McDonald's
Burger · West Islip
About McDonald's
En McDonald's West Islip, te damos la bienvenida a un clásico de siempre, donde puedes disfrutar de nuestras icónicas hamburguesas y patatas fritas. Con años de historia y un sabor inconfundible, somos el lugar perfecto para una comida rápida y deliciosa. ¡Te esperamos para compartir momentos agrada...
En McDonald's West Islip, te damos la bienvenida a un clásico de siempre, donde puedes disfrutar de nuestras icónicas hamburguesas y patatas fritas. Con años de historia y un sabor inconfundible, somos el lugar perfecto para una comida rápida y deliciosa. ¡Te esperamos para compartir momentos agradables y sabores que te encantan!
What Customers Say About McDonald's
McDonald's in West Islip receives mixed reviews. Many praise the fresh, hot food, clean environment, and excellent service, especially highlighting managers like Carolina and Christina. However, some customers report order inaccuracies, rude staff, and uncomfortable seating.
Popular Dishes
Best For
Tip: Use the app for deals. Some reviewers suggest avoiding the Deer Park Ave location and dining in due to uncomfortable seating.
Features
Frequently asked questions about McDonald's
McDonald's West Islip Reviews
Saw a customer be soo rude to a gentleman taking orders through drive thru this evening absolutely horrible and disgusting although he was yelled at and attacked by this crazy lady in front of me he was super sweet and kind to me as well as was able to accommodate my order and meet me at the window to make sure he had gotten it correctly the gentleman had the most beautiful green eyes
McDonald’s West Islip, out of Grinch meals Very apologetic! Very helpful on happy meal toy selection, manager and workers all so nice helpful, food always amazing good ! Came out fast ! Always a pleasure to eat there ! They work hard I worked at McDonald’s at 16 so I know!keep up good work and I will keep coming in
Out of all the Mcdonalds in the area, I go here because its faster, the food is good and the place is clean. Other mcdonalds, not so much, Dont go to the Deer Park ave one by Deer Park, its gross. This West Islip one is the best, I wish it was 24 hours.
What can I say, it's McDonald's. Unhealthy comfort food that makes you feel like you're living on the edge because you know it's not good for you but hey.... life is short, right? Y'all know what I mean.. lol
James was very helpful in the drive thru the app glitches with my order but he immediately accommodated me and made the experience very easy I appreciate him!!
I just had a nice chat with the manager here, Christina. She was incredibly personable and friendly. The food at this location is always fresh and tastes the best!
Visited the West Islip Location today. Food was great. Service was better. Restaurant very clean. Carolina the Manager was Outstanding! She is very Professional, Courteous & personable. Checked on me & the customers always working very hard I Highly Recommend this Location
Great service. Great people. Fresh hot delicious food seasoned perfectly. Good portions. Great deals especially with the app. I highly recommend. Personally I think they have the best fries and chicken nuggets of most or all "fast food" restaurants.
We are heading back right now from the beach and our ritual is to stop at McDonald’s on the way home. We stop at the same one every time but tonight we experienced one of the drive through speakers weren’t working and everyone was ordering and pulling up on the other line. So we drove up to the window and told them what happened. Well. They were sooooooooo nice! They took our order and got our food immediately. The girl at the window was so accommodating and not rushing us ,double and triple checking, making sure we had everything! Awesome experience. Everything was piping hot and so good.
Lady in a red sweatshirt on 1/6/26 slammed my order on the table and walked away with an attitude. I didn't speak to anyone or say anything to anyone, I ordered at the kios for Dine-in.
The foods ok…it’s McDonald’s, what do you expect? lol. What I will say is that it’s nearly impossible to dine in here since they renovated the place a few years ago! The chairs are like children’s chairs and very uncomfortable! It also seems like anytime I order through the drive through,they mess up my order! One time they told me to park in spot 1 to wait for my Drive Through order. There was someone already in spot 1, so I parked to the spot next to it. I kid you not we wait for a good 15 minutes. The lady in spot one gets 4 bags of food in that 15 minutes, I go in to complain that I’ve been waiting for 15 mins and they tell me they gave my order to the lady next to me!
Terrible experience. The young guy that took my order got EVERYTHING WRONG.. the bathroom was dirty and the people have the wrong attitude... please fix this place.. ASAP
I paid full price for a hamburger, and they forgot the patty. The old manager lady couldn't read the order details.
The person that took our order thru the phone call me sucks for u
Placed my order waited 20 minutes nothing. Asked to see the manager. She said they were having trouble. I watched other customers order and get there meal. I said this is ridiculous. Just return my money. Mcdonald's is a waste . Go to Wendy's or Burger King.
At almost almost every McDonald’s I went to They greeted me with a sentence hello will you be using the mobile app today? Thank you. This was the lady said what do you want? that was very rude and I do not appreciate that. we pulled up to the window to pay to receive our food. When my sister told the lady what had happened. The lady ignored us and rode her eyes. We asked for fresh food cook to order and I received molded apples and cold cookies. The service was horrible. I would never come here again.
Wish I could leave a big fat zero . All the workers need to be fired ASAP . You can't even put onions on a burger we're they belong . But I ordered extra onions and extra pickles but got only the pickles. No onions on all five burgers . Fire the Manager then school everyone all over about your burgers . Won't ever go back.
I was here at 11:50 am on 7/12/25 and I’m a delivery driver so I’m here all the time. The old lady in the burgundy McDonald’s shirt has no manners whatsoever which gave me a weird feeling from the start, she’s hustling with boxes and I hold the door she doesn’t even say thank you or acknowledge me. Then I’m here again and some kid is asking for a drink that they didn’t give him and she was being rude for no reason. I mean, if you can’t give him a drink for policy reasons fine but that’s a kid, please be nice. Our society is so afraid of talking in person nowadays and people like her will never make it better. Poor kid just wanted a gosh dang drink that he ordered. I hope this lady find joy someday. Or a new job
So that's a buttermilk chicken sandwich. It was half the size of the roll, rubbery with wilted lettuce. The frys had a aftertaste and the hot apple pie was not hot. I got there about 11pm it was busy but I guess at night just reheated leftover stuff! I know it's only fast food but this was terrible.
Sign in to leave a review
Sign inRemove ads and manage your menu
Explore Your Area
7 Photos
Explore McDonald's's photos
About McDonald's
How to get there
131 Sunrise Hwy, West Islip, NY 11795
Highlights
Services
Dining Options
Restaurant Info
Amenities
The Neighborhood
Location
131 Sunrise Hwy, West Islip, NY 11795
📍 Explore the Neighborhood
Gaming
🎮 Earn Points While You Explore!
Play Find Me and redeem points for discounts at McDonald's and other restaurants
Earn Points at McDonald's!
Play Find Me and redeem rewards here
Earn extra points and redeem them for rewards at McDonald's
🏆 Rewards at McDonald's
10% Discount
At McDonald's
Free Appetizer
On your next visit
VIP Table
Premium experience
to redeem rewards and earn points
📋 How Do Rewards Work?
Play Find Me
Every 100 score points = 1 reward point
Collect Points
Workers earn 2x points per game
Redeem Rewards
Discounts, free food and VIP experiences
Is it yours? Claim it FREE!
Remove ads and manage your menu