Castleton Farm-to-Bagel

Farm to Bagel catered my daughter's graduation party, and I couldn't be happier with their service. The food was not only fresh and delicious but also perfectly suited to the occasion. Casey was incredibly helpful, working closely with me to ensure we had just the right amount of everything. I highly recommend Farm to Bagel. Thank you Casey!

It was my first time trying this place and I just have to say it was amazing! I am gluten sensitive so I was looking at the gluten free options and there was a large selection and I felt like a kid in a candy store. Then there was a lady who was sitting down who happened to be the owner who mentioned they have gluten free apple pie. Delicious! Then I saw gluten free pop tarts on the menu so I got one of those as well. This is definitely something I have never seen homemade and it was great. Gluten free or not you wouldn’t be able to tell by the taste! The owner Casey (not sure of spelling) was super nice and we chatted while my food was heating. Then she told me she has gluten free frozen empanadas that need to be heated. I have to say I was ecstatic because the only place on the island that I heard had gluten free empanadas had very limited hours and wound up closing. Anyways they were chicken empanadas and she mentioned they had a little kick. I have to say most of the time I don’t order chicken because it doesn’t have enough flavor to be but with these had the perfect amount of flavor and the dough used surrounding it was also delicious. I am not the best cook so when I heated it at home and flipped it I did break it but that’s my fault. I honestly think this should be a menu staple with beef and chicken options possibly. Just a recommendation. I know I am ranting a bit, but it was so good and I highly recommend trying. I’m sure it will not disappoint. Near or far it’s worth the trip.

I’m new to Farm To Bagel and I’m glad I came across this establishment. The staff is extremely friendly, atmosphere is cool and more importantly the food is excellent. I can buy a breakfast sandwich at a wide array of deli’s but if you’re looking for freshness than stop by Farm To Bagel. Nice variety of menu items as well.

As long time S&T customers, we've been searching for a replacement, and this is it. As far as I can tell, this is one of the few local bagel places that gets the nice exterior crunch and soft inside :) I'd say maybe the bagels (and the veggie cream cheese) are a notch less good than S&T, but very happy to have found this place.

Great food; literally from (the New Jersey farm) to table. Cozy atmosphere with kind and attentive staff -- highly recommended!

Sean Kelly

Great food; literally from (the New Jersey farm) to table. Cozy atmosphere with kind and attentive staff -- highly recommended!

Robert Dicks

Just had the big al Panini and I have to say it was amazing. Great food, great service. Great atmosphere. I'm definitely coming back

Ann

The food is delicious and staff is very friendly. Very happy I found my new spot.

Christopher Balakrishnan

As long time S&T customers, we've been searching for a replacement, and this is it. As far as I can tell, this is one of the few local bagel places that gets the nice exterior crunch and soft inside :) I'd say maybe the bagels (and the veggie cream cheese) are a notch less good than S&T, but very happy to have found this place.

Joe

I’m new to Farm To Bagel and I’m glad I came across this establishment. The staff is extremely friendly, atmosphere is cool and more importantly the food is excellent. I can buy a breakfast sandwich at a wide array of deli’s but if you’re looking for freshness than stop by Farm To Bagel. Nice variety of menu items as well.

Lauren

Nice menu selection with some gluten free and healthy options. Ordered the avocado toast which was delicious and the staff was friendly and helpful. I'm looking forward to returning to try their smoothies, jam, hash and paninis.

Lets go Cowboys

This place is awesome! First of all it is the ONLY place i know of that sells eggs straight from the farm. They also sell homemade jellies and sauces. Secondly they make their own bagels. We get toasted everything bagels with vegetable cream cheese and they are delicious! Not too doughy and nice and crispy. Today I tried their orange cranberry muffin and it was also delish. They have a counter seating area if you want to eat there and also deliver. Lastly, staff is very friendly and someone always acknowledges you when you walk in which is such a nice change vs. other places. Love these small businesses and hope others do too, so go check it out!!

Susan Sangiorgi

Farm to Bagel catered my daughter's graduation party, and I couldn't be happier with their service. The food was not only fresh and delicious but also perfectly suited to the occasion. Casey was incredibly helpful, working closely with me to ensure we had just the right amount of everything. I highly recommend Farm to Bagel. Thank you Casey!

A. Flores

I have been to both locations a few times now and have had very pleasant experiences. It is a gluten free heaven with so many options you won’t know what to do with yourself. The freshness of the food is evident in how it looks and how it tastes yet it is still very affordable. They cook everything in front of you and you can see how clean the staff keep the kitchen. Anyways, the reason I am writing this review today is in response to my experience today at 11am. Karen served me and she was just wonderful- incredibly hospitable, personable and patient. She embodied the atmosphere and energy of the business, so much so you’d think she’s the owner. Furthermore, the chef (didn’t get his name) was notably refined in his culinary skills and I have to say, he cooked our grilled cheese/ egg sandwich significantly better than the other location. Ps. Huge thank you to the business for the first responder/ veteran discount!!! I noticed it today for the first time and will definitely continue to be a regular customer thanks to the customer service I received today, as well as the law enforcement appreciation.

WonderManUltra

This restaurant is amazing. The food was delicious and fresh. The chicken and waffles was delicious. The chicken was juicy and cooked to perfection. The Belgian waffles were warm fluffy and delicious. The bagel with cream cheese was yummy. I loved it also their muffins are spectacular. It was a very fresh muffin Delicious. There’s smoothies and fresh juices are also amazing. Very delicious. My favorite flavor was the detox flavor and the delivery driver was a sweetheart. Very kind very respectful. This place is amazing 10 out of 10.😁

Gab O

I’ve been on and off gluten free for years. But recently I had to go back because of my thyroid. My husband found this place online so we went today and I couldn’t be more happy. The food was fantastic and the service was even better. The people who work there are so kind and helpful. I can’t wait to go back and grab some more muffins and bagels. You can’t even tell that they are gluten free!! I found my new favorite spot.

Devon Giddings

This place is the best thing to hit this side of the Island in a looooooonngggg time. The Gluten free options are endless. I just left work and rushed to get the Gluten Free Fried Chicken. I’m still licking my fingers because of the hot honey. The atmosphere is great, portion sizes are good, and the people that work there are amazing and friendly. I plan to frequent this establishment 2-3 times a week. There’s something for everyone!

I am a fan of Farm to Bagel...I have Celiac and the GF options are amazing! However, in my last 2 visits, including today, they made my food on the gluten grill. I had to point it out to them to remake it. Which they did, no problem...but what if someone who didn't know ate the food? I sent my sister from Boston there, she'd have no idea! That'd be a fine ride back home! Please, Farm to Bagel, do a better.job educating the staff!!! We GF-ers depend on you!

Maureen Fisher

I am a fan of Farm to Bagel...I have Celiac and the GF options are amazing! However, in my last 2 visits, including today, they made my food on the gluten grill. I had to point it out to them to remake it. Which they did, no problem...but what if someone who didn't know ate the food? I sent my sister from Boston there, she'd have no idea! That'd be a fine ride back home! Please, Farm to Bagel, do a better.job educating the staff!!! We GF-ers depend on you!

This place is okay, but the prices are CRAZY. 21 dollars for an omlette? Lol. I didn't even have coffee. Funny I didn't see the free deals with the outside that day. Thats the first sign of business doing bad. LOWER your prices. 21 dollars and it's not even a diner.

Steve Leyland

This place is okay, but the prices are CRAZY. 21 dollars for an omlette? Lol. I didn't even have coffee. Funny I didn't see the free deals with the outside that day. Thats the first sign of business doing bad. LOWER your prices. 21 dollars and it's not even a diner.

Hi, if you are vegan please note I have tried multiple times to go here, or even call ahead of visiting, and they never have the vegan options listed on their menu. Extremely disappointing, they do NOT have the vegan items they advertise. Do not go there for that.

Francesca Bernhardt

Hi, if you are vegan please note I have tried multiple times to go here, or even call ahead of visiting, and they never have the vegan options listed on their menu. Extremely disappointing, they do NOT have the vegan items they advertise. Do not go there for that.

The guy behind the grill consistently gets my order wrong. It’s genuinely disappointing because I want to support this business. 3 times in a row I’ve asked for something off the menu, it’s bagged up before I see the bag, and it’s something entirely different. Other than that, the hot bar items and salads are excellent. Baked goods are great. Jams and marmalade are great. Just becoming frustrated with the made to order food.

Cliff Jackson

The guy behind the grill consistently gets my order wrong. It’s genuinely disappointing because I want to support this business. 3 times in a row I’ve asked for something off the menu, it’s bagged up before I see the bag, and it’s something entirely different. Other than that, the hot bar items and salads are excellent. Baked goods are great. Jams and marmalade are great. Just becoming frustrated with the made to order food.

Ordered 2 BLTS 2 smoothies and some curly fries, came out to 78 dollars? Then when I asked the girl for a receipt to see my total she told me “it blew away in the wind” food was disappointing, service on the phone was awful, rude and impatient staff on the phone taking orders. Stay away from this place. Plenty of great delis on the island that will actually satisfy you for HALF the price.

They claim farm to bagel but why was everything was slap together, processed prepare just a waste of my money. I ordered a eggplant parmigiana and sausage and peppers and onions and it was cold and hard.

Janice Johnson

They claim farm to bagel but why was everything was slap together, processed prepare just a waste of my money. I ordered a eggplant parmigiana and sausage and peppers and onions and it was cold and hard.

The Lion

Ordered 2 BLTS 2 smoothies and some curly fries, came out to 78 dollars? Then when I asked the girl for a receipt to see my total she told me “it blew away in the wind” food was disappointing, service on the phone was awful, rude and impatient staff on the phone taking orders. Stay away from this place. Plenty of great delis on the island that will actually satisfy you for HALF the price.

J. Ramos

Needs inspection, no rotation or proper handling of prepared food, no proper certification of food handling non exposed for clients safety, and inexperienced staff training to achieve proper services to paying customers. The owner was advised about this, but the owner has no background in the food industry.