dena strong

Italian Affair is our go to when we get together with family and friends. We celebrate birthdays, graduations and life with them 🥳 We love the pizza and the atmosphere. Their prices are more than fair considering how large the 🍕 pizzas are. We have been patrons for 20 years.

Elizabeth Lamb

We travel a lot, and this is THE BEST pizza we've ever found! The crust is perfect, sauce tasty and they are not stingy with the cheese. We've never gotten just a slice though-always order our own and take the rest home. There isn't much ambiance to the place, but the pizza is wonderful and staff is kind. We'll miss this place!

Terri Linn

Wowzer our first time at this restaurant, deliciousness all in one sitting, pricing was perfect for single income family, atmosphere was quite and reserved. I recommend their menu, its hands down 100% better in quality, quanity and very flavorful plus their drinks are tasty in comparison to other local / nation-wide chain restaurants 🍕🍕🍕 in the Texoma Tri-Plex area.

Eric Harp

BEST PIZZA IN THE WHOLE ENTIRE WORLD HANDS DOWN!!!!!!!!!!!!!! This place is awesome. It has been awesome since it was in the Midway Mall. The staff is great. The pizza is to die for. I HIGHLY recommend checking this place out if you are in town. Absolutely amazing food and the price is awesome. Thank you guys.

If you're looking for new York style pizza in the area, this is the place. The building itself inside and out are definitely dated, but it reminds me of pizzerias back in the day in NY. The pizza itself was great, we also had the spaghetti and meatballs which weren't so great. There wasn't really any flavor to it. But we will definitely be back for the pizza

B Darling

Not to shabby. Pizza had very little sag nice and crispy crust. Reasonable price

Charles Otis

I really wanted to like this pizza. Everything about it was great, the shop, the people, the prices, etc. But, I got a large sausage, and it was so salty it was nearly inedible. Everything else was amazing, and I'd absolutely try a pepperoni or supreme. The sausage portion on the pizza was very generous but either the sausage itself or the sauce or combination was just so salty I left half the pizza to the garbage. I'm willing to bet other pies are really good or it was just a mistake in that particular batch, but I can't say what I ordered was 'good'.

Jason Baldridge

I’ve been eating this pizza since I was a teenager. I went to Midway Mall. We ordered slices of this pizza. It moved to Woods street. It’s local staple. It’s a thinner crust, but it’s magic. It’s not crunchy crackers and cheese. It’s crisp, and a tad doughy. I like it. If you want pizza that’s not a chain, visit these folks. It’s priced well.

Brihan Browne

Quick, and tasty no frills atmosphere but the pizza is full of love. The crust is 👌perfection.

Very disappointed. If you advertise that you close at 8 PM, you should be serving food until 8 PM. Stopping at 7:30 PM on a Friday night makes no sense for a pizza place. If you want to close at 7:30, then change your posted business hours. The chairs were already up on the tables and most of the lights were off at 7:34 PM. This used to be one of my favorite restaurants, but it’s clearly not what it used to be.

J S

Pizza is the best in Sherman but the restaurant is filthy and disgusting. The ice machine hasn't been cleaned in a long time. There's mold where the ice comes out. I dont know how the health inspector doesn't stop by more often

Charles Russell

Gotta say this place used to be good for mall pizza. Now I've got to amend my thought. Just tried to order at 19:32. They close at 20:00. The person who answered the phone informed me that they quit taking orders at seven thirty. So effectively they close at 7:30pm. They don't seem too concerned with selling a pizza. Good luck to you folks. I won't be back, and I suggest everyone who follows me take note. You already close at 8 which is early. Now employees are shortening the hours another half hour. I hope the owner sees this because it really was a good place at one time. Pizza Inn just a few blocks away would be a much better choice for now. Edit: I wish the owner cared about this place. It used to be good. Tonight, phone of the hook from 7:15 to 7:28. After 2 minutes of ringing, they answered and said "we had to quit taking orders tonight. We just got too busy.". So, owner, you could make more money by getting rid of this crew and hiring people who want to work. Anyone considering coming here, not worth your time or money until this service issue gets fixed. Sad.