Crestwood Pizzeria & Restaurant

This place is amazing the best food around here and service especially when you take out, always hot and on time

I was waiting at the train station and hungry, saw this place was open. Pizza was surprisingly good. Best slice I had in a while. I’ll order an entire pie next time.

Hardest working guys in the pizza business. Great pizza shop right off of the Crestwood Metro-North station. Small place, but big on food. Super friendly staff. Great selection of pizza, pasta, rolls, and appetizers. One of the best places for calamari. Calzones are great. They get super busy at times, so there might be a wait but it's worth it. They do their best to get it out as fast as they can and are friendly the whole time. You can't go wrong with this place.

WOW. I called a few days in advance to order some catering trays as we were coming in from out of town. Spoke w the owner John who despite being busy ran down all my options and prices. Great. Order placed. (Bunch of pasta trays.) Walked in and he greeted everyone by name. EVERYONE. And knew their orders too. It's a pizza place, small, but clean. I thought, maybe we should have just ordered the pizza as it looked amazing. Second guessing myself, we packed up our food and went back to the hotel. Enough to feed a great crowd, and it was delicious. Everyone kept asking how I found such a great place in Tuckahoe and I followed the reviews. If you do, you will not be sorry. Thank you John and team for taking such good care of our team.

We have have our favorite neighborhood pizzeria back home in NYC but the pizza here at Crestwood is just as good. As a matter of fact, everything we had ordered: pepperoni pizza, penne vodka, wings and calamari. All tasted amazing. So glad we decided to order from this restaurant and look forward to trying their other foods the next time we’re back in the area.

Excellent pizza, Excellent service, Excellent communication. Our lacrosse team traveled from LI to play a game, after placing my order that morning Joe called to confirm the details, the delivery was on time, the girls loved the pizza & garlic knots, thank you for making this an easy team dinner.

Genuinely great food and exceptionally kind, no attitude customer service. The owner, John, is lovely - A+! And don’t be afraid to ask for customized pizzas - they will do to your specifications. This is your hometown, Friday night cozy pizza takeout place!

j o

Buffalo pizza was on point. Will be going back here.

Jonathan Sonnenberg

I was waiting at the train station and hungry, saw this place was open. Pizza was surprisingly good. Best slice I had in a while. I’ll order an entire pie next time.

John Mitonino

This place is amazing the best food around here and service especially when you take out, always hot and on time

Antonio Rogliano

Love their pizza. Whenever I’m in a rush to get on the train they rush to get a slice for me hahah. Theyre great

Alexandria Hercules

The best pizza around. Perfect crust and cheesy! The gnocchi Alfredo was spot on and the garlic knots are perfect! My new favorite pizza place 😊

Dana Colbert

Excellent pizza, Excellent service, Excellent communication. Our lacrosse team traveled from LI to play a game, after placing my order that morning Joe called to confirm the details, the delivery was on time, the girls loved the pizza & garlic knots, thank you for making this an easy team dinner.

Francis Averilla

We have have our favorite neighborhood pizzeria back home in NYC but the pizza here at Crestwood is just as good. As a matter of fact, everything we had ordered: pepperoni pizza, penne vodka, wings and calamari. All tasted amazing. So glad we decided to order from this restaurant and look forward to trying their other foods the next time we’re back in the area.

John Carbone

Hardest working guys in the pizza business. Great pizza shop right off of the Crestwood Metro-North station. Small place, but big on food. Super friendly staff. Great selection of pizza, pasta, rolls, and appetizers. One of the best places for calamari. Calzones are great. They get super busy at times, so there might be a wait but it's worth it. They do their best to get it out as fast as they can and are friendly the whole time. You can't go wrong with this place.

Andrew McDevitt

WOW. I called a few days in advance to order some catering trays as we were coming in from out of town. Spoke w the owner John who despite being busy ran down all my options and prices. Great. Order placed. (Bunch of pasta trays.) Walked in and he greeted everyone by name. EVERYONE. And knew their orders too. It's a pizza place, small, but clean. I thought, maybe we should have just ordered the pizza as it looked amazing. Second guessing myself, we packed up our food and went back to the hotel. Enough to feed a great crowd, and it was delicious. Everyone kept asking how I found such a great place in Tuckahoe and I followed the reviews. If you do, you will not be sorry. Thank you John and team for taking such good care of our team.

Arvyn Gutierrez

Pizza is awesome. Customer service is great. They value treating you right and offering good quality food. Hands down the best Broccoli and Mushroom pizza no matter where you from. You won't be disappointed.

CA Davis

Genuinely great food and exceptionally kind, no attitude customer service. The owner, John, is lovely - A+! And don’t be afraid to ask for customized pizzas - they will do to your specifications. This is your hometown, Friday night cozy pizza takeout place!

zawgurn

Great Pizza good for a quick bite and inexpensive. Plus the Pizza is large for a low price so you get a good value. People there are very nice as well. Try my best to go once a week

Right across from the Crestwood train station, this family-run pizzeria is as local as it gets. In a town with deep Italian roots, Crestwood Pizza is the kind of spot where everyone on the street is carrying their pizza boxes, and the owners know half the customers by name. Inside, it’s organized chaos—the kind only a busy, well-loved pizza place can have. The staff move like fighting a war (because they are), yet still calm as just another regular day for them. Despite the rush, they’re friendly, efficient, and warm. The pizzas are classic New York style or Sicilian style. The single slices are pre-made and warmed up, but still come out tasting great. Fair prices, generous portions, and an atmosphere full of neighborhood charm make this a spot I’ll keep coming back to. Whether you’re hopping off the train or just craving a solid slice, it’s a dependable local gem.

Great pizza and fantastic rolls. Very delicious cheese pizza. Reasonable prices. Conveniently across from Crestwood MetroNorth station. Metered street parking. Cash and credit are both accepted. Dine in available. 11/2022

Our annual tradition for Halloween is to go to Eastchester for trick-or-treating. We always get Crestwood pizza for everyone there. Located across from the Tuckahoe train station. Conveniently located for Eastchester and Tuckahoe residents. Always hot and fresh. I love the mozzarella they use. Looking forward to next Halloween to get sone good New York pizza.

Yunong Shi

Right across from the Crestwood train station, this family-run pizzeria is as local as it gets. In a town with deep Italian roots, Crestwood Pizza is the kind of spot where everyone on the street is carrying their pizza boxes, and the owners know half the customers by name. Inside, it’s organized chaos—the kind only a busy, well-loved pizza place can have. The staff move like fighting a war (because they are), yet still calm as just another regular day for them. Despite the rush, they’re friendly, efficient, and warm. The pizzas are classic New York style or Sicilian style. The single slices are pre-made and warmed up, but still come out tasting great. Fair prices, generous portions, and an atmosphere full of neighborhood charm make this a spot I’ll keep coming back to. Whether you’re hopping off the train or just craving a solid slice, it’s a dependable local gem.

Space Dandy

Great pizza and fantastic rolls. Very delicious cheese pizza. Reasonable prices. Conveniently across from Crestwood MetroNorth station. Metered street parking. Cash and credit are both accepted. Dine in available. 11/2022

Andrew Izzo

Our annual tradition for Halloween is to go to Eastchester for trick-or-treating. We always get Crestwood pizza for everyone there. Located across from the Tuckahoe train station. Conveniently located for Eastchester and Tuckahoe residents. Always hot and fresh. I love the mozzarella they use. Looking forward to next Halloween to get sone good New York pizza.

We got a meatball wedge (sub sandwich), pepperoni roll and 2 lobster ravioli. First, their prices aren't listed. They seemed to charge whatever they wanted (i.e., more if you are from out of town). I think they charged me $5 to $10 more ($50 on a $40 to $45 bill). As for the food. The meatball wedge was good. The pepperoni roll was very good, but a bit small. The lobster ravioli had a red sauce, which surprised and slightly disappointed my wife. Also, only about 5 ravioli in each dish. She said it was OK tasting. So, I don't think I would go back because of the unethical pricing. Overall, I am disappointed by them.

Chuck H.

We got a meatball wedge (sub sandwich), pepperoni roll and 2 lobster ravioli. First, their prices aren't listed. They seemed to charge whatever they wanted (i.e., more if you are from out of town). I think they charged me $5 to $10 more ($50 on a $40 to $45 bill). As for the food. The meatball wedge was good. The pepperoni roll was very good, but a bit small. The lobster ravioli had a red sauce, which surprised and slightly disappointed my wife. Also, only about 5 ravioli in each dish. She said it was OK tasting. So, I don't think I would go back because of the unethical pricing. Overall, I am disappointed by them.

I ordered Penne Vodka with chicken cutlet and buffalo wings. The penne barely had flavor and any sauce. Wings where the same no flavor , I expected it to be better after looking at the reviews. For the price I would go to another pizzeria

Just wanted to share that today, 2/7/26, my 15 yo son went into this pizzeria while airing for me to pick him up- we live 10 minutes away. Tried to buy a soda but his debit card would not work for some reason. The employee a Male Hispanic threw him out because he didn’t buy anything and made him wait outside in feels like -14 weather til I got there. Btw the place was empty when I got there. I understand that you may not want kids hanging around if they are not purchasing but on a cold day like today he could have let him wait there the less than 10 minutes it took me to get there.My son and I have been there a few times in the past food is nothing to rave about and I used to be in the Pizza business for many years. I hope nobody thinks this is a nice family place because it’s obviously Not. Luckily for the employee my son told me what happened once we were almost home. Just food for thought… No Humanity Here !!!

Anthony Tirado

I ordered Penne Vodka with chicken cutlet and buffalo wings. The penne barely had flavor and any sauce. Wings where the same no flavor , I expected it to be better after looking at the reviews. For the price I would go to another pizzeria