Stefano's Pizza

Not sure about others' experiences, but ours was great. We ordered 3 pizzas for pickup on Memorial Day Saturday. All three were wonderful. The crust on all 3 was perfect. The Mill Valley had a good amount of sausage and other toppings. The Pesto Deluxe tasted great with the artichoke hearts. The BBQ Chicken was notably good. It wasn't the goopy BBQ sauce-covered pizza others make. The chicken was cooked well without being dried out. The BBQ sauce was applied with a light touch. Perfect gem of a place!

Eric was extremely helpful and accommodating staying 30 minutes past close to make a pizza. The exceptional customer service and amazing pizza were a highlight of our trip to the Bay Area.

Best takeaway pizza in Marin! Edit: rating the service down a notch. Some of the young guys they employ here don't seem to bother to look at online orders until you show up. Still the best pizza in Marin though.

Rigoalberto Guerrero

Love all of Stefano’s very good pizza. Quality ingredients you can taste.

Gabriella Oliveira Dias

Delicious pizza, perfect crust, and high-quality ingredients. Excellent service and a very pleasant atmosphere. Highly recommend Stefanos Pizzeria!

Emrah Durmaz

I do food delivery on the side. On Sunday night, I ordered a pizza for myself from this spot. The guy probably didn’t realize it was my order. :) He asked if I was hungry and hooked me up with two extra slices. Super nice of him. The pizza was great. I’d definitely recommend this place.

June Wong

Not sure about others' experiences, but ours was great. We ordered 3 pizzas for pickup on Memorial Day Saturday. All three were wonderful. The crust on all 3 was perfect. The Mill Valley had a good amount of sausage and other toppings. The Pesto Deluxe tasted great with the artichoke hearts. The BBQ Chicken was notably good. It wasn't the goopy BBQ sauce-covered pizza others make. The chicken was cooked well without being dried out. The BBQ sauce was applied with a light touch. Perfect gem of a place!

Matthew Bingham

Eric was extremely helpful and accommodating staying 30 minutes past close to make a pizza. The exceptional customer service and amazing pizza were a highlight of our trip to the Bay Area.

Andrew Trott

Best takeaway pizza in Marin! Edit: rating the service down a notch. Some of the young guys they employ here don't seem to bother to look at online orders until you show up. Still the best pizza in Marin though.

Timothy McDermott

Visiting for the weekend. Stefano’s Mill Creek was walking distance. We had a “The Works” pizza and a Greek salad. Food was ready quickly and delicious. Staff was friendly and helpful. Definitely recommend this place.

Anthony

We ordered via Postmates so we didn’t have to directly interact with anyone, but it got to us very fast regardless. The pizza was VERY good. There was a ton of chicken on our pizza, and I base my opinion almost entirely on the flavor and the amount of protein the business chooses to use. Some places really skimp on the protein to save money. Prices are somewhat high, but so is the real estate here.

Laura F Gibble-Fisco

My husband has been going to Stefano's for years! He grew up in Mill Valley and it's his favorite pizza. It really has become my favorite as well. There's just something about it that's delicious and unbeatable to us. Their slices are huge and their prices are reasonable. Eating in is as much fun as grabbing to go. Really great people there, too. There's always a smile!

Stacey McIntosh

Walked in at 11am as they opened. Friendly staff. Ordered a slice of pizza, garlic bread, and the steak and mushroom sandwich. Order was ready quickly. Pizza was delicious as was the bread and sandwich. Fresh and tasty ingredients. Price was good. Will definitely eat at Stefano's again.

AKS

Great pizza. More importantly, great, great staff. Always looking out for the customer. Just ordered a pizza for delivery -- had one coupon which was a good value, but staff applied another couple with even a greater value!!!! Will keep on coming back with customer service like that!!! Thanks.

Nice pizza parlor. It’s a chain in Marin county. Sometimes the pizza is a little tired. Other than that it’s usually wonderful.

Pedro Fernandez

Nice pizza parlor. It’s a chain in Marin county. Sometimes the pizza is a little tired. Other than that it’s usually wonderful.

It's good, but once it's cold, it is inedible. I love cold pizza 🍕 but eat it immediately. Great for kid parties. It's currently ~23 for a large; pretty pricey. The large is much smaller than you'd expect

Worth the trouble...been here a long time for a reason. Isn't going to cheat on you. For my part. I wish there was more pasta items, however I admit it's main problem and perhaps only standout problem is that it is hard to sit inside unless I pretend to be a construction worker.

Is it the best pizza you will ever have? No. Have the prices gotten worse? Yes. Does that change the fact that it’s a staple of any teen living in mill valley and is a great place to grab a quick bite or a pizza for multiple people to eat without draining the bank account? Not at all. They’re quick, always have slices ready, and make good New York style pizza and that’s what matters most Not super special, but that doesn’t make them bad either and not having to pay an arm and a leg for a pizza counts for something in Marin

Remembering Truth

Worth the trouble...been here a long time for a reason. Isn't going to cheat on you. For my part. I wish there was more pasta items, however I admit it's main problem and perhaps only standout problem is that it is hard to sit inside unless I pretend to be a construction worker.

Daniel May

Is it the best pizza you will ever have? No. Have the prices gotten worse? Yes. Does that change the fact that it’s a staple of any teen living in mill valley and is a great place to grab a quick bite or a pizza for multiple people to eat without draining the bank account? Not at all. They’re quick, always have slices ready, and make good New York style pizza and that’s what matters most Not super special, but that doesn’t make them bad either and not having to pay an arm and a leg for a pizza counts for something in Marin

Eric Sabban

It's good, but once it's cold, it is inedible. I love cold pizza 🍕 but eat it immediately. Great for kid parties. It's currently ~23 for a large; pretty pricey. The large is much smaller than you'd expect

Very average to below average pizza. I didn't walk in here looking for anything amazing, but Costco is my bar and this was below that. few pieces of pepperoni, the oil was just swimming pooling on everything and the slice was super thin. The chicken was fried but was burned. Still not bad. It was $6 for a slice, at least that's what I was charged.

Fatty

Very average to below average pizza. I didn't walk in here looking for anything amazing, but Costco is my bar and this was below that. few pieces of pepperoni, the oil was just swimming pooling on everything and the slice was super thin. The chicken was fried but was burned. Still not bad. It was $6 for a slice, at least that's what I was charged.

We just had a takeout and there are bugs on top of the topping, not just one bug there are a few of them, had to toss them because of that. Taste is ok for the over priced pizza. Not recommended.

FEI XIE

We just had a takeout and there are bugs on top of the topping, not just one bug there are a few of them, had to toss them because of that. Taste is ok for the over priced pizza. Not recommended.

I genuinely felt gross after eating here. It is pizza you would serve at a child’s birthday party. S’barros is better. I like many kinds of pizza but they have to have one thing: flavor. This was completely bland. Zero tomato flavor. Greasy. Cardboard.

I called and spoke with a man, Francesco, I believe. 7:38pm. I ordered a Pizza pie, green salad, and carrot cake dessert. I tell him I'm at a hotel, BW. Food arrives 8:33pm. Seemed like a long time for a local place. Ok, I open the bag with salad and cake, No utensils, napkins, a plate... nothing. I immediately pick up phone to let them know I need these utensils, thinking they could text/call their driver to turn around and deliver the goods. NOPE. I call at 20 minutes later and ask what's up, and I'm told driver is just returning and will leave again . At this point, it is an hour and half before I eat salad or dessert. Which I paid for. Thank goodness I can eat pizza with my hands. Ask to speak with Manager for I thought taking the salad off would be a nice gesture and this young women got upset and told me, "this is not my problem". Really? Not great customer service.

Amy Norman

I genuinely felt gross after eating here. It is pizza you would serve at a child’s birthday party. S’barros is better. I like many kinds of pizza but they have to have one thing: flavor. This was completely bland. Zero tomato flavor. Greasy. Cardboard.

Kerrie Flynn

I called and spoke with a man, Francesco, I believe. 7:38pm. I ordered a Pizza pie, green salad, and carrot cake dessert. I tell him I'm at a hotel, BW. Food arrives 8:33pm. Seemed like a long time for a local place. Ok, I open the bag with salad and cake, No utensils, napkins, a plate... nothing. I immediately pick up phone to let them know I need these utensils, thinking they could text/call their driver to turn around and deliver the goods. NOPE. I call at 20 minutes later and ask what's up, and I'm told driver is just returning and will leave again . At this point, it is an hour and half before I eat salad or dessert. Which I paid for. Thank goodness I can eat pizza with my hands. Ask to speak with Manager for I thought taking the salad off would be a nice gesture and this young women got upset and told me, "this is not my problem". Really? Not great customer service.