212 New York Pizza

Belkyn Rojas

Family owned businesses, very kind and polite people,excellent service amazing food, pizza was on point, hot out of the oven, garlic knots were delicious nothing I’ve ever tasted before. Would highly recommend this place, we will definitely be coming back.This place is really good. Our family loved it.

Amita Sachdeva

I stumbled upon this place by chance today while walking to the Oakmont Market, and I’m so glad I did. As soon as I stepped inside, I was greeted by the owner with such warmth that it felt like reconnecting with an old friend. We chatted, shared stories, and talked about how important community and family are. These days, it’s rare to walk into a restaurant and instantly feel at home, but that’s exactly what it felt like here. This is a true family-owned business (also a rarity in the bay area), and you can tell immediately how much pride they take in both their food and their service. The owner personally helped me choose a few items, prepared everything fresh on the spot, and sent me off with not just delicious food but also the kind of welcoming feeling you carry with you the rest of the day. If you’re in the area, do yourself a favor and stop by. Places like this deserve our support and we should help them thrive!

Alan King

We ordered takeaway and very impressive. We opted for the thin crust option, which was perfect. We modified the order on the website and all was correct, then delivered to us in around 30 minutes. The pizza was really well presented and packaged. The knots we ordered also were delicious. We ordered the medium for 2 and the knots, which was plenty. The paneer pizza is the way to go! Looking forward to ordering again! 🍕

Nuna

Genuinely the best place I have accidentally stopped at. The pizza was so delicious and taste so fresh and homemade. The girls in the front are so friendly and I believe it’s a family business and very clean to sit and eat my lunch will be coming back here! Got garlic knots and a mini 212combo highly recommend

Brittany

thank you tiktok for introducing me to this pizza shop! service was fast and warm and the pizza I ordered was fresh, delicious, and didn’t upset my stomach like some places do sometimes. this was the tuscana pizza, so so good I will definitely come back here again when im in the area! they have a great menu with lots of variety

Nupoor Kulkarni

Such good pizza, I will be coming back! And the hot sauce and garlic dipping sauce are a huge plus. I love supporting our local businesses!

Bad (Sean)

good pizza at a fair price, the super friendly service and fast speed makes this place a 5/5 but for the food itself and the price its a 4/5. The normal crust is quite thick already so be careful when going for extra thick. Sauce is very good here as well.

Anshwar Syed

I personally say this place in Bay Area has a mouth watering pizza v delicious n fresh . I know about this place since my college days wen there pizza store was by the name VIA MIA @some other location ,me n my frnds always been huge fan of there Chicken Milano pizza. Wen I was away fromCA for years I always thought of their pizza n wished to eat whenever I gt bak to CA . N wen m bak here I always go n suggest anyone who like pizza , wings , cheese Garlic bread n many more options to eat. . This is how their chicken Milano pizza( I think now if goes by new name as Chipotle ). They give u good portion of chicken ,cheeze and veggies in it .

Ahmad Sameem Shamal

Serving us really delicious pizza , Try Garlic Etaliana yummy .

Harleigh Tillman

In town for the weekend and picked this place because of its proximity to where I'm staying, and I absolutely lucked out. Food and service were incredible, only thing I 'disliked' about the place is that I don't have one near me.

Got a chicken calzone delivered to my house with subs garlic knots, everything was delicious, calzone was filled well and tasted amazing and the knots were very soft and flavorful! 10/10 will order again

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ I had an excellent experience at this pizza place! The pizza was incredibly tasty, with fresh ingredients that made every bite delightful. I especially appreciated that all the meats were halal, making it a great choice for those seeking such options. Highly recommend to anyone looking for delicious and accommodating dining!

Came from Dallas TX and stopped at 212 New York Pizza for dinner. The pizza was made fresh and it was so good and delicious. Service was amazing and cashier was so welcoming. We ordered Veggie, chicken pesto and zaatar and all were flawless and so yummy. Will definitely come again. Thank you!

212 New York Pizza has become my go-to pizza place. Not only is the pizza delicious, but there are some different flavor combinations that are really great. Finally, the friendliness and welcome is really outstanding. If you in the mood for pizza, 212 New York would be a great place to try!

Excellent from start to finish. One of the best customer experiences I’ve had.

Joel Zamora

Got a chicken calzone delivered to my house with subs garlic knots, everything was delicious, calzone was filled well and tasted amazing and the knots were very soft and flavorful! 10/10 will order again

Tareef Rahman Khan

Pizza is fresh and tasty with lots of cheese and toppings provided. The staff working here are all friendly including the owner. Sitting area is neat and clean. The food is halal as too which is a bonus for people looking for such options.

Saeed Izadi

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ I had an excellent experience at this pizza place! The pizza was incredibly tasty, with fresh ingredients that made every bite delightful. I especially appreciated that all the meats were halal, making it a great choice for those seeking such options. Highly recommend to anyone looking for delicious and accommodating dining!

Alice Baum

212 New York Pizza has become my go-to pizza place. Not only is the pizza delicious, but there are some different flavor combinations that are really great. Finally, the friendliness and welcome is really outstanding. If you in the mood for pizza, 212 New York would be a great place to try!

Maysaa Enaya

Came from Dallas TX and stopped at 212 New York Pizza for dinner. The pizza was made fresh and it was so good and delicious. Service was amazing and cashier was so welcoming. We ordered Veggie, chicken pesto and zaatar and all were flawless and so yummy. Will definitely come again. Thank you!

First time coming to this location since the original owners sold. The originals were very much so New York style pizza and the old owner was incredibly nice so I love going here years and years ago. I gave the new look a try and while I would not describe this as New York style pizza, it is still very solid in its own right. The young man working the counter was polite and helpful, the prices were okay in the menu options were rather robust. Settled on a pepperoni pizza and was pleasantly surprised by how well they did the portions. Great amount of cheese, pepperoni, and the crust was tasty. Worth checking out if you want a no frills pizza.

My friend Judge and I had a very good pizza here today. They had a really good vegetarian pizza. Bathroom was in the back but it was clean. I took a pic of the pizza cook when I walked by. Very nice guy, good price. The kitchen was a little cluttered but it was clean. I watched them make the pizza and they took good care to keep it banmerry from the meat. Please hit the like if you enjoyed the photos and review.

yafy fyfyf

First time coming to this location since the original owners sold. The originals were very much so New York style pizza and the old owner was incredibly nice so I love going here years and years ago. I gave the new look a try and while I would not describe this as New York style pizza, it is still very solid in its own right. The young man working the counter was polite and helpful, the prices were okay in the menu options were rather robust. Settled on a pepperoni pizza and was pleasantly surprised by how well they did the portions. Great amount of cheese, pepperoni, and the crust was tasty. Worth checking out if you want a no frills pizza.

Tamo

My friend Judge and I had a very good pizza here today. They had a really good vegetarian pizza. Bathroom was in the back but it was clean. I took a pic of the pizza cook when I walked by. Very nice guy, good price. The kitchen was a little cluttered but it was clean. I watched them make the pizza and they took good care to keep it banmerry from the meat. Please hit the like if you enjoyed the photos and review.

Good pizza, reasonable price,nand the people working there are super friendly. Only disappointment was the "extra thick" crust. It just wasn't that thick to me. Seemed like normal pizza thickness. But overall I was satisfied though.

Pickles McGee

Good pizza, reasonable price,nand the people working there are super friendly. Only disappointment was the "extra thick" crust. It just wasn't that thick to me. Seemed like normal pizza thickness. But overall I was satisfied though.

Kids like their cheese pizza. They said it's better than Costco. Came here to pick up a pre-ordered pizza for a potluck around 11:30 am on a Sunday while family waited in the car. The cashier was on the phone speaking softly which didn't sound like he was taking an order. After a while a girl sitting at the table doing her makeup finally ask if I was picking up an order and got up to give it to me. It's really "home style" here. 😂 I was the only one in line. Service was awful and seem unsanitary.

Debbie Sikic

Kids like their cheese pizza. They said it's better than Costco. Came here to pick up a pre-ordered pizza for a potluck around 11:30 am on a Sunday while family waited in the car. The cashier was on the phone speaking softly which didn't sound like he was taking an order. After a while a girl sitting at the table doing her makeup finally ask if I was picking up an order and got up to give it to me. It's really "home style" here. 😂 I was the only one in line. Service was awful and seem unsanitary.

Ordered a large combination Pizza with Jalapenos peppers. And when I opened it there was no freaking peppers on it. The hot wings for 6.99 was so small you needed a microscope to see them. I did not like it at all. The crust was gummy and they were tight with the toppings. What a trip. Never no more. I will order from fast Pizza who give you what you ordered and way more toppings. A man name Mohammed took my order and I confirmed jalenpeno peppers more than 3 times on the order. And he still didn't have none on there. But best believe they charged my card for them. What a joke, BEWARE!!!! They got jokes for you.

Jacqueline Writt

Ordered a large combination Pizza with Jalapenos peppers. And when I opened it there was no freaking peppers on it. The hot wings for 6.99 was so small you needed a microscope to see them. I did not like it at all. The crust was gummy and they were tight with the toppings. What a trip. Never no more. I will order from fast Pizza who give you what you ordered and way more toppings. A man name Mohammed took my order and I confirmed jalenpeno peppers more than 3 times on the order. And he still didn't have none on there. But best believe they charged my card for them. What a joke, BEWARE!!!! They got jokes for you.