Brian Giordano

Love the prepared food here. Healthy choices that are delicious. I love their protein bite meals, and my son loves the yogurt parfait. Bagels and lox are also top notch

Neil

Bagels are great, I just wish they had better coffee. If they did, I'd probably go more often.

carl lieberman

When looking for a good bagel with a nice spread on it The Bagel chalet is a perfect place everything is fresh. And don't forget their hot coffee

+6

Michael Curotto

Decent bagels but came with the family got 3 bagels 2 juices and 2 iced coffee for $50... with prices like might as well go to the diner.

Nena Scarlett

The sausage, egg and cheese was decent, definitely not worth $10. The small Potatoes also decent, but not worth $6. Add a blueberry muffin and iced latte all for $30, definitely not worth that price for a regular breakfast run. Never again...prices too high for what you get.

Syed Abrar

I am a uber driver. Bro just stop taking the new uber order if you can’t deliver everything on time. Very excessive wait time to get the order. At least 30 mins wait time. And a staff said if the order is there is there if not it’s gonna be a wait. That is so trash. No correct management

Siphokazi Bhengu

I had an extremely disappointing experience at this location on August 22 2025. After waiting over 30 minutes for an order while watching other customers and drivers be served, I politely asked about the delay. An employee named Anna responded with eye-rolling, spoke over me, and dismissed me with a hand gesture as though I wasn’t worth her time. As she walked away, she made a mumbled remark that came across as derogatory and deeply unsettling. This kind of behavior is unprofessional, discriminatory, and harmful to customers. It reflects very poorly on the business and made me feel unwelcome. The manager on duty (Mario) did step in and tried to take accountability, but the conduct of Anna was unacceptable and overshadowed everything else. I will not be returning, and I strongly urge management to review their hiring and training practices. No customer should be treated this way.

Melicia Mc Leish

I went into the Bagel Chalet this morning to order breakfast and was completely turned off after placing an order. There was what appeared to be a fruit fly infestation specifically in the area with the danishes, muffins etc., which is unacceptable in a good establishment. I brought it up to one of the workers who stated that “she knows and people tell them all the time”. If they are aware of this then why is this still an issue and how long has this been going on for. I am in disbelief that they continue to sell these items to unsuspecting consumers knowing this issue. They need to dispose of the food and address the infestation. I brought this matter up to the manager before leaving, who appeared nonchalant about the issue as well. Prior to leaving the store, he appeared to be removing one of the containers of sweets and fanning the flies as though that would resolve the problem. I will never eat from this place again and this makes me weary about eating out.

Steven Fox

Do not go to this bagel shop unless you want to grossly overpay to get a mediocre sandwich, if you even get it all. My office used to order from them every week until they forgot a sandwich on two separate occasions. The food used to be good, but has declined recently along with the service. They also took advantage of the egg prices and charge over $10 for an egg sandwich after most delis came back down to $6.50. There are plenty of other options in the Merrick/Bellmore area that don’t rip you off or forget your sandwiches. Btw, they still owe me an egg sandwich from our last order😡

joseph Renga

$24 for 2 bagels and 2 medium coffee, my wife couldn’t even finish the bagel it was so hard. Recommend the other bagel store down Merrick by levy park, almost half the price and double the taste. But on to good to go you can get 2 doz bagels for $6 doesn’t make any sense, just money hungry people.

Meg D

Ordered a cinnamon raisin bagel with butter. Got cream cheese. This may seem small and trivial but bagel chalet has gotten so bad lately with their service. The bagels are great, but there are constant mistakes. This place has 10 people sitting down and a few on line, it’s not crazy busy where they can’t pay attention and listen. 7/10 times we have a problem here. Usually it takes a very long time to get our order because they put it on top of the toaster To Go meanwhile we said to stay, and it’ll be wrong or it’ll be wrapped up to go instead of given in a tray which again, doesn’t seem like a big deal but it comes down to listening. The staff aren’t listening closely to the customers and are screwing orders up. There’s no accountability. No leadership. No manager on duty. No veteran staff to guide anyone. It’s all kids and people who may not have the greatest English, hence all the mistakes. We have looked past it many times but I think they’ve lost our business.