Jamie Rose Tripoli

Got a plain pie and an order of garlic knots. This was a great NY slice. The sauce was amazing and the amount of cheese was perfect. Also I should mention it was only $21 and came in less than 30 min (I live 7 min away)!!! Can’t wait to order again

Bee Ryan

Thank goodness for the people at Garlic! The staff was incredibly patient as our party took time to decided from the many deliciously presented pizza options. We settle on a few classic flavors. The crust was thin, the cheese and sauce were on fire, and the order was completed very fast! I highly recommend anyone, whether it be your are visiting or if you live here, to try Garlic! You won’t be disappointed!

Diana Nunes

I would like to start off by saying that their grandma eggplant pizza is amazing! We were so obsessed with it at work that we ordered it 3 nights in a row! The staff at Garlic is super friendly and always have a smile on their faces. The place is really clean and has a cool bar in the back. It also has outdoor seating in the back which is a nice outside escape from the city noise. They have a lot of varieties of pizza always fresh and ready to serve. Thank you Garlic for offering some of the best pizza I’ve ever had!

+2

Dianne Roque

I have to write this review while I am still here because this pizza was banging. NYC finest! Some really delicious options to pick from. We did 4 of the options available and shared and they were all devoured.. try out they cocktails to go, Mango and Sangria were tasty and alcohol heavy 😋 1st time here and I will definately make this my pizza stop when I am around and in the mood for some slices. If you are trying to make up your mind where to go, this is the place, thank me later.

+3

Gav Hitchenor

We ordered slices to go from this small walk in pizza shop. Service was speedy and at a great price. The classic cheese had huge slices and was very good. We ordered to go the next night and got classic cheese and buffalo chicken. Highly recommend the buffalo chicken - it was amazing!

Marc Tyndall

Garlic does two things really well. Firstly, they have great service. The staff are knowledgeable about their pizzas and their customer service meets every expectation you’ll have. The beer is good and the small bar in the back is quaint, but well stocked. Secondly, the pizza is fantastic! Seriously. Some of the slices may seem a little unique but the flavor is, like I said, fantastic!

james bond

Hands down the best pizza in NYC. This place is great! Heads up! Hidden menu item called the "V&E Special" . This bad boy is a double chicken parmigiana with fresh tomatoes and basil. If you come in and get a chicken parmigiana and feel like its amazing wait until you get the V&E special.

Terra Xen

True homage to some good old fashion New York Pizza My husband and I just came to NYU Hospital for a family member two days ago. We drove in from Virginia and was hungry after we had spent a couple of hours talking to the doctors and staff. One of the nurses recommended Garlic after I said I wanted a authentic Ne York slice. We walked to the place and from first impression on we knew we had made the right choice. The decor and vibe is very inviting and the pizza was so freaking good. Highly recommend🤓

+1

CW

Visited this spot based of a recommendation and I can be very skeptical when it comes to those, but this was one that I'm glad I acted on as it was simply worth the trip 🙌🏽 The pizza was amazing and quality ingredients definitely popped with every bite and taste. Can't even say anything bad as it was simply that good and worth this solid review. Great job Garlic 👌🏽

UGP

Great pizza place - everything sold by the slice was rectangular. I’ve only seen Sicilian pizza done like this until now. Anyway, we really enjoyed the crust - a little chewy, a little doughy, not heavy… just really good. They had a ton of choices! Will be back

Joe Yoo

not bad pizza, although i found the tomato sauce to be too sweet and not enough acid. dough is decent in flavor and texture.

Charisse

Was in the area briefly and wanted something to eat quickly. Pizza is good and the sauce was very flavorful. Pepperoni is real pepperoni and I have the artichoke Slice very good. Nice little friendly place for decent pizza and not expensive.

Ashley S

I had a distressing experience at Garlic Pizza due to the behavior of one of their employees. As I was walking my 16-year-old dog, who recently had spinal surgery and is slow-moving due to his age and condition, the employee was in the process of disposing of garbage into the basement. Instead of showing patience, he yelled at us for moving too slowly and threw a bag of garbage towards my dog, blaming us for the incident. I am currently pregnant and was unable to quickly move my dog out of the way. This behavior could have potentially harmed my dog. I've attached a photo to this review for reference. I hope Garlic Pizza management addresses this issue seriously. No one, especially those with disabilities or special needs, should be treated with such disrespect.