New York Pizza Express

austin

$20 flat for a large pizza, I don't know what the reviews are talking about but in terms of flavor this is probably the best pizza I've had since real New York pizza. For sure the best I've had in Florida, maybe the bad reviews are only written when delivered, but I picked it up and had an amazing first bite... and then amazing rest of my bites LOL. Definitely a hidden gem holyyyy! AND THE MOST AFFORDABLE NY PIZZA EVER

Sara Miller

So I'm very confused at all of the negative reviews because the pizza I got delivered was just fine. Pics included. Nice thin crust. Very tasty. It's very good. Delivery driver was very nice too. I'm thinking someone got p*sed off and got people to write fake reviews on Google? Because they have a 4.9 on the slice app. Hmmmm. All in all very good pizza. Would order again!

Ordered pizza for delivery - half pepp, half spinach/tomato/garlic. It was delicious, the sauce and the cheese had so much flavor. Even the crust was super tasty by itself. We were in a hotel after a concert and ordered at 11pm. I am sure they were busy, but it arrived when they said it would. Delivery person was very courteous. Will definitely order again when in the area

Born and raised here in Tampa but this my very first time ordering from here and on my soul I don’t know why the reviews are bad ..I just ordered on uber eats and felt I needed to come on here and leave them a good review because our pizza was so good ! I couldn’t even take no pictures because it was gone in a blink of an eye and to top it all off It’s a really good deal for the price as well! So to each is on but me and my babies enjoyed it definitely will order again!

Valencia Anderson

Born and raised here in Tampa but this my very first time ordering from here and on my soul I don’t know why the reviews are bad ..I just ordered on uber eats and felt I needed to come on here and leave them a good review because our pizza was so good ! I couldn’t even take no pictures because it was gone in a blink of an eye and to top it all off It’s a really good deal for the price as well! So to each is on but me and my babies enjoyed it definitely will order again!

mary dixon

Ordered pizza for delivery - half pepp, half spinach/tomato/garlic. It was delicious, the sauce and the cheese had so much flavor. Even the crust was super tasty by itself. We were in a hotel after a concert and ordered at 11pm. I am sure they were busy, but it arrived when they said it would. Delivery person was very courteous. Will definitely order again when in the area

We stayed a a local hotel to catch a cruise and had got the infamous menu under our door. So here we are again and decided to order from them. I had their spaghetti dinner and my wife had the eggplant parm, both came with a salad and garlic knots. Everything came hot and in the time they said it would. They also included plates and utensils. The portions were good size, we could have shared one dinner. The sauce was very good, the meatballs were small but there were plenty and the eggplant parm was not like the average dinner. Usually the eggplant is covered with melted mozzarella but this was just breaded eggplant that was crispy and had good flavor. The knots were made from pizza dough and pretty standard. The salad was the same, pretty standard. Overall the food was good hot and the delivery was excellent. Lots of times they forget plates and utensils. We definitely would order again!

We were staying at La Quinta for the night before heading out tomorrow. We ordered from this spot, and they told us an hour and a half or less of a wait. We said fine, as long as the food gets here hot. It didn't arrive until an hour and 45 minutes later. The food was warm, and the fries were nasty. My wife's sub was mediocre and the meat in her Philly cheese steak was minimal. We weren't impressed. I won't lie, my sub was decent, which is why we're giving them a two stars. They can do a lot better and improve with what they say and keep their word. God we should have read these reviews before we ordered because everything that was said is so true lesson learned and they are still promoting at this hotel

DraMatik Gonzalez

We were staying at La Quinta for the night before heading out tomorrow. We ordered from this spot, and they told us an hour and a half or less of a wait. We said fine, as long as the food gets here hot. It didn't arrive until an hour and 45 minutes later. The food was warm, and the fries were nasty. My wife's sub was mediocre and the meat in her Philly cheese steak was minimal. We weren't impressed. I won't lie, my sub was decent, which is why we're giving them a two stars. They can do a lot better and improve with what they say and keep their word. God we should have read these reviews before we ordered because everything that was said is so true lesson learned and they are still promoting at this hotel

the food is ok, was a bit disappointed and should’ve listened to the other reviews. seems like all they do is sprinkle parmesan on their wings and garlic knots and call them “garlic parm”. it wasn’t terrible, but for the price i would expect more.

I saw the menu inside my hotel room. I called at 5:06pm on a Thursday evening, I placed my order and the guy on the phone said it would be an hour. I said okay. Took my address, asked for my room number, but did not take any payment over the phone. Happy about this- but it took an hour and a half, I even called and the guy said the driver was on his way. I ordered Garlic Knots, and the raviolis and it came with a side salad. Eh, pasta was decent but garlic knots were not even knots. Just big pieces of dough with Parmesan & butter melted together. And there a total of 8, but should have gotten only 6. Some didn’t even have any seasoning on them, a waste. The side salad was eh too, the tomatoes weren’t exactly tasty. I paid $21.50 and gave a $7.00 tip. Who ever packed it, put the smaller container of the pasta on the bottom, so the lid was coming off. Probably won’t be going back- one and done.

Kate Scott

I saw the menu inside my hotel room. I called at 5:06pm on a Thursday evening, I placed my order and the guy on the phone said it would be an hour. I said okay. Took my address, asked for my room number, but did not take any payment over the phone. Happy about this- but it took an hour and a half, I even called and the guy said the driver was on his way. I ordered Garlic Knots, and the raviolis and it came with a side salad. Eh, pasta was decent but garlic knots were not even knots. Just big pieces of dough with Parmesan & butter melted together. And there a total of 8, but should have gotten only 6. Some didn’t even have any seasoning on them, a waste. The side salad was eh too, the tomatoes weren’t exactly tasty. I paid $21.50 and gave a $7.00 tip. Who ever packed it, put the smaller container of the pasta on the bottom, so the lid was coming off. Probably won’t be going back- one and done.

After reading the reviews I will not purchase any pizza from this place. I have lived in North Tampa for 8 years now and I never even think of this place when I want pizza. I'm staying in a hotel and see the menu and was intrigued but after checking reviews and seeing the owner would rather respond to argue with customers calling them fake, I choose to save myself the disappointment. Race track has way better pizza for half the price! Maybe instead of arguing and making excuses you guys should increase your effort to improve unless you just don't care to but until then I will not spend money here.

Jeremy “Futureflow” Davis

After reading the reviews I will not purchase any pizza from this place. I have lived in North Tampa for 8 years now and I never even think of this place when I want pizza. I'm staying in a hotel and see the menu and was intrigued but after checking reviews and seeing the owner would rather respond to argue with customers calling them fake, I choose to save myself the disappointment. Race track has way better pizza for half the price! Maybe instead of arguing and making excuses you guys should increase your effort to improve unless you just don't care to but until then I will not spend money here.

Just ordered quick delivery awful taste and pizza was not cooked. Called and was insulted by the staff. Grand baby and daughter went without dinner they insisted there wasn’t anything wrong and did not reimburse me and left me talking on the line. No response no responsibility or apology no customer service= no dinner tonight. Awful experience!

Ordered, Cuban Sub, Garden Salad and a tiramisu. Got a cold turkey with a tiny amount of lettuce and a little mayo a garden salad with a tiny cup of VERY unflavorful Italian dressing and a frozen block of a cake, which took about a half hour to thaw out and did not even resemble the actual desert in looks and for sure in taste.

If I could give zero stars I would the pizza was absolutely disgusting! It looked like they sat it in water before putting in the box. Box was dry pizza was soaked & it wasn’t grease! Entire order was not edible after calling and speaking with the Manager I was told they make homemade food and his cook said the food was cooked perfect! CRAZY!!! Never again! Refused to refund order! Do not eat here!

Ordered breadsticks with my 2 medium pizzas and the breadsticks left me speechless…. And not in a good way. Called them to see if there was anything they can do to fix it and was told, “thats just how they come”…. Pizza tasted like trash and breadsticks were even worse. Company shouldn’t even be able to call themselves “New York style pizza” what a joke

So I spent 26.52 on this food.. I ordered Penne Vodka, Garlic Bread, a salad and cheesecake.. Everything was horrible.. The pasta taste like tomato sauce and water.. The GARLIC BREAD was regular BREAD not a hint of GARLIC and the cheesecake was frozen solid.. What I should of did was just throw my money in the trash. Please don't waste your money..

This place is terrible DO NOT ORDER FROM HERE!! I watched them shove menus under all the doors on my floor then threw the rest in the stairwells at hotel. If you find a menu under your door during your hotel stay THROW IT IN THE TRASH, That's what you will have to do with the food you get hours after you order it anyways, throw it in the trash. TIP- DO NOT ORDER FROM MENUS SHOVED UNDER YOUR ROOM DOOR talk to the front desk that's where you will get the best recommendations.

Beware we ordered food and we’re quoted an hour which we thought was insane, but just called and they actually held our order so they could deliver other orders in the area, now it will be an hour and a half. We would have said no thanks! Finally got our food, no napkins, no silverware, no sour cream for potato skins, which were disgusting. Tasted like they were bad and undercooked. Grey in color🤮 Wings had rubbery skin except for the ones we requested baked, those must have been fresh. Pizza was good but a huge waste of $57!! I wish I had read the reviews first. Lesson learned!

Terrible service. I ordered a Calzone and they did not put the cheese. When I called to ask why, the owner would not even speak on the phone, he made the part time helper reply. His response was "we were out of cheese, so we just sent you the food without cheese". What? No cheese at a pizza place? What kind of pizza place makes Calzone with no cheese? They ruined my dinner and I worked all day and expected a simple meal. The calzone only had three ingredients, Ham, Dough, and cheese. The owner sounded very rude over the phone. Do not order from this place they will cook awful and take your money. The ham was also uncooked and in large chunks with fat and gross. The worst pizza place I have ever wasted my money from in Tampa. I travel up often and I will never use this place and I will tell everyone to never eat there.

First of all, it took two hours for Pizza to get to us. And it was ice cold. I called the manager to complain and the delivery driver took the pizza and touched it with his hand and said it’s piping hot. I’m definitely not eating it now. We gave the pizza and wings back to the driver. We also ordered all flats for our wings, and they were definitely not. Mostly drums. The delivery driver was rude and the manager of this place had no idea how to deal with it. Would not recommend this at all!! No wonder why it’s a 2.5/5. Stay away!!

It took 1.5 hours to deliver the food. We ordered chicken tenders and a Chicken burger. The tenders looked like they were half eaten and the chicken burger was a bun with two tenders. Ridiculous and disgusting. Please look at the photos.

We are staying at a hotel and thought the menu was for a pizza joint nearby or on the hotel's property. It's only after placing an order and going to pick up that it was observed that the restaurant was 19 minutes drive away. We called, and a delivery option for $5 was offered. It took over an hour in addition to the 30-minute original wait time to get the food. The receipt was for $50 in total....$10 more than the food price. Then I made the error to add 'nice' tip. What a rip-off! The food was awful!

Ordered through Uber and a baseball sized portion of the pizza was missing. It was just bare crust. It’s like they put the ingredients on and then wiped it away or something. Didn’t bother to fix it. It got done cooking, they put it in the box, and sent it off. No one saw that and tried to fix it???

Don’t order or go here they are filthy scammers that give the wrong order on purpose and don’t give reimbursements I ordered a two topping pizza and received a cold one topping pizza, and I also ordered chicken wings which then they gave me chicken nuggets with garlic?! And to top that off the delivery man lied about giving a refund.

I really wanted to give y’all a chance because it looked like you’ve been trying to do better but it seems this places problems run deep. it’s poor business, poor delivery and bad advertising. This was supposed to be a “Giant” 16” pizza. That is supposed to at least feed 3-4 people. What we received was a bland flavorless medium sized pizza. You can order a better medium pizza at dominoes for $6.99. I mean really. At the very least advertise your food properly so we could have ordered an extra pizza. It barely fed 2 people. I even tried to call and he told me check the box. Well if it’s a 16” box the 16” pizza should be to the edge. Look at the small pizza in this big ahh box. You might be use to scamming people but you can’t scam somebody in the same industry as you. Do better.

Ordered food at 5:43pm I ordered pepperoni pizza, bbq wings, buffalo wings, and a Pepsi. When I called I was told $40, after almost an hour I called at 6:33pm they said the order was on the way. The driver didn’t arrive until 7:04pm. When the driver came the order came to $46. Which made no sense since I was told it was $40 on the phone when I called they try to make the price come up to $46 when the app and online says dif prices that come up to $36/37 not no $46. DO NOT ORDER FROM THESE PEOPLE THEY CHANGE THE PRICE. WHEN I ASKED THEM FOR A DISCOUNT SINCE IT TOOK SO LONG THEY ASKED ME TO ASK THE DRIVER!! FOR A DISCOUNT.

I ordered a small pizza, French fries, mozzarella sticks, and a 2 liter of soda. The food took approximately 2 hours to arrive. Once it did the fries were extremely soggy, mozzarella sticks were burnt, and pizza was barely warm. Honestly, this was the first and last time I will ever order from here.

Me and my dad used to get pizza from here all the time. Safe to say we enjoyed the food, so what a surprise it was to me when I found a long piece of hair in my food. Y’all don’t got hairnets? Hey Ty e owner saying it’s a fake review I got receipts of me coming here all the time and from the one that night in which I had hair in my pizza. Y’all want me to add those photos too? What’s y’all number let’s talk

Took 1 hr and 40 minutes to be delivered. Deals don't say boneless wings, and when I see wings I assume it's wings not chicken nugget pieces. Pizza was more then cold it tasted 2 days old and extremely dry, not enough sauce not enough cheese. Chicken nuggets I got where dry and gross. I feel like driving back up there a demanding a refund how can your charge so much for something so nasty and be proud of what you are making. I wasted 50$ never will go back in my life grossest thing I ever tasted worst then pizza hut, dominos and all the cheap pizza places. They need to edit there pricing.

I have been in a hotel for a week and have had their flyer slid under my door 3 times! I am sure anyone who does this practice doesn't have good food.

They’ve fallen off :( used to be good cheese pizza was chewy as hell couldnt even finish. Ordered for takeout mind you so thats as fresh as it gets lol

Our food came with fermented marinara sauce. The sauce was so fermented that the lids on the cups had expanded to the point of busting open. One of the people in our group didn’t realize it was bad and now he’s been attached to our hotel toilet all night and this morning. The garlic knots weren’t knots they were dough triangles with a dusting of Parmesan and a drop of butter. They were so hard I could use them bust the window out of my car. The pizza had almost no sauce and three pieces of pineapple. The Stromboli was gigantic but had little man energy, garbage. Don’t order from here if you want good food, if you don’t care about sitting on the toilet all day, this is your place. This guy is padding his reviews, so any five stars you see it’s the owner😂

09/25 I order lasagna, chicken gyro w/ fries and Greek salad and wings for my family they took over a hour to deliver the fries were cold and hard couldn’t even eat them , the lasagna was a very small portion the salad was plain and the wings were not fully seasoned I will never order from here again paid 60 bucks and my family couldn’t even eat it because it was horrible

Yet another flyer placed under a hotel door. Ordered a pizza, garlic knots, and a calzone. Garlic knots were little flavorless bricks, no sauce on the pizza, and the marinara sauce was fermented. Our group is taking turns with the diarrhea 12 hours later. For all that is holy, don’t eat here. Congratulations Mr owner man, you made me write my first review in 10 years.

I usually always look up ratings and reviews before ordering from anywhere, but we were hungry and this just happened to be slipped under our hotel door. We ordered the chicken caesar salad, spaghetti and meatballs, and a slice of New York cheesecake. It took almost 2 hours for delivery and when it arrived I immediately regretted it. The salad smelled horrible as soon as I opened the lid. The lettuce was wilted and brown and the amount given was laughable. I should asked them to hold the e. Coli. My son enjoyed the spaghetti but you could tell it wasn’t homemade. The cheesecake was a joke. It was warm and broken in half and the top layer was super waxy to the point we had to remove it to see a normal consistency. This was a reminder to myself to ALWAYS check ratings and reviews!

Smh. The hotel staff said they’ve already notified the owners to STOP putting their menu under the hotel doors and they don’t promote this pizza place due to the amount of complaints they receive from hotel customers. They were about 45 minutes late; and I had call them, they “forgot” to call me. Realized reviews say they’re chronically late. I flew in. I was hungry. I placed an order for a double pepperoni pizza. The pizza wasn’t cut all the way, in the middle of the pizza the dough must have ripped because it was just sauce and toppings in the middle, and the amount of garlic used could have killed an entire colony of vampires. The owners need to really investigate their management and how they operate. There are too many negative reviews stating the same problems. Or the owners are managing and need to evaluate their ability to own a pizza shop..because this isn’t it. The business stays in business by being shady and relying on unaware tourists.

I should’ve read the reviews online first. They slipped there flyer a few nights in a row so I decided to order. An hour and a half later for a pizza so greasy that the bottom of the pizza was literally soggy from grease. TRASH! Save yourself the disappointment and do not order from here

We order one of their specialty pizzas. They give us a burned old cold pepperoni pizza with frozen ingredients on top. Believe me when I say vegetables were non cooked. I don't like to waste food but it was totally inedible. It's a shame because we order three times before and it was ok. Never again.

Staying at the hotel and ordered chicken Alfredo and a steak gyro. The man who answered the phone said 1hour and I waited a little under 2 hours. The food was cold and horrible. NEVER ORDER FROM HERE! THIS PLACE SHOULD BE CLOSED FOR SERVING THIS HORRIBLE FOOD TO PEOPLE.

Took about 1.20 hours to deliver. Ordered eggplant parmesan which looked not appetizing, it smelled burned and when I opened it it was indeed burned. It was close to cold, the garlic knots are extremely big and didn't taste good. Eggplant Alfredo I asked for fettuccine but didn't get it. The worst $26 I spent, because I couldn't eat any of it. Oh! Except the mountain dew, that I took

Brianne Pickering

Smh. The hotel staff said they’ve already notified the owners to STOP putting their menu under the hotel doors and they don’t promote this pizza place due to the amount of complaints they receive from hotel customers. They were about 45 minutes late; and I had call them, they “forgot” to call me. Realized reviews say they’re chronically late. I flew in. I was hungry. I placed an order for a double pepperoni pizza. The pizza wasn’t cut all the way, in the middle of the pizza the dough must have ripped because it was just sauce and toppings in the middle, and the amount of garlic used could have killed an entire colony of vampires. The owners need to really investigate their management and how they operate. There are too many negative reviews stating the same problems. Or the owners are managing and need to evaluate their ability to own a pizza shop..because this isn’t it. The business stays in business by being shady and relying on unaware tourists.

Charitee P.

I usually always look up ratings and reviews before ordering from anywhere, but we were hungry and this just happened to be slipped under our hotel door. We ordered the chicken caesar salad, spaghetti and meatballs, and a slice of New York cheesecake. It took almost 2 hours for delivery and when it arrived I immediately regretted it. The salad smelled horrible as soon as I opened the lid. The lettuce was wilted and brown and the amount given was laughable. I should asked them to hold the e. Coli. My son enjoyed the spaghetti but you could tell it wasn’t homemade. The cheesecake was a joke. It was warm and broken in half and the top layer was super waxy to the point we had to remove it to see a normal consistency. This was a reminder to myself to ALWAYS check ratings and reviews!

Dean Taylor

I should’ve read the reviews online first. They slipped there flyer a few nights in a row so I decided to order. An hour and a half later for a pizza so greasy that the bottom of the pizza was literally soggy from grease. TRASH! Save yourself the disappointment and do not order from here

Angel

We order one of their specialty pizzas. They give us a burned old cold pepperoni pizza with frozen ingredients on top. Believe me when I say vegetables were non cooked. I don't like to waste food but it was totally inedible. It's a shame because we order three times before and it was ok. Never again.

Latasha Rhodes

Staying at the hotel and ordered chicken Alfredo and a steak gyro. The man who answered the phone said 1hour and I waited a little under 2 hours. The food was cold and horrible. NEVER ORDER FROM HERE! THIS PLACE SHOULD BE CLOSED FOR SERVING THIS HORRIBLE FOOD TO PEOPLE.

Luisa Blanco

Took about 1.20 hours to deliver. Ordered eggplant parmesan which looked not appetizing, it smelled burned and when I opened it it was indeed burned. It was close to cold, the garlic knots are extremely big and didn't taste good. Eggplant Alfredo I asked for fettuccine but didn't get it. The worst $26 I spent, because I couldn't eat any of it. Oh! Except the mountain dew, that I took

Farmer with shotgun

Me and my dad used to get pizza from here all the time. Safe to say we enjoyed the food, so what a surprise it was to me when I found a long piece of hair in my food. Y’all don’t got hairnets? Hey Ty e owner saying it’s a fake review I got receipts of me coming here all the time and from the one that night in which I had hair in my pizza. Y’all want me to add those photos too? What’s y’all number let’s talk

Micaela Amaro

Took 1 hr and 40 minutes to be delivered. Deals don't say boneless wings, and when I see wings I assume it's wings not chicken nugget pieces. Pizza was more then cold it tasted 2 days old and extremely dry, not enough sauce not enough cheese. Chicken nuggets I got where dry and gross. I feel like driving back up there a demanding a refund how can your charge so much for something so nasty and be proud of what you are making. I wasted 50$ never will go back in my life grossest thing I ever tasted worst then pizza hut, dominos and all the cheap pizza places. They need to edit there pricing.

Dan C

I ordered a small pizza, French fries, mozzarella sticks, and a 2 liter of soda. The food took approximately 2 hours to arrive. Once it did the fries were extremely soggy, mozzarella sticks were burnt, and pizza was barely warm. Honestly, this was the first and last time I will ever order from here.

Zero Stars should be an option. I have never written a review, but people should be warned to order elsewhere. Don’t waste your money. I’ve ordered pizza in Tampa weekly for 25 years. The pizza was gross and cold, The person taking the order was rude, the order was over 25 minutes late. Then after talking to the hotel were we got the flier, I was told that this company had been illegally soliciting on the property. Oh and extremely overpriced. Pizza was so gross!

Should have read reviews before ordering. To call this NY Pizza is a sacrilege. Tasted horrible. Barely any sauce. just garlic and cheese. extra greasy. potato skins were burned and they didnt send the drink. Please just close.

Hotel staff (13 minutes away) recommended them, I called and ordered, was told 45 min to an hour for delivery.... After an hour and 10 minutes I called and was told they were on the way.... 20 minutes later I called and told them to cancel it... 10 minutes later they still knocked on my hotel door offering me $25 off for the cold pizza and motz sticks, I declined again, the driver responded, well we told you an hour, I responded yeah, and it's been over an hour and a half, and closed my door.... I opened this website just for the purpose of leaving them a review and was not surprised at all to see their rating is at 2.6 stars. They deserve less

This is the 3rd time I’m Staying in a particular hotel and recovering from a cancer surgical procedure and they slide the menu under the door which took us by surprise as I was resting and disturbed us. The hotel keeps addressing it. I see several others have complained about the same practice and yet they keep doing it. There 2.6 Stars will soon be zero stars. Smart business move.

Hands down the worse place to order. I order a pizza with chicken wings. The pizza had no sauce and dried. The chicken wings were even worse. They were super salty I put them in the garbage horrible. Don not order from this place I don't know how they still in business.

Heba Girgiss

Should have read reviews before ordering. To call this NY Pizza is a sacrilege. Tasted horrible. Barely any sauce. just garlic and cheese. extra greasy. potato skins were burned and they didnt send the drink. Please just close.

William Champy

Hotel staff (13 minutes away) recommended them, I called and ordered, was told 45 min to an hour for delivery.... After an hour and 10 minutes I called and was told they were on the way.... 20 minutes later I called and told them to cancel it... 10 minutes later they still knocked on my hotel door offering me $25 off for the cold pizza and motz sticks, I declined again, the driver responded, well we told you an hour, I responded yeah, and it's been over an hour and a half, and closed my door.... I opened this website just for the purpose of leaving them a review and was not surprised at all to see their rating is at 2.6 stars. They deserve less

Misty McFarlane

Zero Stars should be an option. I have never written a review, but people should be warned to order elsewhere. Don’t waste your money. I’ve ordered pizza in Tampa weekly for 25 years. The pizza was gross and cold, The person taking the order was rude, the order was over 25 minutes late. Then after talking to the hotel were we got the flier, I was told that this company had been illegally soliciting on the property. Oh and extremely overpriced. Pizza was so gross!