Nik-N-Willie's Pizza-n-Subs

Got pick up from here with my husband good juicy chicken on the Cesar salad, and great fresh ingredients in the pizza. You can tell management is more interested in making regulars than just the sale

Food is just wonderful. Good size portions and very tasty.

Best freaking pizza ever!! Super kind staff! Perfect place to sit down and eat a perfect meal or call it in. Me and my husband come here every time we come to Mammoth and are always so pleased with our experience! These guys deserve perfect reviews and tips!

I love Nik n Willie's. Owners are always working too! Not a bad item on the menu! Love the yard bird and the thai chicken!

Great thin crust pizza. Good sauce and plenty of cheese, which is how we like our pizza. The guys running this place are very friendly. The parking is limited. Atmosphere is more of a lunch place than a dinner place. If we lived in the area, this place would be our go-to for takeout pizza.

Pizza is so good. The crust is perfect New York style , no flop! The staff is courteous and fun. So glad we stopped here !! A couple beers on tap that paired well with the ‘Za and a fridge full of domestic and craft beer. Would be here daily if we were local. Thanks guys for making our stop in Mammoth Epic.

My family of 6 downed an Xlrg carnivore for lunch and it filled them up such that they weren't hungry for dinner! Excellent place and the last Nik-N-Willies since COVID took out the other locations. Special shout out to Paul for saving my jacket and other items my kids left at the table. Thanks again Paul! You're awesome!

Ordered BBQ chicken pizza 🍕, not bad. The staff was very welcoming 😊

Our pizza was wonderful. If I ever am back in Mammoth I will be back at this place multiple times. Everything was perfect about our experience. What inspired this review was watching the (I assume) manager or owner deal with a jerk of a customer. I don’t want this guy to leave a bad review for something that the restaurant was not at fault for.

Good sub, went there just yesterday, got a warmed Italian sub, was definitely everything I was expecting, price was great too, definitely going back.

One of the best pizzas I've had. Crust was thin but not too thin, crispy but not burnt, sauce and toppings were spread to the edges. We had a veggie pizza and it was cooked Perfectly and not soggy. The pig out sandwich was awesome stuffed full. Service was great and we got our food quickly. Prices were right especially for quality food.

I get attitude from employees from other pizza places in mammonth like you are bothering them and their prices are very high. But i found this gem where i wss greeted with a smile, price was good anf the pizza excellent. My go to place from now on.

Both the Siena and Big Nick and Wild Willie’s pizzas were excellent. Friendly staff and the food was ready on time each time, so will definitely be back.

This hole in the wall pizza place is closed to where I stayed. I was able to walk over. There is a small parking lot, and parking seemed pretty easy. There was a line when I got here, and the tables a were full. It is a sign of good food! I saw a lady picking up 10 pizzas while I was waiting in line! I ordered a meatball sub and a medium pizza. Food was made to order and it was very fresh. The break for my meat ball sub was very soft and yet a little crispy! The pizza crust is thin, and crispy. The topping was not overcooked or dried. They prepared small containers of ranch inside the fridge for customers to self-serve. I will come back again for their pizza! It was well made!

Absolutely delicious pizza served at a joint settled in the center of the main city with friendly workers and a manager who actually cares how the customers like the food. I came here after reading all the positive Google reviews, with some even saying this is the best pizza they ever had. I kid you not, while waiting for our food, I literally heard a couple behind us exclaim to the manager after he came to ask them how their food was: “this is the best pizza we’ve ever had.” So yeah, people are actually saying this! I’ve had better pizza, but this was for sure top 5. They have small to XL pizzas with several options or you can create your own. For our Nik n Wild Willie’s pizza, everything was cooked perfectly and they made sure to lather even the closest part of the crust with sauce so you didn’t just end up with a breadstick at the end of your slice. The sandwiches were hot and the bread was soft yet crunchy. We also got four fountain drinks (each $1.50) with an unlimited refill fountain next to the seating area. For an XL pizza, 2 sandwiches, and 4 drinks we spent $69.50. Not bad at all considering the quality of food, cleanliness of the establishment, and friendliness of the service. I’d absolutely come here again if I return to Mammoth! Miscellaneous: they sell beer, but in bottles from their refrigerator. There is one all-gender restroom inside. There is plenty of parking outside. There are plenty of indoor and outdoor seating options.

Great sandwiches! Didn’t have the pizza, but definitely coming back because it looked amazing! Service was a 10! Large menu!

We've been going here for 20 years and It is my kids favorite place in Mammoth. The pizza is always great and I usual order a salad as well. Very reasonable price, especially for Mammoth. While I've never had any of their sandwiches, I've been told they are very tasty as well. The staff is very friendly and helpful. You order at the counter but they will bring you the food to your table. The soft drinks are self served, and I've never heard anyone complain about how many refills you get. They have several beers on tap, all good and the price is also reasonable. Seating is limited but most people who order do take out or have it delivered. Even with the limited seating, I've never seen them ask anyone to leave, even after you've finished your food. They have several televisions, usually playing sports, but when my children were small they would change the station to play cartoons for them. Parking can also be very limited but I've always been lucky. You can also order a pizza uncooked in case you want to take it back to your condo and cook it later.

Cool pizza vibe 🍕, had the pepperoni pizza and an amazing time, really recommend it

There are several pizza joints in Mammoth but Nik-N-Willies is the best in town. We had the 16" "The Veggie" pizza last night. The ingredients were all fresh and high quality and there was no pizza grease! The crust was perfectly crunchy and the flavors were so savory and delicious. Nik-N-Willies is SO GOOD!

Great Pizza, I can see myself coming back here I would definitely not skip out on any salads. I had The Nicks & Willie special. Also a cold beer to go with it.

Justin Miller

Both the Siena and Big Nick and Wild Willie’s pizzas were excellent. Friendly staff and the food was ready on time each time, so will definitely be back.

Erica Fung

This hole in the wall pizza place is closed to where I stayed. I was able to walk over. There is a small parking lot, and parking seemed pretty easy. There was a line when I got here, and the tables a were full. It is a sign of good food! I saw a lady picking up 10 pizzas while I was waiting in line! I ordered a meatball sub and a medium pizza. Food was made to order and it was very fresh. The break for my meat ball sub was very soft and yet a little crispy! The pizza crust is thin, and crispy. The topping was not overcooked or dried. They prepared small containers of ranch inside the fridge for customers to self-serve. I will come back again for their pizza! It was well made!

Simon Eats Too Much

Absolutely delicious pizza served at a joint settled in the center of the main city with friendly workers and a manager who actually cares how the customers like the food. I came here after reading all the positive Google reviews, with some even saying this is the best pizza they ever had. I kid you not, while waiting for our food, I literally heard a couple behind us exclaim to the manager after he came to ask them how their food was: “this is the best pizza we’ve ever had.” So yeah, people are actually saying this! I’ve had better pizza, but this was for sure top 5. They have small to XL pizzas with several options or you can create your own. For our Nik n Wild Willie’s pizza, everything was cooked perfectly and they made sure to lather even the closest part of the crust with sauce so you didn’t just end up with a breadstick at the end of your slice. The sandwiches were hot and the bread was soft yet crunchy. We also got four fountain drinks (each $1.50) with an unlimited refill fountain next to the seating area. For an XL pizza, 2 sandwiches, and 4 drinks we spent $69.50. Not bad at all considering the quality of food, cleanliness of the establishment, and friendliness of the service. I’d absolutely come here again if I return to Mammoth! Miscellaneous: they sell beer, but in bottles from their refrigerator. There is one all-gender restroom inside. There is plenty of parking outside. There are plenty of indoor and outdoor seating options.

MyVisit MyView

Great sandwiches! Didn’t have the pizza, but definitely coming back because it looked amazing! Service was a 10! Large menu!

Anthony Smith

We've been going here for 20 years and It is my kids favorite place in Mammoth. The pizza is always great and I usual order a salad as well. Very reasonable price, especially for Mammoth. While I've never had any of their sandwiches, I've been told they are very tasty as well. The staff is very friendly and helpful. You order at the counter but they will bring you the food to your table. The soft drinks are self served, and I've never heard anyone complain about how many refills you get. They have several beers on tap, all good and the price is also reasonable. Seating is limited but most people who order do take out or have it delivered. Even with the limited seating, I've never seen them ask anyone to leave, even after you've finished your food. They have several televisions, usually playing sports, but when my children were small they would change the station to play cartoons for them. Parking can also be very limited but I've always been lucky. You can also order a pizza uncooked in case you want to take it back to your condo and cook it later.

Jay M

There are several pizza joints in Mammoth but Nik-N-Willies is the best in town. We had the 16" "The Veggie" pizza last night. The ingredients were all fresh and high quality and there was no pizza grease! The crust was perfectly crunchy and the flavors were so savory and delicious. Nik-N-Willies is SO GOOD!

Pete Nieblas

Great Pizza, I can see myself coming back here I would definitely not skip out on any salads. I had The Nicks & Willie special. Also a cold beer to go with it.

BK

Ordered a bunch of subs and a pizza. The staff was super friendly and helpful on deciding on which sandwiches to get. Their suggestions were spot on. The meatball sub was delicious and covered in cheese, sauce and pepperoncinis. The 9 inch sandwich is easily a sandwich for two because of how massive it is. It had a great ratio of meatballs to sauce to other toppings to make it a must for any mammoth visit. Also tried the gobbler which was excellent. The cranberry balanced nicely with the turkey and gave a throwback to thanksgiving dinner.

I look forward to stopping at Nik-N-Willie's on our yearly trip to Mammoth Lakes. Their pizzas are amazing, as are the meatball subs! The staff is super friendly too! See you next year!

This pizzeria really nailed the crunch! The pizza crust was crispy and flavorful without being dry, and the wings were incredibly tasty with the perfect crunchy bite. If you love texture and flavor, this place is a must-try. Food was so good I didn’t even take pictures I just dug in.

This restaurant has been open for 29 years for a reason! Best sandwich I've had in a while. As soon as we walked in we knew we made the right choice, the place smells amazing. Payed 15$ for one sandwich but it was huge and loaded. I payed 15$ for a smash burger in the village and was still hungry. This sandwich could have fed me for days. Im excited to try the pizza the next time I come up.

Excellent food and the employees were even more incredible! Highly recommend.

Ana Acosta

This pizzeria really nailed the crunch! The pizza crust was crispy and flavorful without being dry, and the wings were incredibly tasty with the perfect crunchy bite. If you love texture and flavor, this place is a must-try. Food was so good I didn’t even take pictures I just dug in.

alex ellis

This restaurant has been open for 29 years for a reason! Best sandwich I've had in a while. As soon as we walked in we knew we made the right choice, the place smells amazing. Payed 15$ for one sandwich but it was huge and loaded. I payed 15$ for a smash burger in the village and was still hungry. This sandwich could have fed me for days. Im excited to try the pizza the next time I come up.

Jason Villa-Nunez

Good sub, went there just yesterday, got a warmed Italian sub, was definitely everything I was expecting, price was great too, definitely going back.

Mike Kahara

I look forward to stopping at Nik-N-Willie's on our yearly trip to Mammoth Lakes. Their pizzas are amazing, as are the meatball subs! The staff is super friendly too! See you next year!

You know a good pizza spot when you can smell the carmelizing cheese-sauce-crust combo from down the street. Solid place if you are in the area.

Stumbled onto Nik-N-Willies’s while charging our Tesla @ILuvAmp. Italian Sub sandwich was really good and fair price. Prefer fountain drinks to cans, selection could be better. Only a few tables outside, but we got one right away. Most locals probably grab and go. Would definitely revisit

Very nice people. The pizza was delicious, only we had the impression that the dough had not been out of the refrigerator long enough. The bottom was a bit tasteless.

Been coming up to Mammoth for over 20 years but never tried to place out. Usually we go to Z-Pizza but it closed several years ago. Got a small Nik and Wild Willie's pizza two nights ago and it was really good. It looked great and was filling. Had four slices for dinner and then finished the last two before checking out the next day. For less than $20, it was a good value. It was pretty busy but service was efficient. Called in my order and my pizza was done on time but there was a lady ahead of me who was pointing out the price on their website was lower than what she was charged so had to wait a little while longer and the line started to form behind me. Oh well, should have to take the opportunity to pay for my pizza once I got there instead of waiting for it to get pulled out of the oven. Will definitely come here again if I'm in Mammoth again and wanting pizza.

I enjoyed my lunch at this pizza place after hiking13 miles. I always return when I'm in the Mammoth Lakes area. There are so many good places to eat in Mammoth Lakes, but I do enjoy this place. Employees were nice. Note: Parking is a NIGHTMARE! Only a handful of spaces available, which means the street is parked up to. Only downside to this place.

Buffalo wings were bomb! Chicken parm sandwich lacked flavor and was just ok. Nordi Pie pizza was nothing special. $4 Arnold Palmer cans that you can get at grocery store for $1 was a bit steep. Overall a bit overpriced for what we got.

Loved it! Ordered Pizza and Chicken wings. Had no issues customizing the toppings on the pizza. Toppings were fresh, crust was perfect and overall the service was quick and great. Highly recommend.

Really good pizza. Made to order or take and bake. A little expensive but it's a small town in the middle of nowhere. Crust is to thin for me. Ingredients are top notch. Also had a decent beer selection.

Backpacker_ Hiker

I enjoyed my lunch at this pizza place after hiking13 miles. I always return when I'm in the Mammoth Lakes area. There are so many good places to eat in Mammoth Lakes, but I do enjoy this place. Employees were nice. Note: Parking is a NIGHTMARE! Only a handful of spaces available, which means the street is parked up to. Only downside to this place.

Nargis Mesyagutova

Buffalo wings were bomb! Chicken parm sandwich lacked flavor and was just ok. Nordi Pie pizza was nothing special. $4 Arnold Palmer cans that you can get at grocery store for $1 was a bit steep. Overall a bit overpriced for what we got.

Rudy

Loved it! Ordered Pizza and Chicken wings. Had no issues customizing the toppings on the pizza. Toppings were fresh, crust was perfect and overall the service was quick and great. Highly recommend.

matt morris

Really good pizza. Made to order or take and bake. A little expensive but it's a small town in the middle of nowhere. Crust is to thin for me. Ingredients are top notch. Also had a decent beer selection.

Chicken and bacon looked prepackaged and not freshly cooked. Bread was ok. Food was ok.

Pizza is too cheesy for us but the sandwich is good, freshly made.

Pizza was cheap but lacking quality. The sauce tasted like plain tomato sauce and the crust was very plain as well. I recommend using a more flavorful, seasoned sauce and adding more butter to the dough + brushing it with butter right before baking. Will give a significant boost in taste!

Service was good, nothing amazing. The pizza was not great. It was kind of tough and I was disappointed as this place got great reviews. It looks like an old dive restaurant, which I love, but I would not come back.

Amy

Service was good, nothing amazing. The pizza was not great. It was kind of tough and I was disappointed as this place got great reviews. It looks like an old dive restaurant, which I love, but I would not come back.

We loved the Makin Bacon pizza last year & got it several times over the summer season & recommended this place to our lodge guests. We are back in Mammoth & ordered our favorite pizza for take out. It was over baked & dry. We did not enjoy it at all & thought it had no sauce on it. I don’t know if the recipe changed or it was just forgotten in the oven but it was a huge disappointment.

They were nice, but there were three issues that made my experience not so great. First, the veggie sandwich I ordered was not good at all. It was basically a bunch of pizza toppings shoved into a piece of mediocre bread with cheap cheese melted on it. Not good at all. The slice of pizza we ordered was one of the worst I had. A load of cheese (the same kind used in the bread) melted on a piece of thin “crust”. Third, lots of flies!

Didn’t have wings. Made the wrong pizza. Didn’t give us the salad we ordered. Pizza was 6/10.

Mohammed Hashim

They were nice, but there were three issues that made my experience not so great. First, the veggie sandwich I ordered was not good at all. It was basically a bunch of pizza toppings shoved into a piece of mediocre bread with cheap cheese melted on it. Not good at all. The slice of pizza we ordered was one of the worst I had. A load of cheese (the same kind used in the bread) melted on a piece of thin “crust”. Third, lots of flies!

Matthew Greenawalt

We loved the Makin Bacon pizza last year & got it several times over the summer season & recommended this place to our lodge guests. We are back in Mammoth & ordered our favorite pizza for take out. It was over baked & dry. We did not enjoy it at all & thought it had no sauce on it. I don’t know if the recipe changed or it was just forgotten in the oven but it was a huge disappointment.

We stopped here because of the reviews. The pizza was not very good, too oily and yet still tasteless. It didn't sit too well and left us with upset stomachs.

Laura Kendrick

We stopped here because of the reviews. The pizza was not very good, too oily and yet still tasteless. It didn't sit too well and left us with upset stomachs.