Kiki R.

Thank you so much to the hostess who picked up my call on Christmas Day and made our last-minute reservation happen. I had been here once before with friends, and I was so happy to finally bring my beloved friends back on Christmas. We loved everything from the moment we walked in. All of us truly enjoyed every detail from the drinks to dessert. The service was excellent as always, and the cozy atmosphere with warm lighting made the experience feel extra special and memorable. We shared a variety of appetizers and entrées, and everything was absolutely delicious. We will definitely be coming back!

+10

Jonathan Arcentales

Came for a pre Christmas dinner with my wife and we will definitely come back. Hostess was very accommodating since we didn’t have a reservation. The food was amazing, we shared the lobster fettuccine, frutti di mare squid ink pasta and scallops. Thanks to all the staff for their kindness and to our waiter Renan, who gave us excellent recommendations. Next time we’ll have the Chilean sea bass and the olive cake!

Justina Tenaglia

The food here was 10/10!! Pietro was the best server! His recommendations for wine and food exceeded our expectations! Go eat here and request Pietro!!! The best tiramisu , arancini, lobster rolls & eggplant parm! The chicken cutlet melted in your mouth . Rigatoni vodka is a must!

+1

Victoria Haigh

We had a reservation for 2pm, but with any family get together, plans changed and we arrived 1hr early. We were able to be sat early in the lounge area. The food was incredible, and we had Lina as our server. She provided top-tier service, was super friendly, and offered excellent suggestions for the vegetarian in our party. If you're able to check this place out, ask for Lina!

Danielle Taylor

Excellent food. Absolutely delicious. 10/10! We got the ravioli special which was stuffed with veal for the appetizer. PACKED with flavor! Then we got the mushroom risotto and lobster fettuccini for our main courses. It was hard to pick a favorite because it felt like a new flavor sensation with each bite. The lemon cake lacked the flavor punch, but was enjoyable. The service from “Ms BK” was superb. She was fun and gave us great guidance in the menu. The atmosphere was energetic and fun. I can’t wait to go back!

jayreCurl213

It was my girlfriend and I first time here in New york. When I looked for a restaurant to celebrate Thanksgiving with her I ended up stumbling upon this restaurant. My girlfriend being a big fan of Italian food we went ahead and tried it. The food was delicious, the atmosphere was romantic and the overall service was fantastic! Mauricio was our server and he did an amazing job attending us! He was welcoming, informative with menu selections, and engaging. Can't recommend the food enougg and if you ever have the chance ask for Mauricio to be your server! You won't regret it! A true professional 🙂

Flower Power Chick

Wonderful spot to have a bite before Broadway show. We didn’t have reservations, but got a spot at the bar. Incredibly appreciative of the warm response when we said we had no reservations and just wanted to sit at the bar. So used to rude eye rolls. Barstaff was exceptional! We had apps, cocktails and a dessert and they brought us warm focaccia bread. Attentive, funny and approachable! Then, brought us complementary limoncello after dessert. I like a high quality restaurant that isn’t pretentious and rude and unapproachable. Kindness, friendliness and even a fun conversation elevates the experience! Well done.

+1

Felecia Derry

It was Mauricio's first day servering (on his own) and he did absolutely amazing! The food and drink recommendations were great! We had a nice time for our anniversary. Everything was yummy! Ambiance was also great! We got the colognes & roasted chicken for dinner, creme brûlée for dessert. Drinks were old fashioned and Thunderbird.

Gabriella Garcia

Such a top-tier experience! We made a reservation (which was definitely a good idea) and got a lovely table. Our server Lina was super friendly and recommended an amazing Chardonnay. The food was incredible — my mom had the Frutti di Mare, my boyfriend went for the Lobster Fettuccine, and I had the Vodka Pasta — all perfectly cooked and full of flavor. Even the bread they serve at the beginning was delicious, and they offered to bring more! For starters we ordered the octopus and burrata — both fresh and beautifully plated. We finished with the profiteroles, a perfect dessert to share (comes with vanilla ice cream for each, so more than enough for three). Excellent food, great service, cozy atmosphere, and even an ABBA playlist in the background — loved every minute of it! 💛🍝✨

+3

Green Dot Events

We had an amazing experience at this restaurant! As soon as you walk in, it is STUNNING. The food was absolutely delicious — every dish was full of flavor, and the desserts were the perfect finishing touch. Our favorites were the meatballs, Cacio e Pepe & the Rib Eye. For drinks, the Old Fashioned and French 75. Our waitress, Nicole, went above and beyond to make sure we had everything we needed. She was friendly, attentive, and made us feel so welcome throughout our meal. The service and atmosphere together made it such a great dining experience. I highly recommend this spot — we’ll definitely be coming back!

Jennifer Park

We didn’t have any reservations but the hostess was very accommodating and was able to find a table for us right away. Our server Lina was very knowledgeable with the menu and we tried most of her recommendations which did not disappoint! She made our experience a very friendly and personable one which I genuinely appreciate. My family came to New York on vacation and I must say that the food was one of the best I’ve ever had!

+1

Agnieszka Popczyk

Absolutely outstanding experience at Osteria Siciliano! From the moment we walked in, we were greeted with genuine warmth and hospitality. The atmosphere is cozy yet elegant — perfect for a family dinner or a romantic evening out. Every dish was bursting with authentic Sicilian flavor — the pasta was fresh, the seafood perfectly cooked, and the desserts were heavenly (the cannoli is a must-try!). The staff made us feel like family, attentive without being overbearing, and clearly passionate about what they do. You can tell every plate is made with love and tradition. We left full, happy, and already planning our next visit. Highly recommend Osteria Siciliano to anyone who loves true Italian food and heartfelt

Reza Nia

We had a great authentic Italian dinner and highly recommend it. Our server, Allen, made the service 5 star. The highlight dishes were the porterhouse steak and cacio e pepe pasta, both were amazing. The other classic pasta was also very good. Both antipastis (roasted octopus and eggplant) were just okay, but the sides, sautéed mushrooms and roasted potatoes were fantastic. Overall, it was very good, and only the antipasti could be improved, everything else was perfect.

+2

Sasha Charles

I really enjoyed my dining experience. The ambiance is beautiful. The hibiscus spritz was so good! It was refreshing with a nice kick to it! For appetizer, I had the octopus. It was perfectly prepared, and it paired so well with the sauce and potatoes. My scallops entree was amazing, my guest had the salmon, she enjoyed it! The portion size was very good! The service was amazing. Lina was so attentive and personable. The flow of the dining was fast. I arrived at 445, and I had ample time to make it to my 7pm Broadway show without rushing. I would go back.

Went here for a business dinner. The ambiance was perfect, nicely lit, & good energy. \n\nEveryone got something different and everyone loved everything they got. \n\nI got the mushroom risotto 10/…

Our table was for two, and our waiter was Renal, him us recommended a couple of drinks based on our taste preferences. We started with an octopus dish from the menu, which was excellent. Then we or…

Our table was for two, and our waiter was Renal, him us recommended a couple of drinks based on our taste preferences. We started with an octopus dish from the menu, which was excellent. Then we or…

Our table was for two, and our waiter was Renal, him us recommended a couple of drinks based on our taste preferences. We started with an octopus dish from the menu, which was excellent. Then we or…

We had a great time at Osteria La Baia. Such a great choice, the vibe was really nice and made the whole night feel special but still relaxed. The service was on point, super friendly and attentive…

We stopped into Osteria La Baia randomly after a quick shopping evening. The hostess was happy to provide us a table for two with no reservation. The ambiance and decoration of the restaurant was v…

Beautiful Italian restaurant - came for a lovely catch up lunch with an old friend. Great vodka pasta and wine - just what I needed on a cold afternoon in December. Also this place is huge !!

We stopped into Osteria La Baia randomly after a quick shopping evening. The hostess was happy to provide us a table for two with no reservation. The ambiance and decoration of the restaurant was v…

Beautiful Italian restaurant - came for a lovely catch up lunch with an old friend. Great vodka pasta and wine - just what I needed on a cold afternoon in December. Also this place is huge !!

I was lucky enough to get a same day reservation, even though the restaurant looked completely full when we arrived. From start to finish, the experience was excellent. Every staff member we intera…

The food and service was amazing. We came in without a reservation and they accommodated us. All of the food and drinks came out fresh and delicious highly recommended

Food was outstanding! We had the Caesar salad to start and shared the vodka pasta & ribeye for dinner. pasta was better than Carbone's! Service was excellent. We also ordered the tiramisu for des…

I had the porterhouse with spinach and potatoes, and everything was so yummy. Great location . The restaurant was elegant and upscale, but absolutely worth it for the quality of the food and experien…

I had the porterhouse with spinach and potatoes, and everything was so yummy. Great location . The restaurant was elegant and upscale, but absolutely worth it for the quality of the food and expe…

We came to NYC via train from Brewster NY. Unable to check in out hotel we decided to find a spot for a late lunch. Great expresso martinis to get the afternoon started.

The location is perfect, near Times Square and the theater district, yet not in the touristy chaos of Times Square. staff IS AMAZING! Chef Ramirez prepared a feast, both visual and literal, for ou…

Great restaurant. food and service were excellent. The female host in 10/16/25 was very nice and accommodating. I will definitely be back!

Great restaurant. Food and service were excellent. The female host in 10/16/25 was very nice and accommodating. I will definitely be back!

I went here Saturday night - 2 couples. This is not your typical 'red sauce' italian restaurant. From the attendants at the front podium to the wait staff - everyone was friendly and engaging and…

I went here Saturday night - 2 couples. This is not your typical 'red sauce' Italian Restaurant. From the attendants at the front podium to the wait staff - everyone was friendly and engaging and…

Smart upmarket eatery with delicious food, attentive service and a premium price. Clearly a very popular place with most tables taken.

I think the food was exceptionally good and delicious, and for the atmosphere it was something out of this world. The employees were really kind and were always there to help. Thank you very much!

I ate here for a special dinner with my family for my 60th birthday. What a treat. The food was exceptional, the service excellent and the atmosphere just perfect. Everybody in the group loved the …

Great service, delicious food. Beautiful atmosphere. Mayor Eric Adams was there at the same time! We had the octopus starter, my husband had the frutti de mare, my sister the scallops and I had th…

Great service, delicious food. Beautiful atmosphere. Mayor Eric Adams was there at the same time! We had the octopus starter, my husband had the frutti de mare, my sister the scallops and I had …

La Baia in Midtown was so much fun Burrata: tomatoes, pesto sauce, rocket leaves, green olives, arugula octopus Carpaccio: Artichoke dressing, Sicilian pistachios, parsley, cherry tomatoes Fettuci…

The dinner at Osteria La Baia was a delight from start to finish. The food was outstanding, the wine excellent, and the piece that brought it all together was our waiter, Walter. He provided perfec…

Osteria La Baia is a really enjoyable restaurant on 52nd and 6th in New York. Food and service excellent and great selection of wines. Recommended .

A fabulous vibe, drinks and food! We were greeted with a smile and the service was fantastic! Everything from start to finish was too notch! Can’t wait to go back!

Amazing decor. Delish food. Service was excellent. Saw the newly elected Mayor of NYC dining there. Reasonable priced by NYC standards I would recommend.

Nice place, very central and busy. Even though we had a reservation, we waited 3-5 minutes to be seated. The service was friendly, up to that point. We ordered cocktails, pasta and, as a main course, branzino, which we paired with Pinot Grigio. To finish, we ordered tiramisu. Everything was delicious and the portions were very generous; however, a couple of hours later, we felt ill, nothing serious. Perhaps we are not used to such heavy meals.

Samantha Boren

Came for dinner and sat at the bar. Customer service was excellent from start to finish. It was a beautiful dining experience, however, the pasta was not as good as I was expecting, it needed lots of salt and wasn't very warm when served. I'd definitely come back and maybe try something different.

+2

This is a really nice restaurant with beautiful decor and top notch waitstaff. The veal chop was not what we expected... it was more like a veal parm... scallops were so so... I like some carmeliza…

This is a really nice restaurant with beautiful decor and top notch waitstaff. The veal chop was not what we expected... it was more like a veal parm... scallops were so so... I like some carmeliza…

Food: Very good and fresh. I got the frutti di mare and it was delicious. Our party shared a few apps, which were all very good and came out hot and fresh. We also shared a few desserts and my favori…

food: Very good and fresh. I got the frutti di mare and it was delicious. Our party shared a few apps, which were all very good and came out hot and fresh. We also shared a few desserts and my fa…

The dinner was very good. The vibes are New Yorkish-Italian. We started with the octopus -- it was tender, not rubbery in texture, great credit to the chef. My husband ordered the ribeye medium-rar…

Positive: the food is definitely great, the gnocchi has a light texture, and the pasta had a fantastic rich sauce. Tiramisu did not disappoint, though definitely large and better sharing. Halfway t…

Managed to get an early table at this restaurant which was very close to Radio City where I had booked a show. The restaurant is extremely busy with a good vibe. Food was good however service felt …

Very good and expensive. Server was friendly and attentive. I was torn between giving this a 4 or a 5 for this review. 4.5 would work. The beef tartare was very good but you'll need to ask for mor…

Well located and good service. We tried the lobster pasta and fresh raw fish really good. The place is really nice decorated. Nice please to go to have a lunch or dinner.

Underwhelming. I came to this place with a lot of expectations- the reviews looked great! Let me start by saying what was great- the focaccia bread, the tiramisu were truly exceptional. Service was top notch. However- the quality of a restaurant is known by its consistency in ensuring each dish is flavorful- not just a few. We ordered the veal shank in risotto, and the lobster fettuccine. Both were mid. They didn’t add bread crumbs to the lobster fettuccine. It had a tomato and parsley base- and the flavors were missing. Overall- I have been to better Italian restaurants in nyc. I would skip this one.

Anna-Mariia Lytovchuk

Overall, the food was excellent. We truly enjoyed the beet salad with apples — it was outstanding. My gnocchi were very tender and flavorful, and my husband’s lasagna was also delicious. However, our experience was affected by the attitude of the waiter. We are from Eastern Europe and have a noticeable accent. Unfortunately, the waiter acted as if he couldn’t understand us, repeatedly asking us to repeat ourselves in a nervous and dismissive way. It felt uncomfortable, as if we should feel “lucky” just to be dining there, which took away from an otherwise pleasant evening. On a positive note, the food was memorable, and I’m attaching photos to share that part of the experience.

Olivia M

Osteria La Baia might have glowing Google reviews—but I suspect that’s more from gentle nudges by the waitstaff than pure customer enthusiasm. We arrived with a reservation and were seated at a cramped corner table tucked beside a large private party. The noise was chaotic—like dining inside a speaker. When we asked our waiter to move, he told us to “ask the hostess” instead of handling it himself. Eventually, the manager stepped in and relocated us to a much better spot where we could actually hear each other. Once things settled, the experience improved. The roasted octopus starter was just okay—nothing to write home about. The Cacio e Pepe with truffle had great flavor but was a bit too oily. The Gimlet was the standout—perfectly balanced. My friends enjoyed their salad and risotto, so the food wasn’t the issue. Overall? The meal was fine, but the service and seating left a sour note. Not a disaster, just not the polished Italian experience the reviews make it out to be.

+8

We had a reservation for a Saturday evening. The restaurant has good ambience with tables and booths. We started with a Caesar salad, which was good. We shared the pappardelle bolognese, cacio e Pe…

We had a reservation for a Saturday evening. The restaurant has good ambience with tables and booths. We started with a Caesar salad, which was good. We shared the pappardelle bolognese, cacio e Pe…

My friend and I dined here on January 28 and shared several dishes, including the Lobster Fettuccine, Meatballs, Steak, Tiramisu, and Crème Brûlée.\n Within approximately 12 hours, both of us became …

My friend and I dined here on January 28 and shared several dishes, including the lobster Fettuccine, Meatballs, steak, Tiramisu, and Crème Brûlée.\n Within approximately 12 hours, both of us bec…