Sicily's Best Pizza

Super friendly people and really great pizza for a good price. I would recommend this place to anyone that lives in a dang 30 block radius. It's seriously the best.

Hello folks welcome all new people new eye balls and new beeeeeeeeeeeeeeez thanks for reading my post nice pizzeria smells good in here very clean fair prices depends on what you want soda are cool to get various selection of food items to choose from I recommend any here so if you are near here come on down grab a slice or the whole box a sandwich lets eat until the next time peace

we consistently order the grandma pie. the sauce is incredible. the crust is perfect. might be the best pizza I've ever had.

Exactly what you want from a NY pizza joint. Reliably tasty slices, good delivery service. Occasionally bummed they aren't open on Sundays, but oh well.

Hidden little secret, no line on a Saturday afternoon 12:30. Perfect slice of pepperoni, thin crispy crust, foldable with just a bit of grease drip..ahhhh

My son just moved back to the old neighborhood .We had the margarita pizza it was delicious

Great authentic NY pizza, very fair price and nice friendly service. I’d highly recommend this place!

If we could give more stars we would! What a great experience and the best authentic pizza! My family of 6 came in around 8p for some Brooklyn pizza last night and we found it! Food was hot and ready, he was able to make my gluten free pizza. We had no complaints from the kiddos which is rare thing. The owner was pleasant, funny, down to earth and just pretty awesome! We had great conversations and talked about places to go around. Thanks for great food and a great memory! Oh the cannolis were super yummy as well!!

Apparently I never had a REAL Sicilian square until I came here... I got a vodka Sicilian slice and it totally blew my mind. Other places serve thick, dry bread with some cheese on top and call it a sicilian slice. This place is the real deal, the inner crust structure melts in your mouth and I would recommend this place to anyone

Haven’t had original New York pizza in 4 years and when we ordered from here we weren’t disappointed. The pizza was delicious and very flavorful. The sauce was good and you could tell it was authentic and homemade. Delivery was fast and professional, would definitely order from here again

MY GO TO CHOICE FOR A SAFE AND DELICIOUS MEAL! It's day 16 of my wife and I being locked in and it was time to treat ourselves. I've had Sicily's Best a few times and loved it but of course I was nervous to get take out. It seems like Russian roulette out there with business that either take this health crisis seriously or don't. Well, this will be our go to treat now during these weird times. The door was propped open so I didn't need to touch it and the owner was making pies with a mask on his face and sanitizing his hands regularly. He offered me a squirt of sanitizer for myself and told me that he's overpaying for it, but he wants to keep his workers clean and healthy too. I watched as he pulled my pizza straight out of the oven and into a box with no other contact. The pie was as delicious as always. It was supposed to last until lunch the next day but it didn't make it past the night.

Best PIZZA in the world. The owner is super nice and cares about his customers They were getting ready to close and he offer us a table outside while they clean inside. The workers were the best and made sure we had everything to be comfortable outside. Again THANK YOU SO MUCH.

Bruschetta was AMAZING! The tomatoes and the balsamic vinegar combo was just perfect! The Pizza, and the rest of the food was really good too.

The food was fresh the people were polite place was clean and the prices were right

Super! Siciliani DOC a Brooklyn! I LOVE Sicily's Best.

Jessica Novotny

If we could give more stars we would! What a great experience and the best authentic pizza! My family of 6 came in around 8p for some Brooklyn pizza last night and we found it! Food was hot and ready, he was able to make my gluten free pizza. We had no complaints from the kiddos which is rare thing. The owner was pleasant, funny, down to earth and just pretty awesome! We had great conversations and talked about places to go around. Thanks for great food and a great memory! Oh the cannolis were super yummy as well!!

Charlie Tiberio

Apparently I never had a REAL Sicilian square until I came here... I got a vodka Sicilian slice and it totally blew my mind. Other places serve thick, dry bread with some cheese on top and call it a sicilian slice. This place is the real deal, the inner crust structure melts in your mouth and I would recommend this place to anyone

Nick G

Haven’t had original New York pizza in 4 years and when we ordered from here we weren’t disappointed. The pizza was delicious and very flavorful. The sauce was good and you could tell it was authentic and homemade. Delivery was fast and professional, would definitely order from here again

Tomasz Roszkowski

MY GO TO CHOICE FOR A SAFE AND DELICIOUS MEAL! It's day 16 of my wife and I being locked in and it was time to treat ourselves. I've had Sicily's Best a few times and loved it but of course I was nervous to get take out. It seems like Russian roulette out there with business that either take this health crisis seriously or don't. Well, this will be our go to treat now during these weird times. The door was propped open so I didn't need to touch it and the owner was making pies with a mask on his face and sanitizing his hands regularly. He offered me a squirt of sanitizer for myself and told me that he's overpaying for it, but he wants to keep his workers clean and healthy too. I watched as he pulled my pizza straight out of the oven and into a box with no other contact. The pie was as delicious as always. It was supposed to last until lunch the next day but it didn't make it past the night.

Kaitlyn

Best PIZZA in the world. The owner is super nice and cares about his customers They were getting ready to close and he offer us a table outside while they clean inside. The workers were the best and made sure we had everything to be comfortable outside. Again THANK YOU SO MUCH.

Hosh

Bruschetta was AMAZING! The tomatoes and the balsamic vinegar combo was just perfect! The Pizza, and the rest of the food was really good too.

Salvo D'Aguanno

The food was fresh the people were polite place was clean and the prices were right

Giovanna Leone

Super! Siciliani DOC a Brooklyn! I LOVE Sicily's Best.

Ordered delivery from this place on a whim and is hands down, the best pizzeria I've had in the Bushwick area. Everything they cook is great quality from the pizza and sandwiches to their pasta dishes. I ordered for my family and the pizza was excellent with a great cheese to sauce ratio and had tons of flavor, I give it a 8.9. Their pasta is delicious with perfect aldente, portions, and flavor. I've tried the fettuccine alfredo and lasagna with meatballs. Not to mention, they provided top notch customer service remembering every single detail of my large order, always clear with time, and fair prices.

Always attentive with Customers , pizza fresh I love there Pasta and white pizza .

Came here on a whim after a playgym with 3 hungry kids. Owner was very nice, pizza came out fast and delicious roughly 10 min. Owner was kind enough to add in zeppoles for the kids. Would recommend to come here again. Thank you

This place is a hidden gem. The service is excellent and the pizza is amazing! Reminds me of the pizza I grew up on in Brooklyn during the late 70's and 80's. Caspar is a cool guy and serves up some great tasting food. If you are in the neighborhood and want some really good Italian food check this place out.

Great underrated pizza. Crust isn't too thick or floury, and slightly crunchy yet soft inside (a lot of newer places burn the crust way too much for the aesthetic look). Tomato sauce slight sweet and not over seasoned. Cheese is flavorful and perfectly proportioned. One of the best slices you can get in the neighborhood; a quintessential classic slice (leagues above your 99¢ places, but not unnecessarily beautified like a lot newer, gentrified places would make).

Matty Tuzynski

Great underrated pizza. Crust isn't too thick or floury, and slightly crunchy yet soft inside (a lot of newer places burn the crust way too much for the aesthetic look). Tomato sauce slight sweet and not over seasoned. Cheese is flavorful and perfectly proportioned. One of the best slices you can get in the neighborhood; a quintessential classic slice (leagues above your 99¢ places, but not unnecessarily beautified like a lot newer, gentrified places would make).

Ica Gonzalez

Always attentive with Customers , pizza fresh I love there Pasta and white pizza .

Diana Malinsky

Came here on a whim after a playgym with 3 hungry kids. Owner was very nice, pizza came out fast and delicious roughly 10 min. Owner was kind enough to add in zeppoles for the kids. Would recommend to come here again. Thank you

Bruce Rodriguez

Ordered delivery from this place on a whim and is hands down, the best pizzeria I've had in the Bushwick area. Everything they cook is great quality from the pizza and sandwiches to their pasta dishes. I ordered for my family and the pizza was excellent with a great cheese to sauce ratio and had tons of flavor, I give it a 8.9. Their pasta is delicious with perfect aldente, portions, and flavor. I've tried the fettuccine alfredo and lasagna with meatballs. Not to mention, they provided top notch customer service remembering every single detail of my large order, always clear with time, and fair prices.

Manuel Vásquez

This place is a hidden gem. The service is excellent and the pizza is amazing! Reminds me of the pizza I grew up on in Brooklyn during the late 70's and 80's. Caspar is a cool guy and serves up some great tasting food. If you are in the neighborhood and want some really good Italian food check this place out.

Good Sicilian slice. The crust was a bit thick.

I sort of love this place. Compared to a lot of the other pizzeria's in the neighborhood Sicily's Best is pretty delicious. The pies are pretty great, the grandma pie is okay, nothing compares to Spumoni Garden's legendary grandma pie. If you have several mouths to feed check out the specials as they are pretty great deals. Service is always quick and pipping hot. No complaints here.

Local pizza with delivery! The whole fresh pies are excellent and the stuffed shells were particularly good as well. NYC pizza joint. Haven’t tried the Sicilian, so review based on slice, multi topping slice, chicken parm, pasta, service, delivery.

Pretty good standard NYC pizza. Thin crust with lots of toppings to choose from, all quality ingredients. The meat stromboli is delicious and filling! Clean, but small dining area. Staff. Very friendly.

Small place but nice selection and very good pizza for a local spot. Sat outside listened to Italian music and for a few minutes was taken away. Very pleasant and they have pinwheels, calzone, pastas,sandwiches and refrigerated drinks & more.

Kids gave the plain slice a big thumbs up. The chicken slice was great ... a meal. The pepperoni bites were perfectly done.

Regular pizza slice was decent. Street parking a nightmare. No delivery service.

The flavor was good but my chicken roll dough was raw and I specifically said well done.

Got takeout pizzas from here twice. The Buffalo chicken was solid. The Veggie pizza is made from soggy, probably canned veggies, has no flavor. Crust on the pizza is ok, but wasn’t too happy w my experience.

Love their pizza But their chicken cutlet parmesan is not cooled right it has a rubbery texture

got extremely bloated and have a upset stomach from eating here. got the deep dish margarita and 3 pepperoni bites.

Ordered delivery to try a new place in the neighborhood. Food came and the sauce immediately smelled spoiled. Ordered baked ziti and they gave me penne in marinara sauce and cheese.

Senochi Kang

Ordered delivery to try a new place in the neighborhood. Food came and the sauce immediately smelled spoiled. Ordered baked ziti and they gave me penne in marinara sauce and cheese.

Just ordered here for the first time. Very disappointed. Pizza was below average. Pizza was dry ( not enough sauce), and they are very cheap with the toppings. Ordered a veggie pie. It was basically peppers with very little of anything else. Ordered a Sicilian pie with extra cheese ,meatballs and mushrooms. Still not enough cheese, very little sauce, barely any mushrooms. Won't be coming back.

If I can say one thing this place was very underwhelming and disappointing. The white slice was more bread than cheese. It seems like they were saving money by making light slice. The worst part were the bland wonder bread like garlic knots.

I got a few slices here. The regular cheese slice is good but nothing special. I can’t say much good about their Sicilian slice though. Probably the worst Sicilian slice I’ve had. It literally just tasted like thick bread with sauce and cheese on it. Usually the combo of it together is more than the sum of its parts but not this time.

Alvaro Imbrett

If I can say one thing this place was very underwhelming and disappointing. The white slice was more bread than cheese. It seems like they were saving money by making light slice. The worst part were the bland wonder bread like garlic knots.

jia-lian Lin

I got a few slices here. The regular cheese slice is good but nothing special. I can’t say much good about their Sicilian slice though. Probably the worst Sicilian slice I’ve had. It literally just tasted like thick bread with sauce and cheese on it. Usually the combo of it together is more than the sum of its parts but not this time.

FrankieDoodles01

Just ordered here for the first time. Very disappointed. Pizza was below average. Pizza was dry ( not enough sauce), and they are very cheap with the toppings. Ordered a veggie pie. It was basically peppers with very little of anything else. Ordered a Sicilian pie with extra cheese ,meatballs and mushrooms. Still not enough cheese, very little sauce, barely any mushrooms. Won't be coming back.

Ordered two slices. Dude wasn’t very friendly but I ignored it. He said “cash only” even though the last guy had a grub hub pickup. I asked about cards and he said it was “broken”. I walked out of there without food, right past the picture that showed they took Amex, Mastercard, and Visa. Thanks.

They drop your food and still give it to you after. Trash

The worst fettuccine alfredo I've ever eaten in my life. Look at that, it looks like it's all butter. , nastyy

I don't know how this place has good ratings. Just ordered a bunch of food and it was all horrible. I ordered a combo that came with a meatball sub, large cheese pie, ziti, and garlic knots. They didn't even give us the garlic knots. The sub was burned to a point where you couldn't even eat it. The ziti was almost like a soup because it was also left in the oven for to long. The pie was the only decent thing. Will never order from here again.

fernando ortiz

The worst fettuccine alfredo I've ever eaten in my life. Look at that, it looks like it's all butter. , nastyy

Michael Anthony

I don't know how this place has good ratings. Just ordered a bunch of food and it was all horrible. I ordered a combo that came with a meatball sub, large cheese pie, ziti, and garlic knots. They didn't even give us the garlic knots. The sub was burned to a point where you couldn't even eat it. The ziti was almost like a soup because it was also left in the oven for to long. The pie was the only decent thing. Will never order from here again.

Not a professional place at all, in terms of counter service. My family often orders here a lot and I'm not talking a small order but $80 to $100 in food, from pizza to pasta plates. The issue occured when I sent in my wife In person for the first time to order us specialty slices. My wife ordered 1 margarita slice, 1 plain slice, 1 ceasar chicken slice & 1 buffalo chicken slice. The issue was the slices were so small to be labeled a specialty slice and it wasn't fresh at all, I can understand if I came during closing but it was early noon. Now the main issue is generally when I order a buffalo slice they usually give me a drizzle of ranch right on top. This guy had the audacity to charge my wife a $1.50 for a side of ranch. Why would I need 6 ounces of ranch for one buffalo slice ? Not only that my wife stated the guy had a bad attitude And I'm going to make a big assumption that this guy is hindering your business regarding food quality and customer service because the food quality hasn't been up to par from when we first ordered and now it cost you. Oh and btw yes I'm 270.

Mustache

Not a professional place at all, in terms of counter service. My family often orders here a lot and I'm not talking a small order but $80 to $100 in food, from pizza to pasta plates. The issue occured when I sent in my wife In person for the first time to order us specialty slices. My wife ordered 1 margarita slice, 1 plain slice, 1 ceasar chicken slice & 1 buffalo chicken slice. The issue was the slices were so small to be labeled a specialty slice and it wasn't fresh at all, I can understand if I came during closing but it was early noon. Now the main issue is generally when I order a buffalo slice they usually give me a drizzle of ranch right on top. This guy had the audacity to charge my wife a $1.50 for a side of ranch. Why would I need 6 ounces of ranch for one buffalo slice ? Not only that my wife stated the guy had a bad attitude And I'm going to make a big assumption that this guy is hindering your business regarding food quality and customer service because the food quality hasn't been up to par from when we first ordered and now it cost you. Oh and btw yes I'm 270.