Menu
Fresh Brothers
PosDo

© 2026 PosDo · v3.0

Fresh Brothers
Photos

Fresh Brothers

Pizza · Balboa Island

Savor Sunset Pizza on Balboa Island

4.1 · 119 reviews Google
www.freshbrothers.com

About Fresh Brothers

Nestled in the heart of Balboa Island at 1124 Irvine Ave, Newport Beach, CA 92660, Fresh Brothers brings a unique slice of culinary delight to the vibrant community. Our restaurant is more than just a place to eat; it's an experience that captures the essence of our island home with its charming sea...

Nestled in the heart of Balboa Island at 1124 Irvine Ave, Newport Beach, CA 92660, Fresh Brothers brings a unique slice of culinary delight to the vibrant community. Our restaurant is more than just a place to eat; it's an experience that captures the essence of our island home with its charming sea breezes and stunning sunset views. We offer a variety of dining options, from casual takeaways to cozy indoor seating, ensuring there’s a perfect spot for every occasion. Our focus lies in crafting authentic, handcrafted pizzas using only the finest ingredients. Each bite is a testament to our commitment to quality and flavor. With a 4.1/5 rating based on 119 reviews, we are proud of the warm response from our patrons who appreciate not just what’s on their plate but also how it makes them feel. Join us at Fresh Brothers and let us share with you more than just pizza—experience the joy of good food and great company.

What Customers Say About Fresh Brothers

Fresh Brothers on Balboa Island is known for its friendly staff and delicious pizza, including vegan options and deep dish. Customers frequently praise the excellent service, especially mentioning staff like Andrea, Dominique, Claudia and Liz. Some customers have experienced issues with order accuracy and consistency.

Popular Dishes

pizza (12) deep dish pizza vegan pizza Meatball sub charred pepperoni kids’ pizza

Best For

Families Groups Quick Bite Casual

Tip: If you're unsure what to order, ask the staff for recommendations, especially Claudia, who is known for her excellent suggestions.

Features

🌳 Outdoor 🅿️ Parking 🚗 Delivery Accessible 🍽️ Lunch 🌙 Dinner 🥗 Vegetarian
🎯 Casual Trendy 👨‍👩‍👧 Family 👥 Groups

What to see nearby

Harper Park
A 403m

Harper Park

parque

View details
Mariners Park
A 479m

Mariners Park

parque

View details
Pinkley Park
A 741m

Pinkley Park

parque

View details

Data from Wikidata

Explore the area around Fresh Brothers

Fresh Brothers is located in Balboa Island, surrounded by cultural and historical points of interest. Here are some of the most notable places nearby.

Parks & Gardens

  • Harper Park (A 403m) — park in Orange County, California, United States of America; geonames ID = 5355499
  • Mariners Park (A 479m) — park in the United States of America
  • Pinkley Park (A 741m) — park in Orange County, California, United States of America

Data from Wikidata

Frequently asked questions about Fresh Brothers

Fresh Brothers is located at 1124 Irvine Ave, Newport Beach, CA 92660, Balboa Island.
Near Fresh Brothers you can find points of interest such as Harper Park, Mariners Park, Pinkley Park.
Fresh Brothers offers pizza cuisine.
Fresh Brothers has regular opening hours. Check their profile for updated schedules.
Fresh Brothers offers the following services: dine-in, takeaway, delivery.
The most recommended dishes at Fresh Brothers based on customer reviews are: pizza, deep dish pizza, vegan pizza, Meatball sub, charred pepperoni.
Fresh Brothers is ideal for families, groups, quick bites, casual dining.
Fresh Brothers on Balboa Island is known for its friendly staff and delicious pizza, including vegan options and deep dish. Customers frequently praise the excellent service, especially mentioning staff like Andrea, Dominique, Claudia and Liz. Some customers have experienced issues with order accuracy and consistency.
If you're unsure what to order, ask the staff for recommendations, especially Claudia, who is known for her excellent suggestions.
119
Reviews

Fresh Brothers Balboa Island Reviews

4.1
119
5★
69%
4★
8%
3★
5%
2★
5%
1★
13%
Reviews (40)
n
nicole summers

Great pizza! My kids absolute favorite. The price and quality is amazing. Claudia is always so sweet, has a smile, she even remembers our order. They are lucky to have her, she has the best customer service. Pizza is made fresh and always hot. Can't beat it. We love Fresh Brothers at Westcliff.

J
Jaclyn

Mgr Claudia made some excellent suggestions of items to add to my pizza. Don't skip the charred pepperoni.

m
mina bernabe

First time eating there. The food was delicious. Far exceeded my expectations

S
Susan Clark

We love your pizza and you are great with me changing toppings around.

Y
Yi Chang

I love this location of Fresh Brothers, the service there is fantastic. All the cashiers are wonderful people. And when you buy the food, they aren’t like other places where people trying to let you give more tips. So every time when I order, I would love to give them all the cash that I have or add over 20% tips with my card payments. Also, one time when I was in very low of my blood sugar, their servers gave me 20 ounces of regular coke before I pay for it. Later I paid for it. How awesome they are! I love this place and their people and of course their food also.

A
Aaron Kellar

I don't normally do Google reviews, but the staff member that helped us on Sunday, 9/1, over the Labor Day Weekend was absolutely amazing. She was so kind and helpful and it seemed like she was cooking, cleaning, taking orders and also had such a gracious attitude. I would come back to this location next time we are in town, just based on this amazing customer service.

S
Sabrina Faye

I just love this pizza. The fact that they have vegan cheese is so awesome and seems hard to find at other pizza spots. It’s always super fresh, always consistent. On top of that, location is easy to find, easy parking and super clean. Liz helped me out today and she was so kind. She had the best attitude and positive vibe about her. Highly recommend this location! 😊

J
James

Meatball sub was great! Guy was nice too 👍

m
megnet welsh

This place is amazing! The staff is beyond friendly and generous! Went with a group of people right at closing and they were even more hospitable then. We got both vegan pizza and conventional pizza. Both were outstanding. I am allergic to eggs and milk so it's Really nice when I do not have to go somewhere after my friends have eaten or live on French fries. Will defiantly go again!!!

S
Shane Gray (Vulcan Gaming)

They’re deep dish pizza specifically is super amazing to me! They add a little bit extra cheese compared to most local pizza places. Dominique at the Front was super helpful and the whole place seems to have a good vibe.

A
Ashley Mobley

Fresh Brothers is clearly the best pizza in town! I love Fresh Brothers Pizza, but the Westcliff location is my favorite! Andrea is the manager at this location and she always goes above and beyond to make sure that all costumers are satisfied!! We appreciate her and her staff!🍕🍕🍕 Keep up the good work!!!

James
James

Meatball sub was great! Guy was nice too 👍

nicole summers
nicole summers

Great pizza! My kids absolute favorite. The price and quality is amazing. Claudia is always so sweet, has a smile, she even remembers our order. They are lucky to have her, she has the best customer service. Pizza is made fresh and always hot. Can't beat it. We love Fresh Brothers at Westcliff.

Susan Clark
Susan Clark

We love your pizza and you are great with me changing toppings around.

mina bernabe
mina bernabe

First time eating there. The food was delicious. Far exceeded my expectations

Jaclyn
Jaclyn

Mgr Claudia made some excellent suggestions of items to add to my pizza. Don't skip the charred pepperoni.

Aaron Kellar
Aaron Kellar

I don't normally do Google reviews, but the staff member that helped us on Sunday, 9/1, over the Labor Day Weekend was absolutely amazing. She was so kind and helpful and it seemed like she was cooking, cleaning, taking orders and also had such a gracious attitude. I would come back to this location next time we are in town, just based on this amazing customer service.

Yi Chang
Yi Chang

I love this location of Fresh Brothers, the service there is fantastic. All the cashiers are wonderful people. And when you buy the food, they aren’t like other places where people trying to let you give more tips. So every time when I order, I would love to give them all the cash that I have or add over 20% tips with my card payments. Also, one time when I was in very low of my blood sugar, their servers gave me 20 ounces of regular coke before I pay for it. Later I paid for it. How awesome they are! I love this place and their people and of course their food also.

Sabrina Faye
Sabrina Faye

I just love this pizza. The fact that they have vegan cheese is so awesome and seems hard to find at other pizza spots. It’s always super fresh, always consistent. On top of that, location is easy to find, easy parking and super clean. Liz helped me out today and she was so kind. She had the best attitude and positive vibe about her. Highly recommend this location! 😊

Shane Gray (Vulcan Gaming)
Shane Gray (Vulcan Gaming)

They’re deep dish pizza specifically is super amazing to me! They add a little bit extra cheese compared to most local pizza places. Dominique at the Front was super helpful and the whole place seems to have a good vibe.

Ashley Mobley
Ashley Mobley

Fresh Brothers is clearly the best pizza in town! I love Fresh Brothers Pizza, but the Westcliff location is my favorite! Andrea is the manager at this location and she always goes above and beyond to make sure that all costumers are satisfied!! We appreciate her and her staff!🍕🍕🍕 Keep up the good work!!!

megnet welsh
megnet welsh

This place is amazing! The staff is beyond friendly and generous! Went with a group of people right at closing and they were even more hospitable then. We got both vegan pizza and conventional pizza. Both were outstanding. I am allergic to eggs and milk so it's Really nice when I do not have to go somewhere after my friends have eaten or live on French fries. Will defiantly go again!!!

A
Amana

Great Spot for a Quick Bite! The pizza crust was just right—not too thin, not too thick—and had a perfect texture. My daughter had a kids’ pizza and really enjoyed it. Plenty of parking, spacious layout, and nice outdoor seating make it a convenient and pleasant place to stop for a quick, tasty meal.

Amana
Amana

Great Spot for a Quick Bite! The pizza crust was just right—not too thin, not too thick—and had a perfect texture. My daughter had a kids’ pizza and really enjoyed it. Plenty of parking, spacious layout, and nice outdoor seating make it a convenient and pleasant place to stop for a quick, tasty meal.

M
Michael L

With Fresh Brothers, the pizza is good and the staff is both courteous and interested in doing their jobs well. My gripes are the astoundingly overpriced cost of their pizzas along with an absolutely frustrating experience of trying to customize orders from their app. Case in point, one of the staff there was really big into recommending their giardiniera sauce. Yet if you order through your app, the option doesn't exist (I ended up with a pizza that had no sauce but had giardinera peppers on it when I feebly attempted to place my order.) All and all it's not a bad place to sit down and have a meal but the online ordering experience is lacking and there are certainly more budget-friendly options for pizza out there.

J
Jaimee O

I feel that the pizza is mediocre here. I'm not a big fan of the sauce they use and I really feel that it overwhelms the toppings. I've had Fresh Brothers three times and, every time I go, I don't hate it but I don't enjoy it very much either. I know different people like different pizza but it isn't for me. Beyond that, I came in last on a Sunday and was very disappointed that I couldn't buy pizza by the slice. Apparently they only do that on the weekdays which seems counterintuitive.

V
Vicki Farrell

Their pizza is awesome, but their quality control is awful. We have ordered multiple times and the majority of times something is wrong, missing, etc. One time we got an additional pizza that wasn’t ours, another we asked for regular ranch dressing and got that horrible “creamy” ranch that does not taste good. Tonight the pizza was great but the mixed salad we got was wet and soggy with no tomatoes. From now on we are only ordering pizza.

Jaimee O
Jaimee O

I feel that the pizza is mediocre here. I'm not a big fan of the sauce they use and I really feel that it overwhelms the toppings. I've had Fresh Brothers three times and, every time I go, I don't hate it but I don't enjoy it very much either. I know different people like different pizza but it isn't for me. Beyond that, I came in last on a Sunday and was very disappointed that I couldn't buy pizza by the slice. Apparently they only do that on the weekdays which seems counterintuitive.

Vicki Farrell
Vicki Farrell

Their pizza is awesome, but their quality control is awful. We have ordered multiple times and the majority of times something is wrong, missing, etc. One time we got an additional pizza that wasn’t ours, another we asked for regular ranch dressing and got that horrible “creamy” ranch that does not taste good. Tonight the pizza was great but the mixed salad we got was wet and soggy with no tomatoes. From now on we are only ordering pizza.

Michael L
Michael L

With Fresh Brothers, the pizza is good and the staff is both courteous and interested in doing their jobs well. My gripes are the astoundingly overpriced cost of their pizzas along with an absolutely frustrating experience of trying to customize orders from their app. Case in point, one of the staff there was really big into recommending their giardiniera sauce. Yet if you order through your app, the option doesn't exist (I ended up with a pizza that had no sauce but had giardinera peppers on it when I feebly attempted to place my order.) All and all it's not a bad place to sit down and have a meal but the online ordering experience is lacking and there are certainly more budget-friendly options for pizza out there.

M
MOODY360TV

Great food but one person on cash register only who is handling phone Orders and walk ins. Phone is ringing off the hook and the machines (iPads) are peeping from online order. Inefficient process. #MOODY360TV. You need to hire more people

MOODY360TV
MOODY360TV

Great food but one person on cash register only who is handling phone Orders and walk ins. Phone is ringing off the hook and the machines (iPads) are peeping from online order. Inefficient process. #MOODY360TV. You need to hire more people

M
Mister D!

I am both a customer and do food service delivery. Sue (sorry if wrong name...could be Elizabeth--young girl with reddish hair and glasses) is always extremely nice and professional. She knows how to prepare food, help customers, etc. However, there have been two different times (not with Sue), where I wasn't given a bag (when it was needed for smaller items), had to ask for it, and was treated like I interrupted something (scrolling cell phone, etc). One was this evening--June 18, 2024. The teenage kid (zits, blond hair, possibly autism spectrum) just plopped my order on the desk and didn't give me a bag for the wings. Worse, he didn't give me the ranch dressing that was requested. When I went back and asked, he said they ran out. I understand that, but wouldn't it have been better to tell me before so I could contact the customer and ask for a replacement? Then, there is the shorter really heavy set Hispanic woman who is rude every single time. She always acts like she is being interrupted, and NEVER gives bags for the smallest items. There is no way she should be still working there, but I'll leave that up to the managers. If you'd like to talk to me more about this, I'm open. I like Fresh Bros. and I want you guys to succeed.

Mister D!
Mister D!

I am both a customer and do food service delivery. Sue (sorry if wrong name...could be Elizabeth--young girl with reddish hair and glasses) is always extremely nice and professional. She knows how to prepare food, help customers, etc. However, there have been two different times (not with Sue), where I wasn't given a bag (when it was needed for smaller items), had to ask for it, and was treated like I interrupted something (scrolling cell phone, etc). One was this evening--June 18, 2024. The teenage kid (zits, blond hair, possibly autism spectrum) just plopped my order on the desk and didn't give me a bag for the wings. Worse, he didn't give me the ranch dressing that was requested. When I went back and asked, he said they ran out. I understand that, but wouldn't it have been better to tell me before so I could contact the customer and ask for a replacement? Then, there is the shorter really heavy set Hispanic woman who is rude every single time. She always acts like she is being interrupted, and NEVER gives bags for the smallest items. There is no way she should be still working there, but I'll leave that up to the managers. If you'd like to talk to me more about this, I'm open. I like Fresh Bros. and I want you guys to succeed.

K
Kanav Aggarwal

I had an awful experience at this location. I asked the cashier (Elizabeth) for recommendations and placed an order based on her suggestion. It was a Margherita. However to my surprise, the size and quality of pizza was ridiculous. Margherita was just a cheese pizza with a slice of tomato. None of the pesto,basil or fresh mozzarella. I asked the cashier what it is and they simply refused to accept their mistake. Even the so called manager was just a bus boy out of HS. Handed them the pizza and walked out. Called main brach and their way of fixing problem is handing out coupons. Like I am ever gonna return to Thrash Brothers.

E
Eric Jay

Will not be returning to Flop Brothers—ever. Pizza looked like a multi oval shaped mound of too much, rubbery cheese. A far stretch from the pictures. Tasted like two day old pizza. Total waste of $21.54. My orders have been in a steady decline. Better luck gambling in Vegas than getting a good pizza here.

G
Greg Iversen

For what it’s worth, the pizza is great, if they get it right…but they won’t. 4 straight orders were wrong, 4 straight, that’s crazy in the food world. You have to have something systemically wrong for that to happen. 2 times they blamed slice and made us take 30 minutes to hash it out with them, 2x it was their fault. Today we showed up to pick up our pizza and they said it would be 30 minutes longer, then came back and brought pizza back and they STILL messed it up. I thought it was only us, but I literally ran into another dad picking up his pizza before me today who said they always mess up his family’s orders too. Hope your luck is better than mine, but probably won’t be.

Kanav Aggarwal
Kanav Aggarwal

I had an awful experience at this location. I asked the cashier (Elizabeth) for recommendations and placed an order based on her suggestion. It was a Margherita. However to my surprise, the size and quality of pizza was ridiculous. Margherita was just a cheese pizza with a slice of tomato. None of the pesto,basil or fresh mozzarella. I asked the cashier what it is and they simply refused to accept their mistake. Even the so called manager was just a bus boy out of HS. Handed them the pizza and walked out. Called main brach and their way of fixing problem is handing out coupons. Like I am ever gonna return to Thrash Brothers.

Eric Jay
Eric Jay

Will not be returning to Flop Brothers—ever. Pizza looked like a multi oval shaped mound of too much, rubbery cheese. A far stretch from the pictures. Tasted like two day old pizza. Total waste of $21.54. My orders have been in a steady decline. Better luck gambling in Vegas than getting a good pizza here.

Greg Iversen
Greg Iversen

For what it’s worth, the pizza is great, if they get it right…but they won’t. 4 straight orders were wrong, 4 straight, that’s crazy in the food world. You have to have something systemically wrong for that to happen. 2 times they blamed slice and made us take 30 minutes to hash it out with them, 2x it was their fault. Today we showed up to pick up our pizza and they said it would be 30 minutes longer, then came back and brought pizza back and they STILL messed it up. I thought it was only us, but I literally ran into another dad picking up his pizza before me today who said they always mess up his family’s orders too. Hope your luck is better than mine, but probably won’t be.

Sign in to leave a review

Sign in
👑 Is it yours? Claim it FREE!

Remove ads and manage your menu

Explore Your Area

More restaurants in Balboa Island →
📸

Gallery

📸

No photos available

Photos will appear here when synced from Google Places

📍

About Fresh Brothers

How to get there

1124 Irvine Ave, Newport Beach, CA 92660

Balboa Island, CA 92660

Loading map...
Fresh Brothers
Tap for directions

Highlights

Good Rating
4.1/5 stars
💬
Many Reviews
119 reviews
💰
Moderate Price
Price level
👨‍🍳
pizza
Cuisine type

Services

🍽️ Lunch
🍾 Dinner
🍰 Desserts
🥗 Vegetarian Options
🥡 Takeout
🚚 Delivery
🍴 Dine-in

Dining Options

🍽️ Dine In
🥡 Takeout
🚚 Delivery

Restaurant Info

Status
Verified by owner
🕐 Hours Today
11AM-9PM
Rating
4.1/5
💬 Reviews
119
💰 Price Level
$$
📞 Phone
+1 657-845-2345
🌐 Website
www.freshbrothers.com

Amenities

🅿️ Parking
🌿 Outdoor Seating
Wheelchair Accessible
🚻 Restroom
💳 Credit Cards
📱 Mobile Payments
🏘️

The Neighborhood

Location

1124 Irvine Ave, Newport Beach, CA 92660

Balboa Island, CA 92660

📍 Explore the Neighborhood

Weather
26°
Weather updated hourly · Jobs and events refreshed daily
Harper Park

park in Orange County, California, United States of America; geonames ID = 5355499

A 403m
Mariners Park

park in the United States of America

A 479m
Pinkley Park

park in Orange County, California, United States of America

A 741m
🎮

Gaming

🎮 Earn Points While You Explore!

Play Find Me and redeem points for discounts at Fresh Brothers and other restaurants

🎮

Earn Points at Fresh Brothers!

Play Find Me and redeem rewards here

Earn extra points and redeem them for rewards at Fresh Brothers

🏆 Rewards at Fresh Brothers

💰

10% Discount

At Fresh Brothers

1000 pts
Available
🍽️

Free Appetizer

On your next visit

2500 pts
Limited
👑

VIP Table

Premium experience

5000 pts
Exclusive

to redeem rewards and earn points

📋 How Do Rewards Work?

1

Play Find Me

Every 100 score points = 1 reward point

2

Collect Points

Workers earn 2x points per game

3

Redeem Rewards

Discounts, free food and VIP experiences

Call
Leave a Review on Google
👑

Is it yours? Claim it FREE!

Remove ads and manage your menu

Sign in & Play

Check your email!

No password needed — we'll email you a link

We sent you an access link

Check your spam folder if you don't see it