Matt Merideth

Great pizza, usually comes early

Tim Barnes

Great food great service. Pizza crust is typically on point. Delivery is always excellent and on time

Milani Eldred

This place is amazing. First time trying it and their pizza is THE BEST!!!! Mozzarella sticks and tenders were really tasty too, but slightly overcooked (which wasn't an issue). The staff is super friendly, helpful, and kind to everybody. I would absolutely recommend this place!

Shea Tilton

We stopped in for lunch with our kids on a whim...BOY AM I GLAD WE DID! First the people there are so nice and kind it was very welcoming. The pizza was EXCELLENT. Crispy, cheese and full of flavor. And the wings were just as good if not better. Glad we found this place I think it might be our go to for pizza from now on!

Christopher Millimaci

OH MY LORD….. i am very questionable when looking for new places to eat, BY FAR THE BEST PIZZA AND WINGS in the entire area. This was greatly worth the drive from Fulton. Pizza and wings were spot on! I will definitely be ordering from here now on. Friendly and amazing customer service as well! If i could give this place 10 stars, i would give it 11!

The New York-style pepperoni pizza was just about what I was expecting: thin, foldable and a bit greasy. The generous amount of cheese did surprise me, though, and I liked its flavor. The crust tasted like what you get at Cam's in Watertown. Although the pie was cooked perfectly, I would have preferred more pepperoni. There were a couple of hiccups with the fries; we ordered a fresh-cut batch, but were told that option was no longer available. So we shifted to waffle fries. ... But what came out were curly fries. That was a head-scratcher. However, the fries were hot, crispy and delicious. The dining area was not fancy, but it was neat and clean.

Great little hand tossed pizza joint. They dont skimp on the cheese which I love. Friendly, fast, small town atmosphere. Fresh ingredients.

Ed H

Great little hand tossed pizza joint. They dont skimp on the cheese which I love. Friendly, fast, small town atmosphere. Fresh ingredients.

Rob Oatman

The New York-style pepperoni pizza was just about what I was expecting: thin, foldable and a bit greasy. The generous amount of cheese did surprise me, though, and I liked its flavor. The crust tasted like what you get at Cam's in Watertown. Although the pie was cooked perfectly, I would have preferred more pepperoni. There were a couple of hiccups with the fries; we ordered a fresh-cut batch, but were told that option was no longer available. So we shifted to waffle fries. ... But what came out were curly fries. That was a head-scratcher. However, the fries were hot, crispy and delicious. The dining area was not fancy, but it was neat and clean.

I dont usually review things. But a local business, I happened to be in the area, pizza was actually good. I would recommend

The pizza is good with lots of cheese but stingy with the toppings, I paid extra for pepperoni, sausage, peppers and onions, all four toppings were minimal and at the price you pay. I don’t mind paying $27.00 for a medium pizza if it was covered well with the meat and veggies. I would then be spreading the word for everyone to try their pizza.

Nice local pizza spot that I traveled too. Been spotting out pizza slices of late. A very saucy pizza slice with a good tangy flavor. One of the better cheese blends of this type and when fresh hot out the oven I bet it's a big cheese pull. First slice when nice a lite with a simple crunch.

Michael Sanderson

I dont usually review things. But a local business, I happened to be in the area, pizza was actually good. I would recommend

Judy Kastenhuber

Noah was very polite. The pizza was very good. It was cooked perfectly

Bob Giacobbi

The pizza is good with lots of cheese but stingy with the toppings, I paid extra for pepperoni, sausage, peppers and onions, all four toppings were minimal and at the price you pay. I don’t mind paying $27.00 for a medium pizza if it was covered well with the meat and veggies. I would then be spreading the word for everyone to try their pizza.

mike porter

Nice local pizza spot that I traveled too. Been spotting out pizza slices of late. A very saucy pizza slice with a good tangy flavor. One of the better cheese blends of this type and when fresh hot out the oven I bet it's a big cheese pull. First slice when nice a lite with a simple crunch.

Pizza reminded me of college. You know , 2 am , you’ve had a few drinks , so you bust it down .My total was about $5 more then the menu on the register. Wings could use some sauce , and the dining area was ice cold. But for Phoenix , NY , it’s a 10.

Hunter Eldred

Staff are awesome, place is awesome, food is good just the pizza is cut not the best and you gotta recut it sometimes

Mr Davis

Pizza reminded me of college. You know , 2 am , you’ve had a few drinks , so you bust it down .My total was about $5 more then the menu on the register. Wings could use some sauce , and the dining area was ice cold. But for Phoenix , NY , it’s a 10.

I eat at Independent pizzeria in Phoenix approximately once a week to 3 times a week, every week for lunch and dinner. Not sure who the new guy is at the counter, but he has a smile and is friendly, except he does not ask if you want the pizza warmed up at all. The first time, I went with it and was eating luke warm pizza and the second time I came in while he was working, I could see the pizza was in the warmer for a while and I asked if he could heat the 2 slices up in the oven quick. he said the warmer keeps it at 150F, so it is good and he blatantly ignored my request. I said ok, and ate pizza I paid for and I could tell it was sitting in the warmer for a while and it was the last couple slices of the pie, so I know it had been there a while as the dough starts to get a little chewy after being in the warmer for a while. That is not good service to tell the customer what they don't need, even when asking for it. As all the other people I have dealt with, have always asked, if you wanted it heated up, and are great at customer service. As a frequent visitor to this restaurant, I love the food and usually the service and pricing is good as well, but this employee needs to be taught properly, or I may not be back. I am a pizza lover and father of 5. So I hope this gets resolved quickly.

M A

I eat at Independent pizzeria in Phoenix approximately once a week to 3 times a week, every week for lunch and dinner. Not sure who the new guy is at the counter, but he has a smile and is friendly, except he does not ask if you want the pizza warmed up at all. The first time, I went with it and was eating luke warm pizza and the second time I came in while he was working, I could see the pizza was in the warmer for a while and I asked if he could heat the 2 slices up in the oven quick. he said the warmer keeps it at 150F, so it is good and he blatantly ignored my request. I said ok, and ate pizza I paid for and I could tell it was sitting in the warmer for a while and it was the last couple slices of the pie, so I know it had been there a while as the dough starts to get a little chewy after being in the warmer for a while. That is not good service to tell the customer what they don't need, even when asking for it. As all the other people I have dealt with, have always asked, if you wanted it heated up, and are great at customer service. As a frequent visitor to this restaurant, I love the food and usually the service and pricing is good as well, but this employee needs to be taught properly, or I may not be back. I am a pizza lover and father of 5. So I hope this gets resolved quickly.

Ordered delivery online at 5:52, had an ETA of 6:42. i understand it is a friday night but we didn’t receive the food until 7:20. We got a large extra cheese and 20 wings. Wings had flavor but unfortunately our pizza came destroyed 🫤 disappointed for a first time customer

Kaley

Ordered delivery online at 5:52, had an ETA of 6:42. i understand it is a friday night but we didn’t receive the food until 7:20. We got a large extra cheese and 20 wings. Wings had flavor but unfortunately our pizza came destroyed 🫤 disappointed for a first time customer

I have never been told that its pick up only on a Friday

We have been ordering food for 11 years. Today was the last time. The prices keep going up and the quality and quantity has gone down. Tonight's whole subs (club) had 2 slices of of ham & turkey and over done bacon. The mayonnaise, I had to open the sub to make sure it was even on it. This is just tonights order, the list of mistakes from past orders is long and I won't waste your time. So long Independant Pizzeria!

This place is absolutely horrible DO NOT WASTE YOUR MONEY HERE. The food is disgusting and the manager is just as bad.

They advertised themselves on the toast app for delivery. It’s been there for a little while so I decided to try them out as they had good reviews. I place the order; the system takes my money and then they call me immediately saying they don’t deliver to my area but I could come pick it up if I want to. It’s a scam folks- they offer delivery, take your cash and then refuse to deliver it. Don’t be fooled and be left without your money and without your dinner like my family was.

Tiktok

This place is absolutely horrible DO NOT WASTE YOUR MONEY HERE. The food is disgusting and the manager is just as bad.

lori hudson

We have been ordering food for 11 years. Today was the last time. The prices keep going up and the quality and quantity has gone down. Tonight's whole subs (club) had 2 slices of of ham & turkey and over done bacon. The mayonnaise, I had to open the sub to make sure it was even on it. This is just tonights order, the list of mistakes from past orders is long and I won't waste your time. So long Independant Pizzeria!

Melissa Wells

They advertised themselves on the toast app for delivery. It’s been there for a little while so I decided to try them out as they had good reviews. I place the order; the system takes my money and then they call me immediately saying they don’t deliver to my area but I could come pick it up if I want to. It’s a scam folks- they offer delivery, take your cash and then refuse to deliver it. Don’t be fooled and be left without your money and without your dinner like my family was.