Nora and Abe took over in early March 2025, and it’s been an amazing transformation. The food is incredible - and as an Italian who rarely eats Italian out, that’s a high compliment. The sauce is fantastic! The ingredients are fresh, the food is cooked to perfection. I’ve had pizza, pasta, chicken, salad, drinks and dessert - all fabulous! The service is wonderful; the staff is family, and you’ll feel right at home from the moment you walk inside. We have many fine Italian restaurants in Babylon Village, but Mulberry Street is truly a tough act to follow. Try Mulberry Street today, you won’t be disappointed! - Tom Vitale, Babylon Public Library Director & President, Babylon Village Chamber of Commerce

I came tonight with my family to celebrate a birthday. The waitress and the rest of the staff were so kind. Food was absolutely amazing, some of the best food I’ve had in a long time. I will definitely be coming back very soon!

Mulberry Street in Babylon is a true gem! The food was absolutely delicious, and the service was even better. From the moment we walked in, we were treated like family. Our amazing waitresses, Angela and Marcy, were so kind, attentive, and genuinely made our experience extra special. And a big shoutout to Abe and Nora, their warmth and hospitality really stood out and made the whole night feel personal and welcoming. It’s rare to find a place with both great food and an incredible team behind it. We’ll definitely be back and recommending it to everyone we know!

The best dinner I’ve ever had!

Top tier food with a great atmosphere! Love coming here !

By far some of the best pizza I’ve had! Service was top notch! Highly recommend!

i’ve been living on this island for 2 years. This is the best pizza i’ve had. Staff are phenomenal. Quality is exceptional. Call your favorite pizza spot and tell them to be more like these guys.

The best. Since ownership changed there isn't a single item I don't want to order. The food is delish and the service is great. Please check it out. Wednesdays there is a great chicken special. The owner Abraham is always so welcoming. Erica was great too.

Love this pizza place! One of the best in Long Island

Excellent all around big fan of all Their pizzas and calzones

What a wonderful time we had! Joe, our waiter, was so nice and attentive. Food was delicious. Will definitely be back!

Food is delicious and great place to come with family

Amazing pizza pasta always. Staff is very pleasant and professional. Amazing place for families!

I had the most wonderful experience planning my daughter’s Sweet 16 with the Owner Abe. They did all my catering , and went above and beyond making sure everything was perfect. The food arrived on time and was so delicious! Everyone at her party loved it. They made sure we had everything we needed and made themselves available if needed all night. If you want 5 star food and service I highly recommend using them. Not only for parties but dining in is just as good. I’m so happy I made the decision to use them and you should too! Abe thank you for making my evening flawless.

Tonight was our first night here. I saw the wine and dine special for Friday evening which included two entrees and a bottle of wine for $60 on Friday nights. We live in Nassau but figured what the heck, this sounds good. It was certainly worth the drive. Our waitress Peggy was very welcoming & friendly. They bring a nice Bread Basket to the table prior to your meal which included 3 different types of bread. I ordered the eggplant spinach rollatini with penne pasta and my husband ordered the chicken rollatini marinara with penne which had spinach as well. Both meals were huge and absolutely delicious. We both took half home. We got a bottle of Pinot Grigio which was a full size bottle and it was great. We will definitely be back. They also have Monday night pasta specials and Tuesday night chicken specials which you can see on their website and for very reasonable prices. It was a clean, quiet dining room and and all covid protocols were in place. The front entrance of the restaurant is a pizza parlor with a ton of different style pizzas you can take to go or have delivered.

Am I all right now this is the second time we came here this month. Food and the service were fabulous. We will be back

Absolutely fantastic. The food, the service, the ambience are all wonderful. They make you feel like a guest not a customer.

I never had a dish here that I did not love! My favorite dish is the linguine with clams but I’m telling you the zucchini fries are good and the stacked eggplant is amazing! And the portions are huge! My friend Stella ordered the chicken alla mama and that was delicious!

Their specialty pies are packed with flavor, but even a simple cheese slice is so good it could stand on its own. The toppings are generous without overwhelming the pizza, and you can tell everything is made with care. The staff is friendly, quick, and always happy to recommend something new to try.

My family took me to Mulberry Street to celebrate my birthday. There were 12 of us - we all enjoyed our meals - which were delicious and plentiful. Everyone left with enough food for another meal. The staff could not have been more attentive - there for anything we may have needed. I highly recommend anyone go to Mulberry Street if you are looking for a family friendly atmosphere - a meal you will enjoy and a staff that only wants to make your experience a wonderful one.

Such a cute spot and delicious pizza. Their spinach pizza is amazing. Definitely come check it out!

Very clean place, best Italian food and pizza in the area!

The best part of Babylon! Marcy is the best and makes you truly feel like family when you’re there. I live in NYC and when I’m in Babylon, I ALWAYS stop by Mulberry St!

Amazing place. Love the buffalo chicken slice. Always bring my family when they come in from out of town

We had a great experience at Mulberry Street! The food was fresh, flavorful, and clearly made with care. The pasta was cooked perfectly—just the right texture—and the salad was crisp and refreshing, topped with delicious eggplant that added a nice touch. The pizza was very good, with just the right balance of toppings and a crust that was spot on. Ab, the owner, was so personable and welcoming—he truly made us feel right at home. Mulberry Street is definitely a go-to spot for dinner. If you haven’t been yet, check them out—you won’t be disappointed!

Absolutely phenomenal experience at Mulberry Street. The food was flavorful, fresh, and felt like a warm hug from home. The staff made us feel like family—attentive without hovering, and genuinely welcoming. Every dish had heart behind it, and you could tell this place values quality and connection. Perfect spot for a cozy, delicious meal that hits the soul. Can’t wait to come back!

The best pizza I’ve had in a long time. Super fresh! Dave Portnoy needs to come here.

We love coming here for dinner whether it’s for dine in or takeout. I havent had a meal i havent finished or taken leftovers home

Always greeted with happiness and a smile. Abe and his staff are a pleasure to interact with and care about your satisfaction. The food is delicious and the portions are abundanza!!!!

Our server Meagan was a delight. The food was delish. Huge portions. We all needed to take a box home. We had a small issue and the Manager took care of it quickly. He went above and beyond to make sure we were happy. We were quite happy! We will return. Monday through Thursday there are Specials. Take a look, you won’t be sorry! We ordered chicken franchise, chicken Graziella, and Chicken Giuseppe. All were excellent.

This place is the best! I come here as a treat every time I get my nails done in the area. The pizza is amazing! There are so many specialty slices to choose from that are so unique. The staff is friendly and I always feel welcomed. I look forward to going in the summer for a sit down dinner. If you haven’t been to Mulberry Street in Babylon Village, stop by, you are missing out!

If I could hire a Billboard to tell people about how awesome this restaurant is, I would. I have to lean on Google. From the first moment I met Abe, I knew I was in the right place to plan my daughter's 30th birthday. The food is AMAZING! Angela our server did not rush us and made us feel so welcome. Nora greeted us, and when my party turned from 15 to 16, no worries. She added a table so we would have plenty of room. From the ridiculously delicious food, to the wine, homemade cheesecake...even the coffee was off the charts! You will be seeing all 16 of us again! Probably not at the same time, but we will all be back ! Thanks again, Abe. See you soon.

We love Mulberry Street ! The pizza is delicious . Always a good experience when we dine in. The staff are always friendly and welcoming.

I have been a dine in customer for years, but in recent weeks started ordering take out. My husband and I often choose Mulberry over the other local pizzerias down the block. We are very impressed with the size, taste, and overall quality of their take out items!! Great staff as well, we always look forward to eating their food and that’s why my family and I keep coming back!

Great pizza great service super nice staff large slices def recommend!!!!

If you haven’t been, you absolutely should! The food is consistently delicious, portions are larger than I have seen in over 10 years anywhere , the staff, specifically Abe could not be any more welcoming and pleasant. Oh and the espresso martini… 5 stars!!!

The new ownership is second to none. Incredibly hospitable and courteous, and the food is awesome! Highly recommended whether you live in the Babylon area or visiting. Portions are very generous as well

Delicious. We ordered a bunch of apps. Eggplant rollatini. Fried calamari. Rice balls. Everything was delicious. Great service.

Wow! We love Mulberry! The owner is very nice and friendly. Very generous and willing to make his customers happy. We had a spinach slice, a buffalo slice and the pepperoni roll. The pizza had a delicious crispy crust and prices are reasonable. It even reheated really well!

In the heart of Babylon Village there is Mulberry Street Pizzeria & Restaurant and it is an important staple in the Village of Babylon. Families, couples, & friends -of all ages gather at Mulberry Street of Babylon for lunch, dinner and sometimes just for a quick meal after happy hour, in between running errands & late night for a snack before going to bed. Ever since Abe & his family took over this pizzeria & restaurant in Babylon, the pizzeria’s vibe went to a whole new level & has once again become a place that I will frequent as a dedicated client/ customer. Abe always welcomes me & everyone else who walks in the door with a gracious & kind smile. His employees are always smiling, even though they are super focused on making pizza, and focused on preparing all of the deliveries. *Love that many of the employees who worked there in the past, decided to stay & work with Abe & his family. The service is great, whether dining in or ordering out, between the pizzeria & the restaurant, everything is fresh & “on point”. The atmosphere was always nice, but Abe & his family improved this beloved staple in Babylon, both indoors & outdoors. Mulberry Street has a beautiful & comfortable modern atmosphere and it is a pleasure to dine in or to simply to stop in and place a take out order. Thank you Abe for taking & interest in Mulberry Street of Babylon & thank you for welcoming me back as a longtime client & as your new client. Loved the pizza today, the grilled chicken & the Caesar salad!

Met a friend at Mulberry street located in an unassuming shopping center off the main strip. We ordered a delicious beet salad and some meat eggroll. Both were delicious and a perfect way to start a meal along with the delicious garlic knots they put on the table. We also ordered a delicious Sicilian ribbon pasta layer with eggplant peas and mozzarella. The sauce was so rich and delicious you didn’t miss it was all veggie and no meat. After that unexpectedly heavy dish I’m glad I ordered seabass. It was cooked perfectly served with deckhouse brocolli rabe in a spicy broth. Excellent dish. For dessert Our wonderful server highly recommended the carrot cake and the lobster claw they recently added to the menu. The lobster claw patty was the best I’ve had. Thoroughly enjoyed my visit and meal and highly recommend to pop in for a slice or a nice family meal.

+4

Amazing service! I love the deserts especially the tiramisu with the coffee on top the lady was very sweet and hooked me up with a big slice and added whip, whipped cream and all that fun stuff on it not disappointed at all pizza also 10 out of 10

The best veggie pizza I have ever eaten. They have mainly indoor seating but there are a couple of outdoor tables as well. The salad was also crisp and fresh. The appetizer sampler was ok, maybe a little too much bread in the stuffings.

Hi. Its me. Tiramisu…phenomenal. Pizza was amazing; Cheese slice, BBQ Chicken, and especially that Chicken Marsala slice. 10/10. Thank you so much and until next time.

We ordered out a meal.dinner and delivery was quick on a friday night during lent. Everything was delicious.

The Food and the service were absolutely wonderful. I had the special, "Chicken Rolla tini" and it was scrumptious. My son said the meat was very tender and delicious he had the Rib dinner My Aunt said the sauce was very creamy and tasty she had the ravioli with Alfredo And my husband had the Chicken Franzese which he devoured. The Warm Bread kept coming with butter and the dessert was the inhouse Cheesecake which was Devine. I truly enjoyed myself and will return in the future.

+2

Food was great and the staff were very friendly and generous with the amount of food they gave us. I highly recommend!

I just took my mom out for dinner and the food was as out of this world .... the portions were humongous.... looking forward to left overs for the rest of the week and our waitress Angela couldn't have been any nicer and accommodating.... definitely will be back again soon

What a change the new Mulberry Street is fantastic I've lived in Babylon for 55 years I have been here more times in the last 2 months then I was the previous 55 years. I recommend this place to all

The staff was so friendly, and the pizza is was delicious! Highly recommend. Will definitely be returning

The staff was very friendly and welcoming. We arrived just before closing time, and Joseph was very accommodating, making sure we could leave with our food without any issues.

I’ve been coming here for years with my family. I’ve come out here from Massapequa and even more now that I live up the road. The food is amazing

This is a gem 💎 in Babylon Village, the food is amazing, they serve a generous amount and the staff is outstanding. My first time in the restaurant the owner greeted us and gave us a bottle of wine as we exited. Pizza, Pasta… wine 🍷 Best in town!!! Can’t recommend it enough 👌🏻

Mulberry is hands-down one of the best pizza spots around, the food is amazing! But what really makes it special is the staff. They’re friendly, genuine, and brings great vibes to the whole place. You always feel welcome, and the pizza never misses. I have also dined in and it was the perfect meal and once again the staff was great! 10/10, highly recommend!

absolutely AMAZING… pizza was so fresh and just what I needed after a long day

This was our first time visiting and for sure will NOT be our last. Everything was amazing, the atmosphere, the staff, the food. Best we have had in a long time. For sure our new favorite local spot. Angela was our server and she was so great! You MUST try this place if you want Amazingly fresh food , great service, HUGE portions all at a very good price. We will have leftovers for days. :-)

Love the food and service! The portion was big and good for two meals!

To Good To Go Excellent experience! The pizza was fresh, hot and full of flavor. Was perfectly crispy and the toppings were generous. The staff was friendly and welcoming, and the place was clean.

We stopped in last minute and were welcomed and seated right away. The appetizers and salads came out promptly. The main course came out hot and delicious. We would be returning. Our waitress Angela was incredibly accommodating!

We had a fantastic experience at Mulberry Street, a lovely Italian restaurant in Babylon Village. We were greeted warmly by the manager as soon as we walked in, which set the tone for a great night. Our server, Marcy, was friendly, attentive, and let us know that Wednesdays are their special chicken day which included a salad, garlic knots, cheesecake, and coffee/tea. We ordered the Chicken Marsala and Chicken Da Vinci—both were delicious, and the portions were huge! I also had the Fig Cosmo, which was a standout. Everything was excellent. We’ll definitely be back!

I came back to the Island to visit family and we went here. I’ve been living out of state for the last three years so I hadn’t had truly authentic Italian food in ages and this was just what I needed for my body and soul. The gluten free penne was so good and tender it didn’t even taste gluten free. I would have asked to make sure there wasn’t a mixup but our waiter, Joe, was so on top of things I knew I didn’t have to. He said it was his first night but I almost didn’t believe him. He was warm, pleasant, thoughtful, charming, and carried himself like a damn pro! Oh, and then the manager hands us a bottle of Merlot on the way out, just to thank us for being there! This is the real Italian warmth, hospitality, food, and service you can only find in NY! We’re definitely coming back, and you’d be wise to bring your crew there, too!

Sue Reda

Ordered for delivery and that is why the 4 stars for that. Only because it wasn’t the most timely, the restaurant was probably crazy busy. The pizza on the other hand is 5 stars!! If you like thin crust flatbread this is the place for you. It was so damn good. Will definitely be ordering from this place again and again!!

Mateo Rossi

Let me begin by saying—wow. What started as frustration for my family of eight after a 45-minute wait to be seated on my Christmas Eve reservation quickly turned into awe and complete satisfaction. Despite a packed dining room, visible understaffing, and a longer wait for our meals, the moment the food arrived, it was clear the wait was well worth it. Every dish was outrageously delicious—truly a blessing to the taste buds. The hospitality was exceptional, capped off by a thoughtful Christmas gesture of a complimentary bottle of wine. What could have been a ruined Christmas Eve instead became a truly memorable experience we will always cherish. Thank you, Mulberry Street.

Dianna DeAngelis

Wow! I didn’t know what to except when I walked in for a family dinner, we were a large party of 9. I was blown away!!! Marcie is an amazing waitress first of all and the food is outstanding. There are a bunch of unique options on the menu, and as someone with a gluten intolerance I was excited to find out they had GF bread crumbs and GF pasta. So I ordered the chicken Giuseppe’s and it was awesome. The portions are enormous and delicious. We will be back.

Joann Wilson

Delicious food, great service & fantastic value!

Krista Saad

Delicious dinner tonight at mulberry st!!! the food is always so fresh and cooked to perfection! My all time favorite Italian spot , I could come here every week 😍 side note the tiramisu is my favorite I’ve ever had

Deborah K

Wonderful food, service and ambience! We called this fine establishment less than 30 minutes before our party of 5 arrived for lunch. We were pleasantly surprised with a chicken price fixe lunch, and our end of year Christmas celebration was a success! The selection of chicken dishes were impressive. A delicious house salad was served with a hot fresh basket of garlic knots. The chicken de Vinci was incredible - grilled chicken and Italian sausage with broccoli florets in a sherry cream pink sauce was incredible! It was served over penne pasta (cooked perfectly ala dente). The chicken parm also looked amazing as did the chicken Marsala. All of the food was cooked perfectly, with oversized portions that were all tasty and delicious! Our server Joseph was patient, attentive and accommodated all of our requests. Ground pepper offered from a jumbo pepper grinder made the meal even better!!! We were all pleased with the food and the service and the dining room was decorated tastefully for Christmas. Dessert was also fabulous - homemade cheesecake was one of the best we’ve had at a restaurant. It’s made on-site and is creamy, tasty and complemented our meal perfectly! Everything about our meal was excellent. Wonderful dining experience with stellar service, excellent food and a wonderful dining room.

Mary Massaro

OMG! Best meal, service and atmosphere for our annual holiday get together! Huge delicious portions! Marcy was an AMAZING waitress! So attentive to every detail! Abe the owner was so kind and made us all feel so special as patrons! Overall, great experience!!!!! We will be back for sure!

erin odono

We had another amazing dinner at Mulberry Street in Babylon. This restaurant has been our favorite place for our holiday dinner. The food was delicious and the portions were huge. If you want a great meal and night filled with laughter this is the place.

d t

Amazing staff and amazing food. Would definitely come again

My Play Space

Mulberry Pizza in Babylon Village is absolutely the best! 🍕 The managers, Nora and Abraham, are always so helpful and accommodating. I place several catering orders each month for business parties, and they never disappoint — everything is always on time, fresh, and delicious. The pizza is amazing, and their customer service is top-notch. So grateful for their consistency and kindness — truly a gem in the village! 👏🏼

Allison Yuceturk

We ordered food last night through good to go and when I tell u mulberry street DID NOT DISAPPOINT. They gave us alittle of everything in 3 boxes plus a whole meatball parm. There food is already amazing. I will definitely be doing this again.

Brianna Lindley

Super cute and nice restaurant w/ pizzeria Food is amazing and staff was so wonderful!

Cliff Chandler Jr.

We went for their Wednesday night chicken special and were born away. We have been to this restaurant before but tonight's experience was on another level. Our server, Marcy, was incredible and so sweet not only to us but every table she visited. She gave a great recommendation to make homemade croutons using our leftover garlic knots. The food is always amazing at Mulberry Street and we can't wait to go back again!

Lisa Chicoccariello

Celebrated my birthday with a large group, the manager was super accommodating to all of our needs, the service was outstanding definitely a 10 out of 10….. incredibly large portions of delicious food. Would definitely come back again. They even have specials during the week.

Marta Wiszowata

If you're craving Italian food and big portions, this is the spot. Every dish we ordered was absolutely delicious — rich in flavor and perfectly cooked. Come hungry, because the servings are no joke! Huge shoutout to Abe for making sure everything was on point, and a special thanks to our amazing server Meagan — she was friendly, attentive, and made the whole experience even better. We'll definitely be coming back — this place is a gem!

Frances Villa

9/12/25 I ordered on phone 7 different types of chicken meals & pasta dishes with some special request & plus sides for dinner. Everyone loved their choices. The dinners were very generous portions. From the cook to the delivery man, my food was delivered on time & came hot.(I got too old to cook different dishes for my adult kids when they come to visit ) The manager sent a bottle of wine on the house (so thoughtful). I haven't been the restaurant for 5yrs or more so I don't know about the atmosphere. But I'm sure it will be nice from what i hear But I only tried it again because I read it the new owners are now same as mamas in Copiague. .I tell you that you will not be disappointed. And prepared the way you like it The food is freshly made you can tell. I plan on being a customer again & so are my family members & I told my friends

Coach Jaye

we go for either pasta tonight on Monday or chicken Parm night on Wednesday and in between that we sit at the bar for happy hour. If I had one suggestion, I would make happy hours from 4 to 6 instead of 2 to 5. Servers are always friendly and happy food is always delicious. The owners are always here and if there’s any problems they always sell them.

Rebecka Verzeni-Placa

What a great spot! I love coming in here to grab some pizza and sit outside with my pup! The service is always with a smile and Abe has made the experience very enjoyable. Definitely recommend the vodka slice!!!

HelenofTroynUSA

Our first time here but Foods are delicious with friendly staff. They also have their bar if you want to dine and drink wine at the bar counter.They also have their private room if you have your special occasions. Anyway, I was taking pictures and suddenly staff handed me a bottle of wine. I told him that I don’t drink but he said to me that’s for free😍. According to the saying that “to refuse an offer is a big insult😀” that’s why I accepted it as he seems sincere and I saw that it is sealed, so I’m safe. Although I need to give my review for the satisfaction that we experience wherever we go. So it’s not because I got it, but have to say what I feel like sharing to know people what this place has to offer. If are around this area and craving for Italian foods. Parking is available at the back.Highly recommend.

+3

Always good quality food and large servings at reasonable prices. Great service, polite staff and a calm quiet ambience in which to enjoy your meal.

Always good quality food and large servings at reasonable prices. Great service, polite staff and a calm quiet ambience in which to enjoy your meal.

Always good quality food and large servings at reasonable prices. Great service, polite staff and a calm quiet ambience in which to enjoy your meal.

Always good quality food and large servings at reasonable prices. Great service, polite staff and a calm quiet ambience in which to enjoy your meal.

Always good quality food and large servings at reasonable prices. Great service, polite staff and a calm quiet ambience in which to enjoy your meal.

The food was wonderful and our waitress was fantastic. Everyone in our party of 5 loved the food we ordered. It was served promptly and the staff was very attentive. \nThe room was very comfortable a…

The food was wonderful and our waitress was fantastic. Everyone in our party of 5 loved the food we ordered. It was served promptly and the staff was very attentive. \nThe room was very comfortab…

The food was wonderful and our waitress was fantastic. Everyone in our party of 5 loved the food we ordered. It was served promptly and the staff was very attentive. \nThe room was very comfortab…

Wonderful saff & ambience .. food never ceases to amaze. Mulberry street of babylon village is the best pizza in town hands down!!

Wonderful saff & ambience .. food never ceases to amaze. Mulberry street of babylon village is the best pizza in town hands down!!

Great fantastic food, portions & service\nHighly recommended \nWaiters & waitresses are very attentive & accommodating.

Amazing pizza and customer service Always fresh pizza and large variety to choose from

Wonderful food, service and ambience! We called this fine establishment less than 30 minutes before our party of 5 arrived for lunch. We were pleasantly surprised with a chicken price fixe lunch, a…

Wonderful food, service and ambience! We called this fine establishment less than 30 minutes before our party of 5 arrived for lunch. We were pleasantly surprised with a chicken price fixe lunch, a…

They have great all day meal specials to dine in or to go. You can't beat the value for the price they charge. My husband and I love the seafood night.\nDine in on the left side and pizza palor on …

Best pizza! We ordered a regular pie half chicken parm. Delicious and loaded with chicken on half. Surrounded by pizza places and rather drive 10 minutes to mulberry street. The best! Thank you!

Wow always delish! Our other go to Italian food! We usually get it to go.. The family loves this restaurant! Loved the shrimp franchise, chicken cacciatore & seafood special. Kudos to the new Mul…

Came in for lunch. Food was delicious and plentiful. The chicken Jennifer was great. Ala vodka sauce was great. Complementary garlic knots came out hot n tasty. Short ribs and pappardelle was tende…

We used to live in Babylon and now drive down from our home in CT to meet friends every summer for dinner. We try a different restaurant each time, and while they are all good and never disappointing…

Exceptional food and wonderful service! The family style classic sampler was a bit hit. We all loved it. For entrees I recommend the Shrimp Scampi and the chicken & Arugula Pasta with Walnuts an…

Exceptional food and wonderful service! The family style classic sampler was a bit hit. We all loved it. For entrees I recommend the shrimp Scampi and the chicken & Arugula pasta with Waln…

Exceptional food and wonderful service! The family style classic sampler was a bit hit. We all loved it. For entrees I recommend the Shrimp Scampi and the Chicken & Arugula Pasta with Walnuts an…

Can't go wrong ordering a pizza from here - from the buffalo chicken to the salad pie and even just a plain pie - it's the best around. It is also so hard to find a good garlic knot these days and th…

Can't go wrong ordering a pizza from here - from the buffalo chicken to the salad pie and even just a plain pie - it's the best around. It is also so hard to find a good garlic knot these d…

Can't go wrong ordering a pizza from here - from the buffalo chicken to the salad pie and even just a plain pie - it's the best around. It is also so hard to find a good garlic knot these days and …

Can't go wrong ordering a pizza from here - from the buffalo chicken to the salad pie and even just a plain pie - it's the best around. It is also so hard to find a good garlic knot these days and …

Rating the tiramisu only. It's one of the best in the area. It LOOKS the least impressive (kinda mangled), but is quite good. Cake is properly soaked, but missing top cocoa layer. A little less cream would be good. Not sure $10 is worth it. Mario's bakery a few blocks away is cheaper and more traditional.

Love the food and atmosphere! The only problem was the creepy local obnoxious customer Bill that made it an uncomfortable time!

Having a good time at dinner but then when I tasted my chicken francese, it was very salty, could not eat much. So disappointed. The manager was right on top of it! I don’t like to complain so I didn’t say anything but he knew and came over. He offered to have it made again but we had to go. He had it made quickly and packed it up for me to take home. I heated it up the following evening and it was perfect!!! Message to Manager - that was a great save on your part. Thank you for going the extra mile. Very much appreciated and thank you again.

We ordered dinner the day of the blizzard and we did wait quite a while, but the manager was very professional and ended up making us a new meal to make sure it was warm when we got it. The food was fantastic and we appreciated the professionalism of the service. Food and manager 5 stars, the weather interfering with our dinner 1.

I love visiting my family in Babylon because that means we will have pizza from Mulberry. They ordered 5 different pies, margarita, grandma, sausage, pepperoni and traditional for a pizza party and i…

I love visiting my family in Babylon because that means we will have pizza from Mulberry. They ordered 5 different pies, margarita, grandma, sausage, pepperoni and traditional for a pizza party…

I love visiting my family in Babylon because that means we will have pizza from Mulberry. They ordered 5 different pies, margarita, grandma, sausage, pepperoni and traditional for a pizza party and…

I love visiting my family in Babylon because that means we will have pizza from Mulberry. They ordered 5 different pies, margarita, grandma, sausage, pepperoni and traditional for a pizza party a…

We had no plans on eating here, but where in Babylon and decided to grab some lunch. Unfortunately, no lunch served on Sunday. We ordered 1 soda, 2 chicken parms and one eggplant rollatini. Meal…

We had no plans on eating here, but where in Babylon and decided to grab some lunch. Unfortunately, no lunch served on Sunday. We ordered 1 soda, 2 chicken parms and one eggplant rollatini. Meal…

Floppy, flavorless pizza, their garlic knots taste stale and they are deficient in garlic. Do not eat here if you are a pizza enthusiast, you will not be satisfied. It is overpriced, and the pizza and garlic knots are mediocre.

Service was very slow. It took 55 minutes to get my meal; but the food was delicious!!

Michael Cullinan

We went last night for Christmas Eve. First let me say that the service was excellent. We had several dinners returned for being sour (Gnocci) and a wrong order. Everything was doused in a flavorless red sauce. I’m talking deep end of the pool! Everything was overcooked. When you are an Italian eatery you should have a killer red sauce and know how to cook pasta. The portions were huge. Kind of saying yeah, our food is subpar, but look at all that we give you. Uh no thanks. I had the blackened Salmon in a flavorless sauce, mostly butter, sitting on a block of pasta— Congealed. If you want to chug a flavorless red sauce by the gallon, this is your place. That said it’s as if the staff, manager, knew the goings on and they were super responsive and understanding. They get the props here. Fix the food, overall pretty disappointing for Xmas eve out with family.

Before ordering A delivery/take-out be sure and ask prices to be informed of your costs. I ordered one large white cheese pie and a small bottle of wine to be delivered to my Babylon location...My …

Some of the most expensive and worst Italian food i have ever had in my life. Chicken cutlets were like rubber and the penne ala vodka sauce was watered down or something. No taste to any of this food. Mulberry st in bayshore however is pretty good.

We were three people, and we all were terribly disappointed with our food. Although my order was short ribs over Rialto. There was no result, though to be found. It was simply rice cooked in a beef broth, and I could not get my fork through the short ribs such a disappointment all of our foods. We even order one of the special margaritas we had to send them back. It was just like drinking Soda mixed with seltzer and they call that a margarita. This meal was absolutely terrible. And the service our waitress was nowhere to be found. I had to get up two times to find her. What a terrible experience.

Sadly, my family won't be doing business with this restaurant again. Ordered a pizza and it came burnt. Mistakes happen so we call and the said they would send another pie but to give the driver the original one. Weird but okay. We waited an hour and called again because nothing was delivered. At this point we just asked for a refund. The woman who answered was very rude and said the order was already in and we should wait another 10 minutes. So from the original order until the second pie arrived was over 2 hours. The best part..... The second pie was burnt as well. Pictures of both pies are included. These people just don't care what goes out the door.