Hilltop Tavern

Rebecca Spinac

The best hidden gem in the Slope! Impeccable decor, amazing service and some of the THE BEST food. Perfect for any occasion or casual meal. Do yourself a favor and go!!!

Angelica B

Came here for a family pre-Valentines day dinner and we loved it! It was our first time coming, and we will definitely be back. The food was great, and the atmosphere was very cozy. Everyone working there was welcoming and friendly. We got the wings, the bacon wrapped dates, shrimp with grits, burger, kids grilled cheese, and topped it off with the brownie skillet with ice cream. Oh! The guava lemonade is sooooo good! Can’t wait for our second visit!

Smart Hair Studio Smart Hair Studio

We recently hosted our end-of-summer girls’ party at Hilltop Tavern, and it was nothing short of amazing! From the delicious appetizers and fresh salads to the perfectly cooked fish dishes, every bite was a delight. Though we didn’t order any meat options, the menu had plenty of delicious choices, and everything exceeded our expectations. The service was exceptional, and the atmosphere was perfect for our celebration. A huge thank you to our talented neighbors for making our event unforgettable!

Lisa S

Since Hamilton's is one of my absolute favorite places in Brooklyn, I was really excited to find out that they were opening another sister restaurant that was close to where I live. I got a chance to stop in last weekend for brunch, and I wasn't surprised that this restaurant is just like Hamilton's and Alchemy. It has a nice ambiance, and the food and drinks are fabulous. The service here is splendid as well. They have a good-sized menu, which is similar to Hamilton's, and the prices are reasonable. Hilltop Tavern is a great addition to the Windsor Terrace neighborhood, and I wish the team the best of luck at this location! I will definitely be back in the near future.

Natalia Paulino - Realtor

Stopped here for lunch with my client. We really enjoyed the atmosphere. Great playlist!! The food was perfect. Our waitress was fabulous. We'll be back for sure!!

Sam Escobar

My new favorite restaurant in New York! It opened recently and I’ve already been there twice: Once on Valentine’s Day, which was really lovely—despite being super busy, the service was fast and the food was perfect. Also, I am forever grateful for a dedicated mocktail menu, especially in park slope where that feature is surprisingly rare; nearly every place I looked at exclusively had wine or cocktail pairings for V’Day, which is a bit of a bummer if you don’t drink. The ambiance is warm, inviting, and romantic and the church pews around the outer edges are such a cool touch. The food was fantastic—we had the burrata and little gem salad as starters, the free range chicken au jus and chicken schnitzel as mains, and the skillet brownie and brioche bread pudding for dessert. For drinks, we did a blackberry-like spritzer and raspberry lemonade. Everything was so, so good. I’d go into more detail but I’m not great at articulating specifics on food, so I’ll just summarize the meal and say it was *chef’s kiss* perfect. I liked it so much that I went back for brunch three days later, which is when I ordered the brioche French toast, which was the most incredible, fluffy French toast I’ve ever had. I’m usually more of a waffle or pancake person, honestly, but I’d choose this over those any day. Our server was really nice and super attentive, and honestly everyone who works there has such good style (not that this would impact my rating, lol, but yknow…just noting that it’s a particularly cool spot). We had the warm caramel “blind date” cake for dessert with ice cream and it was absurdly good. All in all, 10/10 will come back (probably next week).

Joe Castagna

Had a great brunch here, got the Swiss breakfast which is a little out of my normal wheelhouse but was very good. My partner got the French toast which we shared and was absolutely delicious! The bartender also know how to pour a proper Guinness pint as well.

Amy Hanen

All the charm and class as Hamiltons, and place is just a perfect addition to the neighborhood. Chicken sandwich is a fave, as is the Date cake 😍. Feels like the perfect neighborhood spot. Don’t skip it.

Juan Oropeza

Great experience in the neighborhood, came for brunch and everything was delicious. Will be coming back!

Daniel Myer

Great spot for breakfast. Had a nice family gathering and loved it.

Everything about Hilltop Tavern is fantastic. Delicious and generous servings, expertly prepared. Friendly service and a warm environment. Both indoor and outdoor seating. Highly recommended, you will be very happy!

Very nice space, stopped in to sit at the bar and have a quick drink before meeting up with a friend. Staff was so friendly. Will be back soon!

Angela T

Very nice space, stopped in to sit at the bar and have a quick drink before meeting up with a friend. Staff was so friendly. Will be back soon!

Charles Olson

Everything about Hilltop Tavern is fantastic. Delicious and generous servings, expertly prepared. Friendly service and a warm environment. Both indoor and outdoor seating. Highly recommended, you will be very happy!

This place is an ideal spot for brunch. They have ample seating options, both indoors and outdoors. The staff were incredibly friendly.

Thehungryboo

This place is an ideal spot for brunch. They have ample seating options, both indoors and outdoors. The staff were incredibly friendly.

Reservation for three on a weeknight, we had only mains and non-alcoholic drinks. All aspects were fine except for an odd exchange with the waiter. I requested a side of bread with my pasta; he responded that “it is not available”. I made it clear that I wasn’t asking for “free” bread but he returned that “we don’t do that here.” This is odd to me because the dinner menu includes burgers, fish tacos, and a chicken sandwich and yet a slice of bread isn’t available for me to eat with my pasta? Really? Two star deduction!

It was a very windy and chilly day last Tuesday. I decided to have brunch around the corner from my doctor's office. I ordered the Turkey Burger w/Truffle Fries and an Arnold Palmer. The Platter also came with a salad. I especially loved the burger because it was fully dressed and also had carmelized onions on top. So delicious and filling!

Mark Long

Reservation for three on a weeknight, we had only mains and non-alcoholic drinks. All aspects were fine except for an odd exchange with the waiter. I requested a side of bread with my pasta; he responded that “it is not available”. I made it clear that I wasn’t asking for “free” bread but he returned that “we don’t do that here.” This is odd to me because the dinner menu includes burgers, fish tacos, and a chicken sandwich and yet a slice of bread isn’t available for me to eat with my pasta? Really? Two star deduction!

ambience is inviting and family friendly, however the food was slightly disappointing. had the truffle ricotta and olive appetizer and that was pretty tasty, but the croque monsieur and the recommended cheeseburger with fries were mediocre. hoped for better...

Michael Cheng

ambience is inviting and family friendly, however the food was slightly disappointing. had the truffle ricotta and olive appetizer and that was pretty tasty, but the croque monsieur and the recommended cheeseburger with fries were mediocre. hoped for better...

Tried this place twice. My thoughts are… They have a nice decor. Ordered a popular drink and my favorite, aperol spritz. They don’t make it🫤 Not a lot on the menu for vegetarians. Some items a bit pricey. Service was slow and had a bit of an attitude. Waited too long for them to come back, while sitting there with empty plates and beverages. Tends to get loud inside. Looking for another go to neighborhood restaurant.

This place has an extremely lovely atmosphere but the food was super disappointing. Everything we ordered was drenched in oil and not in a fun way. The arugula squash starter literally tasted like canola oil and nothing else. My raviolis were swimming in oil and had absolutely no flavor. My bf got a burger served on an untoasted and stale bun. I don’t leave reviews often but feel compelled here because literally every part of the meal was bad.

Aviva Levin

This place has an extremely lovely atmosphere but the food was super disappointing. Everything we ordered was drenched in oil and not in a fun way. The arugula squash starter literally tasted like canola oil and nothing else. My raviolis were swimming in oil and had absolutely no flavor. My bf got a burger served on an untoasted and stale bun. I don’t leave reviews often but feel compelled here because literally every part of the meal was bad.

Anthony Venegas

The food is as cheap as it can be purchased. Everything is hammered. Beer was flat. Servers have been super kind hence the 2 stars.

victoria schell

Tried this place twice. My thoughts are… They have a nice decor. Ordered a popular drink and my favorite, aperol spritz. They don’t make it🫤 Not a lot on the menu for vegetarians. Some items a bit pricey. Service was slow and had a bit of an attitude. Waited too long for them to come back, while sitting there with empty plates and beverages. Tends to get loud inside. Looking for another go to neighborhood restaurant.

Let this not stick here. I'll put it on seamless also! THIS PLACE IS UNACCEPTABLE! High prices and if you order you get less then what you would get in the restaurant! DON'T OFFER TAKE OUT THEN! My spicy Rigatoni box was a quarter empy! And the burger still had a heartbeat! Also how do you sell a Bloody Mary when you have a 100 year old law no hard liquor being served across the street from a church! NO BABY JUICE!!

scott

Let this not stick here. I'll put it on seamless also! THIS PLACE IS UNACCEPTABLE! High prices and if you order you get less then what you would get in the restaurant! DON'T OFFER TAKE OUT THEN! My spicy Rigatoni box was a quarter empy! And the burger still had a heartbeat! Also how do you sell a Bloody Mary when you have a 100 year old law no hard liquor being served across the street from a church! NO BABY JUICE!!

Wasn't greeted and waiter walked right past us. Bartender had to tell waiter to greet us who said just get a seat anywhere. Was given menus and water without glasses. Waited 22+ minutes for service next to a table that hadn't been cleared since we had passed the restaurant looking for parking. Food looked good, but we couldn't try it. A, what I assume was manager, askes the table ahead of us how everything was- but ignored us- who had our menus closed and to the side of the table- a clear sign that we were ready to order. I hate to post this but that was ridiculous! Will change review if I ever get to try the food.

Kaitlyn Patras

Wasn't greeted and waiter walked right past us. Bartender had to tell waiter to greet us who said just get a seat anywhere. Was given menus and water without glasses. Waited 22+ minutes for service next to a table that hadn't been cleared since we had passed the restaurant looking for parking. Food looked good, but we couldn't try it. A, what I assume was manager, askes the table ahead of us how everything was- but ignored us- who had our menus closed and to the side of the table- a clear sign that we were ready to order. I hate to post this but that was ridiculous! Will change review if I ever get to try the food.