Menu
Lily's Babylon
PosDo

© 2026 PosDo · v3.0

Babylon

Lily's Babylon

★★★★ 4.3 · 100 reseñas

Bienvenidos a Lily's Babylon, un rincón acogedor donde disfrutar de la mejor comida americana con un toque irlandés, todo ello en un ambiente de taberna de antaño. Con nuestras ofertas de cerveza, la música de nuestros DJs los fines de semana y la retransmisión de tus eventos dep...

Lily's Babylon

American · Babylon

4.3 · 1,046 reviews Google

Deals available

Be flexible, save more

Be flexible, save more

www.lilyflanaganspub.com
Yelp 3.5 (184) TripAdvisor 4.1 (69) Uber Eats 4.5 (31)

About Lily's Babylon

Bienvenidos a Lily's Babylon, un rincón acogedor donde disfrutar de la mejor comida americana con un toque irlandés, todo ello en un ambiente de taberna de antaño. Con nuestras ofertas de cerveza, la música de nuestros DJs los fines de semana y la retransmisión de tus eventos deportivos favoritos, t...

Bienvenidos a Lily's Babylon, un rincón acogedor donde disfrutar de la mejor comida americana con un toque irlandés, todo ello en un ambiente de taberna de antaño. Con nuestras ofertas de cerveza, la música de nuestros DJs los fines de semana y la retransmisión de tus eventos deportivos favoritos, te invitamos a vivir momentos inolvidables. ¡Te esperamos en Babylon con los brazos abiertos!

What Customers Say About Lily's Babylon

Lily's Babylon is a popular spot known for its friendly staff, flavorful American cuisine, and lively atmosphere. Many reviewers rave about the attentive service, especially highlighting staff members like Alana, Holly, and Yari. The restaurant is a favorite for both casual meals and special events.

Popular Dishes

short ribs Baja fish tacos steak sandwich Nachos Prime Rib Mushroom and Swiss Burger mozzarella sticks potato soup

Best For

Groups Families Celebrations Casual

Tip: Visit on Wednesday, Thursday, or Friday for specials. Be aware that service can be slow when crowded or understaffed.

Features

📶 WiFi 🌳 Outdoor 🅿️ Parking 🚗 Delivery Accessible 🌅 Breakfast 🍽️ Lunch 🌙 Dinner 🥗 Vegetarian Coffee
🎯 Casual 🛋️ Cozy Trendy 👨‍👩‍👧 Family 👥 Groups

Frequently asked questions about Lily's Babylon

Lily's Babylon is located at 345 Deer Park Ave, Babylon, NY 11702, Babylon.
Lily's Babylon offers american cuisine.
Lily's Babylon has regular opening hours. Check their profile for updated schedules.
Lily's Babylon offers the following services: dine-in, takeaway, delivery.
The most recommended dishes at Lily's Babylon based on customer reviews are: short ribs, Baja fish tacos, steak sandwich, Nachos, Prime Rib.
Lily's Babylon is ideal for groups, families, celebrations, casual dining.
Lily's Babylon is a popular spot known for its friendly staff, flavorful American cuisine, and lively atmosphere. Many reviewers rave about the attentive service, especially highlighting staff members like Alana, Holly, and Yari. The restaurant is a favorite for both casual meals and special events.
Visit on Wednesday, Thursday, or Friday for specials. Be aware that service can be slow when crowded or understaffed.
1,046
Reviews

Lily's Babylon Babylon Reviews

4.3
1,046
5★
59%
4★
25%
3★
7%
2★
3%
1★
5%
Reviews (100)
S
Sir Thrasher

The place was awesome. The service, Food & atmosphere was fantastic. There is not 1 thing bad I can say about this place. The guest enjoyed and loved the room that we had for our party. If your looking for a great place Lily's is the place to go to. Also the price was fair.

N
Natasha Lamoury-Ferris

I just had my baby shower in the upstairs room this past weekend at Lily’s. We had about 70 people and it was amazing. From speaking to the catering manager, Nicole to the servers at our party. Everyone was amazing. My guests are still RAVING about the food. We had the penne a la vodka (probably one of the best I’ve had), chicken francese and salmon Florentine. We also added vegetables and potatoes for an additional charge and I’m so happy we did. All my guest kept talking about was how good the potatoes were (lol) and I’m general how good the food was. The room looked beautiful once decorated too! It was so great that we are Probably going to see if we can have the baptism there too! Thank you so much!!

b
bob costello

Great place in Babylon. Staff and food is awesome. Noah is probably one of the best bartenders you will ever have. We are regulars.

D
Diana Brewster

I love Lily's. If it's a rare Tuesday I don't have my son I come here for karaoke but it is a restaurant so I can also try bringing my son sometimes. The food is good. I don't drink alcohol so I can only rate the food and service but Lily's is very good for both of those.

B
Brian Grant

Great food, and good for private parties

J
Jimmy EL

Came here with the wife for live music. The band was great. Bartenders were attentive and drinks were good. Ordered a chicken quesadilla as an app which was average. Will def be back for another happy hour/ music

L
Lisa Cellura

Had my sister's 40th birthday for 25 people last night, the waitress was on point the entire time in addition to her other tables, I wish I got here name to personally shout out some praise. I wasn't sure about the watermelon burrata salad or something else and she said "get it, you'll love it" and talked me into it, it was absolutely amazing...thank you. Great food, atmosphere and service. Nice job, well deserved five stars.

l
lord rom

I stopped in with my wife for a burger, they are delicious! Hand made, nice size, juicy, flavorful. Friday night the live bands are great. Awesome staff,great place to go for a bite/drink!

N
N N

We love coming to Lily’s. Grace is the absolute BEST! She’s warm, inviting and attentive. We look forward to the days she’s working to have her as our server! Thanks Grace xoxo

K
Klynnxo !

I went to a character brunch this morning (paw patrol) and was blow away with how good the food was! Best brunch I’ve ever been to.

J
Janette Dillon

Bartenders are great. Noah and Joe are friendly, funny and extremely attentive. Always a great time.

M
Marcy Carlin

How many times have I come to lilys to be greeted warmly and made to feel welcome. The staff is great. It doesnt just stop there. The food is fresh a d tasty. The new menu is out and i want to try everything .Football on Sundays is lots of fun with raffles also to win.

D
Doreen Lobasso

Just had a birthday dinner for my mom's 80th and can't say enough good things about my experience. Such great customer service with Damien (Manager)and Chris the chef. Chris went above and beyond to provide a great menu and setting for the evening. Nicole the catering manager was great to work with. A Big shout out to Will, who was our go to for everything that night (bartender, server etc)! He really had his hands full and did everything with a smile and no problem attitude. Everyone enjoyed their food and praised the staff. My Mom was so surprised and loved how casual and friendly everyone was. Thank you again to Everyone at Lily's!!

F
Frank Cox

Went to the Sunday Comedy Brunch. 100% will I recommend this event to all. The food was delicious, the comedians were great, and if you stick with the brunch cocktails (unlimited) it's $135 per couple which includes tax and tip. The event is 3 hours so it left us time to go downstairs and enjoy a few pints.

K
Kelly Douglas

We hosted a shower in the newly renovated Shannon Room upstairs at Lily's and it was perfect! The food was great and the staff was so helpful and attentive - they handled our large crowd with ease. Nicole was so easy to work with beforehand and helped put us at ease throughout the entire planning process. Would highly recommend! :)

E
Eileen Andreyev

Another successful shower held at Lily's. Food and service was excellent!

K
Kelly Johansen

This is my first time, but apparently they recently had a renovation and menu refresh. It shows- this place is great. We loved the patio, sliders, bang bang shrimp, and the cocktails. We plan on coming back very soon! Service was also great and attentive.

J
Jillian S

Held my sisters bridal shower here on 5/6/2023 in their room upstairs. The food was awesome, the service was incredible, the staff even helped out those who needed assistance with gifts. Nicole was great at helping us plan everything. It was the perfect party! I highly recommend having your next party/event here! I know my family will be keeping lily's in mind for the future!

T
Tai Vicari

LOVE this place. The food is great and I can drink my Guinness beer. Definitely a must for anyone who wants a taste of Ireland! 🇨🇮🍀🍻

M
Michelle Sinisi

I was very happy to return to what it was many moon ago, BARKERS. I was out for the block party n a friend said the food here is good..she was RIGHT. 3 of us had no complaints loved the mocktail selection which I did have, it was so good I had 2. I had to walk to the other side which brought back great memories at that bar from back in the day n nice to see no changes there. We so enjoyed ourselves we went back for dinner several days later..so glad my friend suggested to eat there..NOT DISAPPOINTED WITH ANYTHING..

V
Virginia Mulligan

It is always a pleasure to come to this place. The staff is very friendly, food is delicious and drinks are amazing! I brought my friends from the city to enjoy the boozy brunch and they all were surprised to visit this place. They have come another 3 times all the way from Manhattan to Lily's for dinner, boozy brunch, and lunch.

A
Artie Graniela

Had dinner yesterday at Lily’s ate Al Fresco, fantastic evening. From the moment we walked in the door the hostess Jen was so accommodating and pleasant to our server Anj (sp) the dinner could not have been better. Mind you the Village of Babylon was hosting their THURSDAY BLOCK PARTY SERIES so the village and Lily were packed but yet we felt valued as customers, our server never missed a beat tremendous. Of of the food and drinks are always outstanding, who knew you can get great empanadas at an Irish restaurant, well take it from me, OUTSTANDING. If you’ve never been you owe to yourself to give Lily’s a shot, I highly recommend it. Niall, you and your team are first rate! Also, a special shout out to Lisa, , thanks for the umbrella and welcome back you always do a great job!

M
Mike Lewis

They put together an excellent Thanksgiving buffet and spread.

J
Joseph Dertinger

Nice place run professionally and they have baked potato at 5:30 pm They didn't run out like some of the big named steak houses in nassau county

J
JANE DE

The food was so good! Buffet food was hot, tasted great and there was plenty !! The potatoes were excellent! The service was great! Everyone was super helpful and friendly! I look forward to returning soon!

A
Alfred Foote

Good food, good company great atmosphere and a proper Guinness.

M
Michael Brennan

Fantastic place! Great staff, great service, great food, great place to go

M
Michael Correa

I had my Fiances Surprise party upstairs, the 2 young ladies that worked the party were great, they helped me set up, the food was great, the room was very nice and clean. GREAT TIME, Thank you. Mike C.

C
Courtney Peterkin

Overall experience was nice. Went for a retirement party and it turned out well. Service was good, food was good, atmosphere was good.

N
Nivia Matos

Haven't gone to Lily's in some time. Living in the area it's one of the few places that upped their food and cocktail menu to please just about everyone in your family. The staff was both attentive and knowledgeable of what is in their menu. This time we had Cassie as our server. She was delightful IG @longisland_wine_dine

F
Frank Lynch

Had my pandemic wedding reception here. We go back every once in a while for dinner. The only problem with going here is that all of the food is amazing, so it takes my wife forever to choose what she wants to eat.

J
Jane A

Awesome experience great food amazing service by alana drinks were made perfectly early Valentines dinner A+

D
David S

Did you know "Half way to Saint Patrick's Day" is September 17th. Go to Lily Flanagan's on Sept 17 and get $5 taps and 17%off your bill! All while enjoying a nice meal, great wings, delish Bavarian Pretzels Octoberfest menu and with live music! Enjoy!

K
Kathy Miller

I recently had a baby shower for my daughter at Lily's. The staff, from the catering manager, Nicole, to the bartenders, (Alanna?) and wait staff were exceptional. They were constantly making sure everything was up to par and far exceeded that. The food was amazing and so many guests were surprised they had never been to Lily's prior. I am sure many of them will return on their own as it was an exceptional experience.

J
Joann Giambruno

Great times on Friday Happy Hours with great bands always have fun!! Country night Wednesdays are great and have lessons to learn line dancing!!! Nachos are amazing make sure you order!!

K
Kevin Jones

Food was amazing, service excellent, a little too noisy sitting in the dining room near the bar.

T
Tatiana Panova

Amazing places just with amazingly delicious food.I want to say a special thank you to Kasadi, this is a bartender ,for her care and good mood.I will definitely come back to this place.

T
Toby Music

Babylon Village has a ton of amazing places and this is just one of many. Great food and drinks. Grace was very nice and is an awesome server.

l
linda tarpinian

We were 330pm at the bar with a friend for happy hour lunch. Great deal. A musician arrived at 5pm, easy listening not too loud. Baked clams were whole and good. Quesadla was good too. I had a French dip with a side of veggies. My friend had the burger and crispy fries.

M
Mike G

Wife threw me a party here not too long ago and it was a great time. Everyone raved about the food (I guess they didn’t expect this caliber of cuisine from a place known as a pub?!?!) and the drinks were flowing and most importantly made appropriately for our type of party goers. My wife said the pricing pp was very reasonable as compared to what other similar establishments were offering her. I’ve been here many times in the past hanging at the bar or for dinner and I think Lily’s provides a great value and a great time. Highly recommend

M
Melissa Scarlata

All I can say is I am so sad that we didn't try this place sooner. Even my picky eaters loved this place. The food was absolutely DELICIOUS. They have a great Prix Fixe deal on the weekends too. The service was also great, our waitress was on top of things and the other staff as well. As soon as we cleared a plate, they took it. This will definitely be a frequent spot for us now on.

S
Savanna Flynn

I had booked Lily Flanagans Shannon Room for my daughters baptism. I was so excited that they had our date available as the room is so gorgeous!!! It is newly redone, bright and airy, with a big bar! I worked with Nicole from start to finish. She was super quick to respond and answered all of my questions. Unfortunately, we were unable to have my daughters baptism here because she got COVID 2 days before the event. Nicole completely went above and beyond for us in these unforeseeable circumstances. Her impeccable customer service went such a long way for my family and I, especially being such short notice. I would 100% recommend working with Lily Flanagans over and over again! Thank you so much Nicole and the rest of Lily Flanagans!

H
Holly Raudies

Every time I visit Lily's I'm reminded of why it's my go-to spot. Food is always on point. The vibe is laid-back and welcoming but gets very busy on the weekends making it perfect for a night out with friends! whether you're catching a game, celebrating with friends, or just having a great meal it's honestly the perfect place for any occasion!

H
H Cabrera1977

This place has by far the best Shepard's Pie I have ever had! It was recommended to me by people in the area and I decided hell yeah let's check them out and safe to say I'm glad I made it over here. The wait staff was great, courteous and very accommodating. If you're in the area for some really good food, especially Shepard's Pie you will not be disappointed.

R
Ronnie Simpson

Food was great place clean and our waitresses was great slso

m
maria bilardi

Came here to see my daughters band play and was so surprised that the food was really good. But even more than that our server Yari was beyond incredible. She served us better than any high end steak house. Sweet,, attentive, and so on the ball! Give her a raise!!!

K
Kalpa Taru

I didn’t get to take any pictures since it was jam packed. The pear ginger sparkler mocktail was awesome. Service was great. The live band made it a little noisy but folks were happy and enjoying it. Location is great - within few blocks of Lirr station. Give it a try.

K
Kenny Young Jr

Our first time eating here. I read online that they had good potato soup (I had a hankering) Firstly, we promptly greeted and shown to our seats. A lovely, young woman with an Irish accent was our server. She was helpful, polite, always close by if needed. Just an all-around great server. My girl had a ginormous salad with really yummy grilled chicken. And yes, I had the soup. We will be going back there. Sooner, rather than later.😊

W
Wilton C.

I booked the Harp room for a retirement party. Food was really good. Service was perfect. Very polite and attentive. I will recommend it to anyone needing a place to have a gathering.

John Jacoby
John Jacoby

This place has the best, best , best food. I love it. Anytime where in Town that's where I like to eat. We also went on a Friday night and there was a band and it was awesome. Very clean place and friendly staff. 😊

Helene Tsouprakos
Helene Tsouprakos

Another fun holiday party for my staff of 60. The food and drink were plentiful and delicious. The waitstaff did a great job keeping the drinks flowing and our plates full. Already thinking about next year!

Bea Angela De Leon
Bea Angela De Leon

We had our gender reveal party last weekend at Lily Flanagan’s. Highly recommended! Staff was friendly (shoutout to Holly, the catering events coordinator) and food was great! Thank you for making our event a memorable one!

Susan McPartland
Susan McPartland

Planning an event at Lily's was truly a breeze! Holly and her staff were communicative and helpful, the event staff were attentive and very friendly. The food was absolutely delicious and the Harp Room was the perfect size and setting for my needs.

Peter Noga
Peter Noga

Very friendly staff. Alana and Co. are always very attentive to everyone. Plenty of options when it comes to their meals and very flavorful. Friendly environment is an added bonus. Made this a weekly spot.

Sally Guan
Sally Guan

We cane for Brunch with bluey event. this is a phenomenal experience! My daughter was so happy to see bluey and don't want to leave the dancing floor. Food comes with different varieties.

Deborah Kelley
Deborah Kelley

We did our wedding luau celebration Sept 13. From booking with Holly to the end of the night everything was perfect. Holly explained all our options and answered all our questions. The price was right the food superb, Anthony bartended for us and he was great. No one, and there was 50 of us, waited for a drink. He set water out and helped us hang decorations. Holly was also there the whole time and I'm sorry I didn't get the 2nd servers name, but everyone was fantastic. Lily's, that's your dream team. Anyone looking to book a party here, do it, you will not be disappointed!

Christina Cavero
Christina Cavero

Was there for a benefit dinner. Food was amazing (had my bridal shower there too many years ago) they are always great, just wasn't a fan of the bartender the night we were there. It was as if we bothered her by ordering.

Alia K
Alia K

Got the Baja fish tacos, steak sandwich and Nachos- all were amazing. Server was really nice and the outside patio was a nice place to eat.

James Wood
James Wood

Excellent food and drinks! My wife and I started with some mozzarella sticks. For dinner we ordered the Prime Rib and a Mushroom and Swiss Burger. Both were fresh and delicious! I’ve been dining at LFRG for many years and never get let down. I definitely recommend Lily Flanagan's!!

Vicky Cianci
Vicky Cianci

Service is impeccable, and on my most recent visit, Yari was the sweetest girl I have ever encountered. She was very patient, attentive, and filled with a wonderful personality. The food is plentiful and delicious. I definitely left with a full belly.

Loretta Laz
Loretta Laz

Food was amazing and the service was great... Nice atmosphere...Full plates and Irish classics are 1/2 price on a couple days during the week .. Great night... The short ribs are my fave.... Definitely going back

Clarissa C
Clarissa C

I have been here many times for drinks but finally decided to try it for dinner and it was a pleasant surprise! The menu has tons of choices, both Irish and American cuisine. Lots of appetizers, which is great for sharing with a big group. The drinks are always good too! We enjoyed a flatbread, steak tidbits, duck breast and dessert. It's a nice sized space with pleasant service!

K
Kurtiz

Great service! The bartenders & waitresses are on top of everything. I came to Lily's to watch a band & this place didn't disappoint me. Bring a date or bring your friends. The dance floor is big & the crowd is fun. I had a great time. I highly recommend Lily's!

C
Carol Van Dyk

Good food! Love their burgers!!!

E
Eileen Rosskamp

First time there food was good but the service was horrible. Seems like if you where not a regular customer you where not waited on in a timly order. My party came in with a reservation we where seated and we waited and waited for some one to take our drink order. Finally after 15 min. The waitress came over and took our drink order. About 15 min later the drinks arrived. All this time we did not get a menu. Finially some one came with menus. We ordered and it was another 20 to 25 min. For the food. Customers who came in after us left before we even got our food. Needless to say we will not go there again nice place but the service SUCKS.

G
Gina T.

Went for the first time on NYE. Great location. Place has charm, nicely decorated for the holidays. Late night buffet dinner was very good. Staff was friendly enough for a busy night. I didn’t see anyone cleaning. There were a lot of spilled drinks as expected and the floor was sticky and gross at one point. DJ was ok, he was playing good stuff but there wasn’t much of a countdown, just randomly started counting down and luckily I heard him so I was ready. I would go back for the actual restaurant experience too.

b
brian cassidy

Food is very good and I’m not easy to please. I prefer my clams whole but there are chopped an excellent. Very moist. Shepherd Pie is very good Kilkenny Chicken is excellent Short Ribs are very good . My buddy like the salmon and Ruben. I’m goons try the French Dip next week

A
Allen Haynes

Had a few meals from this place now. Food is always good. Busy at times and bustling, but service is great. I ordered a Caprese Chicken sandwich and ended up finding a Crispy Chicken sandwich when I got home. The manager got on the phone and made it right with an apology. I'll be back, the food and service is too good not to.

J
Jessie Grace

We've been here before and the food is always good. This time we went here on a Saturday night. Didn't know they have a DJ and stop serving food early. Also a $10 cover charge wasn't in the plan. We stayed anyway and had a good time with friends regardless. Would recommend for a fun night out, just get here early if you want a meal.

T
The Batman (Rosario S. Cassata)

I've visited Lily's several times, and this most recent visit was for a fundraiser. The appetizers we ordered were all quite tasty. They also had a buffet with lots of options, all of which were delicious. The Shepard's Pie was excellent. It's a big bar/pub with dining options. The restaurant has a large bar that serves two sides and a lot of tables. It's informal and offers lots of parking.

J
John (Jmac)

Great time with lots of energy. Beer Nutz band made it even greater.

B
Billing - CECO

had my daughters birthday party and i received several complaints from my guests that the bartender was not friendly and seemed bothered, was not personable, also asked for a specific bottle of alcohol that is always served downstairs and the bartender insisted they didn't carry it and then when my co host said he would go ask downstairs she didn't like that and suddenly a bottle appeared, other than that it was a great room for a intimate party and the other staff was friendly and professional

C
Craig Schrott

Normally 5-star. Usually have a great time, but this time was a little less so. Went for brunch, service was very slow. Then had to send one meal back. Turns out they had a new chef first day on the job. Manager very apologetic. I'm sure that it will be better next time as they are very professional and serve great food and service is usually very good. We will definitely be back.

G
George Mazzocchi

Had our end of season bowling dinner here. Buffet style food was really good. Cocktail hour had awesome food and service. Would def. Recommend for private events.

Frank Hager
Frank Hager

Specials Wednesday, Thursday and Friday. Better than most bar food. Had good burger and fries. Kids chicken and fries. Kids loved their desert. Waitress was overwhelmed with the amount of tables she had.

Kristina Pursley
Kristina Pursley

We came here for brunch and then again for dinner. The potato soup is my favorite. It's so good. The brunch was absolutely delicious. I got a broccoli and cheese omelette and it was huge! It was cooked very nicely; not overcooked or runny. Delicious. I come here at least once every time I visit the island. Great food and great service. The only reason I gave it 4/5 stars is because it gets very very loud. We had to shout across the table to hear one another. Other than that, it's a great place!

C
Christine McGovern, LMT

We ate outdoors which was nice, but our waiter (who was excellent), left after serving our food, and the new one was more interested in schmoozing with the single ladies than actually doing his job. We literally waited 15 minutes for our check after asking for it. There was only about 5 other occupied tables at the time, so it wasn't like it was crazy busy. The food was good though.

T
Tahir Messam

This place is Day and Night... By day a nice sports bar with an Irish Flair. Holidays, Friday and Saturday nights, it's the college playground/night club of the 20 something's that call Long island home!

M
Mai Vio

This was our first visit to Lily's and although the food was excellent our service was not. She seemed friendly enough with other tables but when she came to our table she barely looked at us, reached across my face to pick up dishes while taking to table next to us. I think she even sighed when we asked for dessert to go. Unfortunately we had to reflect this in our tip. We frequent the restaurants in this area a lot and we love tipping generously to show our appreciation of good friendly service. Not sure if we'll be back here. Maybe only if we get a different server.

M
Mer

We stopped by for “$9.95 burger night”, quite misleading. Only their basic burger was that price, no where does it say otherwise, nor did the server mention that every other burger on menu only has a small discount vs. the advertised $9.95. The service was great and ambiance is always nice, it just felt misleading & not accurate in terms of their special burger night pricing.

M
Michele Orsini

My first time ding at Lilly’s in a while unfortunately the battered cod was way over done and way overpriced. My Mom ordered a Ruben just looking at it honestly the meat was dried out, the bread was burnt and a drop of sauerkraut. Sad to see the food went downhill I use to love Lilly’s.

R
Rosetta giannotti

Must have been bad night for Lily. Been there many times and July very good. Well, Sunday night, 6:00 very slow . Waitresses were huddled-and talking.they were interrupted by someone in charge, turned and apologized. The order was uneventful and have had it many times. The fish and chips was not edible …fish was probably sitting all day, fries were frozen and dried out ( wrinkled ) all laying on bits of water cress and shredded red cabbage. Inedible. Took it hand and through it out! The “chef” brought our dinner out carrying it almost over his head. Such a disappointing time after a wonder concert in Bay Shore. Service and food were terribly disappointing for a very expensive dinner. ( 1 drink each , no appetizers, no dessert!

P
Patrick Kenneally

Tonight was our first visit to Lily’s of Babylon. Our service was fantastic. We started with Alanna(?) and she was great. When her shift ended we were handed over to Mark , who was very good but not as good as Alanna. Our complaint is we could NOT taste any alcohol in our drinks at all. I was charged $13 per drink because I asked for the drink in a pint glass and therefore I was charged for a double shot. Sorry, no alcohol. I know what a double tastes like. My wife had two short drinks, then a pint and also couldn’t taste any alcohol. That is our only complaint. The music of the J Haus band was fantastic.

V
Vinny Sahni

Very noisy on St. Patrick’s Day and extremely crowded. People were yelling all around us so we didn’t enjoy it at all and left immediately after our main course.

J
Joanne Agruso

Food is OK. Bar service good, but tables service slow. Was there for karaoke night, which was fun.

A Bio
A Bio

Vibe is good. Babylon. Beer on tap and great bartenders. Food is as expected.

Monica Annunziata
Monica Annunziata

We were 8 people there for a holiday get together at 5 pm. Only 1 bartender that I saw so service was slow. As the night went on, saw more staff but service was terrible. We bussed our own table, Bringing dirty plates and glasses up to the bar and waiting for drinks that never came, so had to self serve at the bar when we had a waitress… most of us enjoyed our meal but I won’t rush back. So many other options in Babylon Village.

Karen Rappaport
Karen Rappaport

W way too crowded on the band side and people that were at tables finished eating, standing up to dance and drink and not giving up the table to someone who now wants to order food. I feel like if you’re finished eating and you’re going to stand up anyway, you may as well give the table away to someone who now wants to eat. Staff does not consider that at all and frankly, Lily Flannigan’s loses a lot of money due to that aspect, I will go back, but never to eat done

Mr T
Mr T

Me and my family have been doing business with Lily Flanagan’s for several decades now and I’ve had mixed experiences. I have thrown several parties here and they ended up going decently. However, I did come in for dinner last night and my experience was just meh. I felt the staff ranging from the hostess and my server wanted to rush us in and out despite there being a low number of people dining in the place and they treated the person with me alot better than me and left me with sink water from a what appears to be over 20 year old sink rather than giving me fresh water as well, who knows what germs are living in that faucet that they don’t know about/don’t want to make public. I also ordered a lemonade and the server thought she could get away with just squeezing once lemon in a glass of water when I wasn’t looking and be able to call it a lemonade. For over 4$ a glass I expect real lemonade, not some water with lemon flavoring. The nachos were alright however, as I am writing this now in bed I am experiencing horrible acid reflux from either the cheese or something else which is annoying. The burger was ok for $10 but could be better. The person with me also tried one of the fish and wasn’t too too impressed with it. I also want to note that it was very loud in the dining room by the bar for a Monday night so if you don’t like that don’t come here, you can talk a little bit but it was difficult to hear yourself think. But yea the way I was treated by my server since she didn’t know I was an adult was completely wrong and would have me reconsider going out of my way to dine at this establishment. I live almost 20 minutes away so I don’t think I’ll come here anymore unless it’s for a party or if I’m in the area with my family. Please update your place and please train some of your staff to be a little more respectful to the customer as it can hurt your business in the long run. I gave these guys the benefit of the doubt since the owners are very humble people and have done a lot to accommodate my family and I over the last few decades, but professionally this place would fall in the 2-3 stars range. Hopefully this place improves by the time I return and maybe they will consider some minor renovations in a few areas by the bar area soon.

J
Jo M

Very, very, disappointed. Extremely unpleasant and unfriendly experience with a female wait staff member who was accusatory and nasty in disposition. I didn't expect that at all. Others in my group felt the same, including complain of constant pounding on return drinks without them being ordered. Others felt booze was watered down. It's not a cheap venue by any means so we were all shocked. My bill was incorrect, not once, but twice and I had to go in to correct it. I paid inside, left, told the wait staff and then the same wait staff member had someone call me because they didn't think I paid the bill. In total we had 4 waitstaff and no one knew what they were doing. Just horrendous. On a great note, the band was awesome! The Red Hots are a must see!

C
Courtnie Nelson

Not really sure if I’ll be back - 4 of us got the Surf and Turf special and after waiting at least 45 minutes for our food all 4 steaks were well over cooked and covered in way too much sauce. Service for drinks and in general was slow. Waitress was very apologetic but overall it was still not a good experience. Prices were reasonable. Another table got wings that looked decent, if I ever do come back.

J
Joey Nickels

I’ve been a long time and loyal customer, never caused any trouble and always took good care of my bartenders. Since acquiring the new venues and the change of menu, I have noticed some changes in quantity and quality of the food and some of the bartenders have been pouring short. Not to make anything out of it, I went with the flow. Until last week. The pulled pork sandwich was so dry and very little pork at that. After receiving my food, one of the bartenders, asked the obligatory “How is everything?” When I replied honestly, the response was an uncompassionate “sorry! “And then walked away. The next bartender came over to refill my double mixed drink. As he was doing so, also asked, “how is everything?” Of course, I responded the same, and I was “rewarded” with an extremely short tip of the vodka bottle as opposed to a 4 ounce pour. He did it in plain sight as to slap me in the face. I said to him, “Don’t you want me to come back?” His reply, “ I didn’t say that! “. But I knew that’s what he meant. So that’s just what I’m doing. After all these years, I’m not going back. I know these people for a long time! No one made any attempt to right the wrong.

J
Jenny Burnett

We have been here a few times and each time we say we are not coming back. It gives off a "locals" pub/bar for sure. With the new changes we wanted to give the new menu a try. Saturday for dinner we went to Lily's for 6pm. The bar was very busy with people standing behind seated people. As a band was playing. Surprisingly we were sat at a table right away. After a short wait we ordered a soda and a cocktail. Our polite server Cayden returned a few minutes later to inform us the margarita keg was being changed. The drink was good. The dining area was not overly busy. We skipped apps and ordered our meals. Over 45 mins later my husband asked Cayden to check on our meals he returned to inform us of the delay and that the head chef would be bringing them out. Chris the chef came out with our meals, apologized and offered desserts on the house. I ordered the pork chop and my husband ordered the lamb chop. The pork chop was so past overcooked I could not chew it. The lamb was good and tender. A man in a suit jacket stopped by our table to ask how we were enjoying our meals. I informed him my pork chop was very hard and he said good glad to hear it. I think he wasn't actually listening to me. We both ate the lamb chops and gave up the pork chop. We had an E-gift card to use. They do not have any hand held devices to accept e-giftcards so I had to go with Cayden to the computer to process the gc from my phone.

A
Allison Prestia

For the past few years Lily’s was my favorite place to go to for Sunday football! The crowd was great, and the football card was even more amazing. Now that they aren’t doing the football card they’re Sunday football deals just aren’t holding up to their card. I will not be going back every Sunday like I have done in the past.

K
Kimberly Ledig

The food was good but really overpriced. I ordered a drink that was wrong and asked a server to correct it she rolled her eyes and ignored me. Never going back. Burger bar is way better for food, price, and service.

Danielle Adames
Danielle Adames

I do not like leaving negative reviews but I am hoping Lily's will take this review and try to make the correct changes. I stopped in yesterday with my boyfriend around 7pm and the place was packed with a good amount of people patronizing the local bands. However, after the bands left, the crowd turned into a bunch of underage looking kids. We decided to leave but the main door we came through had been closed off. We then had to find our way out of the crowd of about 100+ kids that had gathered outside. Not only were there no bouncers in sight to control the crowd, but it felt like a huge fire hazard not having multiple clear exits with no obstruction. I hope they work on this matter so no one gets hurt.

J
Joseph Kerns

Was there a few Fridays ago. Not great. Went downhill for socializing on weekends. Used to be a great place, not anymore. Turned into a times square dump of spoiled 21 year olds, bad music and bad attitudes. Very unfriendly. Used to be a great place a 34 year old could go. Not anymore. What a disgrace. If you want a crowd that has dignity and class while being mature enough to respect others...don't go to this joint. Stay away, unless you like Romper Room and brainless dolts stimulated by cellphones and flashing lights with noise playing on loudspeakers. Pathetic. Long Island has gone downhill.

T
Thomas Maier

What a terrible experience at this huge restaurant/ bar. We came on Taco Tuesday which happens to be karaoke night as well. The food was not terrible, basic bar fare but the staff was inattentive at best and incompetent and rude at their worst. The temperature on the side of the bar where the music was so ridiculously freezing cold that some regulars were wearing winter coats. (That should have given us a clue when we first walked in) Someone mentioned to my wife that they sold Lily Sweatshirts and the waitress told her it was 20.00 and brought her one which she put on. It literally must have been like 45 degrees and windy so we rushed thru dinner and asked for the check. They charged her 30.00 and when we complained the girl lied and said she never said it was 20.00. No matter, we paid the bill and left never to return to this poor excuse for a restaurant!

D
Debbie Baldwin

The food was absolute crap! Shepard's Pie had non existent vegetables! The meat was tasteless! The Fish and Chips were the worst I had ever tasted! The "fish" was the consistency of pure mush. The coating was oily and overpowering! $27.95 for the large plate was pathetic and grossly overpriced! Two pieces of "fish" and maybe 25 fries!! The chocolate lava cake was nothing more than a chocolate chip muffin! I will never, ever cross the threshold of this joke of a so called restaurant!!!

D
Dawnmarie Wood

Sadly...I listened to the barkeep & took his advise for Cuban sandwhich, burned both side couldn't eat bread . No side..= 38$ 5 tip 1 seabreeze . Drinks fine, very dark . Probably should have gotten all dressed up & expect valet parking & sit to eat. Sorry I was at beach all day & wanted some seafood soup & cake & maybe shannon seafood all was to go anyway. Not happy

Sign in to leave a review

Sign in
👑 Is it yours? Claim it FREE!

Remove ads and manage your menu

Explore Your Area

More restaurants in Babylon →
📸

85 Photos

Explore Lily's Babylon's photos

Lily's Babylon
Lily's Babylon
Lily's Babylon
Lily's Babylon
Lily's Babylon
+80 More
📍

About Lily's Babylon

How to get there

345 Deer Park Ave, Babylon, NY 11702

Loading map...
Lily's Babylon
Tap for directions

Highlights

Good Rating
4.3/5 stars
💬
Many Reviews
1046 reviews
💰
Moderate Price
Price level
👨‍🍳
american
Cuisine type

Services

🥞 Breakfast
🥐 Brunch
🍽️ Lunch
🍾 Dinner
Coffee
🍰 Desserts
🥗 Vegetarian Options
🥡 Takeout
🚚 Delivery
🍴 Dine-in

Dining Options

🍽️ Dine In
🥡 Takeout
🚚 Delivery

Restaurant Info

Status
Verified by owner
🕐 Hours Today
3PM-12AM
Rating
4.3/5
💬 Reviews
1,046
💰 Price Level
$$
⏱️ Typical Visit
People typically spend 1-3.5 hours here
📞 Phone
+1 631-539-0816
🌐 Website
www.lilyflanaganspub.com
📋 Menu
View Menu

Amenities

📶 Free WiFi
🅿️ Parking
🌿 Outdoor Seating
Wheelchair Accessible
🚻 Restroom
💳 Credit Cards
📱 Mobile Payments
🏘️

The Neighborhood

Location

345 Deer Park Ave, Babylon, NY 11702

📍 Explore the Neighborhood

Weather
23°
Weather updated hourly · Jobs and events refreshed daily
🎮

Gaming

🎮 Earn Points While You Explore!

Play Find Me and redeem points for discounts at Lily's Babylon and other restaurants

🎮

Earn Points at Lily's Babylon!

Play Find Me and redeem rewards here

Earn extra points and redeem them for rewards at Lily's Babylon

🏆 Rewards at Lily's Babylon

💰

10% Discount

At Lily's Babylon

1000 pts
Available
🍽️

Free Appetizer

On your next visit

2500 pts
Limited
👑

VIP Table

Premium experience

5000 pts
Exclusive

to redeem rewards and earn points

📋 How Do Rewards Work?

1

Play Find Me

Every 100 score points = 1 reward point

2

Collect Points

Workers earn 2x points per game

3

Redeem Rewards

Discounts, free food and VIP experiences

Call
Leave a Review on Google
👑

Is it yours? Claim it FREE!

Remove ads and manage your menu

Sign in & Play

Check your email!

No password needed — we'll email you a link

We sent you an access link

Check your spam folder if you don't see it