Jiffy C

Pizza 151 is more than just great pizza. If you haven't checked out the Tap Room - you ARE missing out. Multi big screen TVs, dart boards, plenty of space and custom bathrooms!!

Dennis Bartholomew

Great food. Pizza is amazing. Not to mention the tap room. Trivia on Fridays at 7pm. Would reccomend. Dine in, family friendly atmosphere.

+1

B.

OMG! Our visit was the best experience ever. I'm from St. Louis, MO and we don't have an option to choose from sweet or traditional sauce. We just don't order from certain places. I was so excited when the person at the front counter asked which kind we wanted. The pizza was amazing and fresh - the crust was so soft and pillowy and the sauce was a dream! For my first bite of NY style pizza in NY, I was totally blown away! Everyone that we spoke to was super friendly. The prices were reasonable, too.

John Braciszewski

This is my go-to place for pizza. However, the other day I ordered a pizza with onion and 1/2 pepperoni. To say there were 4 strands of thin onion on each slice would be generous. Disappointing. Hoping next time will be better.

Jeffrey Pulver

While in Batavia for work I wanted some pizza for lunch. This place hit the spot! Great pizza and a really cool setting. They even have a beer fountain with local brews which I’ve ever seen before.

Sera M

Normally go here 1-2 times a week for dinner since we work a couple of jobs and are finishing our degrees. Simple option. Always thought the food tasted pretty good, and the employees seemed nice. But, that changed a day ago. We ordered 2 pizzas and cheese bread sticks. Paid and TIPPED online. My husband went to pick it up and the guy was reluctant to give him our order. My husband showed him the online receipt and the guy got someone else to come up and talk to my husband. She looked at the order but didn’t hand it to my husband and then asked “Did you tip already?” We did. Kind of wish we hadn’t. I didn’t realize it was expected to tip when you order online and go to pickup your own food. And I didn’t realize you weren’t allowed to have the food you paid for unless you tipped first. We’ve been here so much, it is really disappointing to be treated that way. Probably going to avoid them from now on and go elsewhere. There’s options and appreciation at most places.

Courtney Burley

Their beer/ cider wall was cool, but they did keep it as cold as it should be.. it was warm with a lot of foam. Their cup and char pizza was good, good wings and delicious chimmies. Cool atmosphere ( minus sponge on one TV that was extremely loud, we ended up moving seats).

+5

Paul McCullough

So the food is good, service is very good, the beer selection is very good. But, there had to be a but, the taps they have, have the CO2 turned up too high causing a lot of foam, which causes wasted beer and WAY over charge for the pours. Get the food, and until they fix the taps, avoid the beer And I know how to pour a beer and the pictures says it all

Stephen

Perhaps “151” stands for the cheese-dough-sauce ratio (1:5:1), but this pizza wasn’t exactly what I anticipated. All jokes aside, the pizza was not excellent here. I cannot speak for the other menu items, but then again i did not see a menu anywhere here. Leaving off on a positive note, atmosphere was incredible here, with a large dining room with polyurethane tables that reminded me of bowling balls. Staff was super friendly and they have cute, little matching shirts.

Michael McKenzie

Every time I order, which is only because the kids like the sweet sauce, I get a pizza that’s either partially burnt or the cheese doesn’t go to the edges

Mary Scollin

The pizza was billed as NY thin & crispy. Not even close. Thick, doughy crust, barely any sauce. Soooo disappointing. Buffalo medium wings were fine, otherwise would have given only 1 star.

Stacy Nichols

Never get our order right. We order pizza and wings all the time but lately they been messing up our order. Wings were too hot ordered mild got medium. They need to train their staff better.

George O'Sullivan

Don't come here for fresh slices. Slice I had looked like it was sitting in the heater for hours. Dried out, looks sad, even the front desk employee went and asked a manager about the slices being old. She said "we've sold much worse than that", and proceeded to sell me the slice. I got in my car looked at the slice, and tossed it out the window. Thanks guys.