was actually made to order. As you can tell from the photo, the pepperoni and jalapeños could definitely use more cooking time. Not sure if they usually make pizza like this, or because they were busy so each pizza will come out the oven slightly early. Also expect the New York prices.

Adam S.

The regular slice was much thicker than I like. It was soft and had zero crisp. It needed more time in the oven.

Daniel Pino

Est. 1979 Layout/atmosphere *12 tables; one TV Food/drink *Sicilian slice - OK; liked the crust, didn’t like the cheese

Mr. Jack

WITH ALL THE RESPECT YOU CANT TOUCH DIRTY MONEY PEOPLE GIVE YOU AND COINS AND GIVE THEM CHANGE WITH NO GLOVES THEN GO TOUCH THE DOUGH AND TOPPINGS WITHOUT EVEN WASHING YOUR HANDS THIS A NEXT LEVEL I WONDER IF YOU EVEN WASH YOUR HANDS AFTER USING THE BATHROOM……..

Micki Magnowski

Ordered a pie delivered waiting for it came somewhat quickly, but the pizza was so salty. I threw it out and they were supposed to be highly rated. Never go there again.

Zulaikha Tariq

I rarely leave negative reviews, but I felt like this needed to be said. My mom and i ordered a pizza from this place last night, and it was honestly a big disappointment. The pizza arrived lukewarm, which wouldn’t have been a huge deal if it hadn’t also tasted old and burnt. The crust was dry and tough like it had been reheated, and the cheese had that rubbery texture that only happens when it’s been sitting out too long. There are too many good pizza spots around to spend money on something that tastes like leftovers from two days ago.

Shaye Nicole

This was the establishment’s response to my honest review! The one thing I hate the most, is when a place of business has no accountability. I appreciate the offer for “another slice”, but I’ll decline. The review was simply based off of the “QUALITY” of the slice of pizza I had. I did not say I “DROPPED” my slice. Please read your reviews thoroughly! The quality of the pizza SUCKED! Have baked, Thin, flimsy, no taste, cheap pepperoni, and THE SLICE BROKE WHEN I FOLDED IT! and I hate that! I do t understand, Maybe I should’ve said it like that the first time.

Kevin Forster

Pizza came exceptionally quick but that's the only positive. Ordered a large pepperoni pizza and when it came it looked likei was carried on its side. Everything was all pushed to one side of the box.